Alone: A Detective D. D. Warren Novel

Bobby Dodge, a Massachusetts State Trooper, has just completed a grueling fifteen-hour shift filled with accidents and confrontations, including a drunk and belligerent ad executive. Despite his exhaustion, he feels restless and decides to visit a local bar, the Boston Beer Garden, to unwind. While there, he watches a news report about an armed suspect barricading himself in his home, a situation that seems to mirror the chaotic and unpredictable nature of the day he's just endured. As Bobby contemplates going home, his pager goes off, signaling a new emergency. Reluctantly, he leaves the bar, knowing that his night will be far from over.

Meanwhile, Catherine Rose Gagnon's life is marked by a traumatic past. On October 22, 1980, she was abducted by a man who kept her in a makeshift underground prison for twenty-eight days. Rescued in November, she struggled to reintegrate into society, haunted by her ordeal and the trial of her captor, Richard Umbrio. Years later, in 1998, Catherine's life remains troubled. She finds herself in a desperate situation, contemplating self-harm, when a phone call interrupts her. The chapter ends with Catherine, now married with a child, facing a volatile and dangerous confrontation with her husband, who she believes has a gun. She calls 911, hoping for rescue, echoing the theme of isolation and the need for external intervention to survive.

Rushing to a hostage situation in Back Bay, Boston, Bobby Dodge, a member of the Massachusetts State Police Special Tactics and Operations (STOP) Team, finds the scene more complex than anticipated. The area is already cordoned off with police presence, and media vans add to the chaos. At the command center, Lieutenant Jachrimo, the Boston Police Department's incident commander, briefs Bobby on the domestic barricade involving Jimmy Gagnon, who is believed to be holding his wife, Catherine, and their child hostage. The initial 911 call from Catherine was cut short, and subsequent reports of gunfire have heightened the tension. Bobby learns that the Gagnons have a history of domestic disputes, but this is the first time a firearm has been involved.

Tasked with establishing a perimeter and gathering intelligence, Bobby selects a nearby brownstone to set up his sniper position. A resident named George Harlow eagerly assists him. Bobby sets up his equipment, focusing on the illuminated fourth-floor balcony of the Gagnon residence. With his gear ready, Bobby reports in as Sniper One and begins to monitor the situation closely, aware that the next few moments could be crucial.

Positioned as Sniper One, Bobby Dodge meticulously describes the layout of the Gagnon residence to his team, noting the positions of the French doors and windows. Through his binoculars, he observes the lone male subject, Jimmy Gagnon, standing inside the room, his hands visible but not clearly holding a weapon. Bobby searches for Catherine and the child, but initially finds no signs of them, increasing his tension and concern.

Adjusting his sniper position, Bobby ensures he is ready for any immediate action. He reflects on the differences between a shooter and a sniper, emphasizing the need for detachment and precision. As he monitors the scene, he notices Jimmy Gagnon's posture and demeanor, recognizing signs of aggression and dominance. Bobby continues to scan the room, documenting his observations and setting up a detailed diagram of the building for his team.

The situation escalates when Bobby spots a handgun in Jimmy's hand and identifies Catherine and the child hiding behind the bed. As the tension builds, Jimmy becomes increasingly agitated, yelling and moving around the room. Bobby reports the movements to Lieutenant Jachrimo, who asks about the condition of the woman and child. Bobby observes that Jimmy is now aiming the gun at Catherine's head and trying to take the child from her. The moment reaches a critical point when Jimmy shoves the child away and turns his attention back to Catherine, prompting Bobby to take decisive action and shoot Jimmy to prevent further harm.

In the aftermath, Bobby sees Catherine rush to the child, protecting him from the sight of his father's body. She looks directly at Bobby, mouthing a silent thank you. Bobby stands up, realizing the intensity of the situation and the consequences of his actions. The scene is soon overwhelmed by the arrival of additional law enforcement, and Bobby prepares to face the aftermath of his decision.

The entry team confirms the death of Jimmy Gagnon, and the scene transitions into a crime scene managed by the DA’s office. Bobby is placed in the back of a patrol car, treated as a potential suspect despite not being in trouble. Media gathers, and Bobby’s lieutenant, John Bruni, reassures him about the process and the support he will receive from the Employee Assistance Unit (EAU). Bobby reflects on a similar incident involving a fellow trooper and the subsequent public and legal scrutiny, which adds to his anxiety about the implications for his career.

Bobby’s teammates and the EAU officers guide him through the protocol, explaining his rights and the investigative process. He is interviewed by investigators from the DA’s office, who scrutinize every detail of his actions and decisions. Bobby’s fatigue and stress are evident as he struggles to maintain composure during the intense questioning. He describes the events leading up to the shooting, emphasizing the immediate threat he perceived from Jimmy Gagnon. The investigators’ skepticism and repetitive questioning test Bobby’s resolve, but he remains as neutral and factual as possible.

After the lengthy interrogation, Bobby seeks solace with his girlfriend, Susan, a concert cellist with the Boston Symphony Orchestra. The stark contrast between his gritty, violent world and Susan’s refined, artistic lifestyle is highlighted as he struggles to reconcile the two. Bobby’s emotional turmoil culminates in a passionate and almost violent encounter with Susan, reflecting his inner turmoil and the darkness that has consumed him. Lying on the floor, Bobby feels a profound sense of darkness and despair, haunted by the image of Catherine and her child.

Dr. Elizabeth Lane, a psychiatrist, contemplates the idea of adopting a pet to fill the void in her life, especially during the holiday season. Despite her luxurious condo and successful career, she feels a deep sense of loneliness and the weight of her past, including a failed marriage and the absence of children. Her professional life is filled with clients struggling with various mental health issues, particularly around the holidays.

The buzzer at her office interrupts her thoughts, and she discovers Bobby Dodge, the state trooper involved in the recent shooting, waiting outside. Despite the late hour, she agrees to see him, intrigued by his presence and the circumstances that brought him there. Bobby is hesitant and skeptical about therapy, asserting that he did his job and saved a woman and child. Elizabeth, noting his defensive stance, begins the session by explaining the parameters of their interaction, including the limited confidentiality due to his employment with the state police.

