The Language of Liars

by

15 Chapters + Epilogue

View Book Overview
Purchase at Books-A-Million Affiliate link: we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.

1. Nineteen Words for Doubt. Twenty-six Ways to Lie.

Ro, a young Ponto from Orro, has excelled at learning languages but struggles with routines and the judgment of his seniors at the Warren, a prestigious institution that secretly trains linguists to enter other beings' minds. Such a jump requires an instant of complete understanding of a foreign language and transfers the linguist's consciousness into the body of another being, apparently overriding its original mind. The Orro leadership wants spies, and Ro hopes to become the first successful jumper in generations by studying the Star Eaters, whose unusual physiology lets them extract the meridian element essential to interstellar travel. Ro's ambitions persist despite his increasingly painful failures in the Warren's simulated Star Eater environments.

After Senior Aga rebukes him for missing training, Ro visits his family hive, where his sisters and Lalo welcome him. Lalo shares his intellectual curiosity and hopes to study exotic materials engineering. Ro finds the comfort he has been missing at the Warren. Mother Hobi, an older linguist who never jumped, draws him into an intimate conversation using an Oltasol expression that obliges the listener to share a vulnerability. She hopes Ro will not succeed: a jump is effectively permanent for a Ponto lifetime, would take him away from his family and possible bonds with Lalo, and would displace an unwitting Star Eater's consciousness. Ro argues that the Star Eaters might recover later and that understanding them could benefit many civilizations. Mother Hobi calls the claim a self-reinforcing lie but does not change his declared purpose.

Ro returns to the Warren's practice cocoons and immerses himself in a simulated Star Eater body. Memories of Lalo and Mother Hobi suddenly make him question whether losing his home, identity and another being's autonomy is justified. At the very moment his thoughts fill with the Star Eaters' forms of doubt, the supposedly near-impossible jump occurs.

Key Events

  • An Orro internal record identifies the Warren's ability to jump into other minds as a means of obtaining spies.
  • Senior Aga challenges Ro about missed training, and Ro worries that exceptional linguistic skill may not compensate for his difficulties with the Warren's routines.
  • Ro visits his family, reconnects with Lalo, and speaks with Mother Hobi about the personal and ethical costs of the jump.
  • Mother Hobi warns that taking another being's body is theft and doubts the rationalizations that make it seem acceptable.
  • During simulated Star Eater practice, Ro experiences serious doubt and unexpectedly jumps into a real Star Eater.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • Senior Aga
  • Lalo
  • Mother Hobi
  • Coro
  • Sa
  • Mother Pogo

Themes

  • Language and cross-species understanding
  • Duty, autonomy and sacrifice
  • Family bonds and institutional expectations
Back to Top

2. the Sound of Space. the Shape of Speech.

A Warren training text presents Star Eater 'confusion periods' as natural episodes of lost memory and altered personality, and instructs a successful jumper to imitate one rather than reveal the intrusion. Ro's first moments in an actual Star Eater body are profoundly disorienting. Sensory impressions overwhelm him, and he initially assumes the cocoon's simulation has malfunctioned. He gradually hears a nearby Star Eater ask if he is all right and urge him to continue because they are behind their quota. The language conveys meaning directly but leaves grammatical roles and the precise nature of the request uncertain.

Ro realizes he is inside a dirty, uncomfortable, gravity-free metal vessel rather than the simulated open space he expected. His new body is smaller, physically strained and unlike the practice version. He cannot reconcile these differences with an ordinary simulation adjustment. As the physical reality of the jump becomes undeniable, he responds to the other worker's repeated inquiry by asking who he is.

Key Events

  • A Warren manual instructs jumpers to imitate the Star Eaters' reported confusion periods, revealing the institution's strategy for concealing mind takeover.
  • Ro awakens amid sensory overload in a small, uncomfortable Star Eater body aboard a metal vessel.
  • Another Star Eater asks if he can continue working because they are behind quota, but the Star Eater language leaves parts of the request ambiguous.
  • Ro realizes he has truly left the cocoon and asks, 'WHO AM I?'

