Prologue
An unidentified young man has visited three abandoned properties whose tracks meet at a country road: an ivy-covered cottage, an open farmhouse with its front door missing, and a boarded-up sandstone bungalow. The dust shows one set of boot prints entering and leaving each house. On a hot February afternoon, a man celebrating his twenty-first birthday arrives at the tracks in a small red rental car, carrying a laptop and a university notebook from Sydney. He stops when the rough surface jolts the vehicle and checks for damage. Looking toward the houses, he remembers the land before its decline and feels uneasy about his reason for being there. A persistent low droning sound hangs over the area. After hesitating beside the locked car, he finally moves away from it. More than five hours later, his parents find the vehicle at the junction, with his belongings still inside. His birthday dinner is waiting at their home six kilometers away. They call for him as darkness falls, but receive no answer. The prologue does not reveal what happened to him.
Key Events
- Dusty footprints show that a lone visitor has entered and left each of three abandoned houses.
- On his twenty-first birthday, a young man drives a red rental car to the point where the houses' access tracks meet.
- He stops, checks his car, hesitates in the heat, and leaves his belongings in the locked vehicle.
- More than five hours later, his parents find the car and call for him without receiving an answer.
Characters Appearing
- The young man (unnamed)
- The young man’s parents (unnamed)
Themes
- Disappearance and uncertainty
- Abandonment of the three properties
- Changes to the rural landscape
Chapter 1
Five years after the disappearance shown in the prologue, Ro Crowley returns from Sydney to Carralon Ridge, where she lived for decades. She is shaken by the extent of the town's abandonment. The Hewetts have moved away, and the steel arch in their orchard beneath which Ro married Griff twenty-seven years earlier is missing. The community hall is locked, the school and bank have closed, and the former medical center, where Ro treated patients for nearly twenty years, stands vacant. The general store still operates, but the Black Creek Inn is dark at just after six on a Thursday evening. Ro peers through the pub window and sees that the fittings remain although its refrigerators are nearly empty. While walking nearby, she hears irregular metallic banging and what sounds like faint laughter, but cannot identify the source. Her former husband, Griff, calls from the ridge overlooking town, where he has spotted her car through binoculars. He explains that Sylvie now opens the pub only a few nights a month and says their daughter Della was not at the family house when he left. He invites Ro to the unlocked house, almost calling it home before correcting himself. Reluctant to meet there after a year apart, Ro asks to join him on the ridge instead. The shortest road passes the three abandoned houses, so she takes a longer route.
Key Events
- Ro returns to Carralon Ridge and sees the Hewetts' deserted property and the missing orchard arch where she married Griff.
- She passes the closed school, medical center, bank, and community hall, and finds the Black Creek Inn closed on a Thursday evening.
- She hears intermittent clanging and faint laughter but cannot find its source.
- Griff calls from the ridge, where he has been watching town, and explains that Sylvie opens the pub only a few nights each month.
- Ro agrees to meet Griff on the ridge and takes the longer road to avoid passing the three abandoned houses.
Characters Appearing
- Ro Crowley
- Griff Crowley
- Della
- Sylvie
Themes
- Loss of community institutions
- Estrangement and the meaning of home
- Unresolved disappearance
Chapter 2
Ro meets Griff on the ridge overlooking Carralon Ridge. They recall how they met at Heather's wedding at the Black Creek Inn nearly thirty years earlier. From the lookout, the town still appears inviting, but to the west the expanding Lentzer coal mine has destroyed its economic and social foundations. The mine employs workers brought in from elsewhere and supplies its own accommodation and services. Griff formerly led the town's fire response; after the local station closed, Lentzer hired him to maintain residents' firefighting equipment and watch for fires caused by waste coal and windborne sparks. He resents the company's dominance but will not abandon the community. The Hewetts, his godparents, moved nearer their daughter after Lentzer refused to buy their house, leaving it behind without compensation. When Griff drives away, Ro stays to look at three deserted houses on the land where her son Sam disappeared five years earlier. She remembers the evening of his twenty-first birthday: Sam failed to answer calls and did not appear for a family dinner before meeting friends Jacob and Darcy. Della tried messaging him and tracking his phone while Ro and Griff contacted neighbors and searched separately. Griff found Sam's locked rental car at the junction of the houses' tracks, with his computer, notebook, and water bottle inside. Police were delayed by another emergency. Sam was never found. With his next birthday four days away, Ro remains divided between fearing he died that day and hoping he is alive.
Key Events
- Ro and Griff meet on the ridge, recall the beginning of their relationship, and survey Carralon Ridge and the Lentzer mine.
- Griff maintains the community's fire safety for Lentzer after the local fire station's closure; the mine uses a largely self-contained outside workforce.
- The Hewetts abandoned their unsold home when Lentzer declined to make them an offer.
- After Griff leaves, Ro looks toward the three houses and recalls the search on Sam's twenty-first birthday.
- Griff discovered Sam's locked rental car with his belongings, but neither the family nor police found Sam; his fate remains unknown.
Characters Appearing
- Sam Crowley
- Jacob
- Darcy
- Doug and Ruth Hewett
- Heather
Themes
- Unresolved disappearance and grief
- Mining-related displacement and loss
- Obligations to family and community
Chapter 3
Ro arrives at the house where she and Griff raised Sam and Della. She left Carralon Ridge eighteen months after Sam disappeared and has returned only for short annual visits around his birthday. Six months after she moved away, Lentzer offered to buy their home at a reduced price because of a planned mine expansion. Ro left the decision to Griff, who agreed to sell when she confirmed she would not return. The company now owns the property and rents it back to Griff while he works as its community fire safety officer. Ro sees how being a tenant has altered his approach to maintenance. Their twenty-three-year-old daughter Della, now an accountant in Sydney, greets Ro warmly. Ro accepts a room in the separate studio hut that Griff built years earlier for her parents rather than sleep in the main house, where Sam's room remains. Griff has cleaned the hut and left her an envelope addressed to Rowena containing around forty photographs of Ro and Sam over the years. As she looks through them, Ro struggles with memories of her son at different ages. She then takes Sam's university notebook from her own bag. It contains sketches of Carralon and notes related to his inquiries into local history; the final written page bears the date of his twenty-first birthday and a name followed by questions. She places the notebook beside the photographs and composes herself before joining Griff and Della for dinner.
Key Events
- Ro returns to her old home, which she and Griff sold to Lentzer after she moved away; Griff now rents it back.
- Della, who works in Sydney, welcomes Ro to the house.
- Ro chooses the separate studio hut rather than one of the bedrooms in the family home.
- Griff has left Ro photographs of her and Sam, prompting memories of her son's childhood.
- Ro takes Sam's notebook from her own bag and revisits his dated final questions before joining the family for dinner.
Themes
- Grief and the preservation of memories
- Dispossession and the status of home
- Estrangement and family reconnection
Chapter 4
At dinner with Griff and Della, Ro notices that the house's contents have changed and that even the tap water now needs filtering. Sitting in Sam's old place at the table brings back a family conversation ten days before he disappeared. Sam, studying rural science and development, explained that his thesis would examine Carralon Ridge as a case study of how communities respond to mining expansion. He wanted to investigate whether residents could have acted collectively to preserve their town. Della thought the decisive factor was money, while Griff and Ro described the pressure to sell as neighbors departed, local buyers disappeared, and the mine's offers became less generous. Back in the present, Ro says she will visit the three houses where Sam's car was found. Della declines to accompany her and seems evasive about her plans. After Della goes to bed, Ro and Griff quietly wash up and worry about whether their daughter is overworking. Ro remembers meeting Griff at Heather's wedding and, later, their marriage's breakdown following Sam's disappearance. When Ro packed to leave Carralon eighteen months afterward, she asked Griff to come with her; he refused, and they did not see each other for six months. Before she returns to the garden hut, Griff offers to accompany her to the three houses the following day. Ro accepts, though their estrangement remains unresolved.
Key Events
- During dinner, Ro recalls Sam's thesis proposal about how Carralon Ridge residents responded to the mine and whether collective action might have changed the outcome.
- The family recalls how mining offers and departures gradually undermined the town's community and property market.
- Ro decides to revisit the three houses the next day, while Della declines to join her.
- Ro remembers asking Griff to leave Carralon with her eighteen months after Sam vanished; he refused, and they separated.
- Griff offers to accompany Ro to the houses, and she accepts.
Themes
- Collective action and community displacement
- Family bereavement and estrangement
- Conflicting responses to loss
Chapter 5
Griff and Ro drive separately to the deserted houses so that he can check a fire break later and she can leave when she wishes. Before departing, Ro looks into Sam's former bedroom. The room was already largely cleared and converted into spare sleeping space during Sam's move to Sydney for university, before he vanished; its emptiness now unsettles her. At the junction where Sam's rental car was found, Griff and Ro recall the first police response five years earlier. Neighbors had already joined the search, and the town's remaining population of nearly four hundred would help over the following days. The officer asked whether Sam might have gone hiking without telling anyone, although his drinking water remained in the car. Griff and Ro identified the abandoned properties: Ann-Marie Birstock had lost the ivy cottage in her divorce; Bernie Reece had lived at the boarded-up stone bungalow; and the farmhouse had belonged to Griff's cousin Warren Hillary. Warren had died by suicide at the quarry three years before Sam disappeared. Learning that Sam had been close to Warren, the officer asked about Sam's mental health as a possible line of inquiry. In the present, Ro notices movement at the ivy cottage. Ann-Marie, who now rents elsewhere in town, appears on its verandah and beckons them up. Griff agrees to accompany Ro to speak to her, intending again to warn her that the mine owns the property and she should not be there.
Key Events
- Ro enters Sam's old room and recognizes that he had already removed most of his belongings before his disappearance.
- Ro and Griff revisit the location of Sam's parked rental car and remember the community search and police questions.
- The officer learned the ownership history of the three houses and that Warren Hillary, Griff's cousin, died by suicide at the quarry three years before Sam disappeared.
- The police questioned whether Sam had gone hiking and asked about his mental health, without establishing either explanation.
- Ann-Marie Birstock appears at her former ivy cottage and summons Ro and Griff; Griff intends to warn her off mine-owned land.