Elizabeth and Bobby delve into a brief discussion about the shooting, with Bobby expressing anger towards the man he had to shoot, Jimmy Gagnon. He questions the complexity of domestic abuse and the unusual reaction of Catherine Gagnon, who thanked him after the incident. Elizabeth provides a professional perspective, suggesting that while Catherine's reaction is less common, it is not entirely unheard of. The session ends with Elizabeth assigning Bobby some basic self-care tasks and scheduling a follow-up appointment for Monday.

Still reeling from the confrontation at the Gagnon residence, Bobby Dodge drives to the L Street Tavern in South Boston, seeking solace among fellow law enforcement officers. Initially intending to have a Coke, he yields to the encouragement of his peers and drinks several beers, gradually sinking into a state of inebriation. During his time at the bar, Bobby learns more about Jimmy Gagnon's history of domestic violence from Walt and Donny, two Boston PD officers. They recount Jimmy's erratic behavior, including throwing objects and punching holes in walls, and the neighbors' frequent complaints. However, they also reveal that the police never witnessed any direct violence from Jimmy, and Catherine Gagnon remained largely silent during their interventions. As Bobby contemplates the events of the night and the mixed reactions of his colleagues, his thoughts grow increasingly troubled. His drinking spree is abruptly interrupted by Lieutenant Jachrimo, who informs him of a new and alarming development: Maryanne Gagnon, the mother of the deceased Jimmy Gagnon and wife of a powerful judge, has filed a motion for a clerk-magistrate hearing to press criminal charges against Bobby. Despite the evidence of a justified shooting, Bobby could now face personal criminal charges, a situation that is unprecedented and deeply troubling. Already drained and confused, Bobby is further devastated by this news and the realization that his actions may have severe and far-reaching consequences.

Nathan, Catherine's four-year-old son, shows signs of severe stress and malnutrition, his condition alarming. When Maryanne and James, Jimmy's parents, arrive, they observe Nathan's poor health and make mental notes, suspecting foul play. Maryanne tries to pull Catherine aside for a private conversation, but Catherine resists, wary of her in-laws' intentions and the potential influence they could have over the new nanny, Prudence.

James, growing impatient, confronts Catherine, threatening her with the consequences of her actions. Despite the tension, Catherine remains composed, planning a funeral for Jimmy and waiting for her in-laws to leave. She reflects on her tumultuous relationship with Jimmy, including the abuse and infidelity, and the installation of a security system that she believes failed to record the night of the shooting. Despite everything, she acknowledges that she had loved Jimmy in her own way.

Catherine's thoughts turn to Nathan's recurring health issues, including severe pancreatitis, and the medical staff's concerns about his condition. Dr. Rocco, who has been treating Nathan, suggests a referral to Dr. Iorfino, indicating that he is being pressured to remove himself from the case. Catherine is devastated by this news, understanding that her father-in-law, James, is behind the decision. She leaves the hospital, determined to face the challenges ahead, including the legal battle initiated by Maryanne, who has served her with papers.

Bobby wakes up to a phone call from Catherine Gagnon, who thanks him for saving her life but also mentions the ongoing legal troubles. Despite his reluctance to engage, she convinces him to meet her at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, suggesting they share a common enemy. At the museum, Catherine reveals her complicated past with Jimmy, describing him as initially charming but later abusive, and explains that Jimmy's father, a powerful judge, often interfered with police investigations.

Catherine discloses that Jimmy's wealth was tied up in trusts controlled by his father, and now that Jimmy is dead, the money will go to Nathan, her son, in a trust. However, James and Maryanne are suing her for custody of Nathan, claiming she is harming him. She pleads with Bobby to help her, arguing that if she is found guilty of abusing Nathan, it will undermine the justification for Bobby's shooting of Jimmy. Bobby is visibly affected by her proximity and her emotional appeal, though he remains cautious.

Feeling the weight of the conversation, Bobby heads out for a run to clear his head, reflecting on the darkness within himself and the complexities of the situation. He contacts a hospital to check on Nathan's condition, learning that the boy is in the ICU with serious but stable pancreatitis and has had two broken bones in the past year. Concerned, Bobby decides to investigate further, snapping the yellow pages shut and heading for the shower, determined to speak with Dr. Rocco.

Still reeling from his meeting with Catherine Gagnon, Bobby Dodge receives a call from his father, Pop, who expresses concern and offers support. Bobby shares his emotional turmoil, admitting to having a few drinks the night before, and discusses his doubts about the shooting and its impact on Nathan, Jimmy's son. Pop listens and reassures Bobby, but the conversation highlights the strained relationship between them, as Bobby struggles to fully open up to his father.

At the hospital, Bobby seeks out Dr. Rocco to discuss Nathan Gagnon's medical condition. Dr. Rocco, who has been treating Nathan for the past year, explains that Nathan suffers from failure to thrive (FTT), characterized by malnutrition, developmental delays, and brittle bones. Despite extensive testing, the exact cause of Nathan's condition remains unknown. Dr. Rocco also reveals that he never met Jimmy Gagnon and suspects that Catherine was physically abused by her husband, though he never reported it due to fear of not being taken seriously.

Dr. Rocco admits to having a romantic relationship with Catherine, which ended after Jimmy discovered it and threatened to ruin Catherine's life. He also mentions that he was recently fired as Nathan's doctor, likely due to pressure from Judge Gagnon. Despite this, Dr. Rocco remains optimistic, referring Nathan to a geneticist, Dr. Iorfino, and hinting that he believes there might be more to Nathan's condition than meets the eye. The conversation leaves Bobby more confused and concerned about the complexities surrounding the Gagnon family.

Still reeling from the confrontation at the Gagnon residence, Bobby Dodge finds himself being followed by an investigator named Harris Reed. Initially hostile, Bobby is intrigued when Harris claims to have crucial information. Harris reveals that Catherine Gagnon, despite her tragic past, may not be the innocent victim she appears to be.

Harris recounts Catherine's background, painting her as a perfume spritzer in East Boston who quickly married the wealthy and generous Jimmy Gagnon. He describes how Catherine used her beauty and tragic history to manipulate Jimmy, leading to a troubled marriage and the birth of their son, Nathan. Harris emphasizes Catherine's mental breakdown after Nathan's birth and her inability to care for him, suggesting a darker side to her character.

Harris also reveals that Jimmy had planned to file for divorce just days before his death, and that Catherine's behavior, including her alleged manipulation of Nathan's health, may have played a role in the events leading to the hostage situation. He implies that Catherine might have orchestrated the entire scenario to get back at Jimmy, raising doubts about her motives and the true nature of the events that unfolded.

