Chapter 1 Nick Dunne: the Day Of
Nick Dunne wakes up at exactly 6:00 AM, an unusual time for him, feeling a sense of foreboding. The morning sunlight feels accusatory, and he reflects on his life in the rented suburban house he shares with his wife, Amy. The house is a compromise, but Amy sees it as a punishment, a stark contrast to the New York lifestyle they once enjoyed. The house's opulence is a reminder of the economic downturn that forced them to move back to Nick's hometown in Missouri. Nick reminisces about his career as a writer in New York, where he thrived until the magazine industry collapsed. Both he and Amy lost their jobs, leading to a period of aimlessness and despair. His twin sister, Margo, called to inform him that their mother was terminally ill, prompting Nick to decide to move back to Missouri. Despite Amy's reluctance, Nick believed the move would be beneficial, but it has only led to tension and unhappiness. On this particular morning, Nick hears Amy bustling in the kitchen, preparing a special breakfast for their five-year anniversary. Despite the festive atmosphere, Nick feels a deep sense of dread and disconnection from his wife. He observes her humming the theme from M*A*S*H, a song that carries a dark undertone. The memory of their early relationship, when Amy's quirks endeared her to him, now feels cold and distant. Nick arrives late at the bar he and Margo opened, a place that serves as a reminder of his adult status and a source of income. The bar, named The Bar, is a mix of vintage charm and haphazard design, reflecting the town's decline. As he walks to the bar, he notices a group of men walking along the river, their eyes downcast. The sight unnerves him, and he rushes inside, feeling a pressing need for a drink.
Key Events
- Nick wakes up at 6:00 AM feeling uneasy.
- Nick reflects on the economic downturn that forced him and Amy to move back to Missouri.
- Amy prepares a special breakfast for their five-year anniversary, but Nick feels disconnected from her.
- Nick arrives late at the bar he co-owns with his sister, feeling the need for a drink.
Characters Introduced
- Nick Dunne
- Margo Dunne
Themes
- Marital dissatisfaction
- Economic hardship
- Identity and self-perception
- Ominous premonition
Chapter 2 Amy Elliott: January 8, 2005
Amy Elliott's diary entry dated January 8, 2005, captures her elation and excitement upon meeting a new man at a writers' party in Brooklyn. Initially reluctant to attend, Amy goes at the urging of a semi-friend, Carmen. At the party, she feels out of place among accomplished writers but is drawn to a confident, attractive man with a Missouri accent. He engages her with humor and charm, making her feel special and desired. Unlike others, he doesn’t inquire about her job writing personality quizzes for women’s magazines, focusing instead on connecting with her personally. Their interaction culminates in a shared taxi ride through the cold night, where a surreal moment occurs when a bakery is being delivered powdered sugar, creating a cloud of sweetness around them. In this magical setting, the man, later revealed to be Nick, pulls Amy close, brushes sugar from her lips, and kisses her, marking the beginning of their relationship. Amy's diary entry captures the thrill and promise of this new connection, setting the stage for the complexities to come.
Key Events
- Amy attends a writers' party in Brooklyn.
- Amy meets and is charmed by Nick.
- Amy and Nick share a taxi ride and a romantic moment in the powdered sugar cloud.
Characters Introduced
- Carmen
Themes
- Identity and self-perception
- The transformative power of first encounters
- The contrast between personal and professional identity
Chapter 3 Nick Dunne: the Day Of
Nick seeks solace at the bar he co-owns with his sister, Margo, a place that blends vintage charm with haphazard design. Margo, ever perceptive, notices Nick's agitation and tries to lighten the mood with her usual mix of sarcasm and affection, offering him a beer and engaging in playful, albeit slightly raunchy, banter about his marriage to Amy. As they reminisce about their childhood, Nick confides in Margo about his concerns regarding Amy's upcoming anniversary treasure hunt, a task that seems increasingly daunting and unsettling.
Key Events
- Nick visits the bar he co-owns with Margo.
- Margo and Nick engage in playful, sibling-like banter.
- Nick discusses his concerns about Amy's upcoming anniversary treasure hunt with Margo.
Characters Introduced
- Sue
- Carl Pelley
Themes
- Sibling Bond
- Marital Strain
- Anxiety and Uncertainty
Chapter 4 Amy Elliott: September 18, 2005
September 18, 2005, marks an unexpected reunion for Amy Elliott with Nick Dunne. After eight months of silence, Nick reappears, claiming he lost her phone number when it got washed in his jeans. Despite her initial anger, Amy forgives him easily, and they reconnect effortlessly, reigniting their relationship. Amy reflects on the timing of their reunion, noting it coincides with the launch of her parents' latest book in the Amazing Amy series, where the fictional Amy is getting married to Able Andy.
The book launch party is a somber affair, reflecting the declining popularity of the Amazing Amy series. Amy feels a deep sense of loneliness and frustration, as the fictional Amy continues to succeed where she fails. Her parents, Rand and Marybeth, are portrayed as the ideal couple, their love story interwoven with the Amazing Amy books, which adds to Amy's feelings of inadequacy and isolation.
At the party, Amy is interviewed by several interns who ask repetitive and superficial questions about her thoughts on Amy's marriage. The experience leaves her feeling exposed and alone, leading her to reflect on her own single status and the societal pressures to find a partner. She contemplates the nature of relationships, expressing a desire for a genuine connection rather than settling for a superficial or unfulfilling partnership. The chapter ends with Amy's renewed hope and excitement about her future with Nick, seeing him as the solution to her loneliness and the key to a fulfilling life.
Key Events
- Amy unexpectedly reunites with Nick after eight months of silence.
- Amy attends her parents' book launch party for the latest Amazing Amy book.
- Amy reflects on her feelings of loneliness and the pressure to find a partner.
Themes
- Identity and self-worth
- The impact of fictional personas on real life
- Societal expectations and personal fulfillment
- Desire for genuine connection in relationships
Chapter 5 Nick Dunne: the Day Of
Nick waits anxiously on the front porch, repeatedly calling Amy's cell phone, which goes to voicemail. His mind races with worry as he reflects on Amy's meticulous nature and the impossibility of her leaving the house in such a state, with the teakettle still on and the ironing incomplete. The signs of a struggle in the living room only deepen his concern.
Two young officers, Velásquez and Riordan, arrive and seem initially unbothered by the situation. Nick leads them inside to show the disarray, and they begin to take the matter more seriously. The arrival of detectives Boney and Gilpin escalates the situation further. Detective Boney, with her sharp and attentive demeanor, quickly takes charge, questioning Nick about Amy's disappearance and his background. Gilpin, with his more laid-back approach, joins in the investigation.
As the detectives explore the house, they discover the iron still on and a beautifully wrapped anniversary gift, which further confirms Nick's fears. Nick's nervousness and agitation are evident, and he feels a growing sense of urgency to find Amy. Boney's questions about his past in New York and his current life in Carthage reveal his discomfort with the scrutiny. The chapter ends with Nick lying about their anniversary plans, indicating a deeper layer of tension and possibly deception.
Throughout the chapter, Nick's internal monologue provides insight into his strained relationship with Amy, his resentment towards Carthage, and his feelings of inadequacy. The detectives' presence and questions highlight the growing suspicion surrounding Nick, setting the stage for a more intense and complex investigation.
Key Events
- Nick waits for the police and repeatedly calls Amy's cell phone.
- The police arrive, and Nick shows them the signs of a struggle in the living room.
- Detectives Boney and Gilpin arrive and begin a more thorough investigation.
- Boney and Gilpin discover the iron still on and a wrapped anniversary gift.
- Nick lies to the detectives about their anniversary plans.
Characters Introduced
- Officer Velásquez
- Officer Riordan
- Detective Rhonda Boney
- Detective Jim Gilpin
Themes
- Suspicion and Deception
- Mistrust and Paranoia
- Strained Relationships and Inadequacy
- Investigation and Scrutiny
Chapter 6 Amy Elliott Dunne: July 5, 2008
Amy Elliott Dunne's diary entry dated July 5, 2008, reveals her profound happiness and contentment in her marriage to Nick. She describes herself as 'overflowing with love,' relishing the role of a devoted wife who dotes on Nick and steers conversations to include his name. Despite the shift from her independent, feminist self, Amy finds joy in the domestic tasks and the simple pleasures of married life, such as balancing the checkbook and trimming Nick’s hair.
Amy reflects on the trivialities of life that no longer trouble her, thanks to Nick’s calming presence. She mentions the decline of the Amazing Amy book series and her own work, but these issues seem minor in the light of her love for Nick. The couple enjoys spontaneous adventures, like having sex in Delaware, and they cherish their Brooklyn brownstone, a gift from Amy’s parents, which they have decorated with DIY projects and flea market finds. Their home is a sanctuary where they spend cozy evenings listening to vinyl records and enjoying each other’s company.
On their one-year anniversary, Amy has planned a treasure hunt for Nick, filled with clues that lead to significant places from their past year together. The hunt includes stops at Thai Town, Chinatown, Central Park, and the Fulton Street fish market, where they will buy lobsters for a romantic dinner at home. Amy anticipates a night of cooking, dining, and intimacy, symbolizing the compromise and love that define their relationship. Her plans for the evening, including a gift of monogrammed stationery, reflect her desire to maintain the spark in their marriage and her hope for continued love letters.
Key Events
- Amy reflects on her contentment and transformation into a devoted wife.
- Amy plans a romantic treasure hunt for their one-year anniversary.
- Amy and Nick enjoy spontaneous adventures and cherish their Brooklyn brownstone.
Themes
- Contentment and transformation in marriage
- Domesticity and romantic gestures
- Balancing personal identity with partnership
Chapter 7 Amy Elliott Dunne
Still reeling from the reflections on her happy marriage, Amy Elliott Dunne delves into the complexities of her upbringing. Her parents, Rand and Marybeth, treated her like a princess, waking her each morning with adoration and surrounding her with a staff of servants. This upbringing instilled in her a sense of entitlement and superiority, traits that have shaped her adult life and relationships. Despite her privileged background, Amy experienced a profound sense of isolation and difficulty connecting with peers. Her intelligence and maturity set her apart, and she often felt more at ease in the company of adults. An anecdote from her third-grade language skills test highlights her precociousness, where she correctly recited a Shakespearean line, impressing and startling her teachers. This incident, among others, led to her attending private and boarding schools, where she remained somewhat isolated despite being popular. Amy contrasts her own experiences with those of Jennifer Foss, a classmate who was genuinely kind and well-liked. Jennifer’s ability to connect with others without pretense is something Amy admires and reflects on, suggesting a deep-seated longing for authentic connections. Amy’s reflections on her childhood provide insight into her complex personality and the roots of her behavior in her current marriage to Nick.
Key Events
- Amy reflects on her entitled upbringing and the impact it had on her personality.
- Amy recalls an incident from third grade where she impressed her teachers with her knowledge of Shakespeare.
- Amy contrasts her isolated childhood with the genuine kindness of her classmate, Jennifer Foss.
Characters Introduced
- Jennifer Foss
Themes
- Entitlement and Isolation
- The Impact of Parental Expectations on Identity
- Authenticity vs. Pretense
Chapter 8 Amy Elliott Dunne
Vivid fantasies of her parents' deaths, particularly in a car accident, contrast sharply with moments of deep love and respect in Amy Elliott Dunne's complex relationship with her parents, Rand and Marybeth. Amy's conflicted feelings stem from her parents' decision to use her as a subject in their behavioral experiments, which shaped her upbringing and personality. She provides a detailed account of her parents' backgrounds and their famous meeting, where Marybeth, a prominent feminist, and Rand, a corporate consultant, found common ground despite their ideological differences. Their marriage became a model of successful partnership, and they wrote a bestselling book that included a relationship test for couples. Amy reflects on the impact of this book and the subsequent fame on her family, noting how it shifted the focus to her education and development. Her upbringing was highly structured and academically rigorous, with a focus on languages, music, and sports. However, her experiences in team sports were particularly challenging, leading her to prefer solitary activities like long-distance running and tennis. She also discusses her initial attempts to connect with Nick through shared interests in sports, which ultimately proved futile, highlighting her realization that men's appreciation of women's interest in sports is often superficial. The chapter concludes with Amy's description of the weekly family meetings, where the focus was on communication and mutual respect. These sessions often revolved around her needs and feelings, and her parents used a marble system to reward her achievements and compensate for their absences. Amy's manipulative tendencies and her parents' blindness to them are highlighted, illustrating the intricate dynamics within her family.
Key Events
- Amy describes her conflicting feelings of love and hate towards her parents.
- Amy details her parents' famous meeting and the impact of their bestselling book on her upbringing.
- Amy reflects on her challenging experiences in team sports and her preference for solitary activities.
- Amy discusses her initial attempts to connect with Nick through sports and her realization of its futility.
- Amy describes the weekly family meetings and the marble system used to address her needs and feelings.
Themes
- Behavioral Experiments
- Educational Rigor
- Manipulation and Control
- Identity and Self-Perception
- Gender Roles and Relationships
Chapter 9 Amy Elliott Dunne
Amy Elliott Dunne continues her introspection, focusing on her parents' ambitious and controlling efforts to mold her into a 'perfectly whole being.' She recounts how her parents, Rand and Marybeth, meticulously planned and executed educational and social activities to shape her into an ideal child. These efforts often involved detailed discussions and negotiations, where Amy was made to feel both in control and guilty for not meeting their expectations. A specific conversation about her disinterest in softball highlights how her parents tried to persuade her to find a passion in a team activity, leading her to suggest ballet as a compromise.
Reflecting on the broader implications of her upbringing, Amy notes that while her parents aimed to expose her to a wide range of activities and disciplines, their methods ultimately stifled her natural passions and creativity. She developed a strategy of feigning interest in activities only to abandon them later, a tactic that gave her a sense of control over her life. This pattern of behavior, she realizes, has left her adept at reading and mimicking the desires and expectations of others, but at the cost of developing a genuine, inner self.
The chapter also explores the concept of possibility and the gradual loss of potential as a child grows older. Amy laments the narrowing of options and the increasing pressure to excel in specific areas, which she believes contributed to her becoming a 'monster'—a highly functional but emotionally hollow individual. Despite her parents' best intentions, their methods of shaping her personality and behavior resulted in a person who is skilled at adapting to external demands but lacks a true sense of self.
Amy's reflections on her upbringing provide a deeper understanding of her complex personality and the roots of her manipulative tendencies. Her ability to read and respond to others' desires, while appearing perfect on the outside, masks a profound emptiness within. This chapter sets the stage for the reader to understand the psychological underpinnings of Amy's actions and the intricate dynamics of her relationships, particularly with Nick.
Key Events
- Amy reflects on her parents' efforts to create a 'perfectly whole being'.
- Amy describes her strategy of feigning interest in activities to gain control.
