Chapter One
Before dawn, Ben Packard wakes when Franklin, his three-legged corgi, tries to get onto the bed beside a man whose name Packard cannot remember. The previous day, Packard attended Sandy Lake's Labor Day festival in his capacity as acting sheriff. He visited Gary Bushwright's animal-rescue booth and spoke with Sheriff Stan Shaw and Stan's wife, Marilyn. Stan is gravely ill with cancer, relies on supplemental oxygen, and continues to address Packard as sheriff, a title Packard is uncomfortable claiming as his own.
At the festival Packard met the drummer for Maneater, a St. Cloud yacht-rock cover band. The two flirted and went home together after the band's performance. Packard now struggles to recall the drummer's name. An outdated band website identifies the drummer as Brad Ruble, so Packard mistakenly addresses him as Brad.
Packard considers the unusually peaceful start to his day off. He has spent the summer dealing with the aftermath of the Emmett Burr investigation: Jenny Wheeler survived captivity, and investigators recovered three bodies from Burr's property, one still unidentified. Packard is also managing Stan's duties and renovating his house. The moment ends when Deputy Reynolds calls about the shooting of William Sandersen. According to the initial report, someone entered through a sliding glass door and shot Sandersen in bed. His wife, Carolyn Walbach, was unharmed and called police. Packard had promised Deputy Thielen that he would take the next case to relieve her workload, although he had not expected the call on his day off.
Packard tells his overnight guest that he must leave, agrees to a brief shared shower, and sees him out with coffee. As they part, the man offers Packard his business card. Only then does Packard learn that his name is Dave, not Brad.
Key Events
- Packard attends the Labor Day festival and visits the seriously ill Sheriff Stan Shaw.
- Packard meets a Maneater drummer and spends the night with him, initially mistaking his name for Brad.
- The Emmett Burr case remains partly unresolved, with one recovered victim still unidentified and Jenny Wheeler alive.
- Deputy Reynolds reports that William Sandersen was shot in bed and that his wife, Carolyn Walbach, survived.
- Packard learns from the departing drummer's business card that his name is Dave.
Characters Appearing
- Dave, Maneater's drummer and an insurance inspector
- William (Bill) Sandersen, reported murder victim
- Carolyn (Carrie) Walbach, Bill's wife
Themes
- Acting-sheriff responsibilities during Stan Shaw's illness
- Continuing aftermath of the Emmett Burr case
- Packard's private life and new homicide duties
Chapter Two
Packard drives to William Sandersen's house near Blank Township after parting from Dave, whose name confusion resulted from an outdated band website. At the scene, Deputy Reynolds confirms that Sandersen's wife, Carolyn, is unharmed; Deputy Baker is taking her statement. Packard finds the victim in a downstairs bedroom beside a partially open sliding glass door. He does not establish how the assailant entered. Crime-scene technician Erik sees two bullet wounds, although Carolyn reports hearing only one shot. Damage to a finger indicates that Bill raised a hand defensively. Investigators have not located the weapon or spent cartridge cases.
Carolyn, also called Carrie, identifies herself as chief executive of the Gherlick Family Trust, which supports organizations addressing child poverty. She says she visited her mother, who has dementia, and returned around ten the previous evening, while Bill came home around midnight. She slept upstairs because Bill used a CPAP machine and snored. After a loud noise woke her, she went downstairs, found Bill bloody in bed and the patio door open, and locked herself in a bathroom before calling for help. Her story remains a statement to be checked, not a confirmed reconstruction. Packard asks investigators to secure her clothes, test for gunshot residue and collect the handgun in her bedroom along with the house's other firearms.
Deputy Howard Shepard tells Packard that Bill's former wife, Sherrilyn or Sherri Sandersen, is Carolyn's sister. Both women are daughters of John Gherlick, whose family accumulated substantial wealth. Their cousin Danny's son Sam was involved in the earlier case that led investigators to Emmett Burr. Shepard claims Bill spent Sherri's money before marrying Carolyn, but presents this as local gossip. Driving Carolyn to her mother's house, Packard learns that she dated Bill in high school before he married Sherri. Their father later died by suicide, leaving trust funds to his daughters. Carolyn renewed her relationship with Bill after many years of loneliness, whereas Sherri and Bill had divorced after frequent fighting and heavy drinking.
