The Night We Lost Him

Liam Samuel Noone stands at the edge of a cliff in Carpinteria, California, a place he chose to buy land as far away from his hometown as possible. This secluded beachside town was meant to be his new beginning, a sanctuary from his past. During a business trip to meet a potential investor, Liam stumbles upon Windbreak, a charming cliffside cottage owned by an elderly woman who initially refuses to sell. Despite her reluctance, she allows him inside, and years later, Liam reflects on this pivotal moment, feeling a mix of nostalgia and a sense of penance for his past choices. Despite his wealth and success, he feels emotionally and physically drained, questioning how he ended up alone. The chapter culminates in a dramatic turn as Liam is pushed over the edge of the cliff, his last thought a protective one for his children, indicating a deep-seated desire to shield them from harm.

Nora, a neuroarchitect, is evaluating a five-story brownstone in Brooklyn for her client, Morgan, who seems uninterested and distracted by her phone. When Sam, Nora's estranged brother, arrives unexpectedly, Nora is shocked. She hasn't seen or spoken to him much since their childhood, especially after their father's death. Sam reveals that he has been trying to contact Nora for months, but she has been avoiding him and their father's legacy, including his company and any financial inheritance. Sam also mentions that their father's death was not an accident, adding a layer of tension to their reunion.

Still reeling from the shock of seeing Sam at the brownstone, Nora reflects on the last time they met, at Uncle Joe’s birthday dinner five years ago. Joe, their father’s cousin, was more like a brother to him, and the two were inseparable. At the dinner, Sam, who was working for their father, seemed uncomfortable and distracted, often glancing at Tommy, who was on a work call. Nora, who had recently opened her own architecture firm, was discussing a new project with Grace, one of their father’s trusted advisors, when Sam interjected, questioning her business decisions and financial success.

After the dinner, Sam visits Nora to discuss their father’s death, which he believes was not an accident. He presents a blue folder containing the most recent copy of their father’s will, revealing that their father had changed it shortly before his death. Sam suspects foul play and suggests that their father’s behavior had been unusual in the weeks leading up to his death. He also mentions that their father discussed the company’s future with him and Tommy just eight days before he died, leaving them in charge of Noone Properties.

Sam asks Nora to accompany him to Windbreak, their father’s cottage in California, to investigate further. Initially dismissive, Nora’s resolve wavers when Sam reveals that their father left Windbreak to her in his will. The revelation brings back memories of her last conversation with her father, who had invited her to visit Windbreak but was rebuffed due to her work commitments. Sam’s vulnerability and the unexpected inheritance compel Nora to consider joining him on the trip.

Nora boards the subway, clutching the blue folder filled with documents related to her father's death. Her mind wanders through the complexities of his life, from his multiple marriages to his efforts to compartmentalize his various roles. The obituary and will serve as stark reminders of his rags-to-riches journey and his secretive nature, fueling her growing curiosity about the circumstances surrounding his death.

Upon returning home, Nora finds herself drawn to her favorite local restaurant, Sheet Music, where her fiancé, Jack, works as the chef. She watches him prepare his signature strawberry pizza, a dish that has made the restaurant famous. When she mentions Sam's visit and his suspicions about their father's death, Jack notices her distress. Despite his reservations, he offers to accompany her to Windbreak, sensing her need to investigate further.

Later, unable to sleep, Nora returns to the blue folder. A text from Elliot, her ex-boyfriend and the father of her godson, Austin, adds to her unease. A late-night call from an unknown number turns out to be Sam, who insists on her help to uncover the truth about their father's death. Torn by a mix of guilt and a deep-seated instinct, Nora agrees to join Sam in California.

Nora boards the plane for California, leaving Sam behind. He arrives breathless and sweating just in time, revealing he is going through a breakup but remains evasive about the details. Initially irritated, Nora decides to focus on the investigation into their father's death.

Upon landing at Windbreak, they are greeted by Clark, the caretaker, and Detective O’Brien, who leads them through the property, recounting the circumstances of their father’s fall. Nora and Sam find the detective’s account unconvincing, particularly his claim that their father was alone and the absence of security cameras. They press for more details, questioning the reliability of the pedestrian witnesses and the disappearance of the jogger who was present at the scene. Detective O’Brien grows increasingly defensive, insisting that their father’s death was a straightforward accident. However, Nora and Sam remain unconvinced, sensing foul play and unresolved questions surrounding the night of the fall.

Following Detective O’Brien’s departure, Sam and Nora resolve to investigate their father’s death more thoroughly. Sam heads to their father’s office to search for clues, while Nora wanders through the house, her emotions stirred by the familiar surroundings. In the living room, now a makeshift library, Nora pores over photographs and playbills, piecing together her father’s life and the people who shaped it. Memories of her parents’ complex relationship flood back—from their initial romance to the bitter separation and her father’s subsequent marriages. Nora reflects on the strained dynamics within her father’s family, especially the cold demeanor of Sylvia, his second wife, and how he compartmentalized his different lives. These reflections fuel Nora’s determination to uncover the truth about her father’s death and to understand the man he truly was.

Fifty-one years ago, Liam meets Cory for the first time when she emerges from his bedroom. She is strikingly beautiful and familiar to him, despite having never seen her before. Joe, his cousin who recently moved in, introduces them, and Liam is immediately captivated by Cory’s presence and her sharp wit.

As they talk, Liam learns that Cory transferred from Immaculate Heart to Midwood High School. She shares that her father struggles with alcoholism and that her mother is a literature professor. Liam, known for his intense focus and drive, is surprised to hear that Cory has noticed him at the library, where he often studies. The conversation shifts to their futures, with Cory mentioning her involvement in the school’s literary magazine and Liam confirming his plans to attend Yale.

Liam’s feelings for Cory become evident as he tries to keep her from leaving. Despite his usual composure, he stumbles over his words, revealing his desperation to spend more time with her. Cory, intrigued, agrees to stay a bit longer, hinting at the possibility of a deeper connection.