- Amy laments the loss of possibilities as she grew older.
- Amy acknowledges the emotional hollowness resulting from her upbringing.
Themes
- Manipulation and control
- Suffocation of personal identity
- Parental expectations
- Emotional emptiness
Chapter 10 Nick Dunne
Emphatically denying any involvement in Amy's disappearance, Nick transports the reader back to 1998, to a crowded Brooklyn writer party. Surrounded by people he finds boring and pretentious, Nick is not looking for a serious relationship; he prefers a carefree, uncomplicated girl who can laugh at his jokes and share his interests. However, the women in New York City have proven to be complex and difficult to understand, often leaving him feeling inadequate and out of place.
Nick reflects on his job at a movie magazine, a profession that was more lucrative and respected in 1998. As an editorial assistant, he holds a position due to his non-Ivy League background and his father's reluctance to support his aspirations. Despite his efforts, he feels like an outsider in the magazine's hierarchy, often perceived as less capable compared to his Ivy League colleagues. His breakthrough comes with a story about a starlet, which gains him some recognition, but he remains an outsider, struggling to fully integrate into the New York media scene.
The chapter takes a pivotal turn when Amy enters the party. Her striking appearance and obvious out-of-place demeanor immediately catch Nick's attention. She stands out in the room of serious, intellectual types, and Nick is both intrigued and wary of her presence. Her beauty and confidence make her seem almost unreal, and Nick is immediately drawn to her, though he is initially skeptical of her motives and presence at the party. This moment marks the beginning of their relationship, setting the stage for the complex dynamics that will unfold.
Key Events
- Nick emphatically denies killing Amy.
- Nick recalls his life in 1998, working at a movie magazine and feeling out of place among his Ivy League colleagues.
- Nick describes the moment Amy enters the party, catching his attention with her striking appearance.
Themes
- Struggle for Identity in a Competitive Environment
- Initial Attraction and Skepticism
- The Impact of Social Dynamics on Personal Choices
Chapter 11 Nick Dunne: the Night Of
Nick is taken to the police station for further questioning by Detectives Boney and Gilpin. The interview room feels like a set from a TV show, and Nick is acutely aware of the formality and tension. The detectives explain the necessity of ruling him out as a suspect, which involves taking a DNA sample and testing his hands for gunpowder residue. Nick cooperates, though he feels increasingly uncomfortable and wonders if he should have called a lawyer.
During the questioning, the detectives probe into Amy's daily life and her relationships in Carthage. They express concern about the possibility of drug use or drinking, which Nick dismisses. He admits that Amy has no close friends in town, a fact that surprises and troubles the detectives. When asked about Amy's personality, Nick struggles to describe the bitter and abrasive woman she has become, contrasting her with the fun and easy-going person he once knew. The detectives note his lack of familiarity with Amy's blood type, which adds to their suspicions.
Nick finally calls Amy's parents, Marybeth and Rand, to inform them of her disappearance. Marybeth answers the phone, and the call is tense and emotional. She demands to speak to the detective in charge, and Nick fetches Gilpin. The call solidifies the gravity of the situation, as the emergency spreads beyond Nick and the police. Later, Nick discovers that his father has wandered away from his nursing home and was found by the police. The encounter with his father, who is in a deteriorated state, adds to Nick's stress and anxiety.
After the police release him, Nick goes to Margo's place, where he finds solace in her company. Margo offers to help search for Amy, but Nick feels helpless and unsure of what to do. The chapter ends with Margo pouring him a drink and offering support, highlighting the strain on their relationship and the mounting pressure Nick faces.
Key Events
- Nick is taken to the police station for further questioning.
- Detectives Boney and Gilpin take DNA and gunshot residue samples from Nick.
- Nick admits that Amy has no close friends in Carthage, which surprises the detectives.
- Nick calls Amy's parents, Marybeth and Rand, to inform them of her disappearance.
- Nick's father is found wandering away from his nursing home and is returned by the police.
- Nick seeks solace at Margo's place after the police release him.
Themes
- Suspicion and distrust
- Marital deterioration
- Family dynamics and dysfunction
- Personal scrutiny and doubt
Chapter 12 Amy Elliott Dunne: April 21, 2009
Amy's diary entry from April 21, 2009, captures a dinner with her friends Campbell and Insley at a trendy Soho restaurant. The atmosphere is lackluster, with the women overdressed and the food as decorative as it is insubstantial. They discuss having their husbands join them for drinks, but the conversation is strained and the mood is dull. John and George eventually arrive, with John being overly enthusiastic and George tense and apologetic, while Nick never shows up, not even sending a message.
Amy reflects on the dynamics of her friends' marriages, particularly the 'dancing monkeys' phenomenon, where husbands are forced to perform meaningless tasks to prove their love. She and Nick laugh at these scenarios, finding them absurd and unnecessary. Amy prides herself on not coercing Nick into such behaviors, believing that their relationship is based on mutual trust and respect. She contrasts this with the competitive nature of other women who derive satisfaction from detailing their husbands' sacrifices.
Upon returning home, Amy finds Nick waiting for her, and they share a tender moment. Nick explains that he stayed late for a poker game with colleagues, and Amy reassures him that it was fine. Their night ends with passionate sex and a drink, reinforcing their bond. Amy's entry concludes with a touch of irony, lamenting her own 'poor' situation while clearly relishing the genuine love and freedom in her relationship.
Key Events
- Amy and her friends have a lackluster dinner and drinks at a trendy Soho restaurant.
- Nick fails to show up to the gathering, not even sending a message.
- Amy reflects on the 'dancing monkeys' phenomenon in her friends' marriages.
- Amy and Nick share a tender and intimate reunion at home.
Themes
- Marital Dynamics and Authenticity
- Social Expectations and Individuality
- Intimacy and Trust in Relationships
Chapter 13 Nick Dunne: One Day Gone
Nick spends a restless night at Margo's place, drinking heavily and struggling to sleep. Haunted by visions of Amy, he imagines her in pain and calling his name. The next morning, he returns to his house to retrieve some clothes, only to find the neighborhood abuzz with police activity and curious neighbors. Mike, a neighbor, informs him that he has mowed the lawn and expresses his wife's distress over Amy's disappearance, which Nick finds insincere and annoying.
At the house, Officer Velásquez escorts Nick to his bedroom, where he selects clothes while feeling tense and judged. He attempts to open a gift box from Amy, but Velásquez prevents him, reminding him that it's a crime scene. This interaction frustrates Nick, and he is forcibly removed from the house by the officers. Driving back to Margo's, Nick reflects on the need to remain calm and cooperative with the police.
At the police station, Nick encounters Boney, who informs him that Amy's parents, Marybeth and Rand, are there. He observes their close, loving relationship, which contrasts sharply with his own parents' toxic marriage. He recalls his father's abusive behavior and his mother's transformation after the divorce. When Rand and Marybeth see Nick, they hug him tightly, expressing their determination to find Amy. Marybeth, in particular, scrutinizes Nick, analyzing his every move and word.
The police station becomes chaotic as preparations for a press conference begin. A PR representative briefs Nick on the importance of the statement, and Margo arrives to support him. During the press conference, Nick delivers a stiff, unconvincing statement, while Rand tries to salvage the moment with a more emotional plea. The broadcast later shows Nick looking detached and almost bored, which will likely be interpreted negatively by the public.
Key Events
- Nick has a restless night and returns to his house to retrieve clothes.
- Nick is prevented from opening a gift box from Amy by Officer Velásquez.
- Nick reflects on his parents' toxic marriage and his father's abusive behavior.
- Rand and Marybeth hug Nick, expressing their determination to find Amy.
- Nick delivers a stiff, unconvincing statement at the press conference.
Themes
- The psychological toll of a missing spouse
- The contrast between supportive and toxic family relationships
- The challenge of maintaining composure under intense public scrutiny
Chapter 14 Amy Elliott Dunne: July 5, 2010
Still reeling from the emotional turmoil of their third wedding anniversary, Amy is left alone after Nick leaves to console laid-off coworkers. Despite her efforts to create a thoughtful treasure hunt and prepare a romantic lobster dinner, she feels hurt and disappointed. Amy listens to a voicemail from Nick, who sounds drunk and distant, and she feels obligated to be angry, even though she doesn't want to.
Her disappointment deepens as she realizes the treasure hunt she planned will likely go unnoticed, and the lobsters she bought for their anniversary dinner will either go to waste or be eaten by her alone. She confides in her father, who advises her to indulge in a good sulk, but she worries about Nick's reaction when her parents learn of his night out. The chapter delves into the underlying tensions in their marriage, including Nick's resentment over her financial security and the prenuptial agreement.
Later that night, Nick returns home drunk and exhausted, and the atmosphere is tense. He dismisses her attempts to acknowledge the anniversary, and their conversation devolves into an argument. Nick's defensiveness and refusal to apologize further strain their relationship. Amy feels like she is losing control of the promises she made to herself about their marriage, and she is torn between her desire to be understanding and her growing frustration.
The chapter concludes with Amy's discovery of receipts from bars and strip clubs, as well as a phone number from a woman named Hannah, which fuels her insecurities. Despite her anger and hurt, she ultimately chooses to stay and reconcile with Nick, both saying 'I'm sorry' as they embrace in bed. The moment is bittersweet, highlighting the complex dynamics and unresolved issues in their relationship.
Key Events
- Amy is left alone on their third wedding anniversary after Nick goes out to console laid-off coworkers.
- Amy confides in her father about her disappointment, and he advises her to indulge in a good sulk.
- Nick returns home drunk and dismissive, leading to a tense and hurtful argument with Amy.
- Amy discovers receipts from bars and strip clubs, as well as a phone number from a woman named Hannah, fueling her insecurities.
- Despite their argument, Amy and Nick both apologize and reconcile in bed.
Themes
- Marital Strain
- Economic Strain on Marriage
- Communication Breakdown
- Unresolved Resentment
Chapter 15 Nick Dunne: One Day Gone
Following the press conference, Nick is taken to a back office by Detective Gilpin, who updates him on the investigation into the break-ins in the neighborhood. Nick reflects on the economic downturn that devastated Carthage, particularly the closure of the Riverway Mall, which employed a fifth of the town’s population. The mall's collapse has left the town in a state of economic ruin, mirroring Nick's own sense of stagnation and malaise.
Detective Gilpin shows Nick the gift box from Amy, containing a clue for their anniversary treasure hunt. Nick reads the first clue, a suggestive poem, and feels a growing sense of dread. Gilpin follows him to the college, where they find another clue in Nick’s office, along with a pair of lacy red panties hanging from the AC unit. Nick explains that it was a playful act with Amy, but Gilpin collects the panties as evidence, much to Nick’s embarrassment.
Back at the Days Inn, Nick meets with Amy’s parents, Rand and Marybeth, who are visibly distressed by the news coverage of Amy’s disappearance. They discuss the possibility of an Amy obsessive being responsible, mentioning past stalkers, including Hilary Handy and Desi Collings. Rand and Marybeth express their frustration with the police, who seem to be focusing on Nick as a primary suspect. Nick is particularly troubled by the revelation that the police checked his restaurant reservations and found none, raising further suspicion about his involvement in Amy’s disappearance.
Nick’s feelings of guilt and the growing cloud of suspicion around him weigh heavily on him. The complexity of his relationship with Amy and the pressure to solve the treasure hunt, now more ominous, add to his distress. The conversation with his in-laws highlights the tension and uncertainty surrounding the investigation, as well as the emotional toll it is taking on everyone involved.
Key Events
- Nick is taken to a back office by Detective Gilpin to discuss the investigation into the break-ins in the neighborhood.
- Nick reads the first clue from Amy’s anniversary treasure hunt, a suggestive poem, and feels a growing sense of dread.
- Nick and Gilpin find another clue and a pair of lacy red panties in Nick’s office at the college, which Gilpin collects as evidence.
- Nick meets with Amy’s parents, Rand and Marybeth, at the Days Inn, discussing the possibility of an Amy obsessive being responsible for her disappearance.
- Rand and Marybeth express frustration with the police, who are focusing on Nick as a primary suspect, particularly regarding his restaurant reservations.
Themes
- The economic downturn's effect on Nick's sense of purpose and identity
- The complexity and tension in marital relationships
- The cloud of suspicion and the pressure of being a primary suspect in a missing persons case
- The psychological burden of unresolved issues and past behaviors
Chapter 16 Amy Elliott Dunne: August 23, 2010
Reflecting on the summer of 2010, Amy recalls the period marked by her and Nick's layoffs and the subsequent decline in their relationship. Initially, Nick seemed productive, tackling home repairs and reading, but he soon fell into a deep depression, spending his days watching TV, surfing porn, and drinking excessively. The house became a chaotic mess, littered with garbage and unopened shopping bags from expensive stores, a stark contrast to their former life of stability and comfort.
Amy's frustration with Nick's behavior grew, and she felt compelled to nag him about maintaining a basic standard of living. Despite her efforts to be understanding, she was increasingly irritated by his lack of initiative and the deteriorating state of their home. The tension between them was palpable, and Amy felt a profound sense of loss and disappointment.
The situation worsened when Amy's parents, Rand and Marybeth, visited to reveal their own financial crisis. They admitted to living beyond their means and making poor investments, resulting in significant debt. They asked Amy to lend them $650,000 from her trust fund to pay off their debts and stabilize their finances. Despite feeling shock and discomfort, Amy agreed to the request, wiring the money the next day to avoid the waiting period.
This chapter highlights the financial and emotional strain on Amy and Nick's relationship, as well as the broader economic downturn affecting multiple generations. It sets the stage for further complications and the deepening of existing conflicts.
Key Events
- Nick and Amy both lose their jobs, leading to a decline in Nick's mental state and the house's condition.
- Amy's parents, Rand and Marybeth, reveal their financial crisis and ask Amy to lend them $650,000 from her trust fund.
- Amy agrees to lend her parents the money, despite feeling shocked and uncomfortable.
Themes
- Financial instability and its impact on personal relationships
- The burden of family expectations and financial responsibilities
- The erosion of personal and familial stability in the face of economic hardship
Chapter 17 Nick Dunne: Two Days Gone
Exhausted and disoriented, Nick lies awake on the pullout couch in Amy's parents' suite, the sound of their snoring a constant reminder of the night's restless hours. In the morning, he confronts the harsh reality of the ongoing investigation and the growing suspicion surrounding him. Despite their own financial distress, Marybeth and Rand insist on Nick staying with them, their hospitality fierce and familiar. At the Days Inn, now transformed into the Find Amy Dunne headquarters, Marybeth's efficiency and urgency create a bustling environment filled with volunteers, each bringing their own energy and motives. Detective Boney arrives and warns Nick about the possibility of obsessives or groupies inserting themselves into the investigation, particularly noting two attractive fortysomething women. Feeling the weight of suspicion, Nick decides to take a proactive role in the search.