Carolyn says she cannot identify a killer and warns that Sherri resents both her and Bill. She names Bill's friend Roger Freeman, with whom he hoped to open a sports bar. She believes financial tension developed after an argument and says she refused Bill's request to invest $50,000 from her trust. She also identifies casino poker acquaintance Ronnie Winder. Carolyn goes to stay with her mother, where caretaker Zeinab meets her, and Packard prepares to question Roger and Sherri. Neither the familial accusations nor the financial disputes establish guilt.
Key Events
- Packard examines Bill Sandersen's downstairs bedroom and hears that two shots struck him, despite Carolyn reporting one gunshot.
- Carolyn explains the couple's separate sleeping arrangements, the open sliding door, and her actions before contacting police.
- Packard orders gunshot-residue collection, clothing preservation and seizure of accessible household firearms.
- Shepard identifies current wife Carolyn and former wife Sherri as sisters from the Gherlick family.
- Carolyn recounts her earlier romance with Bill and provides leads involving Roger Freeman, a proposed bar, a declined $50,000 investment and poker acquaintance Ronnie Winder.
Characters Appearing
- Deputy Reynolds
- Deputy Baker
- Deputy Howard Shepard
- Becky and Erik, crime-scene technicians
- Roger Freeman, Bill's prospective bar partner
- Sherrilyn (Sherri) Sandersen, Bill's former wife and Carolyn's sister
- Ronnie Winder, poker acquaintance
- Zeinab, caretaker for Carolyn's mother
Themes
- Investigative uncertainty and forensic corroboration
- Family wealth and estrangement
- Potential financial conflicts without proof of guilt
Chapter Three
Packard visits Roger Freeman at his family's dairy farm west of Sandy Lake and tells him that his oldest friend, Bill Sandersen, has been murdered. Roger reacts with apparent shock and grief. He explains that he and Bill grew up together, drifted apart after Roger moved to Minneapolis, and resumed their friendship when Roger returned about ten years earlier to help his family's struggling dairy operation. Roger describes Bill and Sherri's years of drinking and spending Sherri's trust money. He considers Bill irresponsible but insists that he remained loyal to him.
Roger says Bill proposed opening a sports bar with beer, wings, televisions and gambling tickets. They planned to raise $50,000 themselves and finance the rest. Roger deposited his entire $20,000 savings into a business account; Bill promised the same but contributed only $9,700 in installments. Weeks earlier, Bill withdrew $20,000 without Roger's permission and claimed he had invested it in an opportunity that would pay off. Roger confronted Bill but did not learn what the investment was. He admits that the missing money could make him a suspect, denies killing his friend and argues that murder would not recover his investment.
Roger believes Sherri still misses Bill and says her heavy drinking, repeated driving offenses and suspended license have left her isolated. As he shows Packard the dairy farm, Roger describes punishing work and declining milk prices. He then recounts spending the night working and watching television with employee Ricardo before going to bed at the farm. Packard points out that Carolyn said Bill was meeting Roger that night. Roger becomes alarmed and emphatically denies any meeting or contact with Bill for approximately a week; he suggests Bill may have used his name to conceal a visit to the casino. This is a material discrepancy in the victim's whereabouts, not evidence that either account is true. Sherri calls Roger while Packard is present and then sends repeated messages. Roger shows Packard that Sherri has already heard about Bill's death, though this chapter does not establish who informed her.
Key Events
- Roger reacts to Bill's murder and describes their long friendship and reconnection through the dairy farm.
- Roger says Bill contributed only $9,700 to their business account but withdrew $20,000, claiming an undisclosed investment.
- Roger denies that he met Bill the night of the shooting, contradicting what Bill reportedly told Carolyn.
- Sherri calls and texts Roger after learning of Bill's death.
Characters Appearing
- Roger Freeman, dairy farmer and Bill's prospective business partner
- Ricardo, worker at the Freeman dairy farm
Themes
- Disputed financial dealings
- Contradictory accounts of Bill's last movements
- The personal and economic difficulties of farming
Chapter Four
Packard visits Sherri Sandersen at her condominium, expecting to notify her of her former husband's death, but Sherri greets him by declaring that she did not kill Bill. She drinks wine and smokes throughout the interview. She says she attended the Labor Day concert with friends, then went to Bob's Bar with one of them until almost midnight. She admits she was heavily intoxicated and says her friend drove her home. Packard recognizes her as one of the three women dancing near the stage, but he has not independently verified the remainder of her account.