Deeply engrossed in a photograph of her parents, Nora jumps when Clark, the caretaker, enters the room. She is visibly on edge, and Clark empathizes, sharing that he too has been feeling anxious, especially since he was not present when their father arrived at Windbreak. He speculates that their father might have avoided notifying him because he was away with his grandchildren, but Nora wonders if there could be another reason, such as someone else being with their father that night.

Sam bursts into the room, holding a large manila envelope and insisting that they need to leave immediately. Nora is taken aback by Sam’s urgency and asks about the contents of the envelope. Sam, however, is already heading towards the front door, mentioning a name that piques Nora’s interest: Cece Salinger, a hotel magnate. Without providing further explanation, Sam declares that they need to go to Uncle Joe’s place.

Agitated and urgent, Sam explains the connection between their father and Cece Salinger, a powerful hotel magnate, as Nora drives. Sam reveals that Cece had been interested in acquiring Noone Properties for years and had even offered Sam a job at PNG, which their father strongly discouraged. This leads to a discussion about their father’s reluctance to sell the company, despite Cece’s generous offers, and the discovery of recent acquisition plans in the manila envelope.

Upon arriving at Uncle Joe’s house in Hope Ranch, they find it bustling with preparations for a cousin’s engagement party. Sam confronts Joe about the potential sale of Noone Properties, which Joe downplays, insisting it never progressed. Sam remains skeptical, pushing for more information about their father’s behavior in the months leading up to his death. Joe appears reluctant to share more, suggesting that their father’s decisions were ultimately meant to ensure the family’s well-being.

The tension escalates as Sam accuses Joe of hiding the truth, and Joe, visibly upset, ends the conversation abruptly. Nora, noticing Joe’s hesitation and sadness, presses him further, hinting at a deeper, unresolved issue between their father and Cece. Joe’s response, while vague, implies that there was indeed more to the story, leaving Nora and Sam with more questions than answers.

Fifty years ago, Liam and Cory are in Cory’s bedroom on the night before Liam is set to leave for college. They lie on the floor, intimate and close, with Cory’s mother teaching a night class and her father out with friends, giving them a few hours alone. Liam expresses his reluctance to be apart, but Cory is pragmatic and concerned about the changes that college will bring, particularly the influence of Liam’s new environment and friends. Their conversation is heartfelt but tense, reflecting the fear of what the future holds for their relationship.

Driving away from Hope Ranch, Sam and Nora head toward Los Angeles, their minds still reeling from Uncle Joe’s evasive responses about their father’s death. Sam is convinced that Joe’s defensive reaction was not just due to the pressure but because he might have a stake in the matter. Nora, while skeptical, acknowledges that Joe did seem to be guarding some information, but she warns against jumping to extreme conclusions, suggesting simpler explanations for Joe’s behavior.

The conversation shifts to Cece Salinger, the hotel magnate, and rumors of a past relationship between her and Uncle Joe. Sam reveals that Cece’s company, Salinger Group, is headquartered in Los Angeles, and he believes it’s worth investigating further. Nora, though hesitant, agrees to a detour to Santa Ynez to meet Cece, who is willing to talk to them. This decision means delaying their return flight, but Nora is driven by the need to uncover the truth about their father’s death.

During the drive, Jack calls to check in, and Nora feels a mix of comfort and unease at the prospect of returning home. Sam’s phone then buzzes with a message from his office, confirming Cece’s availability in Santa Ynez. Despite the added travel time, they decide to proceed with the meeting, hoping it will provide crucial insights.

Nora and Sam continue their journey north through the Santa Ynez Valley, reminiscing about a past trip Nora took with Jack. Their destination is Cece Salinger’s private ranch, but upon arrival, they learn that Cece has canceled their meeting due to a family emergency. Undeterred, Sam convinces the guard to let them wait on the property, but they ultimately decide to seek Cece in downtown Los Alamos instead.

In downtown Los Alamos, they search for Cece, eventually finding her at Bell’s Restaurant. Despite her initial reluctance, Cece agrees to speak with them. She reveals that she and their father were close, and that she was interested in acquiring Noone Properties. However, the sale fell through, and she suspects their father’s decision was influenced by a conversation with Uncle Joe.

Cece shares that she received two calls from their father the night he died, indicating that he wanted to reach out to her. This new information deepens the mystery surrounding their father’s death and suggests that more was at play than previously thought.

Snow falls softly on Avenue J as Liam encounters Cory, his former girlfriend, during his first Christmas back home after two years. Despite the time apart, the moment feels as immediate as ever, with Liam's world narrowing to just her presence. Cory, wrapped in a scarf and carrying wine bottles, looks as beautiful and sure of herself as she did at their high school graduation, which Liam had deliberately avoided to protect both of them from the intensity of their past relationship.

Their conversation is strained, with Cory revealing that she attends Brooklyn College instead of Wellesley, a decision that Liam tries to accept without judgment. The awkwardness of their reunion is palpable, with Cory forcing smiles and Liam struggling to maintain composure. Despite the tension, Liam extends a weak invitation for Cory to join him at the Christmas party, suggesting they could sneak to the roof and drink hot toddies. However, Cory declines, turning to leave, and Liam, torn by the urge to hold onto her and the need to let her go, almost lets her depart.

At the last moment, Cory hesitates and suggests she might be open to another offer. Liam, feeling immense relief, takes her paper bag and places his hand on her back, guiding her away from the wine store. The chapter ends with a sense of unresolved tension and the promise of a new beginning, as Liam and Cory step into the cold night air, ready to explore whatever comes next.

Sam and Nora walk back to the car, the night sky starlit and the main street nearly deserted. Sam is visibly upset, insisting that Cece has an agenda and is hiding something crucial. Nora, while agreeing that Cece was evasive, notes a genuine concern on Cece’s face when they mentioned their father’s death, suggesting a deeper emotional connection.

Nora’s thoughts turn to the possibility of their father’s self-harm, a notion she reluctantly brings up to Sam. Sam dismisses the idea, but Nora’s architect’s mind compels her to consider all the pieces: the canceled sale, Uncle Joe’s defiance, and the strange calls to Cece. Despite the mounting evidence, both Nora and Sam agree that their father’s nature, his determination, and his love for his children make it highly unlikely that he would harm himself.