During the afternoon search at Wolky Park, Nick is assigned to a seemingly insignificant role, standing at the entrance and offering water to volunteers. A woman named Shawna Kelly approaches him, offering sympathy and a homemade chicken Frito pie. Her overtly flirtatious behavior and attempts to ingratiate herself with Nick are unsettling, and he feels a growing sense of unease and frustration. The encounter highlights the complex dynamics and potential dangers of the situation.
Nick's interactions with the volunteers and the police, particularly Boney, reveal the town's economic struggles and the presence of the Blue Book Boys, a group of laid-off workers who have turned to squatting and criminal activities. Stucks Buckley, an old friend, provides insights into the town's decay and the Blue Book Boys' involvement in recent crimes, including a gang rape. This information adds a layer of complexity to the investigation, suggesting that Amy's disappearance might be connected to broader issues in Carthage.
Key Events
- Nick stays at Amy's parents' suite and reflects on his and Amy's different sleeping patterns.
- Marybeth transforms the Days Inn ballroom into the Find Amy Dunne headquarters.
- Boney warns Nick about the possibility of obsessives or groupies inserting themselves into the investigation.
- Nick is assigned a minor role at the Wolky Park search and encounters Shawna Kelly, who behaves flirtatiously.
- Stucks Buckley provides information about the Blue Book Boys and their involvement in recent crimes in Carthage.
Characters Introduced
- Shawna Kelly
- Stucks Buckley
Themes
- Suspicion and paranoia
- Economic decline and its effects
- Community mobilization in crisis
- Flirtation and inappropriate behavior
Chapter 18 Amy Elliott Dunne: September 15, 2010
Still reeling from the night spent at her parents' suite and the growing suspicion around him, Nick's absence allows Amy to reflect on their current predicament from a motel in southwestern Pennsylvania. She and Nick are on the run, and she is experiencing emotional turmoil, feeling disconnected from her husband and the situation. Nick is asleep, having bought snacks from the vending machine, and is angry with her for not being a good sport about their new adventure. Amy feels a growing sense of unease and resentment, realizing that their lives have taken an unexpected and unwelcome turn.
Two weeks prior, their routine of unemployment and boredom was interrupted when Nick received a call about his mother's terminal cancer diagnosis and his father's Alzheimer's disease. The news prompted a heated discussion about moving back to Missouri to help his parents. Amy felt blindsided by Nick's abrupt and accusatory manner, sensing a shift in their relationship dynamics. Despite her initial resistance, they quickly decided to leave New York, driven by a sense of duty and the lack of other options.
The process of packing and moving was fraught with tension. Nick, determined and guilty, worked tirelessly to load the U-Haul, while Amy moved slowly, feeling physically and emotionally drained. She resented the lack of support and empathy from Nick, who seemed more focused on the task at hand than on her feelings. The decision to leave most of their furniture behind, including their bed, added to the sense of loss and abandonment. Amy felt like an object being moved, stripped of her identity and agency.
As they drove away from New York, Amy couldn't bring herself to look back. The previous night, her parents had visited, giving them a cherished cuckoo clock and promising to take care of her. Despite Nick's reassurances, Amy felt a deep sense of fear and disconnection. She questioned her role in the relationship and her own existence, feeling like she could disappear at any moment.
Key Events
- Amy and Nick are on the run in southwestern Pennsylvania, staying in a motel.
- Nick receives a call about his mother's terminal cancer and his father's Alzheimer's, leading to a heated discussion about moving back to Missouri.
- They quickly decide to leave New York, driven by a sense of duty and lack of other options.
- The packing and moving process is tense, with Nick working diligently and Amy feeling emotionally drained and resentful.
- Amy feels like an object being moved, stripped of her identity and agency, and fears for her role in the relationship.
Themes
- Emotional disconnection and resentment in relationships
- Abrupt and life-altering decisions
- Loss of identity and agency
- Duty and sacrifice
Chapter 19 Nick Dunne: Three Days Gone
Nick reflects on the futility of the search efforts for Amy, noting the listlessness and defeat that hang over the volunteer center. Overhearing a conversation about the possibility of Amy's body being dumped in the river, chopped up, and carried away, adds to his sense of dread. He encounters his former teacher, Mr. Coleman, who makes a cuckoo gesture, hinting at the strange and unsettling nature of the situation.
Marybeth approaches Nick, insisting that he travel to Memphis to investigate Amy's high school stalker, Hilary Handy. Despite his reluctance, he agrees to go, also planning to visit Desi Collings in St. Louis. Later, Joe and Mikey Hillsam suggest a nighttime search of the abandoned mall with the Hillsam brothers and Rand. Nick reluctantly agrees, feeling a mix of apprehension and a sense of duty.
Driving to Hannibal, Missouri, to follow Amy's treasure hunt clue, Nick revisits the town where he once worked as Huck Finn, feeling a sense of nostalgia and unease. He finds the next clue in the courtroom where Mark Twain's father once presided, a clue that praises his wit and humor. The message from Amy is a stark contrast to their recent strained relationship, leaving Nick feeling both touched and guilty.
Returning to Margo's place, Nick spends the day alone, drinking coffee and watching TV, feeling conflicted about his emotions towards Amy. Margo confronts him about his behavior, noting that he seems unusually detached and angry. Later, they join Rand, Joe, and Mikey Hillsam for a nighttime search of the abandoned mall. Inside, they encounter various squatters and drug users, including a man who claims to recognize Amy and mentions that she wanted to buy a gun.
Key Events
- Nick reflects on the futility of the search efforts for Amy.
- Marybeth insists that Nick travel to Memphis to investigate Amy's stalker, Hilary Handy.
- Nick finds a treasure hunt clue in Hannibal, Missouri, praising his wit and humor.
- Nick and the group conduct a nighttime search of the abandoned mall, encountering squatters and drug users.
Characters Introduced
- Joe Hillsam
- Mikey Hillsam
- Melanie
Themes
- The psychological toll of the search for Amy
- Nick's conflicting emotions and guilt in his relationship with Amy
- The decay and abandonment of once-thriving communities
Chapter 20 Amy Elliott Dunne: October 16, 2010
Amy reflects on her first month as a Missouri resident, detailing her efforts to adapt to the midwestern lifestyle. The cuckoo clock, a cherished heirloom from her parents, malfunctions frequently, causing tension between her and Nick. The clock's erratic behavior and Bleecker's reactions add to the sense of dislocation and unease. At a housewarming party organized by Maureen, Amy meets the community, including Maureen's friends and younger women who might become her peers. Despite her efforts to be friendly, Amy feels out of place and is met with a mix of curiosity and awkwardness. The women's reactions to her New York background range from fascination to discomfort, highlighting the cultural gap. The situation escalates when Bill Dunne, Nick's father, arrives with Go and becomes hostile, accusing Amy of not belonging in the house. Feeling humiliated and unwanted, Amy leaves the party and walks in the rain, feeling deeply isolated in her new home. The chapter ends with Amy waiting for Nick to come after her, but he does not, leaving her alone and profoundly alienated.
Key Events
- Amy reflects on her first month in Missouri and the cuckoo clock's malfunction.
- Amy attends a housewarming party organized by Maureen, feeling out of place.
- Bill Dunne, Nick's father, becomes hostile and accuses Amy of not belonging in the house.
- Amy leaves the party and walks in the rain, feeling isolated and humiliated.
Characters Introduced
- Vicky
- Barb
- Binks Moriarty
Themes
- Cultural adaptation and dislocation
- Community acceptance and rejection
- Family dynamics and generational conflict
- Mental health and aging
Chapter 21 Nick Dunne: Four Days Gone
In the vacant Find Amy Dunne headquarters, Nick and Rand discuss Amy's attempt to buy a gun at the mall on Valentine's Day. Rand expresses his dislike for Desi Collings, Amy's ex-boyfriend, suggesting that Amy might be afraid of someone, though not necessarily a man. The conversation then turns to Hilary Handy and Noelle Hawthorne, both of whom are considered potential suspects or sources of information. Nick's frustration with the lack of progress in finding Amy is palpable, and Rand's insights offer a glimmer of hope in the investigation.
Key Events
- Nick and Rand discuss Amy's attempt to buy a gun.
- Rand shares his dislike for Desi Collings.
- Nick and Rand talk about Hilary Handy and Noelle Hawthorne.
Themes
- Suspicion and Investigation
- Past Relationships and Resentments
- Investigative Leads and Speculation
Chapter 22 Amy Elliott Dunne: April 28, 2011
Amy reflects on her life in Missouri, particularly the challenges of caring for her ailing mother-in-law, Maureen, and the emotional distance between her and Nick. Despite the difficulties, she tries to maintain a positive outlook, inspired by Maureen's resilience and the Midwestern attitude of 'keeping on keeping on.'
Amy's efforts to support Maureen and Nick's father, Bill, are met with indifference from Nick, who seems to have disengaged from his family responsibilities. Maureen, understanding of Nick's reluctance to participate in her care, reassures Amy that she doesn't hold it against him. However, Amy feels a deep sense of responsibility and continues to take on the burdens of caregiving.
While caring for Maureen, Amy discovers a book proposal on Nick's computer titled 'Double Lives: A Memoir of Ends and Beginnings.' The proposal outlines Nick's perspective on their life in Missouri, portraying her as a resentful Manhattanite struggling to adapt. Amy is hurt by the proposal, which reveals Nick's true feelings and his desire to write about their situation. She feels that Nick is more interested in his own narrative and less in their relationship.
Amy's reflections on her marriage and her role in the family highlight her growing frustration and the imbalance in their relationship. She wishes she could be the kind of wife who thrives on homemaking and adoring her husband, but she recognizes that this is not her nature. Despite her efforts to be supportive, she feels increasingly isolated and wonders if she and Nick are truly compatible.
Key Events
- Amy cares for Maureen and Bill, feeling neglected by Nick.
- Amy discovers a book proposal on Nick's computer that portrays her negatively.
- Amy reflects on her growing frustration and the imbalance in her marriage.
Themes
- Caregiving and family responsibility
- Marital dissatisfaction and emotional isolation
- The impact of personal narratives on relationships
Chapter 23 Nick Dunne: Four Days Gone
Surprised by Andie's sudden appearance outside Go's house in the middle of the night, Nick lets her in, despite his initial shock. Andie, his mistress, is visibly concerned and frustrated at not hearing from him during Amy's disappearance. Nick tries to reassure her, but the tension escalates as Andie presses for more physical and emotional reassurance. Feeling a mix of guilt and desire, Nick reflects on the start of their affair, which began with Andie's innocent questions and gestures, quickly spiraling into a full-blown relationship. His internal monologue reveals deep dissatisfaction with his marriage and a growing dependence on Andie for emotional support. Acknowledging the danger of their relationship, especially given Amy's disappearance, Nick reluctantly agrees to Andie's demands for more frequent contact, emphasizing the need for secrecy. The chapter reaches a climax when Go, Nick's sister, enters the room and discovers Andie. Stunned and furious, Go confronts Nick with a mix of disbelief and anger, adding a new layer of tension and complicating Nick's already precarious situation.
Key Events
- Andie visits Nick at Go's house, expressing concern and frustration.
- Nick reflects on the start of his affair with Andie and his dissatisfaction with his marriage.
- Andie demands more frequent contact and reassurance from Nick.
- Go discovers Andie and confronts Nick about the affair.
Themes
- Infidelity and its consequences
- Emotional reliance and the dangers of secrecy
- Family dynamics and loyalty under strain
Chapter 24 Amy Elliott Dunne: July 21, 2011
Amy reflects on her recent experience accompanying Maureen to the plasma donation center. Despite her illness, Maureen invites Amy on a field trip with her friends, hoping to lift her spirits. Amy, feeling obligated, agrees to join them, unaware that the outing involves donating plasma. The group, dressed in matching T-shirts, heads to the plasma center, where Amy is introduced to the process and the regular donors, including Maureen’s friends Rose and Cayleese.
Inside the center, Amy is overwhelmed by her phobia of needles and blood. Despite Maureen’s encouragement and the friendly staff, Amy cannot bring herself to participate. She feels a wave of dizziness and faints, leading to a hasty return home. Maureen, concerned, tucks Amy into bed and tries to reach Nick, who is unresponsive to their calls. Amy reflects on Nick’s tendency to disappear, a behavior reminiscent of his childhood, and the strain it puts on their relationship.
When Nick finally returns home late at night, Amy confronts him about his unavailability. Nick, caught in a lie about his phone being dead, struggles to explain his absence. Amy, familiar with his pattern of avoiding commitments, feels a deep sense of disappointment and frustration. The chapter ends with Amy’s realization of the growing disconnect in their marriage and the challenges of living in a town where desperation and denial are commonplace.
Key Events
- Amy accompanies Maureen to the plasma donation center.
- Amy faints due to her phobia of needles and blood.
- Maureen and Amy try to reach Nick, who is unresponsive.
- Nick returns home late and lies about his phone being dead.
- Amy confronts Nick about his behavior and the strain on their relationship.
Characters Introduced
- Cayleese
Themes
- Marital Strain
- Phobias and Vulnerability
- Isolation and Disconnection
Chapter 25 Nick Dunne: Five Days Gone
Nick reflects on the aftermath of his affair with Andie, feeling a mix of relief and guilt as his sister, Go, confronts him about the relationship. Go is devastated and angry, questioning Nick's judgment and loyalty to Amy. She emphasizes the severity of the situation, especially given Amy's disappearance, and urges Nick to seek legal and PR help to manage the media scrutiny. Feeling the pressure, Nick decides to visit Desi Collings in St. Louis to gather information that could help his case and shift the media's focus away from him. Upon arriving at Desi's lavish mansion, Nick is struck by Desi's polished appearance and gentlemanly demeanor, which contrast sharply with his own disheveled state. Desi welcomes Nick with apparent sympathy but quickly turns the conversation to his own relationship with Amy, describing her in idealized terms and revealing a deep, lingering obsession. Desi's mother, Jacqueline, joins the conversation, adding a layer of tension and skepticism. She scrutinizes Nick, questioning his suitability as Amy's husband and expressing her family's continued fascination with Amy. The interaction with the Collings family leaves Nick unsettled, particularly by their possessive and almost reverential attitude towards Amy. He leaves with a sense of unease and a card for their lawyer, feeling that the situation is more complex and dangerous than he initially thought.
Key Events
- Go confronts Nick about his affair with Andie.
- Nick decides to visit Desi Collings in St. Louis to gather information.
- Desi and his mother, Jacqueline, express a deep, lingering obsession with Amy.
- Nick leaves the Collings' mansion feeling unsettled and with a card for their lawyer.