Characters Appearing
- Ann-Marie Birstock
- Bernie Reece
- Warren Hillary
Themes
- Uncertainty in the disappearance investigation
- Family history and grief
- Displacement from former homes
Chapter 6
Ro and Griff find Ann-Marie cutting ivy from the abandoned cottage while her adult son Jacob steadies a ladder. Griff warns of structural hazards, dangerous ground and the lack of nearby emergency services. Ann-Marie, once the town's local nurse, continues to visit and maintain her former home despite Lentzer's ownership and repeated warnings. Jacob mentions that Della called him earlier, surprising Ro because Jacob had been Sam's friend, not hers. Ann-Marie and Griff discuss Monday's memorial for Sam, an informal gathering that has grown from a private Crowley family ritual to include neighbors. Ann-Marie then offers Ro a tour of the ivy-covered house. Its front and back doors have new locks, but the laundry entrance remains accessible. Inside, Ro follows the same rooms Sam visited on the day he vanished. His identifiable boot prints had shown that he entered the house alone after leaving his rental car at the fork, though the prints did not explain where he went afterward. While they are inside, Ann-Marie tells Ro that Griff's work contract with the mine has not been renewed, a fact Griff has not disclosed to her. Ann-Marie wonders whether Ro will continue returning if Griff leaves Carralon. She also urges Ro not to assume that nothing about Sam remains to be found. Ro admits she no longer knows what to believe. Feeling overwhelmed, she leaves the house through the laundry door.
Key Events
- Ann-Marie and Jacob maintain the vine-covered cottage despite the mine's ownership and serious safety hazards.
- Jacob says Della tried to call him, surprising Ro.
- Griff and Ann-Marie discuss the neighborhood memorial for Sam's upcoming birthday.
- Ann-Marie takes Ro inside through an unlocked laundry door; Ro revisits the rooms where Sam's boot prints were found after his disappearance.
- Ann-Marie tells Ro that Griff's Lentzer contract was not renewed and suggests evidence about Sam might still emerge.
Themes
- Preservation of personal history
- Unresolved disappearance and family grief
- Precarious work and community safety
Chapter 7
Leaving the ivy cottage, Griff asks Ro to accompany him to his cousin Warren Hillary's derelict farmhouse. Fallen branches have damaged its verandah and roof. Ro remembers a photograph of Griff as a boy with Warren and Warren's younger brother Damien, who grew up together. She believes Griff deliberately avoids maintaining the house because its continued existence reminds him of both Warren and Sam; she suspects he would rather see it demolished. The visit recalls events eight years earlier, shortly after Ro's father, also named Sam, was killed by a car as he left a gym. The family had been away for the funeral when Griff missed a call from Warren, who left a short message. Returning to Carralon, Griff and their seventeen-year-old son Sam drove to Warren's house to return borrowed tools. They found it deserted, with cooked sausages left untouched on the barbecue. Griff learned that Damien had argued with Warren during a visit several days earlier and had missed his call the previous night. Warren had also called his former partner Sylvie at the Black Creek Inn; their argument ended when she hung up, and he subsequently sent an apologetic message saying he loved her. Police then reported a body at the quarry. Griff asked Ro to collect Sam from the farmhouse and broke down in grief on its back deck, where she held him. In the present, Griff inspects the storm damage but refuses to arrange repairs immediately.
Key Events
- Griff and Ro visit Warren Hillary's former farmhouse and discover fallen branches damaging its rear verandah.
- Ro recalls her father's sudden death in a road accident eight years earlier.
- Griff and the seventeen-year-old Sam went to Warren's home after Griff missed an earlier call and found signs Warren had abruptly left.
- Damien and Sylvie had received calls from Warren; Sylvie received an apologetic final message after their argument.
- Police found a body at the quarry, prompting Griff's grief and Ro's effort to comfort him; he leaves the current house damage for later.
Characters Appearing
- Damien Hillary
Themes
- Family bereavement and unresolved questions
- Decay of abandoned property
- Regret over missed contact
Chapter 8
After inspecting the three houses, Griff offers to accompany Ro on the overgrown bush trail across the road, putting off his planned firebreak inspection. They spot a drone overhead, probably Noel Reece's, which Griff thinks Darcy may be operating. Ro remembers the extensive searches made in this bushland after Sam disappeared. She had hoped he was lost but alive, although she suspected police were also considering whether he had deliberately gone into the woods to die. She considers the possibility that he encountered strangers trespassing in the empty houses, but none of these explanations was established. Investigators searched the mine, interviewed its staff and followed reports of intruders; a mine employee knew that Sam had emailed questions about his research but had not yet received a response. Only after he vanished did his parents learn of a recent breakup, messages suggesting Sam was upset, and intermittent antidepressant prescriptions. Ro recalls details of Warren Hillary's death: his truck was found beside a cut fence at the mine, and his body was recovered from the quarry pool with injuries consistent with a severe fall. Griff and Sam received brief telephone counseling after Warren died, but Ro doubted either had recovered. Ro then tells Griff that Ann-Marie disclosed his nonrenewed Lentzer contract. He confirms that it ends in just under three months and that the lease on their former family house ends with it. He expects to leave Carralon Ridge, though he has no plan for where to go. Ro reassures him that selling the house was financially prudent, but both mourn its loss. They turn back without going farther along the trail.
Key Events
- Griff joins Ro on the bush trail and they see a drone that he thinks Darcy may be flying.
- Ro recalls unproven theories about Sam becoming lost, intentionally disappearing, or encountering trespassers at abandoned houses.
- Investigators searched the mine and learned Sam had sent unanswered research questions; his parents later discovered a breakup and antidepressant prescriptions.
- Ro recalls the evidence surrounding Warren's fatal fall at the mine and counseling that Griff and Sam received afterward.
- Griff confirms his contract ends in under three months, terminating his house lease and likely forcing him to leave Carralon Ridge.
Themes
- Ambiguity in a missing-person investigation
- Mental health and the aftermath of bereavement
- Displacement by mining expansion
Chapter 9
Ro returns to Griff's house and finds Della absent and her telephone unanswered. Fearing another disappearance, she panics, but Della promptly texts to say she is safe and will return soon. Ro considers visiting the vegetable garden she once tended behind the sheds, then decides against seeing its neglected state. Back in the hut, she opens a video recorded by Darcy and Jacob's drone on the afternoon Sam vanished. The two friends had used the drone to monitor the Lentzer mine's activities and gave police and Griff a copy of the footage after Sam disappeared. About six and a half minutes into the first recording, Sam appears outside Warren Hillary's farmhouse. Ro watches him walk onto its verandah and vanish from the drone's view. The camera was then off for forty-four minutes, which the friends said they spent recharging the drone and relocating along the mine boundary. When recording resumes, Jacob is shown sitting on the ground beside Darcy's backpack, but neither boy reported seeing Sam. Ro has traced the route between their two filming positions herself, without obtaining an answer to what happened. Della returns, having talked with Sylvie in town, and says Griff has told her his mine contract and lease are ending. She believes leaving Carralon may be good for her father. She acknowledges calling Jacob, but offers little explanation; she also says she saw the drone. Sylvie is opening the Black Creek Inn that evening, and Della persuades Ro to attend before Sam's memorial. Alone again, Ro studies the last portion of the drone footage: a twelve-second panoramic view shows Sam's parked red rental car and the three houses, but not Sam. His phone stopped connecting to local towers within an hour of the recording, and later records indicated that its last signal remained within the Carralon area. His prints showed he entered and left the houses, but the recordings and phone data do not establish his subsequent movements or fate.
Key Events
- Della's absence briefly terrifies Ro, who receives a reassuring text and decides not to visit her neglected vegetable garden.
- Ro replays footage filmed by Darcy and Jacob on the day Sam disappeared; it shows Sam walking onto Warren Hillary's verandah.
- The camera stopped for forty-four minutes while the two men said they recharged and relocated it; Sam was not seen in later footage.
- Della returns and discusses Griff's impending departure, her call to Jacob, and Sylvie's plans to open the pub that night.
- A panoramic drone shot shows Sam's car but not Sam; his last phone signal remained in the area, leaving the disappearance unresolved.
Themes
- Partial evidence and unresolved timelines
- Parental fear and traumatic memory
- Declining community and the loss of home
Chapter 10
Della drives her parents to the Black Creek Inn, where they meet Griff's cousin Damien Hillary outside. He has returned from years in London and still works remotely for a British firm on overnight hours. Damien cannot stay because he has a scheduled work call. Ro remembers that Sam interviewed Damien for more than an hour on the afternoon he disappeared. Damien acknowledged seeing Sam leave his townhouse shortly after two, a departure also witnessed by Doug Hewett. Damien said he then slept until a recorded evening work call, leaving several hours without independent confirmation. Police investigated the interval but found no evidence against him. Ro has chosen to trust him while recognizing the limits of that choice. She also recalls Damien's shared ownership of Warren's house, the pressure he placed on his brother to sell to Lentzer, and their argument during Damien's brief return from London shortly before Warren's suicide. Warren left his share of the property to his former partner Sylvie; Damien subsequently bought it from her and sold the whole house to Lentzer, then remained living in Carralon. He has expressed guilt about how he treated Warren. When Ann-Marie and Jacob arrive, Ro notices Jacob's strong physical resemblance to Damien. Long-standing town gossip questions whether Ann-Marie's former husband was Jacob's biological father, but no parentage is confirmed. Damien and Jacob exchange little more than an awkward greeting. Damien leaves after asking Griff to look at fallen branches at the Hillary house. Ro remembers that Sam recorded his research interview with Damien, but the recording vanished with Sam; Damien supplied the police with a recollection that was mostly about himself and Warren.
Key Events
- Damien greets Ro, Griff and Della outside the pub before leaving for his UK work call.
- Ro recalls Sam's interview with Damien after two o'clock on the day Sam disappeared, and the unverified interval before Damien's recorded evening call.
- Damien had pressed co-owner Warren to sell the family farmhouse, bought Warren's bequeathed share from Sylvie after his death and eventually sold to Lentzer.
- Ro observes Jacob's resemblance to Damien, which has fueled unverified rumors of his parentage.
- Damien says he cannot stay, arranges with Griff to address the damaged farmhouse, and leaves; his remembered interview with Sam was primarily about Damien and Warren.