This realization leads Nora to a more troubling conclusion: her father was facing something he couldn’t solve, something that pushed him to drastic actions. The chapter ends with Nora and Sam both acknowledging the gravity of the situation and the need to uncover the truth behind their father’s death.

Nora and Sam decide to stay at The Ranch, a property developed by their father, instead of returning to Windbreak or Uncle Joe’s. The hotel, known for its luxury and privacy, evokes memories of Nora’s past visits with her parents and during her father’s wedding to Sylvia. Despite the electricity being out, the room is cozy and welcoming, with a fireplace and candles lit. While settling in, Sam orders their favorite childhood sandwiches, reminiscent of those their father used to make. This gesture brings a moment of comfort and nostalgia. As they eat, they discuss their father’s relationships and the possibility of revisiting Uncle Joe. Nora reflects on her father’s close friendship with Joe and the role of their father’s advisor, who is now deceased.

The conversation shifts to Sam’s personal life, including his engagement to Morgan and a past relationship with Taylor. Nora shares her own engagement to Jack and the recent calls from her ex, Elliot. Sam admits to feeling overwhelmed and reaches out to Nora for support, marking a shift in their relationship. After the meal, Nora takes a walk around the property, reflecting on her father’s legacy and the loss of her axis of stability.

In the reception area, Nora meets Carmen, a longtime employee who shares stories about her father’s kindness and decency. Carmen’s anecdotes about her father’s generosity and hands-on approach provide a new perspective. Nora’s discovery that their father’s phone was not found at the scene of his fall prompts her to wake Sam, suggesting that their father might have been compelled to sell the company, hinting at a deeper conspiracy.

Nora and Sam, still reeling from the events at The Ranch, find themselves flying over Colorado. Determined to uncover more about their father’s death, they spread out his will and the police report on their tray tables. Sam powers up his laptop to access shared files from the company, explaining that their father’s commitments were mostly documented on the company’s network, but his desktop might hold a more complete inventory. They discuss the possibility of finding a backup to their father’s missing phone, leading them to consider who might have access to his personal laptop and phone data.

In a flashback to forty-three years ago, Liam and Cory are wandering through the Strand Bookstore. Cory, absorbed in the new arrivals, is determined to avoid discussing their future. Liam, deeply affected by their growing distance, suggests they could be together in New York, where she could attend a writing program. However, Cory counters that the University of Southern California is offering her a full ride and a more focused writing program, which she sees as a better opportunity. She dismisses Liam’s suggestion of marriage, laughing at the idea and arguing that marriage didn’t save her parents and wouldn’t save them. Emphasizing the importance of their current dynamic, she describes it as a deep, mutual understanding and connection that doesn’t require formal commitment. Frustrated, Liam reveals that he has a ring in his pocket, hoping to convince her otherwise. Cory’s response is both affectionate and firm. She tells Liam that she doesn’t need a ring and that he would be a terrible husband, but she also expresses her deep love and understanding of him. She suggests that if he asks again when the right answer is yes, she will consider it. Liam, still hopeful, kisses her neck, but Cory’s final words make it clear that she is not ready for marriage, and she advises him to throw the ring away if he can’t wait.

Nora receives a call from Meredith Cooper, the EMT who found their father on the beach, while en route to JFK. Despite a poor connection, Meredith confirms that the jogger seen near the scene was tall, Caucasian, and unfamiliar to the community, suggesting he was not a regular. She also notes that she did not see their father’s cell phone on him, adding to the mystery of the missing device.

At the Noone Properties headquarters, Nora and Sam search through their father’s office, finding no paper trail or internal memos related to Cece or the potential sale. Nate, the IT guy, informs them that their father’s phone last pinged a cell tower in Santa Barbara, raising questions about its location and accessibility. Nate also reveals that their father’s laptop and phone were not backed up to the company’s cloud, and that file sharing was disabled for several key computers, including those belonging to Joe and Grace.

Sam and Nora speculate that the missing devices and disabled backups were intentional, possibly to keep certain information private. They consider the possibility that the computers of Joe and Grace might have access to their father’s files. Nate provides contact information for Terry, Grace’s former assistant, who lives in Burlington, Vermont, potentially offering a lead on the missing laptop.

Still reeling from their meeting with Paul Turner, Nora and Sam decide to follow up with Terry, Grace’s former assistant. Terry confirms that all of Grace’s belongings, including her devices, were sent to her and her husband’s apartment in Brooklyn. Determined to find more answers, Nora and Sam head to Brooklyn Heights, where they meet Paul Turner, Grace’s husband, at his apartment. The apartment, once his work studio, is filled with photography equipment and beautiful prints, and Paul is recognizable as a well-known editorial photographer.

Paul is initially resistant to their request to see Grace’s laptop, citing his daughter’s visit and her pregnancy as reasons to keep the meeting brief. Nora and Sam explain their concerns about their father’s missing phone and the potential value of the information on Grace’s laptop. Paul softens when Nora mentions her admiration for Grace and her belief that Grace might have known what was happening with their father.

Paul confirms that Grace mentioned Cece Salinger’s interest in buying the company but insists that their father was not interested. He also reveals that Joe asked for most of Grace’s work files shortly after they were sent to him, which he shipped out. Paul adds that Grace cared about their father and thought he was a good man, but also warned him not to trust his children. The chapter ends with Paul holding the door open, signaling the end of the conversation.

Exiting the elevator, Nora and Sam head back to the lobby after their tense meeting with Paul Turner. Sam, agitated, paces while trying to reach Tommy on his phone, his frustration mounting with each unanswered call. Nora watches him, reflecting on Paul’s eagerness to dismiss them, sensing there is more he isn’t revealing.

Sam’s agitation peaks as he leaves a voicemail for Tommy, his voice laced with accusation. ‘I know you’re up to something,’ he says, his words sharp. Nora tries to soothe him, but Sam insists they need to confront Tommy in person, despite the three-hour drive to North of Hudson. Nora hesitates, torn between her work commitments and her relationship with Jack, but Sam’s urgency and the gravity of the situation push her to agree.