Characters Introduced
- Jacqueline Collings
Themes
- Family Obsession and Possessiveness
- Media Scrutiny and Public Perception
- Loyalty and Betrayal
Chapter 26 Amy Elliott Dunne: August 17, 2011
Still reeling from the recent events, Amy reflects on the recent change in Nick's behavior, noting that he has been unusually loving and attentive. She has been tracking his moods on a calendar, marking days with hearts when he shows affection and black squares when he does not. Over the past nine days, all entries have been hearts, a stark contrast to the previous year of black squares. Amy wonders if Nick's newfound affection is a sign of a genuine change of heart or if he has ulterior motives.
Despite her happiness, Amy's neurotic side questions the sudden change. She catches Nick going through a file box labeled 'THE DUNNES!' which contains important marital documents. This fuels her suspicion that he might be planning to ask her for financial assistance, such as a second mortgage on The Bar or borrowing against their life insurance. Despite these worries, Amy resolves to focus on the positive aspects of their relationship and to trust that Nick's affection is sincere.
Amy recounts several romantic moments they have shared recently, including a trip to a pond where Nick took her swimming, a visit to a playground fort where he whispered sweet nothings, and a nostalgic ride on a carousel bunny. These moments are interspersed with tender kisses and declarations of love, which Amy cherishes deeply. The chapter ends with Amy reaffirming her commitment to her marriage and her belief that Nick has returned to her, despite her lingering doubts.
Key Events
- Amy tracks Nick's moods on a calendar, noting nine consecutive days of hearts.
- Amy catches Nick going through their marital file box, fueling her suspicions.
- Amy and Nick share several romantic moments, including swimming, visiting a playground, and riding a carousel.
- Amy resolves to trust Nick's newfound affection despite her doubts.
Themes
- Marital Trust and Suspicion
- Neurotic Doubt and Romantic Gestures
- Reconciliation Amidst Uncertainty
Chapter 27 Nick Dunne: Five Days Gone
Outside Desi Collings' house, Nick sits in his car, reflecting on a message from Detective Gilpin, instructing him to meet the detectives at his house at four. The summer air show practice runs create a noisy backdrop to the impending meeting. When Gilpin and Boney arrive, they settle into the living room, and the conversation is punctuated by the roaring jets overhead. The detectives begin by questioning Nick about his visit to Desi, but they dismiss his concerns, stating that Desi is not a suspect.
The interrogation intensifies as Boney and Gilpin question Nick about his whereabouts on the morning Amy disappeared. They point out inconsistencies in his story, such as the lack of coffee in the house and the peculiar arrangement of items in the living room, which they believe was staged. The detectives reveal that the kitchen floor tested positive for a significant amount of Amy's blood, which had been carefully cleaned up. This revelation shakes Nick, and he struggles to maintain his composure.
The detectives press Nick about the state of his marriage, probing for any signs of discord. Nick admits to minor disagreements but insists that their marriage was generally fine. The detectives, however, remain skeptical, pointing out financial troubles and large credit card debts in Nick's name. They also mention Noelle Hawthorne, who claims that Amy was troubled by the marriage and worried about Nick's temper. Nick denies these accusations, suggesting that Noelle might be fabricating the friendship and the photos of Amy.
The chapter concludes with the detectives questioning Nick about the increased life insurance policy and a search on his laptop for 'Body Float Mississippi River.' Nick maintains his innocence, attributing the search to a book idea. Feeling cornered and under intense scrutiny, Nick considers getting a lawyer. The detectives exchange a meaningful look, suggesting that they are closing in on him.
Key Events
- Nick meets with Detectives Boney and Gilpin at his house.
- The detectives reveal inconsistencies in Nick's story and evidence of a staged living room.
- The detectives uncover significant blood evidence in the kitchen, which had been cleaned up.
- Nick is questioned about his financial troubles and large credit card debts in his name.
- The detectives mention Noelle Hawthorne, who claims Amy was troubled by the marriage.
- Nick considers getting a lawyer after the intense interrogation.
Themes
- Detective Skepticism
- Evidence of Guilt
- Marital Discord
- Financial Struggles
- Deception and Truth
Chapter 28 Amy Elliott Dunne: October 21, 2011
Still reeling from the intense interrogation by Detectives Gilpin and Boney, Amy reflects on the death of Nick's mother, Maureen. Maureen was a strong, independent woman who refused to slow down until the end, even knitting caps for chemo patients. Her sudden decline and death have left Nick unmoored, and he has become distant and angry, a stark contrast to his previous loving and attentive self.
Amy tries to fill the void left by Maureen by taking on her nurturing roles, such as cutting bread crusts and ironing Nick's T-shirts. However, Nick resents this, saying he doesn't need to be babied. Their relationship has regressed to a series of black squares on Amy's mood calendar, with Nick using her primarily for sex and showing no emotional intimacy. Amy feels increasingly isolated and desperate, wondering if she has become a 'Lost Cause' in Nick's eyes, a term he used to mock women nearing forty.
In a moment of vulnerability, Amy suggests to Nick that they start a family, hoping it might bring them closer. Nick reacts with anger and frustration, explaining that they are in no financial position to have children and that the pressure of providing for a family would be too much for him. He accuses Amy of wanting to have a baby to fix their marriage, a suggestion he finds ridiculous and impossible given their current circumstances. The conversation ends with Nick warning Amy that he is under immense pressure and is on the verge of breaking.
Key Events
- Maureen's death and its impact on Nick
- Amy's attempts to nurture Nick as Maureen did
- Nick's rejection of Amy's nurturing and emotional support
- Amy's suggestion to start a family and Nick's angry response
Themes
- Grief and its impact on relationships
- Marital disintegration under financial strain
- Desperation and the illusion of solutions
- Emotional isolation and resentment
Chapter 29 Nick Dunne: Six Days Gone
Still reeling from the growing tension and fear in his marriage, Nick reflects on the national attention the case has garnered. The media portrays the Elliotts as beloved figures while painting him in a negative light, digging up his past as a ladies' man and his infrequent visits to his father in the nursing home. Go warns him that the media's perception is a significant problem, especially the use of his full name, Lance Nicholas Dunne, which is particularly damaging.
Rand and Marybeth, along with Go and Nick, attend a candlelight vigil for Amy in Tom Sawyer Park. The atmosphere is tense, with media crews and camera flashes everywhere. Rand's behavior is increasingly manic, while Marybeth relies on alcohol to cope. Nick delivers a speech written by Go, trying to humanize himself, but the moment is disrupted when Noelle Hawthorne, Amy's supposed best friend, confronts him on stage, accusing him of harming Amy. Noelle, pregnant and with her triplets, creates a chaotic scene, drawing more media attention and further damaging Nick's reputation.
The chapter ends with Nick and Go fleeing the scene, pursued by reporters who bombard them with questions about Amy's pregnancy. The intense scrutiny and public pressure are taking a toll on Nick, and the situation is rapidly spiraling out of control.
Key Events
- Nick reflects on the media's negative portrayal of him.
- Rand and Marybeth attend a candlelight vigil for Amy, where the media is present.
- Noelle Hawthorne confronts Nick on stage, accusing him of harming Amy.
- Nick and Go flee the vigil, pursued by reporters asking about Amy's pregnancy.
Themes
- Media Influence
- Public Perception
- Family Strain Under Public Scrutiny
- Pressure and Scrutiny
Chapter 30 Amy Elliott Dunne: February 15, 2012
Still reeling from the chaotic candlelight vigil, Amy reflects on the strange and unsettling period in her life, trying to view it from a detached perspective to cope with the growing tension and fear. She is convinced that something is profoundly wrong with Nick, beyond his grief over his mother's death. She notices his angry and unstable behavior, often feeling like he is watching her with a look of disgust, as if she has committed some unforgivable act.
The tension between Amy and Nick reaches a critical point when Nick shoves her hard, causing her to fall and hit her head. Amy is more shocked than hurt, realizing that Nick's anger has escalated to physical violence. Despite the incident, Amy believes that Nick is fundamentally a good man and attributes his behavior to the stress and strain they are both under. She agrees to counseling, hoping it will help them navigate their issues.
Amy's concern for her safety leads her to drive to the abandoned mall, a known spot for drug deals, to purchase a gun for protection on Valentine's Day. The irony of the situation is not lost on her, as it is Valentine's Day, and she plans to cook dinner for Nick after potentially arming herself. She grapples with the decision to stay with Nick, feeling a moral obligation to support him during his grieving period, despite the risks.
Amy's reflections reveal her deep ambivalence and the complexity of her feelings. She acknowledges the absurdity of her situation, recognizing the contradiction between her fear and her unwillingness to leave. The chapter ends with Amy's internal struggle, highlighting the themes of trust, fear, and the lengths she is willing to go to preserve her marriage, even in the face of danger.
Key Events
- Amy notices Nick's increasingly angry and unstable behavior.
- Nick shoves Amy, causing her to fall and hit her head.
- Amy agrees to counseling with Nick, believing he is fundamentally a good man.
- Amy drives to the abandoned mall to purchase a gun for protection on Valentine's Day.
Themes
- Trust and betrayal
- Fear and survival
- Marital conflict and reconciliation
Chapter 31 Nick Dunne: Six Days Gone
Following the confrontation at the candlelight vigil, Go and Nick flee the scene, pursued by reporters. Go, frustrated and suspicious, confronts Nick about his lies, particularly regarding Amy's pregnancy and his reluctance to have children. Nick admits to trying to protect Amy's reputation and his own, but Go's trust in him is shaken, and she retreats to her bedroom, leaving Nick alone and questioning his own actions.
Nick receives a call from the Elliotts, who inform him that Amy was indeed pregnant, as confirmed by a doctor's visit. Rand's aggressive questioning and the impending police subpoena for medical records add to Nick's stress. Go, already distrustful, becomes even more skeptical of Nick's explanations, leading to a tense and accusatory conversation. Nick's history of lying to avoid conflict is brought to the forefront, and Go's concern about his involvement in Amy's disappearance deepens.
Later, Nick meets Andie at a remote Old West fort, despite the risk of being seen. The meeting underscores the dangerous path he is on, as Andie's emotional instability and Nick's desperation to maintain their relationship highlight the growing complexity of his situation. Back at his house, Nick is informed by Boney that Amy was pregnant, a revelation that intensifies the pressure on him and forces him to confront the possibility of his wife's murder.
Nick's father, Bill, unexpectedly appears at the house, having walked from the nursing home. Bill's erratic behavior and insistence that Amy loves him add another layer of chaos to the situation. Nick manages to get Bill back to the nursing home, but the encounter leaves him feeling increasingly isolated and under scrutiny. Boney's final visit to deliver the news of Amy's pregnancy further cements the suspicion surrounding Nick, as he struggles to maintain a facade of innocence and grief.
Key Events
- Go and Nick flee the candlelight vigil, pursued by reporters.
- Go confronts Nick about his lies regarding Amy's pregnancy and his reluctance to have children.
- Nick receives a call from the Elliotts confirming Amy's pregnancy.
- Nick meets Andie at a remote Old West fort, despite the risk.
- Bill Dunne unexpectedly appears at the house, having walked from the nursing home.
- Boney informs Nick that Amy was pregnant, intensifying the pressure on him.
Themes
- Lying and Deception
- Media Scrutiny
- Family Dynamics
- Escalating Suspicion and Pressure
Chapter 32 Amy Elliott Dunne: June 26, 2012
Amy wakes on a bright, blue-sky day, feeling intensely alive despite her fear and anxiety. She discovers Nick is gone and, after a bout of vomiting, realizes she might be pregnant. Despite being on birth control, she had missed a few days, and at thirty-eight, she doesn't expect to get pregnant. She retrieves a pregnancy test from a locked case and, after following the instructions meticulously, confirms her pregnancy.
Overwhelmed, Amy rushes to Noelle's house to share the news, bursting into tears and showing her the positive test result. Once home, she has two conflicting thoughts: she plans to use the anniversary treasure hunt to create a romantic scenario, ending with an antique wooden cradle, to convince Nick they belong together as a family. However, she also wishes she had gotten the gun she intended to buy, as she fears Nick's potential violence.
Amy recalls a recent incident where Nick invited her to go out on a raft, and she imagined him pushing her into the water and holding her under until she drowned. She feels her value has decreased, noting how Nick looks at her now with a sense of being swindled and trapped. Despite her fears, she resolves not to terminate the pregnancy or end her marriage, clinging to memories of their past happiness and hoping they can be happy again.
Amy keeps a lentil in her pocket as a reminder of the growing life inside her. She acknowledges the possibility that Nick might harm her, and if she is found dead, she leaves a cryptic message, hinting at the danger she perceives from her husband.
Key Events
- Amy confirms she is pregnant after missing birth control days.
- Amy shares the news of her pregnancy with Noelle.
- Amy plans to use the anniversary treasure hunt to convince Nick they belong together as a family.
- Amy keeps a lentil in her pocket as a symbol of her unborn child.
- Amy expresses her fear that Nick might harm her.
Themes
- Pregnancy and Fear
- Hope and Desperation
- Marital Strain and Trust Issues
- Motherhood and Identity
Chapter 33 Nick Dunne: Seven Days Gone
Despite his initial reluctance, Nick decides to hire Tanner Bolt, a high-profile defense attorney known for representing men accused of murdering their wives. Recognizing the necessity of top-tier legal representation, Nick travels to New York for a meeting with Bolt. Upon assessing the gravity of Nick's situation, Bolt outlines a strategic plan to manage the case, including improving Nick's public image and identifying an alternative suspect. Bolt reveals new information about Amy's past, specifically a date-rape accusation against Tommy O'Hara in 2005, which Amy never disclosed to Nick. Bolt emphasizes the importance of complete honesty and urges Nick to cut off all contact with Andie, his mistress. Nick agrees, understanding the potential consequences of continuing the affair. Bolt also tasks Nick with compiling lists of romantic gestures towards Amy and potential suspects who might have harmed her. Returning to Carthage, Nick reflects on his relationship with Andie and his growing feelings for Amy, who is now pregnant. He realizes that his affair with Andie was a mistake and that he must focus on clearing his name and finding Amy. The chapter ends with Nick deciphering the fourth clue in Amy's treasure hunt, leading him to a decrepit woodshed behind Go's house, where he fears the worst.
Key Events
- Nick hires Tanner Bolt as his defense attorney.
- Bolt reveals Amy's past date-rape accusation against Tommy O'Hara.
- Nick agrees to cut off all contact with Andie.
- Nick deciphers the fourth clue in Amy's treasure hunt, leading to a woodshed behind Go's house.
Themes
- Legal Strategy and Public Perception
- Honesty and Deception
- Impact of Past Secrets
- Moral Dilemmas and Personal Growth
Chapter 34 Amy Elliott Dunne: the Day Of
In the woodshed behind Go's house, Amy feels a sense of liberation and control, despite the complexity of her plan. She meticulously staged her disappearance, creating a crime scene in the living room, cutting herself to leave a blood trail, and cleaning up to confound the police. Each step on her checklist, from wrapping the first clue in a box to changing into generic clothes and slipping away along the riverbank, was executed with precision.