Sherri describes Bill spending her trust money, leaving her and marrying her younger sister, Carrie. She recalls crashing their wedding at a golf club with friend Kristie, drinking and dancing while Carrie and Bill sat unhappily at the head table and guests departed early. Sherri claims she spoiled the celebration merely by attending and enjoying herself. She says their mother Margaret always disliked Bill, although Margaret now has dementia. When Packard asks who might have killed Bill, Sherri suggests Carrie because spouses are often implicated, then admits she does not know Bill's more recent affairs or enemies.
Sherri works part time managing the condominiums and as a waitress at the Silver Dollar Saloon, where Kristie, the bartender, provides transportation because Sherri cannot drive. Before leaving, Packard asks how she learned of Bill's death. Sherri shows him a message asking her to call because something had happened to Bill, saved under the contact name Dep Shep. Packard recognizes that Deputy Howard Shepard contacted her despite Packard's instructions that he himself would notify the family.
Key Events
- Sherri supplies an uncorroborated alibi involving the festival, Bob's Bar and a friend's ride home.
- Sherri recounts attending and disrupting Bill and Carrie's wedding, and describes their mother's dislike of Bill.
- Sherri suggests Carrie as a possible suspect but says she knows of no specific current enemy.
- Packard discovers from Sherri's phone that Deputy Shepard disclosed news of Bill's death.
Characters Appearing
- Kristie, Sherri's friend and coworker
Themes
- Estrangement following Bill's remarriage
- Witness statements and unverified alibis
- Unauthorized disclosure within the sheriff's department
Chapter Five
Packard returns to Carolyn's house after discovering that Deputy Howard Shepard informed Sherri about Bill's death against instructions. A deputy is casting truck-like tire tracks in a field turnoff where the shooter may have parked. Crime-scene technicians Becky and Erik have recovered two 9 mm cartridge casings. The shots appear to have come from different directions, one toward the bedroom doorway and the other toward the sliding glass door. Bill had raised a hand defensively before the shot that struck his finger and neck. The contrasting trajectories complicate Packard's initial assumption about the shooting and any possible robbery.
On Bill's unlocked phone, Packard finds messages to a contact saved as Roger arranging a late-night meeting. The contact's reply addresses Bill as 'lover.' Roger had just denied meeting or speaking to Bill recently, but Packard notices that the saved number differs from Roger Freeman's actual telephone number. He cannot reach it when he calls. His thoughts return briefly to Marcus, the Minneapolis police officer he dated before Marcus was killed on duty; Packard moved to Sandy Lake after that loss. Packard preserves Bill's phone in a Faraday bag. The bedroom gun safe is unlocked and contains firearms, but none of the four pistols would fire 9 mm rounds. A diamond earring lies on the carpet, and four marks inside the safe suggest a missing box or other object. Packard considers both robbery and a targeted killing as hypotheses, without establishing either. The tire impressions may help identify a vehicle later.
That evening Packard takes Frank to dinner with fellow detective Jill Thielen and her husband Tim, who are his closest local friends. They discuss Bill's family, potential suspects and the puzzling texts. Packard initially wonders whether Bill and Roger were lovers; Tim cautions against excluding that possibility merely because they had wives, while Jill doubts it. When Marilyn Shaw calls, Packard realizes the supposedly intimate messages may have come from someone else whose number Bill saved under Roger's name to hide the real correspondent from Carrie. This remains a deduction, not a confirmed identity.
Marilyn reports that Sheriff Stan Shaw died from complications of cancer about an hour earlier. Packard informs dispatch and Kelly Phelps, the longtime department administrator, who is traveling in California. They hear the department's formal end-of-watch radio announcement honoring Stan's service. The tribute reminds Packard of Marcus's death and the loss of his own place in the public mourning because their relationship was concealed. Stan hired Packard and entrusted him with the acting-sheriff role; his death makes Packard's future position uncertain.
Key Events
- Investigators find two 9 mm casings, differing firing directions and possible truck tire tracks near the house.