Stepping outside, the cool evening air brings a moment of clarity. Nora and Sam share a look of mutual understanding. ‘I was wrong about you,’ Nora admits, her voice soft. Sam nods, appreciating her support. Nora’s mind races with the complexity of their father’s actions and the potential connections to his death. Despite her reservations, she commits to the trip, setting a meeting time for the next morning.

Nora returns to her dark and empty home in Ditmas Park, where Jack is still at the restaurant. Instead of going inside, she sits on the front steps, lost in memories of a late-night visit from her father a year ago, shortly after her mother’s death. They had shared a strawberry sofrito pie and champagne, and her father’s interest in her work seemed deeper than usual, though he appeared to be withholding something.

Nora calls Elliot, who is with Austin, to ask about his last conversation with her father, which took place two weeks before his death. Elliot recalls that her father inquired about Austin and briefly discussed hospital matters but did not mention anything troubling. Nora then asks Elliot about a hospital pathologist who could help determine if someone fell or was pushed, which Elliot finds concerning.

Jack surprises Nora by returning home early, and she abruptly ends her call with Elliot. Jack sits with her, and they share a tender moment, but Nora’s thoughts remain preoccupied with her father’s death and her growing belief that he may have been hiding something. She confides in Jack that she thinks Sam might be right about their father’s death being suspicious, and she expresses regret over her strained relationship with her father at the end.

The chapter ends with a tense moment as Nora distances herself from Jack’s affection, and Jack withdraws, sensing her emotional turmoil. Nora’s phone buzzes again with a call from Elliot, but she pushes it away, further straining their connection.

Nora and Sam drive through the upper Hudson Valley, the rolling farmland a stark contrast to the city they left behind. Nora continues to make calls and send emails to forensic pathologists, seeking an impartial review of their father’s death. She reflects on Paul’s intense reaction to Cece and wonders if this is connected to Uncle Joe’s reluctance to talk about her. Sam and Nora agree that this should be their first question when they meet Tommy.

They arrive at The Acres, a sprawling property being developed by Noone Properties, where Tommy is staying in the Ridge House. The property is a stunning family compound, reminiscent of a project Nora worked on in Woodstock. Nora is touched by the memory of her father’s pride in her work, which she never expressed to him. Sam and Nora walk to the Ridge House, where they are greeted by Tommy’s pregnant wife, Kira, who is notably unfriendly and dismissive. Kira’s comments about Nora’s age and fertility create tension, and she reveals that she and Tommy are trying to finish work on the natural playground. Sam and Nora leave to find Tommy, with Kira’s sarcastic warning about getting lost lingering in the air.

Nora and Sam find Tommy bouncing on an in-ground trampoline, overseeing the construction of the natural playground despite the cold. His greeting is a mix of surprise and sarcasm, but the atmosphere turns serious when Sam confronts him about his conversations with Paul Turner regarding Cece Salinger. Inside the Airstream, the tension between Sam and Tommy is palpable as they argue about the potential sale of Noone Properties to Cece. Tommy reveals he overheard and confirmed the sale with Cece’s in-house contacts, leading to a heated exchange about their roles in the company and their responsibilities. Nora intervenes, redirecting the conversation to their father’s mysterious death and the involvement of Cece and Uncle Joe. Tommy shows them a Forbes magazine article featuring Cece Salinger, which includes a vague reference to an 'old friend.' Nora and Sam connect this to Paul Turner, the photographer of the profile, and realize that Paul’s reluctance to share information might be linked to Uncle Joe. Tommy confirms that Paul suggested any past relationship between Cece and their father was long over, but his silence on Uncle Joe’s involvement raises more questions.

Thirty-nine years ago, Cory and Liam sit in a sandwich shop near Liam’s office in Midtown, sharing a slice of coconut cream pie. Cory, who has moved back to Brooklyn to care for her sick mother and unemployed father, discusses her dissatisfaction with the situation. She had been thriving in her graduate school writing program, enjoying the intellectual environment and her shared apartment in an old firehouse. Now, she must interview for a marketing job to financially support her parents, a reality that pains her deeply.

Liam, seeing Cory’s unhappiness, offers to help with her parents’ situation, but Cory has already rejected his offers. The conversation shifts to Liam’s upcoming wedding to Rachel, whom Cory likes but acknowledges is a good match for Liam. Liam, feeling the strain of Cory’s return under such difficult circumstances, suggests calling off the wedding. Cory dismisses the idea, emphasizing that Liam and Rachel are well-suited. The chapter captures the complex emotions and unresolved tensions between them, as they both struggle with the changes in their lives and the distance that has grown between them.

Despite the challenges, Liam and Cory acknowledge their deep connection and the difficulty of being apart. Cory, while grateful for Liam’s support, is clear that she needs to find her own solutions. The chapter ends with a poignant moment as Cory asks for more pie, a small gesture that temporarily eases the tension between them.

Sam and Nora hike back to their car after their conversation with Tommy, still discussing the potential involvement of Uncle Joe and Cece Salinger in their father’s death. Sam reveals that Cece and Joe finalized their divorce eight months ago, aligning with the timeline of their father’s unusual behavior. He suggests that Joe might have betrayed their father by keeping his relationship with Cece a secret and convincing him to sell the company. Nora remains skeptical, questioning why Cece would volunteer information about the calls if she were trying to hide something.

Feeling the need to show Nora something important, Sam drives them to Kingston, New York, to a farm called Fitzgerald-Grove Stone Fruit. This was the original site for The Acres project, and it was here that he met Taylor, his ex-girlfriend. Sam recounts their history, from meeting at Hotchkiss where he coached baseball and taught a class, to reconnecting years later when he was trying to secure the farm for the project. Despite the farm owners declining the offer, Sam and Taylor became close, and he decides to show Nora the property, including a lake, which he describes as more of a pond.

Sam then takes Nora to Taylor’s law office in downtown Kingston, where they wait for her to finish a court session. While waiting, Sam buys doughnuts and mango tea. When Taylor arrives, she is visibly moved by the gesture. Sam and Taylor share a warm, albeit bittersweet, reunion. Taylor thanks Sam for the doughnuts and mentions her difficult case, and Sam almost reveals his suspicions about their father’s death but holds back. Taylor’s interaction with Sam reveals a deep emotional connection, and she subtly warns Nora to be careful with him, adding a layer of complexity to their relationship.