Amy delves into her deep-seated issues, tracing them back to her parents' numerous miscarriages and stillbirths, which made her feel both special and burdened. Her parents' inability to teach her happiness and her own tendency to adapt different personas are central to her psychological makeup. She admits to playing the 'Cool Girl' for Nick, a role that initially brought her joy but eventually felt unsustainable and false.
Her frustration with Nick’s inability to see her true self and his surprise at her asserting her real personality fuel her resentment. She resents him for expecting her to remain the perfect, accommodating wife and for failing to understand her need to be more than a fantasy. Amy’s decision to fake her own disappearance is a calculated move to punish Nick for his perceived shortcomings and to reclaim control over her life. Despite her newfound freedom, she reflects on the irony of her situation, acknowledging that while she is free, she is deeply unhappy with the person she has become.
Key Events
- Amy stages her disappearance, including cutting herself to create a blood trail.
- Amy reveals her history of pretending to be the 'Cool Girl' for Nick.
- Amy explains the psychological reasons behind her elaborate plan to fake her own death.
Themes
- The Burden of Perfection and Expectations
- The Illusion of Control and Manipulation
- The Cost of Pretending and Authenticity
Chapter 35 Nick Dunne: Seven Days Gone
Feeling a sense of dread, Nick enters the woodshed behind Go's house, realizing the significance of the location. The woodshed was one of the many places where he had cheated on Amy with Andie, and the clue leading him here was a deliberate reminder of his infidelities. Inside, he discovers a collection of expensive items that he had previously denied buying, all neatly arranged and incriminating. The items, which include golf clubs, watches, and designer clothes, are clear evidence that Amy is framing him for her disappearance.
Nick brings Go to the woodshed to show her the evidence. Initially shocked, Go briefly suspects Nick of being involved in Amy's disappearance, but Nick quickly convinces her that Amy is framing him. They speculate on Amy's motivations, noting her need for validation and her desire to see him suffer. The final clue in Amy's treasure hunt leads Nick to a gift box containing two wooden puppets, resembling Punch and Judy. The note inside suggests a trip up the river and a sinister narrative of violence and betrayal, mirroring the plot of the violent puppet show.
Nick and Go interpret the puppets and the Madness song lyrics, realizing that Amy is using the violent Punch and Judy story to frame him for her murder. Punch beats Judy and their baby to death, and each time he commits a violent act, he says, 'That’s the way to do it!' This phrase is a chilling indication that Amy intends to portray Nick as a violent murderer who gets away with his crimes. The realization that Amy has meticulously planned her disappearance and frame-up leaves Nick feeling both terrified and humiliated.
As they grapple with the implications of Amy's elaborate scheme, Nick and Go understand that Amy is using the treasure hunt to manipulate Nick and the police, and that she has set him up to be charged with her murder. The prospect of facing the death penalty adds a new level of urgency and fear to Nick's situation, as he realizes the depth of Amy's manipulation and the danger he is in.
Key Events
- Nick discovers incriminating items in the woodshed, realizing Amy is framing him.
- Nick and Go interpret the puppets and Madness song lyrics, linking them to the violent Punch and Judy story.
- Nick and Go realize Amy's intention to frame him for her murder and the death of their unborn child.
- Nick and Go understand the implications of Amy's scheme and the danger he faces.
Themes
- Manipulation and Deception
- Marital Betrayal
- Psychological Warfare
- Justice and Retribution
Chapter 36 Amy Elliott Dunne: the Day Of
Still reeling from the shock of discovering Nick's infidelity, Amy reflects on the night she followed him to Missouri, where he kissed and went up to the apartment of his mistress. Her betrayal and humiliation fuel her resolve to frame Nick for her murder as a form of revenge. Amy meticulously plans every detail, changing her appearance and purchasing a nondescript car for her getaway. In a gas station restroom, she cuts her hair, dyes it brown, and puts on outdated glasses, transforming herself into a different person. She reflects on the various personas she has adopted throughout her life, from the perfect 'Amazing Amy' to the vengeful scorned wife, and the discipline required to maintain the diary entries that will implicate Nick in her disappearance. Amy's plan is not just about revenge; it is also a way to reclaim control over her life and ensure that Nick is punished for his actions. She details the extensive preparation and the psychological manipulation involved in writing the diary entries, which are designed to paint her as a victim and Nick as a murderer. Her reflection on her past and her relationship with Nick reveals the deep-seated issues and the layers of manipulation and control that have defined their marriage.
Key Events
- Amy discovers Nick's infidelity with his mistress.
- Amy decides to frame Nick for her murder as a form of revenge.
- Amy changes her appearance and purchases a nondescript car for her getaway.
- Amy writes extensive diary entries to implicate Nick in her disappearance.
Themes
- Revenge through meticulous planning
- Identity transformation and control
- Manipulation and psychological warfare
Chapter 37 Nick Dunne: Seven Days Gone
Feeling increasingly cornered and desperate, Nick calls his newly hired lawyer, Tanner Bolt, to inform him that he believes Amy is framing him for her disappearance. Tanner, though skeptical, advises Nick to sit tight and wait for his arrival the next morning. Unable to calm down, Nick paces back and forth, his eyes fixed on the woodshed that holds the evidence of Amy's frame-up.
Late at night, a knock at the back door startles Nick. He opens it to find Andie, his mistress, dressed up and determined to see him. Despite Nick's warnings about the danger of their relationship, Andie insists that she needs to see him, revealing her desperation and fear. Realizing the gravity of the situation, Nick decides to end the affair. He tries to explain that continuing the relationship is not only dangerous but also morally wrong, emphasizing the need to do the right thing.
Andie, however, is not convinced and becomes increasingly agitated. She accuses Nick of using her and being a coward, unable to face his problems. The conversation escalates into a heated argument, with Andie lashing out at Nick for his deceit and cowardice. Nick, trying to contain the situation, grabs Andie's arm to prevent her from leaving in a state of anger. The physical confrontation intensifies, and Andie bites Nick, allowing her to escape through the back door.
Key Events
- Nick calls Tanner Bolt, his lawyer, to inform him that Amy is framing him.
- Andie visits Nick late at night, demanding to see him.
- Nick decides to end the affair with Andie, citing the danger and moral wrongness of their relationship.
- Andie becomes agitated and accuses Nick of being a coward and a liar.
- The argument escalates into a physical confrontation, ending with Andie biting Nick and escaping.
Characters Introduced
- Andie
Themes
- Ethical Choices in Crisis
- Deception and Manipulation
- Consequences of Actions
- Desperation and Fear
Chapter 38 Amy Elliott Dunne: Five Days Gone
Still reeling from the confrontation with Andie and the discovery of the incriminating items in the woodshed, Amy reflects on her current situation from her hiding place in the Hide-A-Way Cabins, where she is ensconced as 'Ozark Amy.' She details the meticulous planning of her disappearance, including the staged crime scene, the mopped-up blood, and the altered alarm code at her father-in-law's house. Amy's plan is to frame Nick for her murder, and she is closely monitoring the progress of her scheme through her disposable cell phone and the media.
Amy is particularly pleased with the media coverage, especially the attention from Ellen Abbott, a prominent crime-news host. She delights in the public's growing suspicion of Nick, fueled by the staged clues, the discovery of his affair with Andie, and the revelation of Amy's pregnancy. Amy's plan includes leaving behind a diary that paints her as a victim and Nick as a violent, cheating husband. She is also manipulating the timeline and evidence to ensure the police build a strong case against him.
Amy describes her life in hiding, detailing her budgeting and financial planning. She has stockpiled cash over a year, siphoning money from Nick and their joint accounts without attracting attention. She is living frugally, spending only what is necessary, and has even splurged on a few comforts like good sheets and a decent lamp. She interacts minimally with the locals, receiving fish from a neighbor named Jeff and tomatoes from Dorothy, the front desk manager.
Amy reflects on her relationship with Nick, noting his outdoor habits and his fear of being trapped. She imagines his nightmare of being wrongfully imprisoned and the claustrophobic conditions he will face. She also contemplates Andie, his mistress, and the need for her to break and reveal the affair. Amy has been monitoring Andie through a fake Facebook profile and is surprised by her discretion. Despite her initial plans, Andie has not yet exposed the affair, which is crucial for Amy's scheme to be fully realized.
Key Events
- Amy monitors the progress of her plan through her disposable cell phone and the media.
- Amy is pleased with the media coverage, especially the attention from Ellen Abbott.
- Amy describes her life in hiding and her financial planning.
- Amy reflects on her relationship with Nick and her plans for his punishment.
Characters Introduced
- Jeff
- Dorothy
Themes
- Revenge and Manipulation
- Control and Power
- Financial Planning and Secrecy
Chapter 39 Nick Dunne: Eight Days Gone
Still reeling from the confrontation with Andie and the discovery of the incriminating items in the woodshed, Nick is visited by Detective Boney early in the morning. She brings him coffee and inquires about the bite mark on his cheek, which he claims are hives. Boney reveals that Amy's purse was found on the banks of the river in Hannibal, with Nick's fingerprints on it, suggesting a staged disposal. Boney questions Nick about his recent trips to Hannibal, implying that he might have planted the purse to divert suspicion. Feeling cornered, Nick calls Tanner Bolt, his lawyer, who arrives to discuss the case.
Key Events
- Detective Boney visits Nick and reveals the discovery of Amy's purse in Hannibal.
- Boney questions Nick about his recent trips to Hannibal, suggesting he planted the purse.
- Nick calls Tanner Bolt, his lawyer, who arrives to discuss the case.
Themes
- Manipulation and Deception
- Legal and Investigative Pressure
- Escalating Suspicion and Paranoia
Chapter 40 Amy Elliott Dunne: Seven Days Gone
Amy reflects on the success of her plan to frame Nick for her disappearance, particularly the revelation of her pregnancy. The media frenzy, fueled by Ellen Abbott's coverage, has intensified, driving public hatred against Nick. Amy takes pleasure in the attention and the impact on Nick, but she is frustrated by the lack of progress in his arrest and the unexpected silence from Andie, her mistress. Amy details her manipulation of Noelle to fake her pregnancy and interacts with Greta, a fellow resident at the Hide-A-Way Cabins, observing her behavior.
Key Events
- Amy reflects on the media coverage and public reaction to her disappearance.
- Amy details her manipulation of Noelle to fake her pregnancy.
- Amy interacts with Greta, a fellow resident at the Hide-A-Way Cabins, and observes her behavior.
Characters Introduced
- Greta
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Media Influence
- Strategic Deception
Chapter 41 Nick Dunne: Eight Days Gone
Nick, Go, and Tanner Bolt search Nick's father's house for any hidden evidence that might help their case. Despite their thorough search, they find nothing, and Tanner expresses his concern about the uncontained issues they are facing. Tanner suggests reporting the contents of the woodshed to the police before they get caught, but he is hesitant to do so without knowing Andie's mindset and Amy's true intentions.
Nick and Tanner discuss the risks of revealing the woodshed contents to the police, particularly the potential implications for Go and the likelihood of the police interpreting the evidence unfavorably. Tanner emphasizes the need to involve Andie in their plan, as her testimony could either help or hinder their case. Nick, however, is reluctant to believe that Andie would betray him, despite the evidence of her recent anger.
Returning home, Nick finds the house surrounded by reporters, who bombard him with questions about Amy's pregnancy and his involvement in her disappearance. He locks himself inside, pulling down the shades to block the intrusive cameras. While showering, he reflects on Amy's manipulative nature and the realization that he is married to a woman capable of extreme deceit.
The Elliotts, Amy's parents, arrive at Nick's house, and Marybeth confronts him about his behavior and his relationship with Amy. She expresses her loss of faith in Nick and accuses him of not loving Amy or wanting the baby. Rand, more composed, asks Nick directly if he killed Amy. Nick denies it, but the Elliotts' visit leaves him feeling alarmed and determined to prove Amy's true character to the police.
Key Events
- Nick, Go, and Tanner search Nick's father's house for hidden evidence.
- Tanner suggests reporting the woodshed contents to the police but is cautious without Andie's involvement.
- Nick returns home to find the house surrounded by reporters.
- Marybeth confronts Nick, expressing her loss of faith in him.
- Rand directly asks Nick if he killed Amy.
Themes
- Manipulation and Deception
- Media Pressure and Public Perception
- Family Dynamics and Trust
- Legal Strategy and Risk Management
Chapter 42 Amy Elliott Dunne: Eight Days Gone
Still reeling from the chaos of her fabricated disappearance, Amy finds a strange comfort in the aimless activities at the Hide-A-Way Cabins. She spends the day with Greta and Jeff, engaging in bumper boats and miniature golf, activities that, despite their haphazard nature, offer a stark contrast to her former life of precision and control.
During a hot-dog lunch, Greta and Jeff invite themselves into Amy's cabin, causing her significant anxiety due to the money belt hidden inside. Amy feels a growing sense of paranoia and realizes the risks of forming connections with others, especially when she is on the run. She politely but firmly asks them to leave, feeling a mix of guilt and relief when they comply.
Later, Jeff offers Amy a job netting catfish for fifty dollars. Despite her initial hesitation, Amy agrees, seeing it as a way to earn extra money and maintain her cover. The job involves a clandestine operation at Catfish Carl’s, where Amy and Jeff work together to catch and kill the fish, a task that is both physically demanding and emotionally jarring for Amy.
Amy reflects on the freedom she feels as a 'ghost,' able to do things she never would have considered before. However, the experience of netting and killing the fish, and the subsequent need to clean up, reinforces her determination to avoid being discovered. She carefully hides her money belt and swims out to the rocks, ensuring it is safe before scrambling back to shore.
Key Events
- Amy spends the day with Greta and Jeff, engaging in leisure activities.
- Amy feels anxious when Greta and Jeff enter her cabin, revealing her hidden money belt.
- Jeff offers Amy a job netting catfish for fifty dollars.
- Amy and Jeff work together to catch and kill catfish at Catfish Carl’s.
- Amy reflects on her newfound freedom and the risks of being discovered.
Themes
- Paranoia and Isolation
- Loss of Identity and Reclaiming Self
- Moral Ambiguity
- Survival and Adaptation
Chapter 43 Nick Dunne: Eight Days Gone
Nick Dunne reaches out to Hilary Handy, a former high school acquaintance of Amy's, to uncover more details about Amy's past. Hilary shares a harrowing story of how Amy manipulated her, leading to Hilary's expulsion from Wickshire Academy after being falsely accused of pushing Amy down a flight of stairs. Hilary believes Amy fabricated the incident out of jealousy over Hilary's achievements and friendships. Nick, disturbed by this revelation, relays the conversation to his lawyer, Tanner Bolt, adding another layer of complexity to the investigation.