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • Unnamed Star Eater coworker

Themes

  • Embodiment and perceptual difference
  • Institutional deception
  • Uncertainty and identity
Back to Top

3. Language Unpaired, Senses Unpaired, Life Unpaired

An excerpt from a public debate disputes whether the conglomerate's treatment of the Star Eaters respects their wishes or merely imposes outsiders' standards. In his new body aboard mining ship 79, Ro initially celebrates his successful jump, then tries to understand unfamiliar Overseer commands and reach a place to rest. The massive mechanical Overseers remain descendants of a system originally used to guard and suppress Star Eaters, although their official duties have changed. A fellow Star Eater patiently teaches Ro to navigate with attraction bracers and leads him to a grid of stark, nearly identical sleeping cells. The cramped, uniform environment reminds Ro of a prison, despite the conglomerate's claim that the Star Eaters are free citizens and choose their work.

The worker accepts Ro's feigned confusion and tells him she recently experienced a confusion period herself. Alone, Ro grieves for his family and the Ponto body he left behind. He remembers his instructions to report through the nexus and eventually meet an Orro astral orb, but even accessing a cell's nexus port triggers painful sensory overload. He postpones reporting until the next shift. Ro also struggles with losing his former senses, bodily features and Ponto gender identity. He reviews the crisis that makes his mission urgent: Star Eaters have apparently stopped reproducing, and the conglomerate's travel and trade depend on the meridian element only they can sense and mine. Orro, which depends on imports, could not survive a collapse of that system. He resolves to learn their secrets and help avert catastrophe, despite his fear and disorientation.

Key Events

  • A public debate exposes conflicting claims about whether outsiders listen to Star Eater wishes.
  • Ro learns that he is aboard mining ship 79 and is sent to the rest cells by an Overseer.
  • A Star Eater worker helps Ro use attraction bracers and reaches the austere rest bays; Ro initially mistakes the environment for something like a prison.
  • Ro cannot operate the ship's nexus comfortably and defers contacting Orro.
  • Ro recalls the severe population decline of Star Eaters and the potential collapse of interstellar trade if no solution is found.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-In-Front
  • An Overseer

Themes

  • Official claims and lived conditions
  • Displacement and personal identity
  • Dependence on an endangered species
Back to Top

4. Words to Devour, Minds to Remember

A report by an earlier jumped Orro Linguist claims that Star Eaters enjoy mining and have freely retained their work-centered lives. Ro's helpful coworker returns and leads him into another shift aboard the collector. He provisionally thinks of her as You-In-Front, a contextual form of address rather than a name. She teaches him to sense meridian through an inherited bodily aptitude and a special form of Star Eater connection. After repeated failed attempts, Ro can finally perceive meridian deposits and experiences the discovery as extraordinary. You-In-Front assigns him to spot the element while she mines it, but Ro struggles with the Star Eaters' spatial directions and the demands of coordinating workers.

Ro accidentally collides with another worker, whom he thinks of as You-Behind, causing her group to lose collected meridian. You-Behind angrily confronts him, and You-In-Front tries to excuse the mistake as confusion. A nearby Overseer orders them back to work, instantly ending their disagreement. Ro worries that his behavior will expose him. He learns that failing quota, rather than having a confusion period, is the real cause for concern, although You-In-Front's repeated insistence that work is life does not answer his questions about how quotas operate. The two switch roles, and Ro finds mining easier to perform than directing it but physically exhausting. His body becomes sluggish as meridian spindles accumulate, and an extraction machine removes them. He still cannot learn the quota's actual quantity and ends the shift acutely aware of his isolation and the Overseer's scrutiny.

Key Events

  • An earlier Linguist's report presents an optimistic interpretation of Star Eater satisfaction with mining, rather than independently verified fact.
  • You-In-Front teaches Ro to sense meridian and the role of spotter and miner.
  • Ro collides with You-Behind and causes a loss of meridian; the Overseer's command ends the dispute.
  • You-In-Front explains that falling short of quota is the real danger, but Ro does not understand the quota rules.
  • Ro undergoes exhausting mining and extraction while fearing that the Overseer is watching him.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-In-Front
  • You-Behind
  • An Overseer

Themes

  • Labor, coercion and quotas
  • Incomplete linguistic and sensory understanding
  • Official narratives versus experience
Back to Top

5. Navigating an Infinite World is Statistically Impossible

Three quotations offer incompatible judgments about the conglomerate's responsibility for the Star Eaters' present work. Ro spends his off-shift trying to explore mining ship 79 and find a way to contact Orro, but the identical metal grid makes its scale almost impossible for him to navigate. He notices a small Star Eater repeatedly stationed near his cell, and later sees several Overseers escort another worker away. His regular companion You-In-Front dismisses the incident as irrelevant to them. When the waiting worker reappears, Ro decides to ask for help using the ship's nexus.