- Bill's phone contains late-night messages to a contact named Roger whose number does not match Roger Freeman's number.
- The unlocked gun safe, diamond earring and apparent missing container raise an unconfirmed robbery possibility.
- Packard infers that Bill may have disguised a secret contact's number using Roger's name.
- Stan Shaw dies of cancer, and the sheriff's department conducts an end-of-watch announcement.
Characters Appearing
- Jill Thielen, detective
- Tim Thielen, Jill's husband
- Kelly Phelps, department administrator
Themes
- Separation of physical evidence from hypotheses
- Concealed relationships and personal grief
- Leadership uncertainty following Stan Shaw's death
Chapter Six
On Labor Day, Packard finds both Sandy Lake Auto, where Bill Sandersen worked, and the funeral home closed for the holiday. Outside the funeral home he meets Wendy, Bill's sister, who is upset that Carrie notified her of the murder by text and asked her to arrange the funeral without speaking to her. They talk at a nearby café. Wendy says family gatherings became awkward after Bill married his former sister-in-law, but she cannot say that he was unhappy with Carrie. Bill had told her he loved Carrie after renewing their high-school relationship. Wendy also reports that their mother Margaret forced Sherri to divorce Bill by conditioning financial help on the separation when Sherri's inheritance was spent.
Wendy says Bill's gambling remained a concern and that she lent him $5,000 from savings inherited from their mother to help start the proposed restaurant with Roger Freeman. Packard tells her Roger deposited $20,000 while Bill contributed $9,700, including the money from Wendy, and then withdrew $20,000 without explanation. Wendy regrets enabling Bill's repeated attempts to obtain easy money. At the station, Packard reviews financial records showing the Gherlick Family Trust holds nearly $300 million and pays Carrie almost $200,000 annually. A lookup of the unfamiliar phone number saved in Bill's cellphone under Roger's name reveals a carrier but no subscriber. Packard suspects a burner number or application, but has not established who uses it.
Jim Wolf, chair of the county board, calls about Stan Shaw's death and says the board intends to put the sheriff's position on the November ballot, although the office was not previously scheduled for election that year. Wolf tells Packard that he must run if he wants to continue as sheriff. Packard recognizes that Jim has opposed his appointment since Stan selected him. The prospect of an immediate campaign troubles Packard: he is not sure he wants to abandon detective work for administrative duties, and he doubts that voters would elect a relatively new resident who is openly gay. He nonetheless resents Wolf's intervention.
Key Events
- Wendy Sandersen reports learning of her brother's murder by text and describes the pressure behind his earlier divorce.
- Wendy identifies a $5,000 contribution to Bill's proposed business and his continuing gambling habits.
- The trust's annual report shows nearly $300 million in assets, while the unknown phone contact remains unidentified.
- Jim Wolf says a special November election will determine the next sheriff and Packard must run to retain the job.
Characters Appearing
- Wendy Sandersen, Bill's sister
- Jim Wolf, county-board chair
Themes
- Financial dependence and gambling
- Distinguishing a suspected burner number from an identified caller
- Conflict over the sheriff election and Packard's career
Chapter Seven
At Margaret Gherlick's house, Carrie is startled when her sister Sherri unlocks the front door and demands to know why Carrie will not answer her calls. Sherri admits borrowing a newly arrived neighbor's car in exchange for marijuana because her own car is recognizable to police and her license is suspended. She drinks whisky and argues with Carrie in front of their mother, whose dementia has not prevented her from making sharp and insulting remarks.
The sisters accuse one another of involvement in Bill's murder. Carrie says the killer could have killed her too, while Sherri questions Carrie's lack of visible grief. Sherri knows Bill took $20,000 from Roger and asks Carrie where the money is; Carrie says she knew nothing of the withdrawal and suggests Sherri might have wanted it. The exchange reveals mutual distrust but neither woman's accusation is established as true. When Sherri tells Carrie to act more like a bereaved widow, Carrie deliberately produces tears and asks whether that is the response Sherri wanted. Their mother asks them to behave.