Key Events
- Nick contacts Hilary Handy to gather information about Amy's past.
- Hilary recounts how Amy manipulated her and led to her expulsion from Wickshire Academy.
- Nick relays his conversation with Hilary to Tanner Bolt, his lawyer.
Themes
- Manipulation and Deception
- Jealousy and Rivalry
- Legal and Personal Consequences
Chapter 44 Amy Elliott Dunne: Nine Days Gone
Amy wakes up feeling nervous and off, concerned about being discovered at the Hide-A-Way Cabins. Her anxiety grows as she reflects on the investigation's slow progress, her dwindling funds, and the suspicious behavior of Jeff and Greta. Deciding to leave immediately, Amy plans to clean her cabin thoroughly to erase any traces of her presence.
Amy makes two calls to the Amy Dunne tip line, offering different tips, but the volunteers seem disinterested. She drives to the library to check on Nick and discovers a viral video of him giving a drunken interview in a bar. Nick speaks passionately about his love for Amy, his regret for failing her, and his determination to find her and make amends. Amy is momentarily moved by Nick's sincerity but quickly reminds herself that it does not change her plan.
Returning to her cabin, Amy finds Dorothy demanding the overdue rent. She pays Dorothy and notices Greta and Jeff watching her from Greta's porch. Amy starts packing her few belongings, reflecting on the minimal possessions she now owns compared to her former life. She meticulously cleans the cabin, her hands trembling with a mix of paranoia and self-doubt.
Suddenly, Jeff and Greta knock on Amy's door, insisting on coming inside. They confront her about the money she has hidden and reveal that they have noticed her fake glasses and dyed hair. Despite Amy's protests, Greta shoves her and steals the money belt. Jeff and Greta leave, warning Amy to be more careful in the future. Amy is left with only a quarter and a dime, feeling violated and terrified.
Key Events
- Amy decides to leave the Hide-A-Way Cabins immediately.
- Amy discovers a viral video of Nick giving a drunken, heartfelt interview about his love for her.
- Greta and Jeff confront Amy, steal her money belt, and warn her to be more careful.
Themes
- Paranoia and suspicion
- Financial desperation
- Betrayal and trust
Chapter 45 Nick Dunne: Nine Days Gone
Nick wakes up feeling a sense of satisfaction after watching the positive online reviews of his impromptu interview. The public seems to be rallying behind him, and he reflects on the need to convince Amy to return. However, his lawyer Tanner's detective has found no leads on her whereabouts. Tanner expresses concern about Nick's recent actions, warning him about the risks of uncontrolled media appearances and the importance of maintaining a positive public image.
Tanner and Go criticize Nick for his risky behavior, but Nick insists that the positive reviews validate his approach. Tanner emphasizes the need for precise timing and control in their strategy, proposing to reveal the contents of the woodshed to the police soon. He also reveals plans for a high-profile interview with Sharon Schieber, a respected news anchor, to further improve Nick's image. Tanner stresses the importance of a well-prepared and natural interview, advising Nick to be extremely careful with his words and gestures.
Tanner advises Nick to disclose his affair with Andie during the interview, apologizing sincerely to regain public sympathy. He explains that while revealing Amy's frame-up to the media is too complex, they will inform the police about it just before the interview airs. Tanner acknowledges the risks of this strategy, including the possibility of the police laughing them out of the station, but believes it is worth the gamble. Nick, though reluctant, agrees to the plan, recognizing it as the only way to potentially bring Amy back.
Nick, Go, and Tanner travel to St. Louis for the interview preparation, where Betsy Bolt, Tanner's wife and a former TV news anchor, leads the rehearsal. Betsy critiques Nick's on-camera presence and uses jellybeans to train him to relax and be more natural. They focus on crafting a compelling narrative that emphasizes Nick's love for Amy, his remorse for his mistakes, and his commitment to recommit to their relationship. The session is intense, with Betsy and Tanner providing detailed feedback to ensure Nick performs well in the actual interview.
Key Events
- Nick reflects on the positive reviews of his impromptu interview.
- Tanner proposes a high-profile interview with Sharon Schieber to improve Nick's image.
- Tanner advises Nick to disclose his affair with Andie during the interview.
- Nick, Go, and Tanner travel to St. Louis for interview preparation with Betsy Bolt.
- Betsy uses jellybeans to train Nick to be more natural on camera.
Themes
- Media manipulation
- Public perception
- Media strategy
- Personal redemption
Chapter 46 Amy Elliott Dunne: Nine Days Gone
Amy Elliott Dunne finds herself penniless and on the run, huddled in her Festiva at the far end of a fast-food complex parking lot on the banks of the Mississippi River. The air is heavy with the scent of salt and factory-farm meat, and the warm evening offers little comfort. Amy is paralyzed by indecision, unable to determine her next move. The car, growing increasingly cramped, forces her to curl up like a fetus to avoid her legs falling asleep, and she is hyper-aware of the constant threat of discovery or attack.
The glowing restaurant signs cast an eerie, prison-like light, heightening her sense of isolation and vulnerability. The thought of suicide crosses her mind as she contemplates the relentless brightness, reminiscent of a prisoner on suicide watch. Her gas tank is nearly empty, limiting her options to a one-hour drive in any direction. The river, a constant presence, looms over her decisions, and she must choose carefully between Arkansas, Iowa, the Ozarks, or crossing into Illinois.
Despite the overwhelming circumstances, Amy suddenly knows what she must do. Her clarity of purpose stands in stark contrast to her earlier paralysis, signaling a shift in her resolve and a potential turning point in her elaborate plan to frame Nick for her disappearance.
Key Events
- Amy is penniless and on the run, sitting in her car in a fast-food complex parking lot.
- Amy contemplates her limited options and the constant threat of discovery or attack.
- Amy's gas tank is nearly empty, limiting her driving options to a one-hour radius in any direction.
- Amy suddenly knows what she must do, signaling a shift in her resolve.
Themes
- Isolation and Vulnerability
- Desperation and Survival
- Shift in Resolve
Chapter 47 Nick Dunne: Ten Days Gone
Betsy fusses over Nick’s appearance, insisting he use powder to control his sweating, while Go trims his hair. Tanner oversees the preparation, ensuring every detail is perfect, and subtly suggests Botox to combat sweat, a suggestion Nick dismissively rejects. At five P.M., Tanner’s phone rings, displaying a call from Boney. He sends it to voicemail, not wanting any new information to disrupt their carefully crafted message. Nick agrees, feeling that Boney’s call would only add unnecessary stress. The team reassures each other that the call is not a cause for concern, and Go expresses her excitement about meeting Sharon Schieber, drawing a comparison to their mother’s opinions on news anchors.
At six P.M., the team enters the living room, where the interview setup is ready, with the St. Louis Arch serving as a backdrop. A producer briefs Nick on the interview protocol, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the integrity of his answers. Just as they are about to begin, Sharon Schieber enters the room, exuding grace and professionalism. Go whispers excitedly about their mother’s admiration for Sharon, who greets them warmly but is immediately interrupted by her producer, who whispers urgently in her ear. Sharon’s demeanor changes abruptly, and she looks at Nick with a serious expression, indicating that something significant has occurred. The tension in the room is palpable, and the interview begins under a cloud of uncertainty.
Key Events
- Betsy and Go prepare Nick for the interview with Sharon Schieber.
- Tanner sends Boney’s call to voicemail to avoid disruption.
- Go expresses excitement about meeting Sharon Schieber.
- Sharon Schieber enters the room and receives urgent information from her producer.
Themes
- Media Preparation and Strategy
- Uncertainty and Tension
- Professionalism Under Pressure
Chapter 48 Amy Elliott Dunne: Ten Days Gone
Feeling worn down by her life in the Hide-A-Way Cabins, Amy decides to call Desi Collings for help. She spends the day preparing, cleaning herself in a McDonald’s bathroom and changing into a cheap sundress. Amy drives to a river casino called Horseshoe Alley, a place teeming with elderly gamblers and young, overdressed boys trying to mimic Rat Pack cool. Initially nervous about the cameras and the crowded environment, Amy decides to proceed with the meeting.
Desi arrives and greets Amy with concern, embracing her and asking about her well-being. Amy bursts into tears, allowing herself a moment of genuine emotion, and then recounts a fabricated story of abuse and violence at Nick’s hands. She tells Desi that she needed to disappear for her safety and the safety of her unborn child. Desi, ever the white knight, offers to take care of her, suggesting she stay at his secluded lake house. Amy is hesitant but ultimately agrees, feeling that the lake house would provide the comfort and security she needs.
The meeting is interrupted by a mustached man who approaches their table, asking if Amy is related to the Enloe family. Desi dismisses the man, but the incident adds to Amy’s unease. As they prepare to leave, Amy sees Andie’s press conference on a TV in the casino. Andie confesses to her affair with Nick, expressing shame and cooperation with the police. Amy’s fury simmers beneath her surface, but she maintains a facade of distress, nodding to Desi’s concerned inquiries. The chapter ends with Amy’s parents, Rand and Marybeth, also giving a statement, withdrawing their support from Nick due to the revelation of his affair.
Amy, now more determined than ever, agrees to go to Desi’s lake house, seeing it as a temporary haven where she can continue her plan. The chapter highlights Amy’s manipulative nature and her ability to use Desi’s protective instincts to her advantage, while also showing the growing public and familial pressure on Nick.
Key Events
- Amy calls Desi Collings for help and meets him at a river casino called Horseshoe Alley.
- Amy fabricates a story of abuse and violence at Nick’s hands to gain Desi’s sympathy and support.
- Desi offers Amy his secluded lake house for her to hide out, which she accepts.
- Amy sees Andie’s press conference, where Andie confesses to her affair with Nick and expresses cooperation with the police.
- Rand and Marybeth withdraw their support from Nick, publicly condemning him for his affair.
Characters Introduced
- Desi Collings
Themes
- Manipulation and Deception
- Strategic Use of Emotional Manipulation
- Public Perception and Media Influence
- Family Dynamics and Betrayal
Chapter 49 Nick Dunne: Ten Days Gone
Still reeling from the shock of Andie's press conference, Nick and his team prepare for the live interview with Sharon Schieber. Sharon, initially angry, quickly warms up to Nick, recognizing his genuine remorse and his strategic use of the 'Ellen Abbott effect' to shift the blame away from himself. Nick delivers a heartfelt apology, drawing parallels to Hugh Grant's famous 1995 apology, and manages to gain public sympathy.
Just as the interview concludes, Go informs Nick and Tanner that the police have a warrant for the woodshed at his father's house. They arrive at the scene to find the woodshed lit up and filled with incriminating items, including expensive goods and pornographic DVDs. Boney and Gilpin confront Nick with the evidence, including his fingerprints on the items, which Amy must have planted. Nick is visibly shaken, especially when he sees Go being taken away by the police.
Determined to clear his name, Nick insists on meeting with the police at the station to tell them the truth, despite Tanner's reservations. They agree to go, with Tanner emphasizing that he will do the talking. At the station, Boney and Gilpin present a thick, charred diary, revealing that Amy kept a detailed account of her life and her marriage for seven years. Nick is stunned, realizing that Amy's meticulous planning extends even to framing him with his own fingerprints.
Key Events
- Andie's press conference is shown on TV during the interview preparation.
- Nick delivers a successful interview with Sharon Schieber, gaining public sympathy.
- The police arrive with a warrant for the woodshed, finding incriminating items and Nick's fingerprints.
- Go is taken away by the police, prompting Nick to insist on meeting with the police to tell the truth.
- The police present a charred diary revealing Amy's detailed account of her life and marriage.
Themes
- Manipulation and Frame-up
- Strategic Media Manipulation
- Family Loyalty and Betrayal
Chapter 50 Amy Elliott Dunne: Ten Days Gone
Still reeling from the shock of the woodshed discovery, Amy and Desi drive across state lines into Illinois to dispose of Amy's car, wiping it down and leaving it with the keys in the ignition. They return to Missouri, navigating wavy hills until they reach Desi's secluded lake house near Lake Hannafan. Despite Desi's insistence that the area is old and sophisticated, Amy remains unimpressed, noting the recent and controversial history of the lake and the house itself.
Desi gives Amy a tour of the house, showcasing its luxurious features, including a cathedral kitchen, a living room with his-and-hers fireplaces, a basement entertainment room, and a wine cellar. Upstairs, he shows her the bedroom he has prepared for her, painted in dusty rose, a color she no longer favors. Desi's attentions and the opulent setting make Amy feel a mix of gratitude and unease, especially when he reveals a greenhouse filled with year-round blooming tulips, a gesture meant to win her favor.
Desi's over-the-top efforts and the speed with which he has prepared the house raise suspicions in Amy's mind. She wonders how long Desi has been planning to bring her here and how long he expects her to stay. Despite the fairy-tale quality of the setup, Amy feels a growing sense of anxiety and asks Desi for some money, just in case she needs to leave quickly. Desi reluctantly gives her two twenty-dollar bills, which makes Amy question whether she has made a significant mistake by trusting him.
Key Events
- Amy and Desi dispose of Amy's car in Illinois.
- Desi gives Amy a tour of his luxurious lake house.
- Desi reveals a greenhouse filled with year-round blooming tulips.
- Amy feels uneasy about Desi's intentions and asks for money.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Appearance vs. Reality
- Trust and Suspicion
Chapter 51 Nick Dunne: Ten Days Gone
Nick Dunne faces intense interrogation by Detectives Boney and Gilpin, who present a charred diary found in his father's house. The diary, written in Amy's handwriting, details her alleged abuse, fear, and a poisoning incident, casting Nick as a violent and controlling husband. Shocked and disgusted, Nick recognizes the meticulous planning behind Amy's frame-up. The detectives relentlessly challenge his alibis and the inconsistencies in his story, pointing out his recent trips to Hannibal and the incriminating items found in the woodshed. They also mention a neighbor who overheard an argument between Nick and Amy the night before her disappearance, further tightening the noose around him. Nick's frustration and anger mount as he struggles to maintain his composure, feeling cornered and desperate to prove Amy's scheme. Tanner, his lawyer, intervenes, presenting the clues from Amy's treasure hunt and the Punch and Judy dolls as evidence of her elaborate plan to frame Nick. However, the detectives remain skeptical, questioning the authenticity of the clues and the inside jokes Nick claims to recognize. Boney, in particular, is unconvinced, noting that the clues do not explicitly lead to the locations where evidence was found. The tension escalates as Boney and Gilpin accuse Nick of being a sociopath and a killer, intensifying the pressure on him. The chapter concludes with Nick feeling increasingly isolated and desperate, as the detectives' skepticism and the mounting evidence against him make it clear that proving Amy's plan will be an uphill battle. His hatred for Amy and admiration for her manipulation are evident, but he remains determined to clear his name and expose the truth.