Themes
- Trust under incomplete evidence
- Guilt after a family death
- Unconfirmed parentage and family secrecy
Chapter 11
Inside the reopened Black Creek Inn, Ro reunites with her oldest friend Heather Reece, now married to Noel. Heather seems strained and asks Ro to visit her home the next morning instead of meeting at the Crowley house. She explains that Darcy is caring for his younger brothers, Kyle and Zach, whose behavior has recently been difficult, so she and Noel could attend the gathering. Their meeting prompts Ro to recall their friendship. After first knowing each other at university, they worked together at a medical practice near Sydney, where Heather was an occupational therapist and Ro trained as a doctor. Their friendship deepened during regular walks, and Heather invited Ro to be a bridesmaid when she married Noel, whose family farmed in Carralon Ridge. Ro initially thought Heather was mistaken to leave the city, but the beauty of the town and the warmth of the wedding changed her view. Heather and Noel were married in the garden of Noel's parents' sandstone bungalow, one of the three houses now abandoned near Sam's disappearance. At the reception, held at the Black Creek Inn, Ro met Griff and they immediately connected. The next morning they viewed Carralon from the ridge, and Ro began imagining a life there. Back in Sydney, she felt dissatisfied with her routine until Griff called Heather to get her telephone number and drove the long distance to take her to dinner. Eighteen months after that first weekend, Ro and Griff married beneath the wrought-iron arch in the Hewetts' orchard and held their reception at the same pub.
Key Events
- Ro reunites with Heather, who is worried about her younger sons Kyle and Zach; Darcy remains home to supervise them.
- Ro remembers Heather's work as an occupational therapist and their friendship during training near Sydney.
- Heather's wedding to Noel brought Ro to Carralon Ridge for the first time, with the ceremony at the sandstone bungalow and reception at the Black Creek Inn.
- Ro met Griff at the reception; they spent the next day together on the ridge, and Griff later drove to Sydney to see her.
- Eighteen months after their first meeting, Ro and Griff married at the Hewetts' orchard and celebrated at the Black Creek Inn.
Characters Appearing
- Kyle Reece
- Zach Reece
Themes
- Friendship and shared history
- Courtship and the loss of a former life
- Family pressures
Chapter 12
At the pub, Ro feels how much of Carralon's former community has disappeared despite the familiar room. Noel Reece and his father, Bernie, greet her, though she senses resentment beneath their politeness toward former residents and those who sold land to Lentzer. Bernie once worked as a firefighter and organized a seniors exercise program, but after an episode of unexplained memory loss, tests uncovered precancerous cells. His health has since deteriorated. Ro recalls how the sale of Warren Hillary's farmhouse changed the market for adjacent houses: Ann-Marie's former husband forced a sale of their ivy cottage, while Bernie resisted selling his ancestral sandstone bungalow until the mine's ownership of neighboring access land, heavy vehicles and legal pressure made staying untenable. The price he received was far below what he wanted. Damien generally avoids public scrutiny because his earlier sale enabled the mine's pressure. At the bar Sylvie offers Ro wine. Ro remembers Sylvie's background as a Melbourne music-venue manager and her relationship with Warren, whom she met while traveling. Ro notices Della in an intense, largely one-sided conversation with Jacob in a corner; she cannot hear what they are discussing. Sylvie asks about Sam's forthcoming memorial and welcomes Ro, but ends their personal conversation sooner than Ro expects. Sam interviewed Sylvie twice in the week before he vanished. Ro recalls a short addition in the margin of his notebook, in different-colored ink, bearing Sylvie's name and a heavily traced question mark, and wonders what it means.
Key Events
- Ro reunites with Noel and Bernie Reece and notices Bernie's decline in health.
- Ro recalls how sales of neighboring properties to Lentzer forced Ann-Marie and Bernie to give up the ivy cottage and stone bungalow.
- Ro notices Della speaking privately and intensely with Jacob at the pub.
- Sylvie offers wine, asks about Sam's memorial and speaks briefly with Ro.
- Ro remembers an unexplained question mark and Sylvie's name added to Sam's interview notes.
Themes
- Pressure on residents to sell their homes
- Divisions within a shrinking town
- Incomplete records and uncertainty
Chapter 13
After returning from the pub, Ro wakes in the night with a headache and is disturbed by the mine's low-frequency noise. She remembers that Della avoided explaining her conversation with Jacob while driving her parents home. On her own laptop, Ro opens Sam's research materials, which she previously copied from the computer recovered in his rental car. Della had guessed the password so police could inspect it. Ro remembers Sam's final birthday, when he opened gifts, helped Griff mend a fence, then left after lunch to interview Damien. Distracted in the kitchen, Ro called that his favorite lasagna would be ready at six thirty but never saw him leave. Later witness and drone evidence placed him at Damien's and Warren's farmhouse, and his boot prints showed he visited all three houses. The interviews in Sam's research document the town's conflicting responses to Lentzer. Damien's replacement account focuses on his justification for selling the Hillary house and his belief that Warren would eventually agree. Noel praises the community and hopes to preserve it for his children, while Heather's answers are more reserved. Bernie recalls the town's former vitality and criticizes its decline. Ann-Marie reports intimidation and a series of unexplained thefts before her ex-husband forced sale of the ivy cottage through legal action; she suspected him, but his involvement was not established. Jacob and Darcy express less enthusiasm about growing up in Carralon than their elders. Ro returns to Sam's notebook, which includes the handwritten note 'Re: Warren and Lentzer. Ask Sylvie?' Sylvie has told Ro on three occasions that she cannot explain it. Ro strongly suspects Sylvie is concealing something, but has no proof of what Sam learned or whether the note concerns his disappearance.
Key Events
- Ro wakes disturbed by the mine's rumble and recalls Della's evasive response about Jacob.
- Ro reviews Sam's interview records from her laptop and remembers failing to say a proper goodbye on his last birthday.
- Damien's replacement statement defends his decision to sell Warren's house; Noel, Heather and other residents gave differing accounts of the town.
- Ann-Marie reported thefts and intimidation before a forced property sale but could not establish who was responsible.
- Ro focuses on Sam's note 'Re: Warren and Lentzer. Ask Sylvie?' and suspects Sylvie is withholding an explanation.
Themes
- Conflicting accounts and uncertain evidence
- Collective decline and housing displacement
- Grief and the search for missing facts
Chapter 14
On a hot, windy morning, Ro removes a small decorative mirror from her studio hut to give to Heather for the Reeces' collection of objects in their saloon. Griff has told her she can take whatever she wants as his departure approaches. Della asks to accompany her, at first claiming she simply needs a break from work. Ro suspects she has another reason and guesses that Della hopes to see Darcy Reece. Della confirms this but emphatically denies any romantic interest. She says she has heard something and wants to question Darcy about it, while insisting that it is probably nothing. When Ro asks whether it concerns Sam, Della says it is not really about him, then recognizes that her mother's hopes are already rising. Della asks for a chance to obtain the facts before explaining, and Ro reluctantly agrees. After Della leaves, Ro looks into the removed mirror and reflects that the expression her daughter interpreted as hope feels to her more like exhausted desperation.
Key Events
- Ro takes the decorative mirror from the hut as a gift for Heather and the Reeces' saloon.
- Della asks to accompany Ro to the farm and admits she hopes to question Darcy.
- Della denies romantic interest and says the matter she heard about is barely related to Sam, without explaining further.
- Ro agrees to wait until Della has checked her information and recognizes her own desperation.
Themes
- Withheld information between mother and daughter
- Uncertainty and fear of premature hope
- Letting go of former possessions
Chapter 15
Ro and Della visit Heather and Noel's farmhouse. Heather meets them on the gravel drive after a run, looking exhausted rather than energized. Inside, her teenage sons Zach and Kyle are absorbed in loud video games despite their ill grandfather Bernie resting nearby. Heather tries to quiet them, and one of the boys insults her, though Ro cannot identify which. Heather later explains that the two teenagers are isolated: they have few local friends, no sports teams and now attend school remotely after long travel to Blenheim proved unworkable. Ro notices printouts of drone photographs from the previous day on the kitchen table, all showing the mine's perimeter rather than the trail where she and Griff had been walking. Della repeatedly scans the sheds and paddocks outside, looking for Darcy. Ro gives Heather the small glass-framed mirror she removed from the Crowley hut for the Reeces' saloon, and her friend accepts it warmly. As they talk, Ro studies a wedding photograph of Heather and Noel with herself and Griff standing only two people apart, not yet acquainted. Remembering their subsequent marriage and losses, Ro considers whether she would make the same choices again and realizes she would for Della's sake. Bernie appears, looking tired, and Heather offers to take him coffee outside while showing Noel the gift. Della stays behind, saying she is going to find Darcy.
Key Events
- Heather greets Ro and Della after running at the Reece farm.
- One of Heather's younger boys insults her after she intervenes over loud video games; she explains their isolation and disrupted education.
- Ro sees recent drone photos of the Lentzer mine on the Reeces' kitchen table.
- Ro gives Heather the glass-framed mirror for the family saloon and studies a photograph taken at Heather's wedding before Ro met Griff.
- Della leaves the kitchen to seek out Darcy while Heather goes to show Noel the mirror.
Themes
- Isolation of young people in a shrinking community
- Family strain and parental responsibility
- Memory and the costs of attachment
Chapter 16
About a year after Sam disappeared, Ro repeatedly visited the three abandoned houses in the evening. On one visit she met Bernie Reece at his former stone bungalow, where he was repairing a board damaged by a possible trespasser. He told her Darcy had seen an intruder on drone footage and warned her to be careful. Bernie remembered Sam as a respectful and patient interviewer and asked why he had come to the houses on his birthday. They could only speculate that it involved his research. Bernie wondered whether all three houses should have been demolished while residents still controlled them. Four years later, during Ro's present visit to the Reece farm, Bernie is far frailer. Della goes toward the barn to speak with Darcy, who is working on a motorcycle, and Heather is surprised they appear to be in contact. Heather and Noel plan to hang Ro's mirror in the Last Chance Saloon. As Ro walks there with Heather, her friend admits that life has become difficult for their family. The younger boys have no local peers, Bernie's health is declining, and Noel is unhappy. Heather would consider leaving Carralon, but Bernie insists on spending the rest of his life there, and Noel refuses to discuss moving. Ro says her own move to Sydney has been better for her overall, while acknowledging that she still values visits to Heather and the town. Heather fears that remaining in Carralon is increasingly damaging the lives of her children.
