A Calamity of Souls
In 1968 Virginia, lawyer John Robert Lee and civil-rights attorney Desiree DuBose uncover the framing of Jerome and Pearl Washington for a wealthy couple's murders, win dismissal of the charges, and confront the lethal racial violence that follows.
Overview
In Freeman County, Virginia, in 1968, Leslie and Anne Randolph, an elderly and wealthy white couple, are found dead in their home. The sheriff's deputies arrest Jerome Washington, a Black Vietnam veteran who works for the Randolphs as a driver and handyman. One deputy beats the handcuffed Jerome and threatens his wife and children; the authorities treat his presence at the house as proof of guilt. Jerome says he entered the house to collect his weekly pay, discovered the bodies, and moved Anne in an attempt to help her. He denies the murders. His wife's grandmother, Lenore Jessup, known as Miss Jessup, asks John Robert Lee, a white lawyer called Jack, to visit Jerome in jail. Jack has never defended a Black client or tried a capital murder case. He eventually agrees to represent Jerome despite intimidation and the objections of his mother, Hilly.
Jack's decision becomes dangerous as Edmund Battle, Virginia's attorney general, assumes the prosecution and businessman Howard Pickett supports the segregationist presidential campaign of George Wallace. Jack receives threats and is attacked. Desiree DuBose, an experienced Black civil-rights attorney who has previously opposed Battle in the Supreme Court's Loving case, arrives to help. After disagreeing about leadership, she accepts Jack's offer to become co-counsel. They confront hostile police, a racially divided community, limitations on criminal discovery and the prospect of an overwhelmingly white jury. Jack's father, Frank, assists him, while Hilly's opposition gradually changes. Miss Jessup's ties to the Lees prove deeper than Jack knew: she cared for his sister Lucy when Hilly was hospitalized after learning of Lucy's disability.
The defense finds important inconsistencies. Jerome has no blood on his clothing or shoes despite the violent wounds, and he has an injured leg that limits the movements the medical examiner says the killer would have needed. The police cannot identify the person who called them or produce the murder weapon. Some witnesses allege that Leslie planned to fire Jerome or leave him money, but the estate documents and their firsthand knowledge do not support those accounts. The Randolph household has its own secrets: Leslie repeatedly abused Anne, who had quietly consulted a divorce lawyer, and their son Sam had sought to have his parents declared incompetent. A small blue convertible, an earlier visitor with a medical bag and conflicting descriptions of a possible inheritance provide additional leads.
The prosecution also charges Jerome's wife, Pearl, with helping to remove evidence. She privately tells the defense that she was at an illegal abortion provider on the day of the murders after being sexually assaulted by her employer. To avoid exposing her history to Jerome, she initially withholds this alibi. Two prosecution witnesses later prove unreliable: Tyler Dobbs admits an anonymous offer to pay his gambling debts in exchange for false testimony, and Linda Drucker confesses that she invented a supposed sighting of Pearl carrying a bloody shoe after anonymous blackmail. Both accounts are struck. Desiree locates Peter Clancy, a neighbor who testifies that he saw Pearl enter the abortion provider's rowhouse around one in the afternoon and leave shortly after six, covering the estimated time of the deaths.
Pressure on the defense turns violent. Jack's office is set on fire; a man who earlier attacked him admits assaulting Lucy, who dies after surgery. Jack's brother, Jefferson, called Jeff, returns from a long absence and intervenes when the assailants threaten Jack and Desiree. Hilly urges Jack to continue rather than give in to the intimidation. During the trial, Judge Josiah Ambrose repeatedly makes rulings unfavorable to the defense and displays open racial hostility. Jack and Desiree later obtain confirmation that Ambrose once belonged to the Ku Klux Klan. A late-arriving bayonet, allegedly found on the Washington property, appears to match the wounds, but Jeff identifies it as a Confederate-era weapon that he personally saw in the Randolph home when he dated their daughter Christine Hanover.