The worker, whom Ro thinks of as You-Outside, says that she has recently experienced a confusion period. Their exchange goes wrong because both use elided grammar: Ro initially thinks she is echoing his own claims and begins to fear exposing himself as a nonnative speaker. After clarifying that each has separately reported confusion, he asks for help. You-Outside demonstrates the nexus interface, which can create a small astral library object linked to a bracer. The two enter a shared simulated nebula, where Ro marvels at the detailed environment. You-Outside seems unhappy or wistful, and Ro asks whether she would like to visit a nebula in reality, but she falls back on the conventional statements about work.

Ro asks about the Star Eater escorted away. You-Outside says that the worker went willingly for 'correction' of insufficiencies; Ro cannot determine what this means or how coercive it is. She then asks whether he knows how much their mining quota is, revealing that she, too, lacks an answer. Ro panics and responds with ritual phrases instead of admitting his own uncertainty. He leaves abruptly, realizes he should have spoken truthfully, and loses his way in the enormous grid, far from the cell and its navigational resources.

Key Events

  • Conflicting introductory quotations dispute whether Star Eater mining is a free choice.
  • Ro observes a worker escorted by Overseers and repeatedly encounters You-Outside near his cell.
  • You-Outside teaches him how to access the nexus and shares an immersive nebula simulation with him.
  • You-Outside describes an Overseer-supervised 'correction' for unspecified insufficiencies and asks the same unanswered quota question as Ro.
  • Ro's evasive response and sudden retreat leave him lost in the unmarked collector grid.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-Outside
  • You-In-Front
  • Overseers

Themes

  • Contradictory accounts of freedom
  • Language ambiguity and mistrust
  • Isolation and tentative connection
Back to Top

6. the Truths We Believe, the Truths We Agree On

An unattributed network post argues that reformers cannot replace the Overseer system without reproducing its same controlling functions, and claims the mining workers accept the arrangement. After spending more than an off-shift lost in the collector, Ro eventually reaches the ore center late for work. An Overseer demands an explanation and threatens correction if he is ill. While trying to explain his navigational mistake, Ro suddenly works out that Star Eater spatial terminology is grounded in their sensory capacities. His excitement at the discovery distracts him from the Overseer's increasingly forceful orders. The machine warns that if he does not resume duties, it will declare him ill, a category that Ro recognizes as uncomfortably close to a flaw requiring correction.

Ro asks to join a group, and the Overseer assigns him to the worker he previously collided with, You-Behind. She demands to know what he discovered. Conscious that she could have seen his public, full-body gestures to the Overseer, Ro lies that he merely figured out a route through the ship. You-Behind angrily calls him a liar, asks what he remembers and spits at him. Ro does not understand what she expects him to remember and invokes his confusion. Overseers interrupt the confrontation but hold Ro responsible for disruptive behavior, ordering him off the shift under the threat of an illness declaration. He obeys, frightened and humiliated.

Key Events

  • An anonymous public post depicts Overseer reform as a largely cosmetic question, a position the narrative does not verify.
  • Ro returns from being lost, arriving late and facing the Overseer's threat of correction for 'illness.'
  • Ro deduces that Star Eater directional words correspond to their unfamiliar sensory system.
  • You-Behind accuses him of lying about what he remembers and spits at him.
  • Overseers dismiss Ro from his shift under another threat to declare him ill, rather than resolving the dispute.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-Behind
  • Overseers

Themes

  • Language and perceptual frames
  • Disciplinary control
  • Knowledge, secrecy and suspicion
Back to Top

7. a Word That Means Friend, but What Does Friend Mean

One of Ro's post-jump reports explains his newly discovered relationship between Star Eater directional language and their extraordinary sensory range. Following the confrontation with You-Behind, Ro makes his first covert reports to Orro through the nexus and successfully creates navigational aids. You-In-Front returns for the next shift, sympathizes with his mistake and invites him to her favorite place outside working hours. Their shared linguistic humor gives Ro some relief. She guides him through abandoned sections of the enormous collector, including old medical and research laboratories, to the open edge of the ship. Ro is disturbed that Star Eaters have no obvious doctors of their own and that foreign scientists are summoned for illnesses or injuries.