Key Events
- During the first year after Sam disappeared, Bernie repaired damage at his former house and warned Ro of trespassers seen in drone footage.
- Bernie praised Sam's interviews and questioned his visit to the abandoned houses, wondering whether demolition would have prevented danger.
- Back in the present, Ro sees Bernie's worsening frailty while Della approaches Darcy at the barn.
- Heather and Noel plan to hang Ro's mirror in the Last Chance Saloon.
- Heather tells Ro she would consider leaving Carralon, but Bernie's wish to die there and Noel's resistance have kept the family in place.
Themes
- Grief and preservation of former homes
- Generational conflict over leaving Carralon
- Community memory and family caregiving
Chapter 17
Heather and Ro walk to the Last Chance Saloon, a large clubhouse Noel and his sons built over many years on the Reece property. It began as a playhouse and gradually became a repository for salvaged furnishings and objects from Carralon's abandoned homes. Its front door came from Bernie's stone bungalow. The interior is now dusty and neglected, and Noel says the children have lost interest in maintaining it. Ro asks whether the missing orchard arch from her wedding was salvaged here, but Noel says it was not. Angry shouting and smashing sounds from the house force Heather to return to the younger boys, leaving Ro with Noel. She smells alcohol on him before noon and notices an empty beer can on the floor, but does not know the extent of his drinking. Noel acknowledges that life with his sons and the accumulation of painful memories have made the saloon difficult to maintain. He and Ro hang her decorative mirror near a watercolor of the town. They discuss Griff's lost mine contract and the social cost of having worked for Lentzer. Ro recalls two former friends confronting Griff in the pub for accepting mine wages after the local fire station closed; Noel intervened and later reassured Griff that residents still needed his fire protection. Ro suggests the Reeces could leave too, but Noel refuses, citing their history and commitment to the town, while admitting that Bernie's health is not the only consideration. Heather returns distressed after another confrontation at the house. Della, standing outside, silently signals to Ro, and Ro ends the visit so the family can address its troubles.
Key Events
- Ro visits the Last Chance Saloon, built from the Reeces' former playhouse using items rescued from abandoned homes.
- The clubhouse has fallen into disuse, and Heather hurries back to the farmhouse after a crash and shouting.
- Ro smells alcohol on Noel and sees an empty beer can but is not told of any diagnosed alcohol problem.
- Ro recalls a confrontation over Griff's mine employment in which Noel defended his role in the town's fire safety.
- Noel hangs Ro's mirror, refuses to consider leaving Carralon, and ends the conversation when Heather returns visibly upset.
Themes
- Preservation of local material history
- Conflict over remaining in the community
- Financial dependence and moral judgments about mine work
Chapter 18
Driving home from the Reece farm, Della tells Ro that Darcy and Jacob refused to answer her questions about an incident involving Warren Hillary. Months earlier, Della met Meaghan Austin, who had dated Darcy while they were teenagers. Meaghan described a drunken night at the creek roughly eight years ago, when she or her sister joked about Warren's ghost and Jacob's supposedly haunted home. Darcy became furious, defended Warren and struck Jacob while arguing. Meaghan then joked that Darcy had a guilty conscience. According to her recollection, Jacob replied that Darcy had done something foolish before Warren killed himself. Meaghan did not know what he meant; Jacob later claimed not to remember, and Darcy ended his relationship with Meaghan. Della warns that this is a secondhand account of an old drunken conversation and establishes neither Sam's involvement nor a cause of Warren's death. She sought clarification from both men, who denied knowing anything about the remark. Della hopes the story might at least clarify Sam's state of mind, while acknowledging that her theories are unsupported. She tells Ro she has imagined Sam dying in a sudden accident or medical emergency, possibly with someone unwilling to summon help from a town where Ro or Ann-Marie might respond. She fears more than anything that he suffered. Della also grieves the coming loss of the family home and mentions that Griff may move to Sydney. She urges Ro to speak honestly with Griff and stop blaming one another for grieving differently. Ro points out they have not been together for years, while Della notes that they are still legally married. They drive past the turnoff to the three houses in silence.
Key Events
- Della recounts Meaghan Austin's hearsay that Darcy struck Jacob during a drunken argument about Warren, after which Jacob said Darcy should feel guilty about something preceding Warren's suicide.
- Darcy and Jacob denied remembering or understanding the exchange, and Della cautions that Meaghan's recollection is old and uncertain.
- Della discusses unsubstantiated accident and medical-emergency explanations for Sam's disappearance and fears he suffered.
- Della mourns the impending loss of the Crowley home and says Griff may move to Sydney.
- Della challenges Ro and Griff to speak about their different responses to grief and notes they remain legally married.
Characters Appearing
- Meaghan Austin
Themes
- Reliability of secondhand testimony
- Family grief and unresolved questions
- Estrangement without legal divorce
Chapter 19
Ro joins Griff in a shed where he is sorting their possessions before leaving the family house. The process is painful for both: Ro finds the pinball machine on which Griff beat Sam's long-standing high score the day before he disappeared, a little green bicycle the children shared, and a Christmas ornament bearing their fingerprints. She finds a child-sized gardening trowel marked with Sam's name and keeps an envelope containing ten sunflower seeds in his handwriting. Griff discovers four old running medals wrapped in a tea towel among Sam's discarded things. He believes they came from Warren Hillary's collection, inherited from Warren's father, but neither knows why Sam possessed them. Ro tells him what Della learned from Meaghan about Darcy, Jacob and Warren's death. Griff doubts that Jacob could have known something Sam did not, but their speculation proves nothing. He then recalls calling Jacob and Darcy separately on the night Sam vanished and hearing the same nearby turbine sound in the background of both calls. He suspects they were together near the quarry, as they had been earlier with the drone, but they did not say so at the time. Ro offers innocent explanations and neither reaches a conclusion. As sorting becomes overwhelming, Griff suggests she leave him to the work, reopening the conflict surrounding their separation. Seventeen months after Sam disappeared, Carralon's medical center announced it would close. Ro felt relief because she wanted to leave town, but Griff accused her of using the loss of her job as an excuse; Ann-Marie had obtained a mobile health-service arrangement that Griff believed Ro might also have pursued. Ro said she could no longer live where Sam had vanished; Griff could not understand how she could leave. In the shed they return to the same impasse. Griff ends the conversation and leaves, saying he will not repeat the argument.
Key Events
- Ro and Griff sort painful family keepsakes, including the pinball machine, the children's bicycle and Sam's labeled trowel and sunflower seeds.
- They find old running medals linked to the Hillary family among Sam's stored belongings without knowing why he had them.
- Ro shares Meaghan's account; Griff recalls hearing a turbine in the background of his separate telephone calls to Darcy and Jacob on the disappearance night.
- The couple revisit their old argument over Ro's move after the medical center closed seventeen months after Sam disappeared.
- Griff refuses to continue the dispute and leaves the shed.
Themes
- Objects preserved after loss
- Incomplete evidence and suspicion
- Incompatible responses to grief
Chapter 20
After the argument in the shed, Ro returns alone to the studio hut and recalls the running medals found among Sam's old belongings. She now remembers the display case that held Warren's father's medals on a wall in Warren's study. Warren had kept much of his parents' furniture unchanged after their deaths, and Sylvie had accepted the house as it was. After Warren died, Damien sold, donated or discarded the contents, offering Griff a share of the proceeds, which Griff declined. Ro wonders why Damien sold the pieces individually rather than disposing of them together, and considers whether his financial circumstances could be less secure than he appears, though she has no evidence. She also recognizes there were much more valuable items in the house than the medals if anyone had wanted to steal something. On her laptop, Ro reexamines Sam's interviews with the young people of Carralon. Zach and Kyle, then ten and eleven, described persistent loneliness and a wish to leave, even though their parents intended to stay. In a joint interview, Darcy and Jacob expressed pride in their parents' public service and commitment to the town while acknowledging poor schooling, few opportunities and frustrations about remaining there. Jacob praised Ann-Marie's efforts to raise him after her divorce; Damien was not mentioned. Ro reads the interview repeatedly and imagines that the three friends may have shared a secret they did not articulate, but realizes this is an interpretation she cannot verify from their written words.
Key Events
- Ro recalls Warren's father's medals displayed in Warren's study and Damien's later sale of its contents.
- She questions why Damien sold household objects individually and considers whether money could be an issue, without reaching a conclusion.
- Ro reads Sam's interviews with Zach and Kyle, who wanted to leave the isolated town.
- Darcy and Jacob's joint interview describes family loyalty but dissatisfaction with their limited opportunities.
- Ro suspects an unspoken common experience may underlie the interview and recognizes that this may be her own projection.
Themes
- Speculation and the limits of documentary evidence
- Conflicting loyalties to the town
- Preservation and disposal of family possessions
Chapter 21
Concerned that Griff has left home upset after their argument, Ro drives to Warren Hillary's abandoned farmhouse and finds him using a chainsaw to remove the fallen branches from its rear verandah. They apologize for their earlier disagreement. Ro offers to help shift the debris and, while Griff cuts the wood, walks around the neglected property. She follows the route Sam took on his final afternoon, as recorded by the drone and tracked by his boot prints. Inside Warren's house, she revisits the empty study and sees the marks where the case of Warren's father's running medals once hung. Griff calls for her assistance with a thick branch lodged through the verandah floor. As Ro levers away a damaged board and Griff pulls the branch, it suddenly gives way, sending her backward and exposing a hole beneath the decking. The two briefly hold hands as Griff helps Ro stand. Ro notices a small metallic object fall through the hole. While examining the boards, Griff finds a dark stain along the edges that had been hidden where the planks joined. Drawing on her experience as a doctor, Ro identifies the appearance as old blood, though no forensic testing has yet established what the substance is. She then reaches into the gap, retrieves the small object from the earth below, and shows it to Griff. It is a key. The discovery does not yet establish whose key it is or what caused the stain.