Harris warns Bobby that Catherine will try to manipulate him and that she is capable of cruelty, urging him to be cautious.

Mr. Bosu sits at a coffee bar in Faneuil Hall, his disappointment palpable as he sips a double mocha latte that fails to meet his standards. Recently released from prison after nearly twenty-five years, he reflects on the changes to the area and the bitter taste of freedom. Incarcerated for the rape of a young girl, Mr. Bosu was expected to be mellowed by age and time, but he feels a strong urge to commit violence once again.

His mind drifts back to his prison days, where he started in protective custody and later joined a neo-Nazi group for protection. Through acts of violence and manipulation, he rose to power, orchestrating a brutal attack in the prison cafeteria. Despite the challenges, he built a reputation as a feared figure, even from solitary confinement. Prison taught him the value of patience and the intricacies of the legal system.

Now free, Mr. Bosu has a clear plan: to use his skills and connections to make a significant amount of money by destroying lives. A list of chores provided by a mysterious benefactor fuels his determination to avoid repeating the mistake that landed him in prison—letting his victim live. The chapter ends with Mr. Bosu crushing his coffee cup and rising from the table, ready to begin his new life of calculated destruction.

Catherine drives to her father’s house, feeling bone-deep weary and emotionally drained. The familiar sights of her childhood neighborhood evoke painful memories, particularly of the trauma she endured as a child. She reflects on her relationship with Jimmy, acknowledging the years of abuse and the sharp pain she feels at his loss, despite the toxic nature of their marriage.

Upon arriving, Catherine finds her father waiting for her. The conversation is strained as she tries to discuss the legal troubles with the Gagnons, who are suing her for custody of Nathan. Her father’s reaction is unexpectedly cold and accusatory, questioning her motives and even suggesting that she might be harming Nathan. Catherine’s frustration and desperation boil over into a heated argument, revealing the deep-seated mistrust and emotional distance between them.

Catherine’s emotional state deteriorates rapidly, and she breaks down, overwhelmed by the lack of support from her father. Despite her pleas for his help, he remains distant and suggests that the Gagnons might be better suited to care for Nathan. Devastated and feeling utterly alone, Catherine leaves her father’s house, her mind racing with the dire consequences of losing her son. As she drives away, she notices a chilling message written in lipstick on her car window: ‘Boo!’

Bobby Dodge returns home to a barrage of messages, most from reporters clamoring for an exclusive interview. The thirtieth message, from Lieutenant John Bruni, invites him over for dinner to unwind. Despite the offer, Bobby feels isolated and contemplates drinking, driven by his emotional turmoil and the haunting memory of the shooting.

He decides to call Dr. Lane and heads to her office. Dressed more casually, she greets him and offers a Coke. The session begins with small talk, but Bobby quickly delves into his struggle with alcohol, revealing a history of drinking that led to a pact with his father to abstain. His recent relapse has left him feeling guilty and out of control, especially as he continues to see Jimmy Gagnon’s face in his mind.

Dr. Lane shares that she had a prior consultation with Judge Gagnon, who sought information about Munchausen by proxy, a condition where a caregiver fabricates or induces illness in a child. The judge was concerned about Catherine Gagnon potentially harming Nathan. Bobby is initially furious about this potential conflict of interest but calms down as Dr. Lane explains her limited involvement. The conversation shifts to Bobby’s background, his reasons for becoming a cop, and his skills as a sniper. Bobby’s discomfort with his natural talent for marksmanship and his tendency to isolate himself, particularly from his ex-girlfriend Susan, are explored.

The session ends with Bobby expressing a determination to uncover the truth about Catherine Gagnon, driven by a mix of guilt and a desire for justice. Dr. Lane’s attempt to reassure him falls on deaf ears, and Bobby leaves, his resolve hardened. The chapter concludes with a sense of impending conflict and the deepening of Bobby’s personal and professional challenges.

Catherine drives to the hospital to check on Nathan, finding him still asleep and under the care of a night nurse. The nurse reports that Nathan is stable, but Catherine is concerned about the quality of care and the hospital's crowded, understaffed conditions. She attempts to secure more nursing care for Nathan but is met with resistance and indifference from the hospital staff. Feeling increasingly paranoid and alone, Catherine leaves the hospital. She discovers a threatening message, 'Boo!', written in lipstick on her car window, which intensifies her fear. At home, she takes drastic measures to secure her townhouse, blocking the broken sliding glass door with a bureau and nailing the master bedroom door shut. She enlists Prudence's help and discusses the possibility of going on vacation to escape the current chaos.

Meanwhile, Dr. Rocco reflects on his long and frustrating day at the hospital. He contemplates his career and his troubled marriage, feeling trapped by the demands of his job and his nagging wife. His thoughts turn to Catherine, and he recalls their passionate affair, which began nine months ago. Driven by a desire to break free from his current constraints, he decides to drive to Catherine's house to apologize and offer his support.

At two a.m., Bobby Dodge is jolted awake by a call from Harris Reed, an investigator working for the Gagnons. Harris informs him of a crime scene involving Dr. Rocco, Nathan Gagnon's doctor. Despite his exhaustion, Bobby heads to the hospital parking garage, where he meets Detective D.D. Warren, a former colleague from Boston Homicide, who is investigating the scene. D.D. reveals the gruesome details: Dr. Rocco was brutally murdered, his body dismembered, and the crime meticulously concealed to avoid detection.

D.D. and Bobby discuss the case, with D.D. suggesting that the murder was likely committed by a jealous spouse or someone with surgical knowledge. She also mentions that the ADA, Rick Copley, is investigating Catherine Gagnon's potential involvement in Jimmy's death and her connection to Dr. Rocco. Bobby is skeptical about Catherine's involvement but acknowledges the complexity of the situation. The discovery of a message written in lipstick on the car window, reading 'Boo,' adds a personal and ominous touch to the crime.

Later, Bobby and D.D. meet at a local diner to continue their discussion. D.D. warns Bobby about the risks of being seen with Catherine, as it could implicate him in the ongoing investigation. She also expresses concern about Bobby's involvement in the lawsuit filed by Maryanne Gagnon. The conversation delves into the psychological aspects of their jobs, with D.D. asking Bobby about his emotional state after the shooting. Bobby's response, that he felt nothing, reveals the emotional toll of his profession and the detachment required to perform his duties.