As the trial nears a verdict, Battle privately offers to drop Pearl's charges if Jerome pleads guilty to involuntary manslaughter. He will recommend five years in prison although the offense permits up to ten. Jerome agrees for his family's sake despite maintaining his innocence. Before that plea can be entered, Jeff mentions a conversation with Christine's maid, Patsy, who places Christine at home on the afternoon of the murders, contradicting her sworn account that she was in Washington, DC, with her husband Gordon. Patsy says Christine went to her parents' house and returned around five in a blue convertible, distressed and wearing a coat despite the heat. The attorneys corroborate the contradiction and recall Christine to the witness stand.
Christine reveals that Anne planned to divorce Leslie because of his violence. On the day of the deaths, Leslie killed Anne with the family's bayonet after discovering the divorce plans. When he attacked Christine, she killed him while defending herself. Frightened of being accused of both murders, she called family lawyer Curtis Gates, who sent his son Walter to conceal the bloodstains, take the weapon and drive her home. Christine later staged a return from Washington with Gordon. Walter spotted Jerome entering the Randolph house and called the police to implicate him. According to Christine, Curtis and Walter subsequently arranged false testimony and planted evidence to prevent the real circumstances from emerging. She links their actions to their interest in acquiring the Randolph land cheaply after Sam's death, although some details of their financial plan remain her interpretation. Curtis, Walter, Christine and Gordon are taken into custody. Battle does not oppose dismissal, and all charges against Jerome and Pearl are withdrawn with prejudice. Ambrose nevertheless refuses to apologize.
Dismissal of the charges does not prevent further violence. Outside the courthouse, after Jack and Desiree speak publicly about equal justice, teenage Kenny LeRoy, the son of a deputy involved in Jerome's arrest, shoots Jerome dead and gravely wounds Jack. Jeff shoots Kenny to prevent him from shooting Pearl. Jack survives prolonged hospitalization and rehabilitation, while Miss Jessup moves in to help the widowed Pearl and her three children. Christine and Gordon are ultimately not charged, but Curtis and Walter Gates go to prison. Jack later leaves Freeman County for Chicago, where Desiree lives. He proposes that they continue practicing together as DuBose and Lee. Desiree explains that her former fiancé Paul was murdered in retaliation for her civil-rights work and that she fears close relationships because of that loss. Jack rejects the idea that their affection caused these deaths, and they agree to work together. The novel ends with their legal partnership renewed; it does not establish a romantic relationship as a settled fact.
Main Characters
- John Robert Lee (Jack), a white lawyer who represents Jerome and Pearl Washington
- Desiree DuBose, an experienced Black civil-rights lawyer and Jack's co-counsel
- Jerome Washington, a Black Vietnam veteran wrongfully accused of murdering his employers
- Pearl Washington, Jerome's wife, falsely accused of helping conceal the murders
- Lenore Jessup (Miss Jessup), Pearl's grandmother and former caregiver to Jack's sister
- Christine Hanover, daughter of the slain Randolphs whose concealed actions determine the case
- Leslie Randolph, an abusive husband who murders his wife Anne
- Anne Randolph, Leslie's wife, who seeks a divorce before being killed
- Curtis Gates and Walter Gates, lawyers and property interests implicated in fabricating evidence
- Edmund Battle, Virginia's attorney general and prosecutor
- Josiah Ambrose, the judge whose past Klan membership becomes public
- Hilly and Frank Lee, Jack's parents, whose views and support evolve
- Jefferson Lee (Jeff), Jack's younger brother and an Army veteran
Central Themes
- Racial injustice in criminal prosecution
- Witness manipulation and legal due process
- Domestic violence and coercive control
- Family obligation and bereavement
- Political power and economic self-interest
Mood & Atmosphere
Tense and frequently violent, with personal grief, legal conflict, and qualified hope for future change
Source Edition
A Calamity of Souls (2025), Grand Central Publishing. How sources are recorded.