Key Events
- Ro locates Griff working at Warren's farmhouse and they exchange apologies after their argument.
- She walks through the abandoned house and studies the former position of Warren's father's medal case.
- Ro and Griff pull away damaged decking while clearing a fallen branch.
- Griff discovers a dark stain along the hidden edge of a floorboard that Ro recognizes as resembling old blood.
- Ro retrieves a key from below the verandah floorboards, with its origin and relevance still unexplained.
Themes
- Material evidence amid unresolved loss
- Reconciliation through shared work
- The limits of early inference
Chapter 22
After finding a key and bloodlike staining beneath Warren Hillary's verandah decking, Ro and Griff remove adjoining boards and discover that the dark marks extend across several of the hidden edges. Ro believes the amount of apparent blood could indicate a serious injury, though she cannot confirm who, or what, bled. She and Griff briefly consider Sam, then reject the possibility because his visible boot prints showed him moving through the three houses without a known injury. They also wonder whether the marks could be Warren's, though his inquest recorded a verdict of misadventure after his body was recovered from the quarry. Ro notices that a clean section interrupts the stains along aligned boards; the rounded end of the recovered Yale key fits the gap in shape, suggesting it might have been wedged between them before the stains developed. They acknowledge it could be unrelated. The key opens none of the accessible locks at Warren's house, its outbuildings or the two adjacent properties. Ro photographs the boards, and Griff covers the damaged area with a tarp. Damien comes to the Crowley house with old Hillary keys, but no match is found, even after comparing additional keys kept by Della and Griff. The family discusses whether to contact police. Della argues they should first talk to Sylvie, who has not returned messages while visiting her ill mother. After dinner, Damien confides that he distrusts Sylvie because she appeared to want him to sell Warren's inherited house while avoiding public responsibility for the transaction; he acknowledges that this is his interpretation. Once Damien leaves, Griff recalls another oddity from when he and Sam visited Warren's empty home: sausages were deeply burned on the side resting against the grill even though Warren was an experienced cook and the gas had been switched off. Griff wonders if something interrupted Warren, rather than merely distress over the mine, but has no proof.
Key Events
- Ro and Griff expose dark stains across several concealed deck-board edges, which Ro suspects may be blood from a serious injury.
- Ro finds that the key fits an unstained gap between planks, without proving any temporal or causal connection.
- Tests of accessible doors, padlocks and spare key collections at the three abandoned houses yield no match.
- Damien expresses suspicion that Sylvie quietly favored the Hillary sale but made him take responsibility for it.
- Griff recalls that Warren's sausages were deeply burned only on their bottom surfaces, raising an unproven possibility of interruption on his final evening.
Themes
- Physical clues of uncertain origin
- Contradictory accounts of Warren's death
- Distrust and attribution of motives
Chapter 23
On Sunday morning, after a restless night, Ro learns from Griff's note that he is on the ridge watching for wind-driven spot fires. She takes the key recovered at Warren's farmhouse to the deserted center of Carralon Ridge and tries it against locks at the closed pub and several abandoned businesses, finding no match. At Damien's occupied townhouse, the key slides into the front-door lock but will not turn. Ro stops before damaging it and recognizes that its shape alone proves nothing. She sees Sylvie's red Ford Capri returning to the pub and goes to meet her. Sylvie is visibly distressed because her elderly mother suffered a minor stroke while Sylvie was visiting; Ro changes her planned approach and asks about her health. Inside the pub, Sylvie inspects the key and Ro's photographs of the stained floorboards but says she cannot identify the key or explain the marks. Ro then produces Sam's notebook and the question 'Re: Warren and Lentzer. Ask Sylvie?' Sylvie is reluctant to revisit the subject while worrying about her mother. Ro presses her, arguing that the end of Griff's contract and sale of their former home may make this her last visit, and questions why Sylvie still stays in Carralon when she could be near her ill mother in Blenheim. Ro suggests that unfulfilled responsibility, rather than an act of wrongdoing, might cause guilt. At last Sylvie agrees to explain what she knows, specifying that she is doing so for Warren's sake. The chapter ends before her account begins.
Key Events
- Ro searches abandoned shops and public buildings for a lock fitting the recovered key.
- At Damien's townhouse the key enters but cannot turn; she concludes it does not open his door.
- Sylvie returns from visiting her mother, who has suffered a minor stroke.
- Sylvie says she cannot identify the key or apparent bloodstains but resists discussing Sam's handwritten question about Warren and Lentzer.
- Ro presses Sylvie to disclose her knowledge before the family leaves Carralon; Sylvie finally agrees for Warren's sake.
Themes
- The unreliability of superficial physical matches
- Grief and reluctant disclosure
- Pressure to account for the past
Chapter 24
At the pub, Sylvie tells Ro that she believes she knows why Warren died and holds herself partly responsible. The high initial price offered by Lentzer could have allowed her and Warren to leave Carralon and settle near Blenheim, where her elderly mother had been placed in care after a fall and pneumonia. Sylvie had persuaded her mother to move from Melbourne but then could not spend enough time with her. Warren refused to sell the Hillary family house, prioritizing his attachment to the land and his neighbors over the future Sylvie wanted for them. Sylvie admits she pressured him repeatedly, kept her wish to sell secret because she feared community judgment, and moved out to the flat above the pub to demonstrate her anger. She regarded the separation as temporary. On Warren's last day he came to the pub and asked to call later; she took the call but they argued, more bitterly than she disclosed to police. She regrets how she spoke to him, and for years she concealed the details from everyone. Sylvie then discloses the central fact that changed her understanding of Warren's death: during that final call, Warren told her he had changed his mind and would sell the house for her. She rejected his offer in anger. Years later, Sam asked Sylvie questions that suggested someone had told him about Warren's unpublicized change of mind. Sylvie had thought no one else knew. The chapter ends with this revelation, leaving open how Sam heard of Warren's intention and whether it bears on the circumstances of either death or disappearance.
Key Events
- Sylvie says Lentzer's first offer might have funded a move near her ill mother's care home in Blenheim.
- She admits pressuring Warren to sell, concealing her own preference from neighbors and moving out as a protest.
- Sylvie discloses that she argued severely with Warren on his final night and had withheld the full conversation from police.
- She says Warren agreed on that call to sell his house for her, but she dismissed his change of heart in anger.
- Sylvie reveals Sam had later raised the undisclosed decision to sell, though how he learned about it remains unknown.
Themes
- Conflicting loyalties within a relationship
- Regret and the concealment of painful conversations
- A previously undisclosed decision
Chapter 25
Ro calls Griff from near the empty bank after Sylvie discloses Warren's last conversation. Griff says he never knew Warren had agreed to sell, but believes it possible because Warren missed Sylvie and hoped to reconcile. Sylvie's account, relayed in the chapter, clarifies that Warren told her by telephone he preferred their relationship to staying in the house. He had already lost the mine's unusually high initial offer, and she angrily told him it was too late before ending the call. She intended to speak to him more calmly the next day, but police reported his death first. Ro explains that Sam revisited Sylvie the afternoon before his own disappearance, ostensibly to clarify a few recorded answers from an earlier interview. Toward the end he asked whether Warren really told her he had agreed to sell and possibly felt guilty about doing so when he died. Sylvie falsely denied he had mentioned selling. Sam would not identify the source of the allegation and appeared relieved by her denial. Ro and Griff consider how someone besides Sylvie could know what Warren said. Griff speculates that an unknown visitor to the property might have overheard Warren speaking on the telephone while cooking outside, but admits he cannot establish this. During their call, Ro repeatedly hears irregular metal clanging from the east side of town, similar to a sound she heard on her arrival. Griff, watching town through binoculars from the ridge, says Darcy's car briefly appeared on the east road earlier but that he saw no person on foot. Ro decides to investigate the sound and asks Griff to keep her in sight and call if she disappears from his view.
Key Events
- Sylvie's account to Ro details Warren's agreement to sell his house to repair their relationship and her angry rejection on the final night.
- Sam had returned to Sylvie the afternoon before his disappearance and asked about the change of mind; Sylvie denied it, although it had happened.
- Griff wonders whether someone at Warren's property overheard his last telephone conversation, with no evidence of who or whether it occurred.
- Ro hears recurring metallic banging east of the town center while talking with Griff.
- Griff reports a recent brief visit by Darcy's car to the east road; Ro investigates while he monitors her from the ridge.
Themes
- Knowledge of a concealed conversation
- The uncertain source of a rumor
- Concern and cooperation between estranged parents
Chapter 26
Following the intermittent clanging sound, Ro discovers Heather and Noel's younger sons Kyle and Zach vandalizing her former consulting room in the closed Carralon medical center. They are using a cricket bat to damage cabinets and furniture and appear more determined than amused. They admit their parents do not know they go there; Darcy gave them a lift into town because they said they were going to the sports oval. Ro drives them home rather than leaving them in the building. During the ride they report that Heather has repeatedly urged Noel to see a doctor and stop drinking. Zach argues that Noel, not the boys, abandoned work on the Last Chance Saloon and that the family remains in Carralon because Noel wants to stay, not only because Bernie is ill. Ro encounters Bernie preparing electrical wiring at the saloon and tells him she found the boys at her former workplace. He asks where they were 'this time', suggesting he knows they have caused trouble before. Ro warns Bernie, as his former GP, that insisting on dying at home in such an isolated location may impose substantial burdens on his family. He responds that Noel is an adult who makes his own decisions and that he has earned the right to remain in the community where he has lived and served. On her way to the car, Ro sees Darcy and Jacob laughing together over Darcy's repaired motorcycle. Hurt by the sight of Sam's surviving childhood friends together, she asks them directly to answer Della's questions, saying Sam would tell the truth if their own mothers asked. She then tests the recovered key in the Reece farmhouse's front-door lock. It does not fit, and Ro drives away.
Key Events
- Ro traces the clanging to the closed medical center, where Kyle and Zach are destroying her old office.
- The boys say Darcy gave them a lift without knowing their intentions and report that Noel has been drinking despite Heather's objections.
- Ro returns them to the Reece farm and challenges Bernie about how remaining there affects the family's care and isolation.
- Bernie insists that Noel, not Bernie alone, has chosen to remain in Carralon.