After their visit to Taylor, Sam and Nora head to Rough Draft Bar & Books. Sam orders two IPAs, his emotions visibly raw. Nora, sensing his distress, gently probes his feelings about Taylor, who recently married an orthodontist named Sherman. Sam’s pain is palpable as he admits his efforts to win her back were futile.

As they continue their drive, Nora reflects on the timing of Sam’s heartbreak and the recent loss of their father. She suggests that Sam’s decisions, including his engagement to Morgan and his commitment to the family business, might be influenced by fear and grief. Sam listens, considering her words, and shares a poignant memory of their father’s advice about fixing mistakes, which resonates deeply with both of them.

The conversation shifts to the nature of certainty and proof. Sam explains how playing baseball provided a sense of clarity and purpose that he has been seeking since his injury. Nora suggests that Sam’s pursuit of certainty in his relationship with Taylor and his career might be a way to prove to himself that he matters. This realization leaves Sam with a profound sense of sadness and introspection.

Two days after Liam and Rachel encountered Cory with her new boyfriend in front of Liam’s office building, Liam and Cory meet for lunch in Central Park. Cory had taken her boyfriend to see Neil Simon’s new play, Lost in Yonkers, and the boyfriend’s critical opinion of the play is a source of tension for Liam, who struggles to focus on anything but the boyfriend’s hand on Cory’s waist.

During their lunch, Liam probes Cory about her new relationship, particularly whether marriage is on the horizon. Cory clarifies that she never said she didn’t believe in marriage, but rather that it wasn’t what saved their relationship. She emphasizes that what truly matters is showing up for each other. Liam insists that he has always shown up, and Cory acknowledges this, but she suggests that they need to find a new shape to their relationship, one that is fair to her new boyfriend and to herself.

Cory reveals that she has been honest with her boyfriend about her past with Liam, and she believes it’s important for them to redefine their dynamic. Liam, despite his pain, agrees to support Cory’s happiness, promising to meet her wherever she needs him to be. The chapter ends with a poignant moment as Cory touches Liam’s face, urging him not to start lying now.

Nora returns home late at night, the bedroom light still on. She quickly scans her emails and reschedules meetings, hoping to avoid a confrontation with Jack. When she finally enters the bedroom, the light is off, and Jack lies on his side, facing away from her. Nora can sense his tension, as if he is waiting for her to make the first move. The silence between them is palpable, a chasm of unspoken words and unresolved feelings. Later, Nora drifts into a dream where her father appears in a surreal and comforting form, offering a fleeting moment of solace.

Still reeling from the tension of the previous night, Nora finds Jack in the kitchen the next morning. Both of them feel the weight of the unresolved issues hanging between them. Jack, with wet hair and no shirt, serves her coffee and cinnamon toast, leaning towards her but maintaining a distance. He asks about her plans for the day, particularly about Austin’s recital, which she had promised to attend. Nora’s defensiveness about Elliot and the recital leads to a deeper conversation about their relationship.

Jack reveals that he has decided to help Becker, his friend from culinary school, take over her Michelin-starred restaurant in northern California while she is on maternity leave. This decision means he will be away for an extended period, a choice he frames as giving Nora the space she needs. Nora is devastated by the news, feeling that Jack is pulling away and that their relationship is at a breaking point. Jack insists that his decision is not about Elliot but about the overwhelming losses they have both experienced, including the deaths of Nora’s parents.

The conversation becomes more emotional as Jack asks Nora what she wants, offering to give it to her honestly. Nora’s response is a desire for time, both to heal and to reclaim moments she has lost. Jack, however, feels that he cannot continue the relationship if he cannot connect with her on a deeper level. He promises to give her space, hoping it will help her pivot or start fresh, but Nora is torn, desperately not wanting him to go but acknowledging the distance between them.

Nora sits alone in the house, surrounded by photographs of her and Jack, her mind swirling with thoughts of their strained relationship. Her phone buzzes, breaking the silence; it’s a call from Dr. Susan Clifton, a forensic pathologist who has reviewed the files Nora sent regarding her father’s death. Dr. Clifton’s voice is measured as she explains that while many aspects of the fall remain ambiguous, certain details, such as a large contusion on her father’s cheek and the velocity of the fall, suggest the possibility of foul play.

Dr. Clifton advises Nora to revisit the scene of the fall, suggesting that new details often emerge with repeated visits. Feeling a surge of determination, Nora calls Sam but reaches Morgan instead, who informs her that Sam wants to move up the wedding. Distracted by the new information from Dr. Clifton, Nora struggles to focus on Morgan’s demands. Later, she emails Jonathan, Noone’s general counsel, inquiring about taking possession of Windbreak and probing for more information about the property’s history.

Jonathan’s response is evasive, and he suggests that Nora can take possession of Windbreak whenever she is ready. When she presses him about any changes to her father’s intentions regarding Windbreak, Jonathan remains tight-lipped. Nora realizes that her father’s loyalty and the depth of his relationships may hold the key to unraveling the mystery of his death. At Austin’s recital, she runs into Elliot, who reinforces her father’s desire to take care of her.

Liam and Cory stand in the empty living room of Windbreak, the house Liam purchased over a year ago. Liam suggests that the house is a way for Cory to reclaim what she lost, referring to her past in California. Initially dismissive, Cory laughs at Liam’s suggestion that they could grow old there together. However, her demeanor shifts when Liam reveals he has already ordered custom-made white bookshelves, identical to those in her graduate school apartment. Cory’s reaction is a mix of joy and sadness; she moves into Liam’s arms, her tears mingling with laughter. Liam, too, is emotional, cherishing the moment but aware of the underlying tension and the uncertainty of their future together. His attempt to lighten the mood by joking about sleeping on the floor fails to mask the deep-seated sadness. The chapter captures the complexity of their relationship, the deep connection they share, and the reality of their separate lives, with Liam’s commitment to his daughter, Nora, and Cory’s marriage.