Key Events
- Detectives present a charred diary detailing Amy's alleged abuse and fear.
- Nick and Tanner present the treasure hunt clues and Punch and Judy dolls as evidence of Amy's frame-up.
- Detectives remain skeptical and accuse Nick of being a sociopath and a killer.
- Nick feels increasingly isolated and desperate to prove Amy's plan.
Themes
- Manipulation and Deception
- Legal and Investigative Pressure
- Desperation and Isolation
Chapter 52 Amy Elliott Dunne: Eleven Days Gone
Amy prepares to watch Nick’s interview with Sharon Schieber, determined to take notes on his lies to fuel her fury. However, Desi’s constant presence makes it difficult for her to be alone. Despite her attempts to fend him off, Desi persists, offering her a meal and her favorite foods, creating an uncomfortable but controlled environment.
During the interview, Nick admits to his infidelity and expresses deep remorse, vowing to be a better man if Amy returns. Amy is touched by his sincerity, recognizing their old secret code when he touches his chin. Desi, however, remains skeptical and dismissive, accusing Nick of putting on a show and lying about the abuse. Amy, feeling a mix of emotions, outwardly agrees with Desi but internally questions whether Nick’s apology is genuine and if they can reconcile.
Reflecting on the early days of her marriage, Amy remembers the tenderness and pure intentions Nick once showed her. She contrasts this with Desi’s controlling behavior, which she finds suffocating. Amy begins to daydream about a future with a reformed Nick, imagining them returning to New York and rebuilding their life together. She acknowledges that despite the current turmoil, she and Nick fit together, with her thorns perfectly fitting into his wounds.
Amy’s internal conflict deepens as she contemplates the possibility of returning to Nick. She recognizes that her feelings for him are complex and that she might have misinterpreted his earlier actions as laziness rather than genuine care. Despite the pain and manipulation, Amy feels a strong pull towards Nick, driven by a desire to find a way back to their early, happier days.
Key Events
- Amy prepares to watch Nick’s interview with Sharon Schieber.
- Desi hovers around Amy, making it difficult for her to be alone.
- Nick admits to his infidelity and expresses deep remorse during the interview.
- Amy is touched by Nick’s sincerity and recognizes their old secret code.
- Amy reflects on the early days of her marriage to Nick and considers reconciling with him.
Themes
- Genuine Apology and Emotional Manipulation
- Reconciliation and Redemption
- Internal Conflict and Self-Reflection
Chapter 53 Nick Dunne: Fourteen Days Gone
Nick wakes up on Go's couch with a throbbing hangover and a deep-seated urge to kill Amy. The days following the Diary Interview with the police have been a blur of fantasies of finding Amy and exacting revenge. Nick is certain he will be arrested soon, and Tanner has advised him to make the most of his remaining free days. The media presence outside Go's house is intense, and Go informs Nick that public opinion has turned against him again, with Sharon Schieber releasing a statement expressing disappointment in the case's direction.
Go and Nick argue about the possibility of Amy softening toward him. Nick believes Amy will want to come back to prove she is the winner, but Go is skeptical. The tension between them is palpable, and they snap at each other more frequently. Go feels resentful, and Nick feels ashamed, a toxic dynamic exacerbated by the situation. Determined to escape the media, Nick decides to go home, and Go helps him by using a hose to spray the crowd, giving him a chance to drive away.
Once home, Nick spends the day consumed by fantasies of killing Amy, feeling a renewed sense of energy and purpose. The media presence at his house is overwhelming, and he is unable to leave. By evening, the camera crews have dispersed, but Nick is still wired and agitated. He drinks heavily, smashing a glass in a fit of rage. A furious knock at the door reveals his father, Bill, who storms through the house, muttering insults and searching for someone. Nick realizes his father is looking for Amy and tries to calm him, but Bill's aggressive behavior and misogynistic ranting trigger deep-seated memories and emotions.
Nick, determined not to become like his father, forcefully escorts him back to the nursing home. The chapter ends with Nick reflecting on his hatred for Amy and the realization that he is a one-woman misogynist, focused solely on her. Despite his rage, he knows the only option left is to beg Amy to come home, hoping to play the role of the good husband and convince her to return.
Key Events
- Nick wakes up with a hangover and fantasies of killing Amy.
- Go and Nick argue about Amy's potential return and the media backlash.
- Nick escapes the media at Go's house and returns home.
- Nick's father, Bill, shows up at Nick's house, searching for Amy and ranting.
- Nick escorts his father back to the nursing home and reflects on his hatred for Amy.
Themes
- Revenge and Hatred
- Family Dynamics and Resentment
- Public Perception and Media Influence
- Toxic Masculinity and Internal Conflict
Chapter 54 Amy Elliott Dunne: Twenty-six Days Gone
Amy reflects on her life as Desi's captive at his secluded lake house. Desi visits almost daily, hovering around her, making her feel like a prisoner despite his assurances of her safety and love. He controls her movements by withholding car keys, house keys, and the gate security code, effectively trapping her within the high walls of the property. Amy is deeply uncomfortable with Desi's constant presence and his manipulative behavior. He brings her elaborate but meager meals, always waiting for her compliments, and fusses over her appearance, encouraging her to look more like her former self. Desi continually reminds her of Nick's supposed mistreatment and suggests starting anew with him, but Amy remains determined to return to Nick, believing she is the only one who can save him from her frame-up. Amy feels a growing sense of repulsion towards Desi, recalling his manipulative and controlling nature from their past. She realizes that she cannot control Desi as she had hoped and fears that something very bad is about to happen. Despite her desire to escape, she is trapped and must find a way to manipulate Desi to achieve her goals.
Key Events
- Desi's daily visits and controlling behavior trap Amy at the lake house.
- Desi brings Amy elaborate but meager meals and fusses over her appearance.
- Desi suggests Amy start anew with him, but Amy remains determined to return to Nick.
- Amy feels growing repulsion towards Desi and fears something bad will happen.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Trapped and Isolated
- Struggle for Autonomy
- Inner Conflict
Chapter 55 Nick Dunne: Thirty-three Days Gone
Nick Dunne's days have stretched into a monotonous blur, but the routine shatters one August morning. Returning from grocery shopping, he finds Tanner, Boney, and Gilpin seated in his living room. On the table, inside a plastic evidence bag, lies a long, thick club with intricate grooves for fingers. Boney explains that the club was discovered during the initial search near his home but was initially deemed insignificant. However, after Nick showed them the Punch and Judy dolls, they re-examined the club and sent it to the lab for analysis.
Boney stands up and meets Nick's gaze, delivering the devastating news: Amy's blood was detected on the club, and the case is now classified as a homicide. They believe this to be the murder weapon. Nick, overwhelmed with shock and disbelief, responds in a hollow voice, urging Boney to reconsider. Boney, sounding somber, tells him, 'It’s time, Nick. It’s time.' The weight of the situation crushes Nick, and he realizes that the next phase of his ordeal is upon him.
Nick's world crumbles as he confronts the reality that the evidence is now overwhelmingly against him. The club, stained with Amy's blood, is a tangible piece of evidence that could send him to prison for murder. Tanner, Boney, and Gilpin's presence in his home marks a critical turning point in the investigation, and Nick understands that his struggle to prove his innocence has become even more urgent and perilous.
Key Events
- Nick finds Tanner, Boney, and Gilpin in his living room with a club found near his home.
- Boney reveals that Amy's blood was detected on the club, classifying the case as a homicide.
- Nick is told that the club is believed to be the murder weapon.
- Nick realizes the gravity of the situation and the overwhelming evidence against him.
Themes
- Evidence and Proof
- Turning Points in Investigations
- Confronting Inevitability
Chapter 56 Amy Elliott Dunne: Forty Days Gone
Amy finds an old piece of twine and an empty wine bottle, preparing for her next move with Desi. She dresses in a clingy pink dress, sans undergarments or shoes, and sets a cozy, inviting atmosphere with a fire and perfume. When Desi arrives uninvited, Amy greets him with unusual clinginess, expressing her desire for his presence and affection. Surprised and pleased, Desi remains cautious, treating her as a 'raped, abused woman.' Amy, feeling a mix of disgust and urgency, guides him towards more intimate actions, repeatedly assuring him of her readiness and certainty. Despite her impatience, Desi moves slowly, kissing her non-sexual areas and hesitating. Amy's frustration grows, and she finally pushes him to penetrate her, whispering commands to increase his pace. Desi's performance is lackluster, and Amy fakes her orgasm, working up tears to match his expectations of a deeply emotional first time. Afterward, she mixes two martinis, slipping three crushed sleeping pills into Desi's drink. Feeling triumphant and satisfied, Desi quickly drinks the martini and soon falls asleep. With Desi unconscious, Amy is ready to begin her next phase of the plan.
Key Events
- Amy prepares for her next move with Desi using twine and a wine bottle.
- Amy greets Desi with unusual clinginess and expresses her desire for him.
- Amy guides Desi towards more intimate actions, despite her disgust and impatience.
- Amy fakes her orgasm and works up tears to match Desi's expectations.
- Amy slips sleeping pills into Desi's martini, causing him to fall asleep.
Themes
- Manipulation
- Control
- Revenge
- Deception
Chapter 57 Nick Dunne: Forty Days Gone
Nick Dunne, out on bond and awaiting trial for the murder of his wife, Amy, reflects on his current state and the bizarre nature of his situation. Despite the oppressive heat of mid-August, he feels a sense of detachment, as if he is a product of an assembly line, labeled as 'Nick Dunne, Killer.' The trial looms over him, and he is haunted by the possibility of prison or even death, but he vows to kill himself before that happens.
Every day, Nick continues to tape messages to Amy, posted on Rebecca's Whodunnit blog, in a futile attempt to find her. The media presence is constant, and Nick has formed an odd camaraderie with the reporters, particularly a cartoon-voiced strongman who talks about his girlfriend. On this particular evening, Nick finishes his taped message, recounting the story of their first meeting in Brooklyn, and turns off the camera. The cuckoo clock above him begins to chime, and suddenly, the media outside erupts in a collective gasp.
The doorbell rings repeatedly, and Nick opens the door to find Amy standing barefoot on the doorstep, dressed in a thin pink dress, bruised, and covered in dried blood. She sobs and flings herself into his arms, and Nick, despite his overwhelming urge to strangle her, plays the part of the loving husband for the cameras. He yells her name and pulls her inside, whispering a harsh insult in her ear. Outside, the media frenzy intensifies, and Amy waves dismissively at the crowd, basking in the attention.
Inside, Nick confronts Amy about her disappearance and the elaborate frame-up. She claims that Desi Collings kidnapped her on their anniversary and held her captive in his lake house. She explains that the clues in the treasure hunt were placed in significant locations, but Nick is skeptical, pointing out the incriminating items and the lies in her diary. Amy insists she can explain everything, but Nick is not convinced. As he moves to call the police, a knock at the door indicates that they are already there.
Key Events
- Nick is out on bond, awaiting trial for Amy's murder.
- Nick continues to tape messages to Amy, posted on Rebecca's Whodunnit blog.
- Amy unexpectedly returns home, bruised and covered in blood.
- Amy claims Desi Collings kidnapped and held her captive.
- Nick is skeptical of Amy's explanation and confronts her about the frame-up.
Themes
- Manipulation and Deception
- Media Influence
- Marital Strife
- Justice and Retribution
Chapter 58 Amy Elliott Dunne: the Night of the Return
The media outside erupts in a collective gasp as the doorbell rings repeatedly. Inside, Amy Elliott Dunne, having escaped Desi Collings, returns to Nick's house on the night of her supposed kidnapping. She is immediately examined by a doctor, who confirms the visible bruises and injuries that corroborate her account of abuse. Detective Rhonda Boney, initially skeptical, is now convinced of Amy's ordeal and Nick's innocence, much to the relief of the public and the media.
At the police station, Amy is questioned by Boney and Gilpin, along with two FBI agents. She provides a detailed and convincing account of Desi's abduction, including the struggle at her house, the mopping of the blood, and the staged crime scene. Amy explains that Desi's plan was to make it look like a runaway wife scenario, but he panicked and left incriminating evidence behind. She also addresses the incriminating items found in the woodshed, suggesting that Nick hid them due to his financial troubles and impulse purchases.
Amy's testimony is laced with subtle manipulations and dramatic flourishes, designed to cast herself as a victim and Nick as a loving husband who was unfairly suspected. She downplays the more extreme entries in her diary, attributing them to her dramatic tendencies and a history of being stalked. Amy also criticizes the police for their initial incompetence, emphasizing that her return has saved both her and Nick from a grave injustice.
The chapter ends with Amy being praised as a hero by Boney, who acknowledges the department's mistakes and the need to correct their approach. Amy's strategic and calculated responses during the interview further solidify her control over the narrative and her ability to manipulate those around her.
Key Events
- Amy returns to Nick's house and is examined by a doctor.
- Amy is questioned by Boney and Gilpin at the police station.
- Amy provides a detailed and convincing account of her kidnapping by Desi Collings.
- Amy downplays the extreme entries in her diary and criticizes the police's initial handling of the case.
- Boney praises Amy as a hero and acknowledges the department's mistakes.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Media and Public Perception
- Justice and Injustice
- Strategic Deception and Redemption
Chapter 59 Nick Dunne: the Night of the Return
Nick Dunne arrives at the police station to fetch Amy, greeted by a throng of reporters and a surreal mix of celebration and tension. The police and Amy's parents, the Elliotts, express relief and support, but Nick is internally conflicted, playing the part of the relieved husband while harboring deep resentment and fear towards Amy.
At the station, Nick faces a tense encounter with Jacqueline Collings, Desi's mother, who accuses Amy of murdering her son. The interaction is chaotic, with Jacqueline's accusations and the reporters' questions adding to the turmoil. Despite the emotional storm, Amy is released after being questioned for four hours. The police, including Boney and Gilpin, seem satisfied with her story, much to Nick's disbelief and concern.
Returning home, the atmosphere between Nick and Amy is strained. Amy insists on staying with Nick, claiming she forgives him and wants to give him a chance to be a better husband. Nick is skeptical and confronts her about the lies, including the fake pregnancy and the murder of Desi. Amy reveals the intricate details of her plan, explaining how she manipulated Desi and staged the kidnapping. She threatens Nick with the possibility of attempting to frame him for attempted murder if he doesn't cooperate.
Feeling cornered and desperate, Nick retreats to a private moment and calls Tanner, his lawyer, to discuss the dire situation. Tanner advises him to play along with Amy for now, as the evidence and Amy's story are too strong. Nick is furious and considers the possibility of killing Amy, but ultimately decides to follow Tanner's advice to play nice and bide his time.
Key Events
- Nick fetches Amy from the police station and is greeted by the press.
- Jacqueline Collings accuses Amy of murdering Desi.
- Amy is released after being questioned and returns home with Nick.