At the ship's edge, You-In-Front teaches Ro to extend his perception of meridian far beyond the nearby ore field. He briefly senses a vast pattern of distant deposits. She explains that many Star Eaters must combine their abilities when their ship needs to jump to another harvesting ground; their collective biological navigation can take the vessel to a distant destination. Ro wonders what it would mean if Star Eaters could choose to travel elsewhere. When he asks whether You-In-Front wants a different life, she treats a change of work shift as the relevant option. Ro admits that he hopes to reproduce someday, but she repeats that their bodies will know when the time is right.

On the return, Ro mentions an Overseer that has watched him over multiple shifts. You-In-Front is suddenly and unusually concerned, admitting she did not notice while concentrating on mining. When Ro presses about what will happen if he fails again, she tells him simply not to fail and remains distant for the remainder of the journey.

Key Events

  • Ro sends his first reports to Orro and learns to make nexus-based maps.
  • You-In-Front invites him outside the active mining zone, passing abandoned laboratories and infrastructure.
  • Together they sense the distant meridian landscape, and You-In-Front explains how workers collectively move their collector ship.
  • A question about reproducing yields the familiar statement that a Star Eater's body will know when to do so.
  • You-In-Front becomes guarded after hearing that an Overseer has been watching Ro.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-In-Front

Themes

  • Linguistic discovery and physical experience
  • Freedom and choice
  • Friendship and institutional surveillance
Back to Top

8. Confidence. Arrogance. Hubris.

A biographical source praises Sayl d'Chifte Hausht's Dissolution-era study of Star Eater reproduction and minimizes controversies over that period's medical research. After eight mining shifts, Ro reaches Orro's clandestine rendezvous orb. He is eager to report both his linguistic discoveries and his progress living among the workers. Instead of receiving congratulations, he meets Master Linguist Koa, who says the Warren regarded Ro as an unsuitable trainee, criticizes his missed shifts, cultural errors and interactions with workers, and dismisses his detailed observations as worthless. Koa tells Ro that his function is to report without interpreting. Once he can avoid drawing attention, the Warren intends to teach him to conceal meridian during mining and divert it to Orro.

Ro realizes that the institutional mission is not primarily the cross-cultural research he had imagined. He objects to taking the element and urges Koa to study Star Eater desires and motives more carefully, since their control over meridian could affect every civilization. Koa insists that Star Eaters make no demands, treats them as unimportant next to Orro's survival, and orders Ro to repeat that priority. Ro's shame shifts into anger. He rebukes Koa for misunderstanding the beings he has never inhabited and recognizes that his unique successful jump gives him some leverage over the Warren. He announces that he has a demand of his own, without specifying it before the chapter ends.

Key Events

  • An in-world historical portrait praises an influential Star Eater reproductive researcher while defending ethically contested Dissolution-era studies.
  • Ro finally contacts Orro after eight work shifts and meets Master Linguist Koa.
  • Koa condemns Ro's mistakes and orders him to cease engaging with workers or independently analyzing their culture.
  • Koa reveals that the mission's operational aim is to conceal and divert meridian to Orro, rather than conduct cultural research.
  • Ro confronts Koa's assumptions about Star Eaters and declares that he has a demand.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • Master Linguist Koa

Themes

  • Institutional control over knowledge
  • Resource scarcity and exploitation
  • Expertise, authority and dissent
Back to Top

9. the Phantom of Choice, the Illusion of Necessity

An interview excerpt presents the Star Eaters' apparent unanimity as an explanation for why none leaves the conglomerate's system. For several shifts, Ro tries to follow Koa's instructions, restricting his encounters with the workers while privately studying Star Eater grammar. You-Outside asks him for help with procedures, whereas You-In-Front has become more reserved. Ro discovers that the term translated as 'quota' really does originate in an expression about quantity, but his uncertainty about how workers use it persists. After a shift, You-In-Front approaches nervously. She says she should have spent more time accompanying him and asks him to tell the Overseers that they were together whenever they ask. Ro reluctantly agrees to provide this alibi, although he does not know what she fears. When he asks what would happen if they disobeyed the Overseers, her question in response could mean several different things because of the language's ambiguous interrogatives.

At the next Orro rendezvous, the Warren has honored Ro's demand for another contact: Mother Hobi replaces Master Linguist Koa. She congratulates him and says his hive has been told only that he is on special assignment. She agrees to receive his linguistic observations, but confirms that he must also help Orro acquire meridian through illicit channels. Other governments already participate in black-market trade, she argues, and Orro's limited resources make the advantage of a successful jump essential to its survival. She warns that exposure would endanger Ro and his people and that his personal friendships must not compromise his cover. She also suggests a worker whose alibi he supports might return the favor. Ro resists reducing friendship to an exchange and remains troubled by the conflict between the Star Eaters' apparent lack of choice and his duty to Orro.