- Ro confronts Darcy and Jacob about withholding information from Della, then finds that the recovered key does not fit the Reeces' front door.
Themes
- Adolescent isolation and destructive behavior
- Caregiving choices within a family
- Pressure to disclose past events
Chapter 27
Ro drives back to the junction of the three abandoned houses and stops at the exact spot where Sam's car was discovered. As a Lentzer service vehicle approaches, she imagines what Sam might have done had he seen someone coming along the road, but knows there is no evidence that he encountered anyone there. Ro considers the mine's pressure on Warren, Sylvie's hidden wish to sell, and the punitive social divisions between townspeople who stayed and those who accepted mining offers. She recognizes that Carralon's reputation for mutual support concealed hostility toward people whose needs and loyalties differed from those of their neighbors. Thinking of Zach and Kyle's destructive boredom, she suddenly connects the behavior of isolated teenagers with something she saw in the abandoned houses and with the objects Griff is sorting in their shed. The chapter does not yet explain what she has realized. When Ro turns her car back toward the road, she stops abruptly for Jacob, who approaches on a bicycle. He says he had been on his way to speak with her, because Sam would have told the truth if his mother had asked. Jacob offers to explain something even though Darcy has not agreed to do so. Ro asks whether it involves the old running medals, and Jacob's expression confirms her suspicion. She puts his bicycle in the boot and drives him to speak with Griff as well.
Key Events
- Ro revisits the precise location where Sam's rental car was left and considers hypothetical encounters with other vehicles.
- She reflects on how pressure from Lentzer divided the town and constrained people's choices.
- The experience with Zach and Kyle suggests to Ro a possible connection to abandoned houses and childhood possessions, not yet explained.
- Jacob arrives by bicycle and agrees to explain something he and Darcy have kept private.
- Ro suspects the matter concerns the old running medals, and Jacob accompanies her to speak with Griff.
Themes
- Community expectations and private needs
- Hypothesis formation from partial clues
- Concealed history among childhood friends
Chapter 28
Ro returns to the family house with Jacob, where Griff and Damien are considering Sylvie's new account and examining spare keys. Della joins them as Jacob admits he and his childhood friends Sam and Darcy played increasingly intrusive pranks on Carralon residents as bored teenagers. Darcy took Bernie's truck and parked it in town, causing Bernie to fear a serious memory problem; medical checks later uncovered another illness. Jacob himself planned the theft of Ann-Marie's bed with Sam and Darcy so that his mother would blame his estranged father. Her distress made Jacob ashamed, and the boys agreed to stop targeting her and Bernie. Their tricks continued mainly against Warren, including moving tools, remotely interfering with his television and stealing his late father's running medals. Darcy took the medals one at a time; Sam was angry when he discovered this and instructed Darcy to return them. Darcy gave them to Sam, who intended to put them back but disappeared before doing so. Jacob says all three regretted their behavior after Warren died, though the chapter does not establish that their pranks caused his death. Damien and Griff recall pranks of their own youth. Damien mentions that Warren had once carved small faces around town, with a mouth shaped like a W. Griff suddenly remembers that Damien may have told Sam about the carvings during his final interview. Damien agrees that he could have done so, but had omitted the detail from the replacement statement he prepared after Sam's interview recording vanished. Griff decides to show Ro and Della the surviving carvings. Damien and Jacob's awkward familiarity also becomes apparent as they exchange messages about meeting privately afterward, without a stated explanation of their relationship.
Key Events
- Jacob admits he, Darcy and Sam played pranks around town, including Darcy moving Bernie's truck and Jacob orchestrating removal of Ann-Marie's bed.
- Jacob reveals that Darcy stole Warren's father's running medals and Sam made him return them so Sam could replace them in the house.
- Jacob expresses remorse and says the boys stopped after Warren's death; no causal explanation of the death is established.
- Damien recalls Warren carving little faces with W-shaped mouths in hidden locations around town.
- Griff suspects Damien mentioned those carvings to Sam during their last interview and takes Ro and Della to see them.
Themes
- Consequences of teenage cruelty
- Correcting mistaken blame and suspicion
- Incomplete recollections of a crucial interview
Chapter 29
Griff drives Ro and Della to the three abandoned houses and shows them small face carvings Warren made as a teenager, each with a zigzag W-shaped mouth. They locate marks on the outside posts of Bernie Reece's boarded-up stone bungalow, on windowsills and other interior surfaces at Ann-Marie's ivy cottage, and throughout the Hillary farmhouse. The pattern of the search closely resembles Sam's boot tracks from the day he vanished. Griff suggests that Sam, troubled by the pranks his friends had played on Warren, went to find the marks after Damien told him that Warren also played tricks when he was young. The explanation makes sense to Ro but is not established as Sam's actual purpose. Even if correct, it still offers no answer to what happened after he left the houses. At Warren's house, Griff and Ro sit together on the verandah while Della walks to the fence. Griff finally explains that after Sam disappeared he felt ashamed of how little he could do, compared with Ro's apparently organized efforts to examine records and work with police. Ro tells him that she saw her own activity as frantic and useless and misread his stillness as indifference. Griff admits he stayed in Carralon because he could not bear to leave Sam alone if his son remained somewhere nearby; he apologizes for opposing Ro's departure. They recognize how differently they expressed the same grief and share a moment of closeness. Della returns in tears, saying she hates the town, and the family prepares to leave the houses.
Key Events
- Griff shows Ro and Della hidden W-mouthed carvings at all three abandoned properties.
- They compare the distribution of the carvings with Sam's previously documented boot prints.
- Griff and Ro consider that Sam came looking for the carvings, but the reason for his disappearance remains unknown.
- Griff explains that shame and the desire not to abandon Sam in Carralon kept him there after Ro left; Ro describes her own misinterpretation of his grief.
- The parents apologize and begin to understand each other, while Della returns from the fence crying.
Themes
- Reframing guilt through new information
- The difference between understanding motive and resolving disappearance
- Reconciliation between grieving parents
Chapter 30
In the final minutes before midnight, Ro sits awake in the studio hut as Sam's birthday approaches. She recalls his birth twenty-six years earlier and the hospital staff who helped her through labor. Griff's bedroom light is still on. Since returning from the three houses, the family has spent a subdued evening together, and Ro has ignored calls from Heather and Sylvie. She has repeatedly read Sam's notes without finding an answer to how he learned of Warren's apparent willingness to sell. After the clock passes midnight, she becomes impatient with her own inability to move beyond those documents and notices the envelope of ten sunflower seeds she found among Sam's childhood possessions. She decides to plant five at the old family home and take the other five to Sydney. With Sam's small trowel and a larger one from the shed, Ro walks to the vegetable garden she once maintained with her children. Expecting to find it abandoned, she discovers that Griff has cleared and replanted its raised beds with established native plants and succulents. At its center stands the original wrought-iron arch under which they married in the Hewetts' orchard, now entwined with jasmine. Griff has rescued and preserved both the arch and the garden without telling her. Ro returns to the main house, goes to Griff's bedroom and climbs into bed with him. They embrace and apologize to one another for leaving and for staying after Sam vanished. Griff confirms that he saved their wedding arch.
Key Events
- At midnight, Ro remembers Sam's birth as his twenty-sixth birthday and the fifth anniversary of his disappearance arrive.
- Ro takes the ten sunflower seeds labeled by Sam and plans to plant half in Carralon and half in Sydney.
- She finds that Griff has restored her formerly neglected vegetable garden with mature hardy plantings.
- The original wedding arch missing from the Hewetts' orchard stands in the revived garden covered with climbing jasmine.
- Ro goes to Griff's bed and they reunite, apologizing for their opposing decisions after Sam disappeared.
Themes
- Restoration of shared family history
- Reconciliation after bereavement
- Living memory and grief
Chapter 31
Ro wakes beside Griff on the morning of Sam's twenty-sixth birthday, five years after he vanished on his twenty-first. Their restored intimacy does not diminish the pain of the date. Griff leaves periodically to watch for possible fires from the ridge, Della remains mostly in her bedroom working, and Ro wanders the house restlessly. She again checks the keys Damien supplied against the one recovered from Warren's decking and finds no match. She then sits in the revived garden beneath the wedding arch. At about the time she last saw Sam alive, Ro uses his childhood trowel to plant five of the ten sunflower seeds beside the arch, without expecting the old seeds to germinate. She and Della prepare the chocolate birthday cake that they have made annually since his disappearance. Griff returns and brings the same candles they have reused over the years. As the family watches the flames, Ro senses the beginning of a memory or association involving light or fire but cannot identify it. On Della's count, all three blow out the candles together, and Ro makes her customary wish. They leave for Sam's memorial gathering, still without an explanation for his disappearance.
Key Events
- Ro wakes beside Griff on Sam's birthday and continues to grieve his disappearance.
- She checks Damien's additional spare keys and again finds no match to the one from the decking.
- Ro plants five of Sam's sunflower seeds with his childhood trowel in the restored garden beside the wedding arch.
- Ro and Della bake their annual chocolate cake, and Griff retrieves the reused birthday candles.
- A fleeting memory associated with the candle flames escapes Ro before the family blows out the candles and leaves for the memorial.
Themes
- Family rituals of remembrance
- Renewed closeness amid continuing grief
- Incomplete recollection
Chapter 32
Ro, Griff and Della arrive at the junction of the three abandoned houses for the fifth-anniversary memorial for Sam. Several neighbors are already gathered. Heather apologizes for Zach and Kyle damaging the medical center, and Ro agrees to hear their apologies after the service. Della initially refuses to speak, as does Ro, who has found public remembrances increasingly difficult. Griff begins by thanking those present and praising his son, but grief interrupts him. Ro unexpectedly speaks instead, explaining that memories of Sam have become harder to maintain in Sydney, where most people did not know him. Reuniting with people who remember him helps her preserve his distinct personality. Encouraged by her mother's words, Della shares a humorous memory of Sam's homemade childhood birthday waterslide, and the family finds comfort in the shared recollection. Then Darcy asks to speak. He says Sam's departure for university and later research questions made him reconsider why he remained in Carralon. Although his parents and grandfather worked hard to preserve the community, Darcy has stayed partly from obligation to them rather than because he sees a future there. He questions why the adults expect his fifteen- and sixteen-year-old brothers to remain isolated in a declining town and acknowledges regrettable things he, Sam and Jacob did as bored teenagers. There is, he argues, no reward for being the last resident to leave. Darcy then announces that he and Jacob intend to move to Blenheim the following month, where Jacob has found work. His parents, grandfather and Ann-Marie are shocked, while Heather seems cautiously pleased. Darcy thanks Sam for first asking him why he stayed.