- Amy reveals the details of her plan to manipulate Desi and stage the kidnapping.
- Nick calls Tanner, who advises him to play along with Amy for now.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Deception and Trust
- Legal and Moral Dilemmas
- Toxic Love and Coercion
Chapter 60 Amy Elliott Dunne: the Night of the Return
Still reeling from the chaotic return to the police station, Amy and Nick arrive home, where the tension between them is almost tangible. Nick is visibly scared, and Amy capitalizes on his fear, asserting her control over the situation. She tells him that she will not let him go, believing that their deep, toxic love is too ingrained to be broken. Amy insists that Nick can either choose to truly love her again or she will force him to be the man she wants him to be.
Nick, furious and desperate, argues that he no longer loves Amy and that they are a toxic, destructive couple. He pleads for a divorce, but Amy refuses, threatening to ruin his life if he tries to leave. She points out that a divorce would not make a good story and that it would tarnish her image as a strong, independent woman who overcame her kidnapping. Amy manipulates Nick, reminding him of his weaknesses and his inability to function without her.
The argument escalates, with Nick accusing Amy of being a manipulative, selfish psycho. Amy counters by reminding him that she is the one who made him into a better man and that without her, he would revert to his old, boring self. She taunts him about his affair with Andie, suggesting that he quickly forgot Andie once he thought Amy loved him again. Amy’s words strike a nerve, and Nick, overwhelmed with emotion, grabs her by the arm and shakes her.
Amy continues to push Nick's buttons, emphasizing that she is the one who makes him a man. Nick, on the brink of breaking, uses all his strength to keep his hands at his side. His eyes are wet with tears, and he is visibly shaking. The chapter ends with Nick's hands on Amy's neck, the tension between them reaching a dangerous peak.
Key Events
- Amy returns home and asserts her control over Nick.
- Nick pleads for a divorce, but Amy refuses and threatens to ruin his life.
- Amy manipulates Nick by reminding him of his weaknesses and his inability to function without her.
- The argument escalates, with Nick grabbing Amy by the arm and shaking her.
- Amy continues to push Nick's buttons, leading to a dangerous confrontation.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Toxic Relationships
- Power Dynamics
- Psychological Warfare
Chapter 61 Nick Dunne: the Night of the Return
Nick Dunne, in a moment of intense rage, grabs Amy by the neck and presses her to the ground, choking her. Amy, still on the ground, gasps and coughs, her breath coming in jagged rasps. Overwhelmed by a sudden, profound question, Nick releases her: If he kills Amy, who will he be? This thought stops him in his tracks, and he drops Amy as if she were burning iron.
As the room falls silent, Nick is left grappling with the realization that Amy has shaped him into his best and worst selves. Despite her manipulative nature and the lengths she has gone to, both to punish and to return to him, he cannot imagine a life without her. The thought of a normal, sweet woman next door pales in comparison, and Nick knows he would never find peace with anyone else.
Nick acknowledges that Amy is toxic and dangerous, but he also sees her as a necessary part of his life. He decides that the best outcome is to have Amy put in prison, where she can no longer harm him but where he can still visit her or at least imagine her presence. Reflecting on how Amy’s story could have gone differently if she had met a different man, one who could have loved and managed her without forcing her to pretend or act out, Nick feels a deep sense of responsibility to stop her.
In this moment of clarity, Nick resolves to take the necessary steps to put Amy in prison, recognizing that it is his duty to stop her madness and protect himself from her further manipulation. The chapter ends with Nick’s determination to take control of the situation, even if it means sacrificing his own peace of mind.
Key Events
- Nick chokes Amy and then releases her, contemplating the question of who he would be without her.
- Nick realizes that Amy has shaped him into his best and worst selves and cannot imagine a life without her.
- Nick decides that the best outcome is to have Amy put in prison, where she can no longer harm him but where he can still visit her or imagine her presence.
- Nick resolves to take the necessary steps to put Amy in prison, recognizing his responsibility to stop her madness.
Themes
- The duality of love and hate in toxic relationships
- The struggle for control and identity
- Moral responsibility and personal sacrifice
Chapter 62 Amy Elliott Dunne: Five Days After the Return
Still reeling from the night Nick nearly strangled her, Amy reflects on the need to be more cautious. His newfound electric energy, while appealing, is also dangerous. Amy decides to implement a 'spectacular precaution' to ensure her safety and maintain control, though she knows it will take time to put in place.
In the meantime, Amy and Nick are working on rebuilding their facade of a happy marriage. Amy insists that Nick must try again to love her, and he reluctantly agrees. The morning after the incident, Amy forgave him, attributing their actions to stress. She demands that things be different, and Nick complies, though she knows he doesn’t fully understand the extent of the changes needed.
Amy’s parents, Rand and Marybeth, visit daily, lavishing her with attention and treating her as if she is fragile and delicate. This attention, while comforting, also creates a tense atmosphere, as Amy notices Nick’s constant edge of bursting with damning words about her. Amy realizes she needs Nick to back her story and stop his denials, as his accusations could undermine her credibility. She is confident that the police and FBI lack the proof to arrest her, but she is preparing for any loose ends, such as potential interference from Jeff and Greta.
Amy has already prepared a detailed story for the police, claiming that Desi kept her blindfolded, gagged, and drugged for several days before taking her to his lake house. She is ready to handle any inconsistencies if Jeff and Greta show up. Amy is also dealing with the aftermath of her return, including calls from publishers and media outlets interested in her story. Her parents are eager to capitalize on the publicity, but Amy is more focused on securing the best deal and ensuring that Nick agrees to the version of the story she wants to tell.
Key Events
- Amy decides to implement a 'spectacular precaution' to ensure her safety and control over Nick.
- Amy and Nick work on rebuilding their facade of a happy marriage, with Amy insisting that Nick must try again to love her.
- Amy’s parents, Rand and Marybeth, visit daily, treating her as fragile and delicate.
- Amy prepares for potential interference from Jeff and Greta by providing a detailed story to the police.
- Amy is dealing with calls from publishers and media outlets interested in her story.
Themes
- Strategic Manipulation
- Rebuilding Facades
- Media and Public Perception
- Control and Power Dynamics
Chapter 63 Nick Dunne: Thirty Days After the Return
Nick meets with Detective Boney and Go at the Pancake House, a familiar setting where tension hangs heavy in the air. Boney, visibly stressed from media scrutiny, confides in Nick that she believes Amy framed him and murdered Desi Collings but lacks the concrete evidence needed to prove it. She explains that the department is under pressure to close the case, and her superiors have ordered her to shut it down. Boney emphasizes that the only way to prove Amy's guilt is through information from Nick, as Amy has successfully rehabilitated his public image, making it even more challenging to uncover the truth.
Key Events
- Nick meets with Boney and Go at the Pancake House.
- Boney reveals her belief that Amy framed Nick and murdered Desi but lacks evidence.
- Boney explains that the department is moving on from the case.
- Nick and Boney discuss the challenges of proving Amy's guilt.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Public Perception and Credibility
- The Elusive Nature of Justice
Chapter 64 Amy Elliott Dunne: Eight Weeks After the Return
Eight weeks after her return, Amy Elliott Dunne feels a growing sense of security and control. The police have ceased questioning her, and the lack of arrest bolsters her confidence. One morning, she notices the jar that once held her vomit is now empty on the kitchen counter, a sign that Nick has disposed of it. She casually discards the jar, recognizing that it no longer holds any leverage over her.
Amy is elated by the good things happening in her life, particularly the book deal she has secured. This deal gives her official control over their story, a symbolic victory that aligns with her view of marriage as a strategic game. She plans to portray Nick as romantic, thoughtful, and deeply repentant, especially regarding the credit card purchases and the woodshed. If Nick won't say it out loud, she will make him say it in her book. Amy envisions Nick accompanying her on the book tour, smiling and agreeing with her version of events.
She titles her book 'Amazing,' a word that encapsulates the astounding nature of her story. The title reflects her belief that her narrative will astound the world, and she is determined to shape it in a way that ensures her ultimate control and Nick's compliance. Her plans are meticulously thought out, and she feels a deep satisfaction in the direction her life is taking.
Key Events
- Amy feels secure and in control, with the police no longer questioning her.
- Amy discards the jar that held her vomit, recognizing it no longer holds leverage.
- Amy secures a book deal, giving her control over their story.
- Amy plans to write Nick as romantic, thoughtful, and repentant in her book.
- Amy envisions Nick accompanying her on the book tour, smiling and agreeing with her version of events.
Themes
- Control and Manipulation
- Narrative Power
- Strategic Marriage Dynamics
- Revenge and Victory
Chapter 65 Nick Dunne: Nine Weeks After the Return
Nine weeks after Amy's return, Nick discovers a jar of Amy's vomit hidden in the freezer. He disposes of the vomit and leaves the jar on the counter, but Amy tosses it in the garbage without a word, leaving Nick feeling uneasy and sensing that something is wrong. His life now seems like a hollow continuation, a shadow of what it once was. Tanner, who has taken on a new case involving a Nashville singer whose wife was found dead in a Hardee’s trash bin, occasionally checks in with Nick, using his case as a defense strategy. Nick, Detective Boney, and Go continue to meet secretly at the Pancake House, trying to find inconsistencies in Amy's story, but their efforts are largely fruitless.
Nick's father dies, and the news brings a sense of emptiness rather than relief. At his father's funeral, Nick decides to confront Amy and leave the house, feeling a need to tell his own story. He starts writing a book, planning to expose Amy as a sociopath and a murderer, positioning himself as the hero of the story. The chapter ends with Nick determined to take control of his narrative and break free from Amy's manipulation, despite the challenges and dangers that lie ahead.
Key Events
- Nick discovers Amy's hidden jar of vomit in the freezer.
- Nick and Boney continue to search for inconsistencies in Amy's story.
- Nick's father dies, and Nick feels a sense of emptiness.
- Nick decides to write his own book, exposing Amy as a sociopath and a murderer.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Confronting Truth and Deception
- The Struggle for Narrative Power
Chapter 66 Amy Elliott Dunne: Ten Weeks After the Return
Ten weeks after her return, Amy Elliott Dunne reflects on the strained facade of their marriage. Despite the outward appearance of happiness, the tension between her and Nick is palpable. Amy is particularly unsettled by the sound of Nick typing late at night, a clear sign that he is writing his side of the story, which she is certain is not a love story.
Amy's attempts to hack into Nick's computer have been thwarted by his new, more secure passwords. This heightened security measure underscores Nick's growing awareness of the danger she poses and his determination to protect his narrative. Despite her frustration, Amy remains vigilant, recognizing the importance of her own precautionary measures to safeguard herself from the potential fallout of Nick's writings.
Amy's observations and concerns about Nick's nocturnal activities highlight the fragile and tense nature of their relationship. She is acutely aware of the battle for control and the need to maintain her version of the truth. Amy's resolve to protect herself and her story is unwavering, as she understands that Nick's writing could undermine everything she has worked to achieve.
Key Events
- Amy and Nick maintain a strained facade of a happy marriage.
- Amy hears Nick typing late at night, suspecting he is writing his side of the story.
- Amy's attempts to hack into Nick's computer are unsuccessful due to his changed passwords.
- Amy resolves to protect herself and her version of the truth.
Themes
- Manipulation and Control
- Protecting the Narrative
- Trust and Deception
Chapter 67 Nick Dunne: Twenty Weeks After the Return
Nick decides to confront Amy with the manuscript of his book, titled 'Psycho Bitch,' twenty weeks after her return. He wants to surprise her, showing that he is no longer part of her story. However, when he presents the manuscript, Amy reacts with a cheerful grin and asks if she can show him something.
Amy leads Nick to the bathroom and, in front of him, pees on a pregnancy test stick, which turns blue, indicating she is pregnant. Shocked, Nick takes her to the doctor, where the results confirm the pregnancy. Amy insists the baby is Nick's, despite his disbelief, as he hasn't been intimate with her since her return. Amy reveals that she has been storing Nick's semen from a previous encounter in a hospital freezer, just in case.
Amy demands that Nick delete his book and sign an affidavit admitting to buying and hiding the items in the woodshed, as well as acknowledging that he once believed she was framing him but now loves her. Realizing he is outplayed and needs to protect his future child, Nick agrees to her demands. He deletes his manuscript and informs Boney that he is going to be a father and will no longer assist in the investigation, retracting his previous statements.
Nick then goes to Go's house to tell her the news. Go is devastated and accuses Nick of being addicted to Amy, warning him of the dangers of staying with her. Despite the tension, they share a moment of closeness, with Go expressing her love for Nick but heartbreak over the situation. Nick believes he can be the best husband and father to protect his child and rise to Amy's level of madness, seeing himself as the hero in their ongoing story.
Key Events
- Nick confronts Amy with his manuscript, 'Psycho Bitch,' and is surprised by her reaction.
- Amy reveals she is pregnant and insists the baby is Nick's, despite his disbelief.
- Amy demands that Nick delete his book and sign an affidavit admitting to his previous actions.
- Nick agrees to Amy's demands and informs Boney that he will no longer assist in the investigation.
- Nick tells Go about the pregnancy, and she is devastated and warns him of the dangers.
Themes
- Manipulation and control
- The dynamics of power and deception in relationships
- The complexity of love and hate in extreme circumstances
Chapter 68 Amy Elliott Dunne: Ten Months, Two Weeks, Six Days After the Return
Amy reflects on the concept of unconditional love, questioning its validity and suggesting that love should have conditions. She believes that both partners should strive to be their best selves, and she sees the disastrous outcomes of undisciplined love. Amy plans to elaborate on her thoughts in her upcoming book, 'Amazing.'
The due date for Amy's baby is tomorrow, which also marks their sixth wedding anniversary. Amy muses on how a year ago, she was undoing her husband, and now she is almost done reassembling him. Nick has been doting on her, doing all the things a good father-to-be should do. Amy feels that they are on their way to happiness, but she acknowledges that Nick still has room for improvement.
During a moment of intimacy, Amy compliments Nick on how wonderful he is to her, expecting a loving response. Instead, Nick reveals that he feels sorry for her because she has to wake up and be herself every day. This comment deeply disturbs Amy, and she cannot stop thinking about it. Despite their progress, this moment of honesty from Nick shakes Amy's confidence in their relationship.
In the end, Amy emphasizes her need to have the last word, reflecting on the challenges and the complexities of their relationship. She feels that she has earned the right to the final say, given the intricate and manipulative nature of their marriage.
Key Events
- Amy reflects on the concept of conditional love.
- Amy and Nick's sixth wedding anniversary coincides with the due date of their baby.
- Nick reveals that he feels sorry for Amy, disturbing her deeply.
- Amy emphasizes her need to have the last word in their relationship.
Themes
- The Illusion of Unconditional Love
- Manipulation
- Motherhood
- Honesty vs. Deception