Still reeling from the gruesome discovery at the hospital parking garage, Bobby Dodge is intercepted by Harris Reed, who insists that Bobby meet with the Gagnons. Reluctantly, Bobby agrees, driven by a mix of curiosity and the pressure of the lawsuit looming over him. The Gagnons, ensconced in a luxurious penthouse suite at the Hotel LeRoux, present themselves as grieving parents, with Maryanne appearing fragile and James dominating the conversation.

James Gagnon skillfully interrogates Bobby about the events of the night Jimmy died, challenging Bobby’s account and suggesting that Catherine may have provoked the confrontation. His questions are designed to cast doubt on Bobby’s decision to shoot Jimmy, hinting at a potential trial where Bobby’s actions will be scrutinized. Maryanne, initially silent and tearful, speaks of her son’s kindness, adding a personal and emotional layer to the Gagnons' grievances.

Bobby realizes the Gagnons are attempting to manipulate him, offering to drop the lawsuit if he helps them portray Catherine as the true culprit. Despite the pressure, Bobby refuses to comply, understanding the implications of their demands. As he leaves, Maryanne’s poignant plea about her son’s annual Mother’s Day gift underscores the depth of her loss, leaving Bobby with a heavy heart and a renewed sense of the complexity of the situation.

Feeling a growing sense of paranoia and isolation, Catherine wakes up to find Prudence, her nanny, already gone for the day. She turns on lights throughout the house, unable to shake the feeling that something is terribly wrong. Reflecting on the traumatic birth of her son, Nathan, and the emotional relief she felt when he was born, she contrasts this with the darkness of her past abuse. Her thoughts are plagued by vivid, terrifying memories of her childhood and her relationship with Jimmy, leading her to feel increasingly unstable.

Preparing to bring Nathan home from the hospital, Catherine arms herself with a Taser she keeps in a safe. However, she discovers that the Taser is missing, likely taken as evidence by the police. As she is about to leave, the doorbell rings, and she is confronted by Rick Copley, the ADA, Detective D.D. Warren, and Investigator Rob Casella. They inform her that they have questions about the events of the night Jimmy died, and despite her protests, they enter her home.

During the interrogation, the investigators question Catherine about the security camera in the master bedroom, which was allegedly not recording at the time of the incident. They also probe into her relationship with Dr. Rocco and the circumstances leading to the confrontation with Jimmy. Catherine maintains her composure, insisting that Jimmy was the one who brought up the gun and that she was trying to protect Nathan. The blonde detective, D.D. Warren, becomes increasingly aggressive, insinuating that Catherine might have been involved in Jimmy's death and in Dr. Rocco's murder. Catherine is shocked and terrified when they reveal that Dr. Rocco was murdered the previous night, and that no gunshot residue was found on Jimmy’s hands or clothes, suggesting that someone else might have fired the gun.

Mr. Bosu strolls through the Public Garden on a crisp Sunday morning, eschewing a coat as he contrasts his bare skin with the bundled-up Bostonians. His mind drifts to his childhood, a mix of fond and harrowing memories, culminating in the pivotal moment when he was labeled a kidnapper. Despite the gravity of his past, he feels a peculiar sense of nostalgia and a strange kinship with his younger self.

Recently released from prison, Mr. Bosu contemplates the new opportunities before him. He has transformed from a menacing ex-con into a well-dressed, middle-aged gentleman, thanks to the intervention of a mysterious benefactor. He pauses at a Gothic cathedral, watching families exit the church, especially the children. His predatory instincts flare, but he reins them in, remembering the thrill of his recent murder.

Reflecting on his arrangement with the benefactor, Mr. Bosu considers the list of targets and the promised payments. He remains cautious about opening a bank account, preferring the anonymity of cash. Deciding to savor the freedom of his new life, he descends the church steps, whistling a tune, and sets off to find a puppy. The chapter concludes with Mr. Bosu’s calculated control and the dark undercurrents of his intentions.

Bobby Dodge visits Harvey Jones, a small-town lawyer, to discuss the clerk-magistrate hearing initiated by James Gagnon. Harvey explains the process, emphasizing the challenges Bobby faces due to the political clout of Judge Gagnon and the lack of independent corroboration of Bobby’s actions. Harvey suggests strategies to bolster Bobby’s credibility, such as highlighting his training and experience, but warns that the Gagnon family will likely dig into Bobby’s personal life to discredit him. Bobby is deeply concerned about his father potentially being called to testify, a prospect he strongly opposes. Harvey acknowledges the risk and the potential consequences if Bobby’s father is subpoenaed. With a heavy heart, Bobby writes a substantial check for a retainer, fully aware that the legal battle ahead will be both prolonged and costly. He leaves the office feeling overwhelmed and uncertain about his chances of winning.

Later, Bobby visits the Massachusetts Rifle Association’s shooting range to practice. His shooting is unusually poor, and he feels a mix of sadness and anger. He watches J.T. Dillon, a renowned shooter, who provides some advice and shares his own experiences with violence and its aftermath. Dillon’s story about his family and his wife, Tess, who killed Jim Beckett, offers Bobby a glimmer of hope and a reminder of the importance of finding an anchor in life.

Catherine arrives at the hospital to pick up Nathan, only to find her in-laws, James and Maryanne, attempting to take Nathan home with them. James uses his charm and authority to persuade the nurse, but the nurse hesitates upon discovering that Nathan’s pediatrician, Dr. Rocco, is no longer available. Catherine intervenes, asserting her role as Nathan’s legal guardian and insisting on taking him home herself. Despite James’s protests and threats, Dr. Gerritsen, the head of Pediatrics, confirms that Catherine has the legal right to take Nathan home.

Inside the hospital room, Catherine comforts Nathan, who is subdued and asks about Prudence, the nanny. She reassures him that they are going home and tries to ease his fears about the recent events. However, James and Maryanne appear with Dr. Gerritsen, attempting to argue for Nathan’s custody based on concerns for his safety. Catherine defends herself, emphasizing her commitment to Nathan’s well-being and questioning the motives of her in-laws. Dr. Gerritsen ultimately sides with Catherine, stating that he cannot legally interfere with her guardianship.