Following the recital, Nora interacts with Austin, who instinctively looks for his father, leading to a poignant moment where Nora reassures him. She then meets Elliot, who offers her coffee, but Nora declines, realizing she needs to stop reaching away from Jack. Nora and Elliot sit on a ledge, discussing their shared sadness and the incomplete goodbyes they have experienced. Nora brings up her father’s last conversation with Elliot, questioning what they discussed. Elliot reveals that her father understood Nora’s need for space and valued her loyalty to her mother, but he blames himself for their strained relationship. Elliot’s revelations add a layer of complexity to Nora’s understanding of her father’s death and her own actions. The chapter ends with Nora feeling a renewed sense of purpose to reconcile with Jack and fully address the mysteries surrounding her father’s death.

Liam and Cory meet at a small restaurant near Rockefeller Center, where the festive atmosphere of the ice-skating rink and the illuminated Christmas tree contrasts sharply with their tense conversation. Cory, unimpressed by Sylvia, Liam’s new acquaintance from his morning show, criticizes her behavior and Liam’s growing involvement with her. Liam tries to defend himself, but Cory is relentless, pointing out that their relationship has always been defined by their refusal to commit to each other in a traditional sense.

The conversation turns heated as Cory accuses Liam of being blind to Sylvia’s intentions and warns him that he will end up on the ‘dark side’ if he continues down this path. Desperate to change the course of their relationship, Liam suggests they should be together, really together. Cory is incredulous, reminding him of their respective marriages and her belief that Liam is making it easy for Sylvia to take over his life.

Cory stands up, ready to leave, stating that she is done with the fighting and the judgment. Liam pleads with her to stay, arguing that they owe each other everything, but Cory is resolute. She suggests that perhaps it is safer for her to keep their relationship as it is, and she leaves for the Carlyle to get a proper drink. Liam, feeling defeated, watches her go, realizing that the only way forward is to respect her decision.

Unable to face Jack at home, Nora decides to visit her father’s old neighborhood in Midwood. She reflects on her father’s eagerness to leave Midwood and his fondness for showing her around his old stomping grounds. Walking down Bedford Avenue, she passes her father’s high school and Brooklyn College, where Uncle Joe studied.

Nora arrives at her father’s childhood home, a small yellow house with green shutters. She rings the doorbell and is greeted by a young mother with a baby. After a brief hesitation, the mother allows Nora to enter and see her father’s old bedroom. Nora explores the room, noticing height etchings on the wall, including a small stenciled message: 'Cory & Liam'.

The young mother mentions that Nora’s father visited the house six months ago with a woman, standing outside on the sidewalk. This information puzzles Nora, prompting her to wonder about her father’s motives and the identity of the woman he was with. Nora leaves the house, feeling a deep connection to her father’s past and the history embedded in the place.

Feeling restless and unable to face Jack at home, Nora decides to visit her father’s apartment in Perry Street. The doorman lets her in, and she finds the apartment eerily empty and devoid of personal touches, a stark contrast to her memories of her father’s presence. The apartment’s emptiness adds to her sense of loss and confusion.

Inez, her father’s third wife, arrives unexpectedly and greets Nora warmly. Inez, now married to Elizabeth, explains that she was at a dinner uptown and is staying for the night. Nora and Inez share a drink, and Nora feels a sense of kinship with Inez, who has become closer to her since her father’s death. Nora asks Inez about her father’s relationship with Cece Salinger, but Inez dismisses the idea of any romantic involvement, suggesting that Cece’s interest in the company was purely business.

Nora’s curiosity deepens as she presses Inez for more information about her father’s life in the months leading up to his death. Inez hesitates and then gently advises Nora to focus on her father’s love for his family rather than digging into potential secrets. Inez’s reluctance to share more information leaves Nora with more questions and a growing sense of unease about her father’s true intentions and the people in his life.

Nora, still reeling from her visit to her father’s apartment, arrives at Morgan and Sam’s loft with a renewed sense of urgency. She is determined to speak with Sam about revisiting Windbreak. However, Sam, dressed for a fundraiser, dismisses her calls, claiming he has been busy. Frustrated by his lack of cooperation, Nora reveals that she has visited their father’s old neighborhood in Midwood and found more personal items there than in their father’s recent apartment. This discovery suggests that Windbreak held the key to their father’s personal life. Despite her efforts to persuade him, Sam remains dismissive and ultimately shuts the door on her.

Cory hangs bird-patterned wallpaper in the living room at Windbreak, her movements deliberate and focused. Liam watches her, a mix of admiration and concern clouding his thoughts. He suggests the room would be perfect for her to write in, but Cory grows defensive, reminding him that it is not her room. The conversation reveals underlying tensions in their relationship, particularly around Cory’s career and the nature of their commitment to each other.

Liam tries to steer the conversation towards Cory’s writing, revealing that he knows she is still writing, which surprises him. Cory shares a memory from her sophomore English class, where a New Yorker writer spoke about writing love letters to one person. This resonates with her, emphasizing that she writes for herself and one other person. Liam, curious, asks who that person is, but Cory deftly deflects. The conversation highlights the ongoing tension between their current lives and the life they could have had together.

Liam’s comments about their alternative life, where they are together with children, irritate Cory, who insists she is happy with her current life. She tells him to go save a spot on the cliff for the sunset, suggesting he is being annoying. Liam, hurt but sincere, expresses his deep happiness whenever he is with her, emphasizing that despite the years, she is still the source of his greatest joy. Cory, though softened, maintains her stance and continues her work, leaving Liam to go outside.

Nora finds herself in the last row of a crowded plane, sandwiched between a mother with a crying baby and a surly man sipping vodka. Offering to help, she takes the baby, and the mother gratefully accepts. The baby calms in Nora’s arms, giving the mother a much-needed respite. During the flight, the mother confides in Nora about her husband’s difficulties adjusting to fatherhood and her plans to stay with her sister. Nora listens intently, reflecting on the mother’s advice about changing the way she frames her questions. This resonates deeply, as she realizes her own investigation into her father’s death might benefit from a new perspective. The conversation shifts to Nora’s reasons for the impromptu trip, but the baby’s cries interrupt them again. The mother takes the baby back, leaving Nora to ponder the new direction her investigation might take.