Key Events

  • Ro continues investigating Star Eater interrogatives and the meaning of quota while limiting overt cultural contact.
  • You-In-Front requests a false alibi that she was with Ro if Overseers ask, without explaining the circumstances.
  • Ro learns that a Star Eater interrogative may admit several interpretations in the same exchange.
  • Mother Hobi appears at Ro's next Orro rendezvous, fulfilling his request to replace Koa.
  • Mother Hobi confirms Orro's illicit meridian strategy and warns that Ro's own safety and relationships must remain subordinate to operational secrecy.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-In-Front
  • You-Outside
  • Mother Hobi

Themes

  • Institutional necessity versus ethical choice
  • Unstable meaning in communication
  • Friendship, concealment and obligation
Back to Top

10. if Sacrifice Lacks Meaning, Does It Need a Different Name

A recorded public discussion describes the poorly documented Dissolution Era, in which Rakyir and Dossania sought control of the Star Eaters and other powers joined a conflict that ultimately subjected the species to collective exploitation. Under Mother Hobi's supervision, Ro settles into mining routines and remedial training. He keeps postponing Orro's request to steal meridian by saying he has not found a functioning abandoned extractor. While exploring an unused section of the collector after work, he senses disturbing vibrations through the ship's framework and follows them into an old medical laboratory.

There, Ro finds You-Behind impaled by laboratory equipment and screaming inside an astral overlay. A Gormi visitor affiliated with the Khord Confederation is present virtually, then vanishes when Ro enters; the physical restraints and invasive instruments remain. Ro laboriously detaches them and escorts You-Behind away, fearing she may die before her regenerative abilities begin closing the wounds. While distressed, You-Behind mistakes Ro for someone she knew before his sudden change. Ro realizes that the Star Eater whose body he took had been close to her and that his jump has deprived her of that person. You-Behind denies the significance of her grief but admits the familiarity she once shared with the previous occupant.

Asked about the experiment, You-Behind says she volunteered and knew what she was agreeing to because outsiders need to study the Star Eaters. Ro sees her consent as compromised by the assumption that the species must accommodate such requests. She refuses his offer to report the abuse and rebukes him for interfering. In anger, Ro returns to the laboratory and destroys some of its equipment. While pulling apart a panel, he senses and uncovers a cache of compact, field-contained meridian hidden inside the wall. The section does not yet establish who placed it there.

Key Events

  • An in-world farcast discusses competing explanations for the historical subjugation of Star Eaters during Dissolution.
  • Ro postpones his assigned meridian theft and grows accustomed to the ship's rhythms.
  • He discovers a Khord-linked visitor overseeing invasive experimentation on You-Behind in an abandoned laboratory.
  • Ro frees You-Behind and learns she grieves the former occupant of the body he has taken.
  • You-Behind says she consented to being studied but rejects Ro's interference; Ro questions the significance of consent under expected submission.
  • After damaging laboratory equipment, Ro discovers field-contained meridian concealed behind a panel.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-Behind
  • Unidentified Gormi researcher

Themes

  • Historical and continuing exploitation
  • Grief, identity and bodily autonomy
  • Responsibility and the limits of consent
Back to Top

11. Relativity of Space, Relativity of Language, Relativity of Mind

A museum plaque describes an artist's attempt to represent the meridian dimension, accessible to Star Eater senses but not directly perceptible to others. In the abandoned laboratory, Ro decides that the concealed meridian must have been stockpiled by Khord, the powerful confederation associated with the researcher he saw torturing You-Behind. He reasons that diverting an illicit cache from a wealthy power to resource-poor Orro would be more justifiable than stealing from the workers. This attribution is Ro's deduction, not a documented account of who assembled the cache.

Ro tries to collect the field-contained meridian spheres but inadvertently scatters them in zero gravity. He activates a magnetic scoop at high power; it attracts the entire stockpile, causing the spheres to collide and their containment fields to merge. The exposed meridian destabilizes. Ro attempts to absorb the release with his Star Eater body, but cannot control it. Space fractures around the collector, and a massive involuntary meridian jump takes the entire damaged ship to an unknown location. The alarms and warped lattice reveal the extent of the accident. Ro fears exposure and wonders what he has done.