After a tense exchange, Catherine and Nathan leave the hospital. On the way home, Nathan remains quiet, and Catherine reflects on the isolation she feels from her neighbors. Instead of going directly home, she takes Nathan to the Public Garden, where they feed the ducks and sit on a bench. Catherine gently probes Nathan about the events of the night Jimmy died, ensuring he understands that it is important to tell the truth to the authorities. Nathan confirms that Jimmy had a gun and that they were scared, which provides Catherine with the information she needs to protect herself and Nathan.

Bobby steps into his home, only to find ADA Rick Copley, D.D. Warren, and Investigator Casella waiting for him. Irritated, he invites them in without offering any pleasantries. The visitors immediately launch into a series of questions about his relationship with Susan Abrahms and his interactions with the Gagnons at social events, hinting that Bobby may have had more contact with them than he remembers.

Bobby denies any significant interactions with the Gagnons and dismisses the idea that he was jealous of Jimmy’s attention toward Susan. Undeterred, Copley and Casella press him further, revealing details about Catherine Gagnon’s strict dietary rules for Nathan and her firing of a housekeeper for feeding him. They also mention the security camera in the master bedroom, which was tampered with on the night of the shooting, suggesting that Catherine may have been involved in orchestrating the events leading to Jimmy’s death.

Copley insinuates that Bobby may have inadvertently aided Catherine by sharing information about his work with the STOP team, or that their relationship went deeper than he admits. As the conversation turns to the murder of Dr. Rocco, Copley asks Bobby about his whereabouts the previous night. Enraged by the insinuations, Bobby dismisses them and slams the door.

Robinson answers a phone call from an irate client, who is upset about Mr. Bosu’s recent botched assignment. The client demands that the next job be handled more discreetly, but Mr. Bosu is demanding a higher fee of thirty thousand dollars instead of the original ten thousand. The client is furious and threatens to put Mr. Bosu back in jail, but Robinson points out the difficulty of catching Mr. Bosu, who seems to have a knack for evading capture.

Mr. Bosu, meanwhile, buys a puppy from a pet store, naming it Trickster. He enjoys the puppy’s company and the freedom of walking it around Boston. During one of their walks, Mr. Bosu meets a stylish, recently divorced woman who flirts with him. He plays along, exchanging pleasantries and a bit of dark humor, which she interprets as playful. The interaction ends with the woman giving Mr. Bosu her contact information, and he promises to call her.

Mr. Bosu and Trickster reach a residential street in downtown Boston, where Mr. Bosu sits on a bench near the target’s apartment. He reflects on his childhood and his first dog, Popeye, who was killed by a neighbor’s car. This event led to Mr. Bosu’s first act of revenge, damaging the neighbor’s car to cause an accident. Now, with Trickster by his side, Mr. Bosu waits patiently, ready to carry out his next assignment.

Still reeling from recent events, Bobby goes for a long run to clear his mind. He reflects on his past, particularly his mother's departure when he was six, and the profound impact it had on him and his brother, George. Bobby wonders why his mother never tried to contact them, and this introspection fuels his emotional turmoil.

After his run, Bobby calls Susan to meet at a Starbucks. The meeting is tense and emotional, with Susan expressing her frustration and hurt over Bobby's recent behavior. She accuses him of running away from their relationship and not giving it a chance. Bobby admits to panicking and feeling overwhelmed, but Susan's accusations hit hard, and she reveals that she has been breaking things in her anger. Bobby's own temper rises, and they end up yelling at each other, with Bobby admitting that the relationship is all they have left.

Susan then addresses Bobby's concerns about the Gagnons, confirming that he only met them once at a function. She suggests that Bobby's reaction to Jimmy Gagnon watching her might have influenced his memory. Bobby shares his fears about the lawsuit and the possibility of going to jail. Susan tries to reassure him, but Bobby is pessimistic, believing that Judge Gagnon will twist the facts to his advantage. Susan hints that Bobby remembers Catherine Gagnon better than he thinks, suggesting that she made a strong impression on him.

Catherine and Nathan are in the family room, where Nathan is watching his favorite movie, Finding Nemo, for the second time. Catherine is anxious about Prudence's absence and the upcoming appointment with Dr. Iorfino. Nathan's behavior becomes increasingly erratic, culminating in him pouring his soy milk on the carpet and declaring that Catherine is trying to kill him. Despite her growing panic, Catherine manages to calm Nathan and clean up the mess together.

Bobby, feeling restless and self-destructive, paces his family room, gnawing on cold pizza and drinking Coke. He contemplates calling his brother or Dr. Lane but is interrupted by a call from Catherine, who claims an intruder has broken into her house. Despite his skepticism, Bobby sees this as an opportunity to get his gun and heads to the Gagnon residence.

Upon arriving, Bobby finds Catherine and Nathan in the lobby and immediately heads upstairs to investigate. He systematically clears each floor, noticing the distinct odor of death as he ascends. Reaching the fourth floor, he discovers the master bedroom, where Prudence Walker's body hangs from the rafters, surrounded by flickering candles, creating a macabre scene.

In the parlor, Bobby and Catherine discuss the grim discovery of Prudence Walker's body. Catherine is bewildered by the note left with the body, which claims Prudence hanged herself due to despondency over Jimmy’s death. She dismisses this, revealing that Prudence was a lesbian and not interested in Jimmy. Catherine suspects that James, her father-in-law, orchestrated Prudence's death to frame her and take custody of Nathan, emphasizing James’s control and manipulation.

Catherine’s desperation and erratic behavior intensify as she tries to manipulate Bobby, offering him a series of increasingly graphic sexual scenarios to distract him from the investigation. Initially drawn in by her advances, Bobby recoils when he realizes the depth of her trauma and the darkness of her past. He firmly rejects her advances, twisting her hands behind her back and warning her to stop. The encounter leaves both of them shaken, with Bobby seeing the little girl who was once trapped in the dark and feeling a deep sense of detachment.

Catherine, realizing her manipulation has failed, becomes more aggressive, threatening to confess that she and Bobby are lovers and that the shooting was staged. Bobby counters her threats by pointing out the inconsistencies in Prudence’s supposed suicide, noting the lack of physical evidence of hanging. He explains that Prudence was likely murdered and staged to look like a suicide, and that the note’s contents are now in doubt. Catherine, visibly shaken, admits her fear of losing Nathan and explains the strict dietary restrictions and medical issues surrounding Nathan’s health, revealing that Jimmy and his parents often undermined her efforts to care for their son.