On the wintery beach near Windbreak, Nora retraces the steps of the jogger and the Coopers, trying to piece together the night her father died. She examines the area where his body was found, considering the various scenarios of how he might have fallen or been pushed. Her thoughts are interrupted by Ben King, her father’s old college friend, who introduces himself and offers his condolences. Nora recalls Ben as the reason her father discovered Windbreak and the connection to her father’s past.

After Ben departs, Nora reflects on her father’s life and the man he aspired to be, contrasting it with Ben’s contentment. She realizes that Cece Salinger’s ex-husband, Davidson Salinger, lives nearby and decides to search for his address. Nora then hurries back to the house, eager to uncover more information. She retrieves yearbooks and photo albums from the personal shelf, focusing on the late 1970s when her father was at Yale.

In one of the photo albums, Nora discovers a group photograph from her father’s college days. Among the people in the photo are her uncle Joe and a young Cece Kayne, standing close to her father. The photograph provides a crucial link between her father, Cece, and the past, suggesting a deeper connection than previously known.

Cory stands at Grand Central Station, visibly upset as she waits for her train to Dobbs Ferry. She confronts Liam about his recent meeting with Cece at the Oyster Bar, accusing him of being dishonest and breaking their agreement to be open with each other. Liam tries to defend himself, explaining that Cece made an offer for the company, which he declined. However, Cory remains skeptical, pointing out that Liam has been making choices that affect their relationship, such as his impending divorce from Sylvia and his growing involvement with Cece. The tension escalates as the train begins to board, and Cory turns to leave. Liam pleads for more time to talk, but Cory is resolute, refusing to miss her class and dismissing the idea that they can resolve their issues. As Cory boards the train, Liam feels helpless and guilty, the deep rift in their relationship becoming more apparent.

Nora stands on the back porch at Windbreak, the sunset casting a warm glow over the landscape. She sips her tea, feeling a rare sense of peace, but her thoughts drift to Jack, wishing he were there with her. Her phone buzzes, and she hopes it might be Jack, but the caller is Cece. Cece sounds anxious, apologizing for the sudden call and mentioning that Uncle Joe told her Nora was at Windbreak. Nora is immediately suspicious about how Uncle Joe knew she was there and asks if he will be joining them for dinner. Cece clarifies that she reached out to Nora without Joe’s knowledge, hoping to talk privately.

Just as Cece is speaking, Clark knocks on the screen door, announcing he’s leaving. Nora excuses herself from the call to talk to Clark, thanking him for coming out and showing him a group photograph of her father, Uncle Joe, and a young Cece. Clark recognizes Liam but not Cece, and Nora suggests pulling up a more recent photo, but Clark declines. He confirms that her father was usually alone at Windbreak, except for the occasional visits from his children. However, Clark then reveals that he met one woman a few times, whom her father introduced as Cory. Nora is taken aback, remembering the name from the etching in her father’s childhood home. She thanks Clark and immediately calls Cece back, but Cece doesn’t answer, so Nora leaves a message. Determined, Nora heads to the living room to search through old photo albums for more information about Cory.

Eleven years ago, Liam waits for Cory on a freezing street corner, having just left a drinks meeting at the St. Regis. Despite the harsh weather, he is determined to see her, and when she finally arrives, they exchange playful banter. Liam presents her with front-row tickets to a revival of The Goodbye Girl, a gesture that brings a genuine smile to her face.

Cory and Liam’s conversation reveals the complexities of their relationship. Cory is planning to spend a year in Paris with her husband to work on their marriage, a fact that Liam is aware of but doesn’t press. Meanwhile, Liam is preparing to marry Inez, a younger woman who wants a traditional family. Despite the upcoming wedding, Liam’s feelings for Cory are evident, and he admits to being honest with Inez about their past. Cory, while supportive of Liam’s decision, hints at her doubts about the longevity of his marriages.

As they walk to the theater, Cory leans on Liam, and the moment feels both comforting and bittersweet. Liam’s gesture of bringing Junior Mints and Twizzlers to the show is a small but significant act of thoughtfulness, highlighting the deep connection they share despite the challenges in their lives.

Nora falls asleep on the floor, surrounded by her father’s photo albums and yearbooks. When she wakes up, her body is freezing, covered in goose bumps, but she persists in her search for any information about Cory. She meticulously combs through the high school yearbook, but finds no trace of Cory among the 630 girls in her father’s graduating class.

While putting the photo albums back on the shelf, Nora notices a thin book titled 'Jabberwocky: The Midwood High School Literary Review.' Curious, she pulls it down and starts flipping through the pages. She smiles at a short story by Uncle Joe, titled 'The Shortstop,' but her attention is quickly drawn to a name that catches her eye: Cordelia Ryan, who has written a poem and a short story.

Nora wonders if Cory could be short for Cordelia and turns to page eight to read the story titled 'The Children Go.' Under the title, she finds a handwritten note signed with her father’s initials, LSN, which reads, 'in case i don’t say it later, they’re all for you.' Her heart races as she continues to flip through the journal, eventually finding the masthead with Cordelia G. Ryan listed as Editor in Chief. A small black-and-white photograph of a young woman with long, unruly hair and wire-rim glasses is beneath the name. Nora recognizes the face as Grace’s, her father’s trusted advisor, confirming that Cory and Cordelia are the same person.

Nora sits on the floor, surrounded by the remnants of her father’s past, her mind racing with the revelation that Cory might be Grace. Memories flood back, each one a snapshot of her father and Grace, now seen in a new light. From childhood visits to adult conversations, she pieces together the deep, unspoken bond between them. The last time she saw them together, the way they looked at each other, now takes on a profound significance.

Determined to uncover more, Nora calls Sam, Elliot, and Jonathan. Jonathan confirms that Grace was indeed supposed to receive the company from her father, a fact that adds another layer to the mystery. Sam arrives unexpectedly, offering his support during this emotional time, and together they begin to unravel the layers of family secrets.