Key Events
- Neighbors gather at the three houses for Sam's fifth-anniversary birthday memorial; Heather asks that her sons apologize for vandalism later.
- Griff struggles to speak, Ro explains how neighbors help sustain her memories of Sam, and Della tells a story about his childhood birthday waterslide.
- Darcy publicly explains that loyalty and obligation, rather than opportunity, kept him in Carralon, and challenges his family's insistence on remaining.
- Darcy says he and Jacob will move to Blenheim next month, where Jacob has obtained a job.
- Darcy explicitly rejects the idea that anyone wins by being the last person to leave the town.
Themes
- Collective remembrance of a missing son
- Obligation to family versus personal prospects
- Young people's constrained opportunities
Chapter 33
Sylvie eases the tension after Darcy's unexpected memorial speech by announcing that the Black Creek Inn will open. Della leaves with Darcy and Jacob, who want advice about remote courses in land management and university study, asking her parents to join them at the pub soon. Bernie and Noel remain at the memorial site with Ro and Griff. Bernie, looking toward the stone bungalow he once owned, wonders whether Darcy is right and whether his grandsons should continue to sacrifice their own opportunities for decisions made by their elders. Noel says the question is complicated but offers no clear answer. Bernie and Noel eventually leave. Alone with Ro, Griff acknowledges that staying in Carralon was not solely about being near the place Sam disappeared. He also wanted to punish himself for feeling that he had failed to find Sam and for blaming Ro as their marriage deteriorated. Ro tells him they were both doing their best and can decide together what comes next. At the exact place where Sam's rental car was found, Griff crouches and touches the ground. Ro kneels beside him as they say goodbye to their son. The gesture brings back an image Ro has seen recently and an incomplete thought that has troubled her for several days. She abruptly stands and retrieves the silver key found between the stained boards at Warren's farmhouse. At last she understands which door it should open, but the chapter does not identify the door.
Key Events
- Sylvie announces the pub reopening immediately after the memorial, and Della goes ahead with Jacob and Darcy to discuss potential studies.
- Bernie questions whether remaining in Carralon justifies the cost to his grandsons, while Noel does not commit to leaving.
- Griff admits that guilt and a wish to punish himself for Sam's loss and the deterioration of his marriage influenced his decision to stay.
- Ro and Griff touch the ground where Sam's car was found and acknowledge their son together.
- Ro suddenly recognizes which door the recovered key should open, but does not disclose it yet.
Themes
- Consequences of remaining in a declining community
- Self-punishment and acknowledgement of grief
- A delayed association of physical evidence
Chapter 34
Eight years earlier, on the last evening of Warren Hillary's life, Warren sits on his verandah during a phone call with Sylvie. He has decided to sell the family property to Lentzer and move away with her, hoping to repair their relationship. Sylvie is angry and upset because she believes he has reached the decision too late. Warren remembers how they met in Bali and how the mine's expansion has strained their life together. Earlier that day, he tried to visit Sylvie at the pub, but she was too busy to talk. After returning home, he questioned whether he could give up a property holding his family's history, then resolved to tell his brother and cousin about his decision. He phoned Damien at a conference hotel in Sydney and Griff, who was away for Ro's father's funeral, but neither answered. Warren prepared sausages on the outdoor barbecue while waiting for Sylvie's break and then called her. As Sylvie continues arguing, Warren checks the food and decides it can wait. He becomes aware of an indistinct noise nearby, but turns his attention back to the call. He walks down the verandah steps into the yard and tells Sylvie that he loves her, has decided to sell, and plans to accept Lentzer's offer the next day. She ends the call abruptly. A second noise behind him makes him turn toward the house. Someone is standing on the verandah, silhouetted by the light from the open front door. The unidentified person greets Warren and remarks that his front door is open. The chapter ends before the visitor's identity or subsequent events are disclosed. Warren's thoughts in this scene show that he had decided to act on his future with Sylvie, but do not resolve what caused his death.
Key Events
- The narrative shifts eight years into the past to Warren's final evening, from Warren's own perspective.
- Warren decides to sell his home for a future with Sylvie despite his attachment to the property and his doubts.
- Warren attempts to telephone Damien and Griff before discussing the decision with Sylvie; neither answers.
- While preparing sausages on his verandah, he speaks to Sylvie, tells her he intends to accept the mine's offer tomorrow, and she ends the call.
- An unidentified person appears on the verandah after the call and comments on the open front door.
Themes
- The conflict between family attachment and a shared future
- New direct evidence about Warren's final evening
- A visitor of unknown identity
Chapter 35
In the present, Ro and Griff drive in silence from the three abandoned houses toward the center of Carralon Ridge. The town's almost complete abandonment makes Ro think about the resident who will eventually be the last to leave. At the Black Creek Inn, they see Della among the remaining townspeople and decide not to interrupt her. They continue past the pub rather than join the gathering after Sam's memorial. Griff turns onto a familiar road and stops at an unnamed destination in the dark. Ro voices concern that her newly formed idea may be mistaken. Griff tells her they should go and find out. Neither the place they have reached nor the object of their investigation is identified in this chapter.
Key Events
- Ro and Griff travel away from the three houses as the town grows dark and Ro considers its eventual abandonment.
- They pass the lit Black Creek Inn, where Della is with neighbors, and decide she is better off there.
- Griff drives to another familiar junction and stops at a destination that the chapter does not yet disclose.
- Ro questions whether her inference is correct and Griff urges her to investigate.
Themes
- Impending abandonment of Carralon Ridge
- Protecting Della from an unsettling inquiry
- Uncertain inference before a confrontation
Chapter 36
Five years earlier, on his twenty-first birthday, Sam Crowley returns from the three abandoned houses to his red rental car. The source now follows Sam's own perspective rather than only the traces his family later discovered. He has spent the afternoon looking for small carved faces that Warren Hillary made as a boy. At an interview earlier that day, Damien casually told Sam who had created the carvings. Sam, who had already recognized the carvings in the houses, realized that Warren himself had behaved mischievously as a teenager. The discovery has lessened Sam's guilt over the pranks he, Darcy and Jacob played on residents before Warren died. Sam still regrets the cruelty, but believes Warren would have understood the boredom behind the behavior. As he reaches his car, Sam spots Darcy's drone flying near the Lentzer mine and reflects that his once-close friendships with Darcy and Jacob have become more distant since he left for university. He is content with that change and plans to meet them at the pub after his family birthday meal. Sam is about to get into the rental car when a vehicle approaches from the east. He recognizes the car and its driver, who waves. Sam returns the greeting, locks his car again and walks down to the road as the other vehicle stops. The driver asks why he is there. The chapter does not identify the driver or reveal what happens next.
Key Events
- The narrative shifts five years into the past and follows Sam directly after his visits to the three abandoned houses.
- Sam confirms that Damien told him Warren made the small carved faces, which Sam visited to relieve guilt over youthful pranks.
- Sam sees Darcy's drone and reflects without distress on how his friendships with Darcy and Jacob have changed.
- Sam recognizes a car approaching from the east, locks his rental car and walks down to greet its driver.
- The driver asks Sam why he is there; the person's identity and Sam's subsequent fate are not disclosed.
Themes
- A missing person's direct perspective on his final known afternoon
- Guilt and a qualified sense of forgiveness
- An unexplained meeting with a familiar driver
Chapter 37
Ro and Griff approach a weathered door while the mine continues to rumble nearby. Ro has the silver key found between the stained boards at Warren's farmhouse and believes it may fit this lock, but is frightened of what the discovery could mean. As she tries to insert it, Griff steadies her shaking hand. The key turns and the door opens. Ro feels detached from what is happening until the grinding machinery suddenly falls silent. During the brief interval, they hear soft footsteps approaching from behind. Griff grips her hand more tightly, and they turn toward the sound as the mine resumes its noise. The location of the door and the identity of the approaching person remain undisclosed in this chapter.
Key Events
- Ro and Griff successfully unlock the door with the key.
- A sudden silence from the mine allows Ro and Griff to hear approaching footsteps.
- Griff and Ro turn to investigate the source of the sound.
Themes
- A discovery with uncertain implications
- Fear of the truth about Sam
- A deliberately withheld identity
Chapter 38
Ro and Griff stand inside the unlocked entrance to the Last Chance Saloon on the Reece farm. The silver key recovered from the bloodstained decking at Warren's farmhouse has opened its front door. Noel approaches across the paddock, saying he brought his father Bernie home from the pub because the gathering had overwhelmed him. He looks wary when he notices Ro's key and recognizes that the usual spare hidden in a ceramic frog on the saloon deck was not used. Ro tells him where they found the key. Griff asks whether Noel can explain the dark stain on Warren's verandah boards. Noel suggests they should speak to Sylvie, but Ro says they already have. Bernie is approaching from the house. Ro proposes asking Bernie what he knows because the saloon's front door was once the front door of his former stone bungalow. The source establishes the key's connection to Bernie and his relocated door but does not yet disclose what happened at Warren's home.
Key Events
- Ro and Griff open the Last Chance Saloon using the key discovered between the stained boards at Warren's farmhouse.
- Noel reacts warily to the recovered key and to questions about the stain.
- Noel suggests asking Sylvie, but Ro says they have already done so.
- Bernie approaches, and Ro identifies the saloon's blue front door as Bernie's salvaged former door.