D.D. storms into the Gagnon residence, visibly angry with Bobby for his involvement in the scene. She accuses him of being a 'fucking idiot' for responding to Catherine's call instead of notifying the Boston Police Department (BPD). Bobby explains that he came because he suspected the call was a ploy to discuss the shooting, but he also admits to feeling deeply conflicted and desperate for answers or validation of his actions.

Bobby recounts his actions upon arriving at the townhouse, describing how he saw the silhouette of a hanging body in the fourth-story window and conducted a full sweep of the residence, discovering Prudence Walker's body. He tells D.D. that Catherine was concerned about the police's interpretation of the suicide note and feared it might affect her custody battle with her in-laws. Bobby admits to telling Catherine that the police would recognize the suicide as staged, which D.D. criticizes as interfering with the investigation.

Bobby reveals that Judge Gagnon offered to drop all charges against him if he testified that Catherine provoked Jimmy into pointing the gun. He mentions a five o'clock deadline for his decision, suggesting that the judge is in a hurry. Bobby believes that James Gagnon is behind the murders of Dr. Rocco and Prudence Walker, as both were allies of Catherine. D.D. remains skeptical, citing the judge's influence and legal expertise, but Bobby insists that the judge is isolating Catherine and may be acting out of desperation to gain custody of Nathan.

D.D. interviews Catherine in the parlor, questioning her about Prudence's last known activities and the security of the house. Catherine provides limited information, stating that she had been out with Nathan and the security system was set when she returned. She denies knowing much about Prudence's local associates or the origin of the candles and rope found in the bedroom. Catherine also reveals that Prudence had been a reliable nanny but had not visited Nathan in the hospital, raising suspicions about her whereabouts and motives.

At 2 a.m., Mr. Bosu is jolted awake by Trickster, his new puppy, who insists on going outside. Reluctantly, he rises, dresses, and steps into the cool night air. The walk offers Mr. Bosu a moment of clarity and reflection, allowing him to mull over the unfairness of life and his recent disappointment in failing to connect with Prudence Walker, the young nanny he had approached earlier that evening.

Prudence’s words about the dysfunctional Gagnon family echo in his mind. She described Catherine as cold and controlling, particularly with Nathan’s diet, while Jimmy was abusive and inappropriate. Mr. Bosu’s frustration intensifies as he realizes Prudence is not interested in him. In a moment of dark resolve, he makes a fatal decision. He grabs Prudence, suffocates her, and stages her death to appear as a suicide, driven by a mix of resentment and disillusionment.

The task becomes more complex as Mr. Bosu must dispose of Prudence’s body and stage the scene convincingly. He hot-wires a car, transports the body to the Gagnon townhouse, and meticulously arranges the macabre scene with candles and a suicide note. Memories of his past and his fixation on Catherine, whom he had once held captive, haunt him throughout the process. Finally, he leaves the scene, feeling a sense of closure and anticipation for his next move.

In a state of extreme distress, Bobby Dodge calls Dr. Elizabeth Lane late at night, expressing his fears and paranoia about the ongoing investigation and the legal troubles he faces. Arriving at her office, he is visibly agitated and on the brink of a breakdown. Elizabeth, noting his manic energy and the severity of his condition, tries to calm him down by offering him water and encouraging him to explain his concerns.

Bobby reveals the complex web of accusations and pressures he is facing, including the judge's offer to drop charges if he implicates Catherine Gagnon, the ADA's suspicions, and the lack of support from his fellow officers. He also discusses his recent interactions with Catherine, the murders of Dr. Rocco and Prudence Walker, and his growing belief that Catherine is in genuine danger. Despite his reservations, Bobby admits that he feels compelled to help Catherine, though he recognizes the risks to his career and mental health.

The conversation shifts to Bobby's troubled past, specifically his mother's abandonment when he was a child. He describes the violent abuse his father inflicted on his mother and brother, and the traumatic night his mother left, leaving Bobby and his brother with their abusive father. Bobby's feelings of anger and betrayal toward his mother are evident, and he draws a parallel between his mother's actions and his current situation with Catherine. Elizabeth understands the deep emotional roots of Bobby's actions and the pain he carries, recognizing that Bobby is struggling with a world of hurt.

The police wrap up their investigation at Catherine’s house, and the space gradually returns to a semblance of normalcy. However, Catherine feels increasingly anxious and vulnerable as the crime scene techs depart, leaving her home feeling violated and unsafe. She stands watch in the front parlor, trying to ensure Nathan gets some rest, but her thoughts are haunted by the recent horrors and the looming shadows.

James Gagnon arrives, offering to take Catherine and Nathan to the LeRoux, but she forcefully ejects him, standing up to his threats. Later, Catherine discovers that all the light bulbs in Nathan's room and closet have been removed and arranged to spell 'BOO'. Fearing for their safety, Catherine and Nathan flee the house in the middle of the night.

In a therapy session with Dr. Elizabeth Lane, Bobby Dodge reveals that he lied about the pact he made with his father regarding drinking. He admits to fabricating explanations to hide the truth of his father’s abuse. Dr. Lane points out that Bobby is still engaging in the same patterns of lying and avoidance that he did as a child, suggesting that he needs to confront his past to move forward. Bobby opens up about his deep-seated anger and feelings of hopelessness, acknowledging that his past influences his present actions. He discusses his recent interactions with Catherine Gagnon and the murders of Dr. Rocco and Prudence Walker. Dr. Lane challenges Bobby’s perception of Catherine, suggesting that she might be more manipulative and capable of causing her husband’s death than he realizes. Bobby, despite his reservations, begins to consider the possibility that Catherine might have engineered the shooting.

Catherine and Nathan, desperate for a safe place, arrive at the Ritz-Carlton. Catherine is shocked when her credit card is declined, and her bank account is frozen. Realizing that her father-in-law, James, is behind these actions, she feels cornered. Briefly considering handing over Nathan to James for money, she ultimately decides against it. Catherine calls a number, pleading for help, as she and Nathan have nowhere else to go.

Mr. Bosu, determined to complete his latest assignment, surveils the home of a fifty-thousand-dollar man, noting the challenges posed by the densely populated neighborhood, the ADT security system, and the unexpected light inside the house. The densely populated area makes it difficult to remain unnoticed, and the ADT security system adds another layer of complexity. To execute his plan, Mr. Bosu decides to use Trickster, his puppy, as a prop to gain entry. He cuts his own arm and smears the blood on Trickster, staging a fake accident to lure the man out.