Nora and Sam confront Uncle Joe at Noone Properties’ West Coast satellite office in Montecito. Initially defensive, Joe eventually agrees to explain the long-standing relationship between their father and Grace. He reveals that their father and Grace were deeply involved throughout their lives, and that their father intended to leave the company to Grace all along.

Sam, still skeptical, accuses Joe of being involved in their father’s death, suggesting that Joe might have been motivated by jealousy or a desire to take control of the company. Joe denies any involvement, explaining that their father was trying to reach him the night he died, likely to discuss something important. Joe then produces their father’s cell phone, which he found at Windbreak, and hands it to Sam. Nora, understanding Joe’s motivation to protect their father’s privacy, decides not to inspect the phone immediately.

Reflecting on the deep connection between her father and Grace, Nora realizes the reasons why they maintained their relationship in secrecy. She understands that their father’s decision to leave Windbreak to her was a deliberate choice, as he believed she would appreciate and preserve the property’s beauty. This revelation leads Nora to a new understanding of her father’s intentions and the complexity of his relationships.

The chapter concludes with Nora identifying someone who might have been present the night their father died, based on the guilt she perceives in that person’s demeanor. This new insight sets the stage for further investigation and a deeper exploration of the events leading to their father’s tragic end.

Still reeling from the revelations at Noone Properties, Nora and Sam’s thoughts linger on the complex web of relationships surrounding their father’s death. Meanwhile, five years ago, Liam and Cory are at the office late at night, sharing Chinese takeout and a bottle of Sam Adams Utopias. Liam reveals that he is leaving the company to Cory, making her the majority owner, CEO, and chair of the board. Cory is initially resistant, concerned about the implications of their long-standing relationship becoming public, but Liam insists that the company belongs to her as much as it does to him.

Cory worries about the reactions of Liam’s sons, but Liam reassures her that they will be minority owners and have a seat at the table. He also expresses his hope that they will take over when Cory retires, though the decision will ultimately be hers. Cory acknowledges the potential risks but is not overly concerned about her own situation, as her relationship with Paul has been strained. Liam reflects on his own separations and the clarity it has brought to his feelings for Cory.

The conversation takes a more personal turn as they discuss their fears of being without each other. Liam confesses that if anything happens to him, he would fold up the tent, emphasizing his deep bond with Cory. Cory reciprocates, assuring him that she has no desire to be without him either. Despite the seriousness of the topic, they try to lighten the mood, focusing on finishing their meal and discussing work-related matters.

Stunned by the weight of Paul's confession, Nora and Sam stand outside his apartment in New York, their hearts heavy with the revelation. They accuse Paul of being the jogger on the beach the night their father died. Paul initially appears surprised and confused, but his hand trembles, betraying his guilt. Reluctantly, he invites them in and begins to explain his relationship with Grace and the events leading to their father’s death.

Paul reveals that he and Grace reconnected after they both moved to New York and became romantically involved, despite Grace’s complicated relationship with Liam. He describes his frustration with Liam’s inability to fully choose Grace, and the pain of being on the wrong side of their love story. On the night of Liam’s death, Paul went to Windbreak to scatter Grace’s ashes, believing Liam would not be there. However, Liam arrived unexpectedly, and they argued. Overcome by emotion, Paul pushed Liam, who fell over the cliff. In shock, Paul fled the scene, fearing the consequences for his family.

Nora and Sam listen to Paul’s confession, with Sam visibly distressed. Nora, understanding the weight of Paul’s grief and the complexity of the situation, reaches out to him, acknowledging the deep connection between her father and Grace. The chapter ends with a sense of closure and a deeper understanding of the events that led to their father’s tragic end.

Still reeling from Paul's confession, Nora and Sam walk the tree-lined streets of Brooklyn Heights, the weight of the revelation pressing heavily on them. The promenade offers a view of the Brooklyn Bridge and the East River, with downtown Manhattan lit up in the distance. After a long silence, Sam breaks the quiet, asking Nora if she believes Paul. She confirms her belief, noting the sorrow and regret in his eyes. They reflect on their grief and the complex web of relationships that led to their father's death.

Liam and Cory stand outside Liam’s childhood home, where they were supposed to visit before heading to his fiftieth high school reunion. Liam, feeling nostalgic, wants to check if the etching 'Cory & Liam' is still in his childhood bedroom. However, he suddenly suggests they skip both the visit and the reunion. Cory, amused by Liam’s predictability, teases him about his indecision.

The conversation turns serious when Liam pulls out a ring, the same one he has carried since the night before Cory left for graduate school. He proposes to her, expressing his desire to wake up with her every day. Cory, tired and emotional, rejects the proposal, emphasizing that they should be content with what they have. Liam persists, revealing that he bought the ring the day after they met, symbolizing his long-standing commitment to her.

Moved by his gesture, Cory takes the ring but refuses to marry him. Instead, she suggests they live together in the same house, which Liam agrees to, noting that they already have a house in mind. The chapter ends with a tender moment as they reaffirm their deep connection and the enduring nature of their love, despite the years and challenges they have faced.

Nora visits a two-star Michelin restaurant in a picturesque setting, savoring a perfect four-course meal. Her favorite dish is a twice-cooked flatbread with fried tomatoes, crisped anchovies, and spicy greens, a dish she knows Jack would appreciate. After the meal, she requests to speak to the chef, revealing her connection to him from their time at Sheet Music in Brooklyn.

Upon entering the kitchen, Nora finds Jack, now sporting a beard. The sight of him takes her breath away, and there is a palpable tension between them. Jack is initially hesitant but then steps forward, listening as Nora updates him on her recent activities at Windbreak and the projects she is working on. She mentions that Sam is doing well and plans to fly back to New York to see Tommy’s babies, who are due soon.

After an eight-hour drive and a thoughtful dinner, Nora decides to keep her proposal simple. She asks Jack if he would like to go get ice cream after work. Jack responds with a small laugh and agrees, suggesting they might have to drive for a while to find an open place. They share a tender moment, with Jack placing his hand on her cheek, and they agree to go for ice cream, a symbolic step towards reconciliation.