Themes
- Identification of physical evidence
- A guarded confrontation with neighbors
- The reuse of old buildings and possessions
Chapter 39
Eight years earlier, Bernie Reece and his son Noel arrive at Warren Hillary's farmhouse on the evening Warren tells Sylvie he will sell his home. Bernie has overheard enough of the phone call to realize Warren intends to accept Lentzer's offer and confronts him on the verandah. Noel initially assumes Bernie's distress is another consequence of recent medication, but Warren's hesitation confirms the decision. Bernie argues that selling the Hillary property will enable the mine to expand, destroy the value of his own stone bungalow and Ann-Marie's cottage, and force others to leave. Warren tries to explain that he has only just decided to sell because he wants to reconcile with Sylvie; he refuses to change his mind. While the confrontation intensifies, the sausages he had been cooking become charred on the barbecue. Bernie removes the key to his own home from his key ring and slams it onto the verandah table, telling Warren he may as well take it if he intends to deprive Bernie of his house. Bernie then begs Warren not to sell. Warren, ashamed and distressed, turns his back and says harshly that he does not care, though his thoughts show that is untrue. As Warren begins to turn back to apologize, Bernie tackles him from behind with enough force to knock him into the table. Warren's head strikes its edge and he falls bleeding onto the wooden deck. He sees the silver key fall from the table and disappear. His awareness fades as he hears Noel address his father in alarm. The chapter directly establishes the assault and head injury, but ends before revealing how Warren later reached the quarry or what caused his death there.
Key Events
- Bernie overhears Warren tell Sylvie he will sell and confronts him at the farmhouse; Noel arrives while they argue.
- Bernie and Noel explain that selling the strategic Hillary property will expose neighboring homes to mine pressure and financial loss.
- Bernie takes his own house key off his ring and slams it on the verandah table in anger.
- After Warren turns away, Bernie tackles him, causing his head to strike the table and leaving him bleeding on the deck.
- The key falls between boards as Warren loses awareness; Noel reacts in alarm, but the later death and quarry circumstances remain undisclosed.
Themes
- Violent consequences of competing loyalties
- Delayed disclosure of a serious injury
- The causal origin of the recovered key and bloodstain
Chapter 40
At the Last Chance Saloon in the present, Bernie admits to Ro and Griff that he caused the attack on Warren eight years earlier. His son Noel confirms that, after Warren was injured, Noel transported him to the Lentzer quarry while Bernie cleaned the blood from the farmhouse verandah. Noel cut a hole in the mine fence, left Warren's truck nearby, and threw Warren's body over the quarry edge, creating the appearance of a fatal fall. Bernie says he and Noel searched for the house key lost in the struggle but never recovered it; they thought it would remain hidden beneath the deck. Ro explains that the candle flames at Sam's birthday and the sight of Bernie using a lighter to strip wiring at the saloon helped her recognize the key's possible destination. Darcy's memorial speech also led her to question why Bernie and Noel continued to live in Carralon despite the distress of their family. Ro calls their decision to remain a form of penance rather than community loyalty. Griff is devastated by the involvement of his old friend Noel in concealing Warren's death. He then asks about Sam, observing that Noel stopped improving the saloon at about the time Sam disappeared five years earlier. He demands to know where his son is. Ro looks toward an empty back corner of the clubhouse and experiences a sudden conviction that Sam has been nearby, perhaps within the very room. The chapter ends with that disturbing intuition, without yet describing physical confirmation of his location.
Key Events
- Bernie admits assaulting Warren; Noel confirms he transported Warren to the mine, cut the fence, left Warren's truck and disposed of his body.
- Bernie says he cleaned Warren's verandah and could not recover the key from the boards.
- Ro links the key to Bernie's former front door through a memory of the saloon, and treats the men's continued residence as possible penance.
- Griff confronts Noel about giving up work on the saloon about five years earlier, around Sam's disappearance.
- Ro notices an unused corner of the saloon and feels that Sam might be or have been there; no physical discovery is yet made.
Themes
- Concealed responsibility for a death
- Complicity and long-term guilt
- The possible connection between two disappearances
Chapter 41
Five years earlier, Noel Reece recognizes Sam Crowley's red rental car beside the three abandoned houses and stops to speak to him. Sam has been exploring the properties and thinks the visit may be useful to his university research. Noel offers him historical maps he has collected and suggests that Sam ride with him to the Reece farm because the rough driveway could damage the rental car. Sam accepts, leaving his belongings and locked car at the junction. The Reece house is empty: Heather has taken Bernie to a medical appointment, and the younger boys are out. Noel brings Sam into the Last Chance Saloon, opening its salvaged blue door with the spare key hidden beneath a ceramic frog. At the back, a corner of the floor is open for repairs because the ground has subsided, according to Noel. Noel gives Sam the maps, but Sam then asks about Bernie's suggestion in a recent interview that Warren was willing to sell his property before dying. Sam says he asked Sylvie, who denied it, and wants Noel to stop Bernie spreading a damaging rumor. Noel resents Sam's insistence that Warren would never have sold. During the argument, Noel lets slip that Sylvie knew Warren had decided to sell, making Sam question how Noel could know that. Noel tries to explain that he overheard Warren and Sylvie discussing it at the pub, but recognizes that Sam will likely discover the inconsistency if he checks the timeline. Noel remembers the night three years earlier when he found Bernie beside Warren's bloodied deck and promised to conceal his father's actions. Afraid that Sam is close to uncovering their secret, Noel resolves to protect Bernie again. As Sam holds his phone, apparently alert to Noel's evasions, Noel strikes it from his hand. The chapter ends at the beginning of this confrontation; it does not yet disclose the complete subsequent sequence.
Key Events
- Noel is confirmed as the driver who met Sam beside his rental car on the day of his disappearance.
- Noel invites Sam to travel with him to the Reece farm for old maps, leaving Sam's rental car parked by the houses.
- Noel opens the saloon with its hidden spare key and shows Sam maps near a floor area already opened for structural repairs.
- Sam challenges Noel about Bernie's claim that Warren intended to sell, and Noel accidentally implies knowledge of a conversation he should not have known.
- Noel remembers concealing Bernie's attack on Warren and, fearing Sam may learn the truth, strikes Sam's phone from his hand.
Themes
- Revelation of Sam's last documented movements
- Complicity and determination to protect a parent
- A fatal consequence of inconsistent testimony
Chapter 42
Thirty-six hours after the confrontation at the Last Chance Saloon, Ro, Griff and Della watch Carralon Ridge from the ridge. Ro is numb, Griff cries repeatedly, and Della has contacted authorities and arranged legal representation for the family. The town below is crowded with police and media vehicles. Ro recalls the immediate aftermath of the confrontation: Noel himself called police, while Bernie waited outside the saloon. Ro and Griff went into the empty rear corner and sat beside the place where Sam had been hidden, remaining there until police arrived. Noel told his father that Bernie had not known about Sam, but Bernie replied that he had understood even without being told. In the present, officers and forensic personnel are working at the Reece property and Warren Hillary's former house. Sylvie, Damien and Ann-Marie stand together near the track and have left messages asking to speak with Ro and Griff; the family is not ready. Della says Jacob has already left for Blenheim and expresses hope that his and Darcy's previously announced move might still provide them a future. Ro remembers finding a handwritten note and a photograph on the Crowley doorstep that morning. The writer, Darcy, apologizes, says neither he nor his mother and brothers knew of Noel's actions, and assures Ro that he will remember Sam and Warren. The accompanying drone photograph, never seen by Ro before, shows Sam smiling into the camera shortly before his disappearance. Ro cannot know precisely when it was taken, but the image helps her recognize that Sam had been happy, loved and enjoying his visit home in his last days. The chapter does not describe a complete forensic determination of how Sam died.
Key Events
- Noel calls the police after his confrontation with Ro and Griff; Bernie says he had understood the secret of Sam even though Noel never told him.
- Ro and Griff sit in the back corner of the saloon where Sam was hidden, and officers arrive to investigate.
- Della arranges legal assistance and the family watches police operations from the ridge thirty-six hours later.
- Ro receives a written apology from Darcy, who says he, Heather, Zach and Kyle had not known Noel's secret.
- Darcy includes a previously unseen drone photograph of Sam smiling during his last visit home, giving Ro a measure of comfort.
Themes
- Belated discovery and family grief
- Distinguishing knowledge from family affiliation
- Remembering the final days of a lost person
Chapter 43
One year after Sam's remains were discovered at the Last Chance Saloon, Carralon Ridge has changed irrevocably. The three abandoned properties have been demolished and Lentzer has built an access road through the cleared land. Heather has moved with her younger sons Zach and Kyle to Sydney, where she works at a busy clinic and the boys attend a larger school. She and Ro no longer communicate, although they shared a final wordless embrace on the empty road before leaving town. Darcy has joined Jacob in Blenheim, and the two share a home and operate an agricultural services business with financial backing from Damien. Darcy is studying online and keeps a quieter social life. Damien works for a Sydney financial institution and explains that he had preserved all the proceeds from Warren's property sale, waiting to use the money for something Warren would have approved of; helping the young men start their business meets that aim. Damien continues to visit Jacob, whose biological relationship to him is not explicitly established. Sylvie manages a pub in Blenheim close to her mother's care home. Ann-Marie has joined the Royal Flying Doctor Service as a nurse in Queensland. Della remains in Sydney, considers leaving investment banking and is in a relationship with Matthew, a schoolteacher she met while volunteering at beach cleanups. The narrative finally confirms that Sam's remains were found under floorboards in an unused back corner of the saloon. His skull was fractured, but there were few injuries to suggest a prolonged struggle; Ro hopes this means he died quickly, without having that certainty. Ro and Griff have formally reunited and bought a cottage in a thriving rural town between Carralon and Sydney. They brought the original wedding arch with them and planted it in their new garden. After considering scattering Sam's ashes in Carralon, they decided not to leave him in a place they would never revisit. With Della, they eventually scatter his ashes in the paddock behind their new home, and Ro finds comfort in the family and the life they have chosen together.
Key Events
- One year later, the three abandoned houses have been demolished for a new mine access road.
- Heather and the two younger boys are established in Sydney; Darcy and Jacob live and work in Blenheim with Damien's investment.
- Sylvie works near her mother, Ann-Marie has joined the Royal Flying Doctor Service, and Della explores a possible career change and a relationship with Matthew.
- Sam's remains were found buried beneath the saloon floor; a skull fracture is established, but Ro's belief that his death was quick is an inference.
- Reunited Ro and Griff settle in a new town with their wedding arch and, together with Della, scatter Sam's ashes on their new property.
Themes
- The aftermath of criminal concealment and bereavement
- The decision to leave a declining town
- Renewed family life without forgetting the dead