When ADA Rick Copley opens the door, Mr. Bosu plays the part of a distressed driver who accidentally hit a dog. Copley, being a compassionate individual, invites Mr. Bosu inside to help the injured puppy. Once inside, Mr. Bosu quickly reveals his true intentions, attacking Copley with a knife. Despite Copley’s attempts to defend himself and call for help, Mr. Bosu, with his superior strength and determination, corners and kills Copley in the bathroom, turning the man’s home into a gruesome execution chamber.

In the aftermath, Mr. Bosu meticulously cleans up the crime scene, washing his hands, cleaning his shoes, and using bleach to obscure blood trails. He retrieves Trickster, who has hidden under a bed, and reassures the puppy. As he prepares to leave, the phone rings, and Mr. Bosu listens to a message from D.D. Warren, expressing concerns about Bobby Dodge’s involvement with Catherine Gagnon. Realizing the significance of his actions, Mr. Bosu decides to use this information to please his benefactor, plotting his next move.

Bobby wakes up on Monday morning, feeling the physical toll of his recent ordeals. He had fallen asleep on the couch after a long night, and his body aches from the uncomfortable position. Despite the pain, he recognizes the need to act quickly, given the five p.m. deadline set by Judge Gagnon. Bobby decides to meet with Harris Reed and heads to the bathroom for a quick shower to clear his mind.

Meanwhile, Robinson, feeling increasingly nervous, decides to flee town. He packs a bag with essential items, including credit cards and fake IDs, and prepares to leave. Before he can depart, Mr. Bosu appears, stopping him from escaping. Mr. Bosu, who has been following the developments at the Gagnon residence, confronts Robinson, effectively trapping him.

At her father’s house, Catherine is deeply troubled by the recent events, including the murders of Prudence and Dr. Rocco, and the growing suspicion that James Gagnon is behind these crimes. Her father, however, remains skeptical and dismissive of her fears, believing that a man of James’s stature would not resort to murder. Catherine feels increasingly isolated and desperate, especially when she receives a call from Dr. Iorfino’s office, requesting a private meeting. Her anxiety spikes further when her father informs her that Richard Umbrio, her former captor, has been released from prison, sending her into a state of shock and fear.

Bobby meets Harris Reed at Bogey’s diner, where Harris is in a good mood, thinking Bobby has come to submit to Judge Gagnon’s demands. Instead, Bobby drops a bomb by mentioning the recent murder of Prudence Walker, suggesting that the judge might be behind it. Harris, initially dismissive, becomes visibly uncomfortable as Bobby presses him for information about the judge’s connections and the meaning of the ‘Boo’ message found at the crime scenes. Harris reveals that Judge Gagnon asked him to investigate a woman named Colleen Robinson, known for connecting people with ‘odd jobs.’ He provides Bobby with Colleen’s cell phone number and discloses that while he can find records of James Gagnon’s past, Maryanne Gagnon seemingly does not exist before 1965, raising more questions about the judge’s background. Determined to uncover the truth, Bobby leaves the diner and calls Catherine, informing her that he knows who the judge hired to commit the murders.

Meanwhile, at the doctor’s office, Catherine reveals that Richard Umbrio, her former captor, has been released from prison. She explains that the judge must have pulled strings to facilitate his early release. Catherine is visibly shaken, recounting the terrifying incident with the night-lights and the ‘Boo’ message, which she believes was left by Umbrio. She admits to Bobby that she never denied harming Jimmy. Bobby, feeling a deep sense of responsibility, pulls her into a brief, comforting embrace, but they are interrupted by the doctor’s receptionist, who calls Catherine in for her appointment.

Mr. Bosu, feeling the physical and emotional toll of his recent murders, stops at a convenience store to buy Puppy Chow for Trickster and a Red Bull for himself. He toasts to Robinson, now dead, and appreciates the new car, documents, and cash he has acquired from her. With renewed energy, Mr. Bosu prepares for his next task, hinting at the complexity of his plans.

Meanwhile, Bobby and Catherine meet with Dr. Iorfino, a geneticist who has been analyzing Nathan’s medical history and test results. Dr. Iorfino reveals that Nathan does not have food allergies but suffers from a rare genetic disorder called Fanconi-Bickel syndrome, which affects his ability to metabolize glucose and galactose. This diagnosis brings a sense of relief to Catherine, who has been searching for answers for years. However, the doctor also mentions that Fanconi-Bickel is an inherited defect, often seen in families with a history of incest.

Bobby connects the dots, suggesting that the genetic disorder points to a dark secret within the Gagnon family. He theorizes that James and Maryanne Gagnon are related and have a history of incest, which they covered up by moving to Massachusetts and adopting new identities. This revelation explains the judge’s intense desire to gain custody of Nathan, as the boy’s condition could expose their family’s deepest, darkest secret.

Bobby and Catherine step out of Dr. Iorfino’s office, still processing the shocking news about Nathan’s genetic disorder. As they prepare to call Catherine’s father, Bobby’s phone rings. It’s D.D., her voice urgent and suspicious. She immediately questions Bobby’s whereabouts and his relationship with Catherine, hinting at a deeper conspiracy.

D.D. reveals that the ballistics report on Jimmy Gagnon’s gun shows it was never fired. Instead, a second gun, registered to Catherine, was found with her fingerprints and recently fired rounds. D.D. suggests that Catherine framed Bobby, manipulating the situation to ensure Jimmy’s death. She also accuses Bobby of being involved in the murder of Rick Copley, a crime scene that involved a knife, which D.D. believes Bobby used.

Bobby is stunned and denies the accusations, explaining that Richard Umbrio, Catherine’s former captor, was recently released from prison by Judge Gagnon. He believes Umbrio is behind the murders. D.D. counters with the fact that Copley wrote Bobby’s name in his own blood before dying. Bobby insists that Colleen Robinson, a middleman hired by the judge, is the key to unraveling the mystery. He refuses to turn himself in, citing his need to protect Catherine from further danger.

Back in the lobby, Bobby confronts Catherine, accusing her of using him and lying about the events of the night Jimmy died. Catherine defends herself, explaining that she acted out of desperation to protect Nathan from James Gagnon. She slaps Bobby in anger, and he nearly retaliates but stops himself, remembering his past. Catherine reveals that Richard Umbrio answered her father’s phone, indicating that Umbrio is targeting her family.