As workers are ordered back to their cells, Ro sees Overseers physically restraining You-In-Front. One questions him about whether she was with him during specific off-shifts. Distracted and frightened, Ro fails to provide the alibi she previously asked for. The Overseer says theft and damage must be punished and sends him to his cell. Ro realizes that the investigators suspect You-In-Front rather than the actual cause of the accident: himself. He obeys, unable to correct their apparent conclusion without endangering his disguise and Orro.

Key Events

  • Ro assumes Khord accumulated the hidden meridian and plans to redirect it to Orro; its ownership is not independently established.
  • Ro accidentally combines unstable meridian caches using a magnetic scoop.
  • The released meridian causes an uncontrolled jump that damages and relocates the entire collector ship.
  • Overseers restrain You-In-Front and question Ro about an alibi he had promised to give.
  • Ro gives a damagingly incomplete answer and realizes the Overseers suspect his friend of theft and damage.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-In-Front
  • Overseers

Themes

  • Good intentions and damaging consequences
  • Resource inequity and rationalization
  • Responsibility and institutional punishment
Back to Top

12. Implied, Implicative, Implicated

An excerpt from an informal conversation speculates about Star Eater genetic memory and reproduction, without establishing any causal link. After the uncontrolled meridian jump, the Overseers confine the workers behind force fields in their cells while government representatives monitor the damaged collector through astral orbs. Ro recognizes that his accident has apparently implicated the innocent You-In-Front. He considers confessing but fears that an investigation would expose Orro's secret jump technology and jeopardize millions of people. An urgent report to Mother Hobi cannot transmit until the next scheduled nexus synchronization.

Ro seeks distraction in simulated environments, then opens a shared astral space with You-Outside, who is frightened in the neighboring locked cell. They remain physically separated by the barrier but converse within the augmented scene. You-Outside reports that the collector has been sent far 'off-space' by a large meridian burn and may require a resource tow. She fears she, too, could be suspected because of her recent confusion. Ro admits that he is afraid, and they comfort each other. He creates a lively simulated city when she asks to be somewhere less lonely.

Angered by the threat of punishment against workers who have done nothing wrong, Ro urges You-Outside to leave with him and others rather than submit to Overseers. She cannot understand why anyone would want to leave and repeats that a body will know when it is time to reproduce. Ro despairs of his failure to understand Star Eater choices and the harm caused by his presumptions. At the end of the scene, he sees an image of Mother Hobi in the simulated environment, but the chapter does not yet explain the appearance.

Key Events

  • The Overseers lock the Star Eaters in their cells while the conglomerate's representatives investigate the damaged ship.
  • Ro weighs confessing against the danger that Orro's secret would be discovered.
  • Ro and You-Outside share an astral simulation from adjacent, physically isolated cells and admit their fear.
  • You-Outside says the collector is far off its former location and may need a costly rescue tow.
  • Ro proposes that the workers leave rather than accept undeserved punishment, but You-Outside does not understand his desire.
  • The scene ends when Ro notices Mother Hobi's form inside the shared virtual environment.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • You-Outside
  • Mother Hobi

Themes

  • Guilt and divided responsibility
  • Coercion and individual agency
  • Friendship across linguistic difference
Back to Top

13. Passive Actions, Required Agents

An official Khord curriculum recounts the War of Dissolution, the founding of the conglomerate, the Star Eaters' controlled labor and their later legal emancipation. Its final claim is that the species remains satisfied with its assigned role. Mother Hobi enters Ro's astral pocket and angrily advises him not to take responsibility for the collector's damaging jump, arguing that someone such as You-In-Front may already have been manipulated into meridian theft. While she warns that any exposure could imperil Orro, Ro suddenly connects several problems of Star Eater language. The workers' word for 'quota' expresses a maximal obligation, not necessarily a numeric target. More consequentially, the much-repeated statement translated as 'the body knows when' could instead mean that the body knows how to reproduce. Ro reasons that a Star Eater's inherited bodily memory might guide reproduction in the way You-In-Front helped him learn meridian sensing. Mother Hobi is horrified and immediately disconnects.

The Overseers release the workers from their cells and assemble all shifts before a vast, overlapping virtual representation of the conglomerate. Mother Hobi publicly accuses the Star Eaters of deliberately withholding reproduction and conspiring to destroy other civilizations. An Overseer tightens its coils around the restrained You-In-Front while authorities demand answers. Ro initially fears that her denial proves the traditional view of Star Eater unity is false, then notices her altered word order and borrowed gestures. Her grammar recalls Lower Senti. Coupled with other workers' blurred inflections, loanwords, confused time references and lack of native conversational markers, this leads Ro to a devastating conclusion: these workers are not native Star Eaters at all. They are other civilizations' Linguists who have jumped into and successively displaced Star Eater minds.