Mr. Bosu arrives at Catherine's father's house, having meticulously prepared for this encounter. He has gathered extensive information about Catherine and her family, finding a deep connection to her through their shared traumatic pasts. Whistling as he approaches the house, he feels a chilling sense of control and destiny. Frank Miller, Catherine's father, answers the door cautiously. Mr. Bosu, posing as a detective, gains entry by pretending to have news about Richard Umbrio. Recognizing Mr. Bosu from the past, Frank reacts violently, striking him and attempting to defend himself. Despite Frank's initial success, Mr. Bosu quickly overpowers him, using a knife to fatally wound him. Frank's bravery and refusal to leave Nathan unprotected are noted by Mr. Bosu, who admires the old man's nobility even as he kills him.

After cleaning up, Mr. Bosu searches the house and finds Nathan in a bedroom. Nathan, small and pale, greets Mr. Bosu hopefully, mistaking him for his mother. Mr. Bosu, playing on the boy's trust, offers to show him a puppy. Nathan, trusting and desperate for companionship, holds out his hand. As they leave, Mr. Bosu answers the ringing phone, speaking to Catherine and pretending to be her father, telling her that Nathan says hi.

Bobby and Catherine decide they need a gun and quickly leave the hospital, taking a back route to avoid security. Bobby calls his father, Pop, for a weapon, despite the police surveillance at Pop’s house. Pop agrees to help and meets them at Castle Island with a handgun and extra ammunition.

Mr. Bosu, driving with Nathan and Trickster, calls Judge Gagnon, demanding $250,000 for Nathan’s safe return. The judge, however, is uncooperative and threatens to call the police, revealing his intention to handle Nathan himself. Enraged by the judge’s betrayal, Mr. Bosu decides to confront him directly. Nathan, unaware of the danger, innocently mentions that his grandfather is staying at the Hotel LeRoux.

Bobby and Catherine arrive at Frank Miller’s house, only to find him dead. Bobby recovers a shotgun and a box of shells, confirming that Frank had put up a fierce fight. They decide to go to Judge Gagnon’s townhouse, but upon arrival, they find it deserted. Realizing that the judge is on the run, Bobby decides to head to the Hotel LeRoux, where they believe the judge and Nathan are located.

Still reeling from the discovery of Frank Miller’s body, Bobby and Catherine discuss the judge's motivations, concluding that he wants to discredit Catherine rather than kill her, to prevent her from uncovering the family's dark secrets. Catherine realizes that if she dies, others like Dr. Rocco and her father could still pose a threat. The judge's plan involves framing Catherine for poisoning Nathan, but Bobby suggests, with a grim determination, that the judge might harm Nathan to eliminate the risk.

Meanwhile, Mr. Bosu arrives at the Hotel LeRoux with Nathan and Trickster. Despite the hotel's strict security policies, Mr. Bosu devises a cunning plan to get Nathan to the judge's suite. He convinces the receptionist to send Nathan up with a bellhop, under the pretense of needing medical attention for a cut. As soon as the bellhop leaves with Nathan, Mr. Bosu ambushes him, steals his keycard, and makes his way to the penthouse floor.

Bobby and Catherine arrive at the hotel and learn that Nathan has already been taken upstairs. Recognizing the urgency, Bobby coerces a valet for a pass key, and they race to the penthouse. Upon entering, they find Harris Reed dead, and the eerie silence of the suite heightens their tension. A child's lullaby plays softly, guiding them to the left wing of the suite. Suddenly, they hear a woman screaming, and Catherine recognizes it as Maryanne.

Bobby and Catherine burst into the suite, finding Maryanne sobbing over James Gagnon's lifeless body. Bobby, already wounded by Umbrio, struggles to maintain his balance and aims his gun. Umbrio, covered in blood, confronts Catherine and taunts her. In a desperate attempt, Catherine fires, but her shots miss, and Umbrio flees into another room. Bobby and Catherine tend to his injury, using a pillowcase as a makeshift bandage, while Maryanne reveals the harrowing events leading to James’s current state.

Maryanne explains that James had tried to protect her from Umbrio but was overpowered. She also confesses that she and James are half-siblings, and that James orchestrated the deaths of her family to be with her. James, now dying, admits his love for Maryanne, but Catherine accuses him of murdering innocent people and releasing Umbrio to kill her and Nathan. Maryanne is horrified by the revelations, and James, in his final moments, still insists that Catherine was never good enough for his son.

Meanwhile, Mr. Bosu, tired of the game, decides to focus on capturing Nathan. He searches the suite and finds the hall closet, realizing it's the perfect hiding spot for a child afraid of the dark. As he approaches the closet, the chapter ends with the tension building, leaving the fate of Nathan and the others in suspense.

Bobby and Catherine, along with the injured Maryanne and the dying James, find themselves cornered at the Hotel LeRoux. Still reeling from the traumatic events, Bobby, despite his own wounds, is resolute in protecting Catherine and Nathan. They quickly devise a plan to lure Richard Umbrio into a trap, with Catherine playing a crucial role by confronting him in the hallway.

Mr. Bosu, now revealed as Richard Umbrio, prowls the hotel suite, searching for Nathan. After a futile search in a closet, he is drawn to Catherine, who stands at the end of the hallway. Catherine buys time by engaging Umbrio in a conversation, appealing to his ego and recalling their shared history. Umbrio, nostalgic and taunting, advances on her, but she strategically leads him into the trap set by Bobby.

Bobby, positioned behind a coffee table, ambushes Umbrio as he lunges at Catherine. He fires three shots, gravely wounding Umbrio. However, the gun is empty, and Umbrio, still alive, grabs Catherine. In a moment of desperation, Catherine finds a gun hidden under the sofa and shoots Umbrio, killing him. The police and hotel security arrive, and Bobby is arrested, while Catherine is reunited with Nathan, who had been hiding in the suite.

January's harshness mirrors Bobby Dodge's somber reflections during his final therapy session with Dr. Elizabeth Lane. They delve into his family dynamics, particularly his strained relationship with his brother George and his complex feelings about his mother, who abandoned the family. Bobby reveals that he and his father recently discussed the night his mother left, sharing vague memories that have allowed them to move on, unlike George. As the session concludes, Bobby contemplates his future in law enforcement, feeling a sense of redemption and forward momentum.