Ro reveals that he is Ponto from Orro and identifies You-In-Front as a jumper from Lower Senti. You-Behind acknowledges that she is from the Khord Confederation and that Ro replaced another jumped Khord-connected occupant of his body. Other workers begin disclosing their origins, including Vallamung, Far Naranyu and the Alliance System. A collective question grows over whether any native Star Eater remains. Ro understands the apparent uniformity of Star Eater culture as successive outsiders imitating what earlier outsiders expected. As the enormity of this accumulated destruction becomes clear, he says that their combined actions have killed the Star Eaters and describes it as genocide. The question of a formal census remains prospective in the scene.

Key Events

  • An official Khord curriculum gives a state-sanctioned history of Star Eater enslavement and supposed satisfaction.
  • Mother Hobi insists Ro hide his role in the collector accident and proposes that You-In-Front may have been involved in illicit mining.
  • Ro reinterprets 'quota' as an attitude of maximization and proposes that 'the body knows when' could mean that the body knows how to reproduce.
  • Mother Hobi publicly accuses the Star Eaters of withholding offspring, and an Overseer restrains You-In-Front.
  • Ro recognizes the linguistic signs of nonnative speakers and publicly identifies himself and the workers as jumpers from other worlds.
  • You-Behind identifies herself as Khord-affiliated; additional workers reveal origins in multiple domains, leaving the possible survival of any unoccupied native Star Eater in question.
  • Ro recognizes the collective overwriting of Star Eater identity and culture as genocide.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • Mother Hobi
  • You-In-Front
  • You-Behind
  • Conglomerate representatives
  • Other jumped Linguists

Themes

  • Linguistic misunderstanding and historical erasure
  • Collective institutional responsibility
  • Exploitation concealed as cultural consensus
Back to Top

14. Reverse, Repair, Redeem

A historical commentator's crude dismissal of Star Eater rights illustrates the false assumptions that sustained the conglomerate's account of the species. After the revelation, Ro and the other jumped Linguists remain on the now-docked collector while scholars and mediators arrive and governments dispute responsibility. You-In-Front tells Ro she misses the immense forests of her homeworld. They discuss whether the jump could be reversed, but investigators have ruled out returning the original Star Eater minds, and the jumpers may be trapped for the host bodies' extraordinarily long lifetimes. Ro learns that Star Eater neurology appears to have made mind jumping possible, undermining the Warren's belief that the Ponto empathic sense alone explained its supposed special power. How the different governments first acquired the method remains uncertain.

The original species' reproductive knowledge cannot simply be recovered by asking the present workers, because no remaining native mind can teach the others the genetic-memory process. The long-lived bodies will eventually die without reproduction, potentially destroying the interstellar infrastructure that relies on meridian mining. Ro and his companion mourn the loss of the Star Eaters' bodies, minds, culture and language. They also recognize that continuing to mine may save lives but might perpetuate the coercion that made the catastrophe possible. Different jumpers could now choose differently, with consequences no one can predict. When You-In-Front asks Ro's name, she identifies herself as Jəʊ'hann, from Lower Senti, and uses a masculine gender marker. Asked whether he is male, Jəʊ'hann answers that he no longer knows what they are.

Key Events

  • The collector is docked while outside scholars and mediators assess the revelation and governments argue over culpability.
  • The possibility of restoring the native Star Eater minds is rejected; the jumpers may remain in borrowed bodies for centuries or millennia.
  • The jump mechanism appears to depend on Star Eater neurology, and the political history of how other governments gained the technique remains unclear.
  • The species' lost genetic memory of reproduction implies eventual bodily extinction and threatens interstellar civilization.
  • Ro and You-In-Front debate future obligations and the possibility of choosing different lives.
  • You-In-Front reveals the name Jəʊ'hann, associated with a masculine marker in Lower Senti.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • Jəʊ'hann (formerly called You-In-Front)

Themes

  • Irreversible cultural destruction
  • Agency after collective wrongdoing
  • Displaced identity and grief
Back to Top

15. Causative Case, Involitive Grief, Plural Guilt

Three post-revelation commentaries disagree over who bears responsibility for the destruction of the Star Eaters and the approaching collapse of interstellar civilization. Ro leaves the mining fleet, as do nearly half the other workers, who are actually displaced Linguists. Some return toward their original homeworlds; others depart without explaining their plans. After the secret becomes public, the conglomerate's governments argue while the reduced mining workforce accelerates the galaxy's resource crisis. Ro receives messages from his hive, including Lalo and his litter-sisters, urging him to remain and maintain the meridian supply. Orro's millions may have to become refugees as imported essentials run out, but Ro no longer believes continuing to mine can undo the destruction.

Jəʊ'hann accompanies Ro, along with a few Linguists from other worlds whom he had not previously known on the collector. You-Outside hopes to return home to an aquatic world, although Ro does not know whether this is physically possible. He has not seen You-Behind since the public disclosure and cannot establish her fate. Ro's new purpose is to recover the original Star Eaters' language, culture and identity through surviving documents. He believes that even an incomplete record would acknowledge the beings whose minds and society were erased. His companions begin expressing features of their original cultures through clothing and personal adornment despite their borrowed Star Eater bodies. When Jəʊ'hann asks where to begin, Ro says they must find all surviving records and listen to what those records can tell them.

Key Events

  • After public disclosure, nearly half the jumped miners leave the fleet, sharply worsening the meridian supply crisis.
  • Ro's family urges him to continue mining because Orro faces loss of imported essentials and possible mass displacement.
  • Ro leaves anyway, convinced that remaining cannot repair the collective destruction.
  • Jəʊ'hann and several other Linguists accompany him; You-Outside's return home remains uncertain and You-Behind's fate is unknown.
  • Ro and his group commit to recovering the historical language, culture and identity of the original Star Eaters from surviving records.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • Jəʊ'hann
  • Other displaced Linguists

Themes

  • Collective culpability and social consequences
  • Limits of restitution
  • Recovery of erased histories
Back to Top

16. Epilogue: the Stories We Tell. the Stories We Steal.

Five annual commemorations after the revelation, Ro and his research companions prepare another release of their limited findings about the original Star Eaters. Their work, presented in a collective research series titled On Those We Called the Star Eaters, is based on historical sources, but Ro acknowledges that the researchers cannot avoid interpretation or recover a complete account. They live in an orbital research station supported by activists near a sparse nebula suitable for their Star Eater bodies. Only five members of their original group remain. Some have returned to mining, while others have left for different purposes. Across the galaxy, meridian shortages have begun affecting remote regions and governments have imposed numerous austerity measures. Ro recognizes that their station may eventually lose support and that their historical work may never restore what was lost.

Jəʊ'hann, now experimenting with poetry and new sensory experiences, grieves the inadequacy of the records and the lost possibility of physically embracing others in their altered bodies. Their research suggests the replacement of native Star Eater minds began long before legal emancipation and continued until even the beings' authentic culture had become obscured. Ro notices gaps in fragmentary population records that could indicate some original Star Eaters disappeared before extinction. Jəʊ'hann imagines that survivors deliberately fled with children into remote nebulae and concealed their location. Ro wants the story to be true but explicitly recognizes that missing entries could simply reflect lost records. Neither escape nor surviving native Star Eaters is established.

They consider the approaching civilian deaths and the risk that any reconstruction of an extinct people's beliefs could repeat the outsiders' original mistake of speaking for them. Jəʊ'hann asks what hope remains when even surviving fragments cannot restore the people themselves. Ro answers that their effort may achieve only a smaller lie, an acknowledgement that the research remains incomplete and vulnerable to the researchers' own assumptions.

Key Events

  • The Epilogue is set at the fifth anniversary of the revelation, when Ro's group releases another source-based but incomplete research report.
  • Five of the original researchers remain at a station near a sparse nebula as galactic meridian shortages and austerity measures expand.
  • Ro and Jəʊ'hann acknowledge the irrecoverability of native Star Eater culture and their own difficulty forming physical bonds in borrowed bodies.
  • Fragmentary population records may suggest missing individuals, but they do not establish a successful Star Eater escape or surviving native descendants.
  • Jəʊ'hann imagines survivors hiding in distant nebulae; Ro explicitly distinguishes that attractive possibility from evidence.
  • Ro accepts that even a conscientious reconstruction may represent only a smaller lie rather than full historical truth.

Characters Appearing

  • Ro
  • Jəʊ'hann
  • Remaining research companions

Themes

  • Limits of historical knowledge
  • Responsible representation of other peoples
  • Unresolved loss and ethical scholarship
Back to Top