After Sherri leaves, Carrie tries to draw out Margaret's memories. Carrie asks about a jeweled hummingbird pin, and Margaret recalls that Carrie's father gave it to her and that it contains rubies and diamonds, but cannot explain its significance. The narrative then discloses something Carrie has not told Packard: before Bill was shot, the killer specifically demanded to know where the hummingbird pin was, and Bill said it was not there. Carrie has the pin on a coat in her own front closet, rather than with the rest of her jewelry. She wonders how the killer knew it existed and why it mattered. Carrie does not disclose this information to Sherri in their argument.
Key Events
- Sherri confronts Carrie and confirms she knows about Bill's missing $20,000 from Roger.
- Both sisters accuse the other of possible involvement without presenting evidence.
- Carrie asks Margaret about an inherited ruby-and-diamond hummingbird pin.
- Carrie's private recollection reveals that the killer demanded the pin from Bill before shooting him.
- Carrie knows the pin is on a coat in her home, not in the safe.
Characters Appearing
- Margaret Gherlick, mother of Carrie and Sherri, who has dementia
Themes
- Sisters' competing accusations and distrust
- Memory loss and inheritance
- Critical information retained in Carrie's perspective but not shared with investigators
Chapter Eight
On Tuesday, Packard interviews Stephen Carter, owner of Sandy Lake Auto, where Bill Sandersen worked selling used cars. Stephen says Bill needed employment after divorcing Sherri and preparing to marry Carrie; he was personable but nostalgic and often talked about his youth. Stephen specifically says Bill never told him of the proposed restaurant. Two mechanics, Paul and Ryan, describe Bill as boastful and sometimes disrespectful. Paul reports that Bill recently attended an expensive private poker game after Ronnie Winder helped him obtain an invitation. Paul does not know where the game was or how much Bill lost; Bill claimed he left with the money he brought, a claim Paul doubts.
Packard obtains Bill's employment records, laptop and notebook. Katherine, who helps him access the computer, describes Bill's middling sales performance and his habit of bothering her with flirtation. The notebook contains names and dollar amounts without an immediately clear connection. Katherine later slips Packard a business card with her personal number. At Winder Marine, Ronnie acknowledges recommending the high-stakes game but says he warned Bill that he was badly outmatched. Ronnie describes a $10,000 minimum buy-in, wealthy players and his own $16,000 loss at a previous game. He refuses initially to name the host, citing customer relationships. Packard threatens to subpoena records; Ronnie agrees to ask the host to contact him. Whether Bill incurred additional gambling debts remains unverified.
At the station, administrator Kelly Phelps grieves Sheriff Stan Shaw and urges Packard to run for sheriff. That evening the county board approves Jim Wolf's proposal for a special November election despite Commissioner Janelle White's suggestion that Packard finish the term at lower cost. The board formally thanks Packard for serving as acting sheriff. The commissioners also approve plans for a new microbrewery. Afterward its developers, cousins Kyle and Mark, introduce themselves; Kyle invites Packard to see the brewery, and Packard notices his lingering attention.
Later, the poker host calls Packard first from a blocked number and then identifies himself as Leon Chen, who lives at 800 Silver Creek Lane in an affluent lakeside neighborhood. Chen says he has arranged for everyone who played with Bill to attend another game the following night and invites Packard to interview them at 8 p.m.
Key Events
- Stephen Carter says Bill was employed at his dealership but had not disclosed the bar proposal.
- Paul describes an invitation to a high-stakes poker game without confirming Bill's losses.
- Katherine provides Bill's laptop and sales information; Packard takes the laptop for forensic examination.
- Ronnie Winder says he referred Bill to a wealthy host's poker game but does not organize it himself.
- The county board approves an early sheriff election and a brewery; Packard meets Kyle and Mark.
- Leon Chen agrees to gather the poker players for Packard's questions at his home.
Characters Appearing
- Stephen Carter, auto dealership owner
- Paul and Ryan, dealership mechanics
- Katherine, dealership employee
- Ronnie Winder, owner of Winder Marine
- Kyle and Mark, brewery-developing cousins
- Leon Chen, private poker host
Themes
- Financial leads without verified gambling losses
- The sheriff's electoral transition
- Social connections and local investigative access
Chapter Nine
On Wednesday, the medical examiner tells Packard that Bill Sandersen was killed by gunshots to his neck and chest. Evidence of recent intercourse includes pubic hairs from another person, some dyed dark with gray roots. Packard connects the finding to Sherri's dark-dyed hair and the intimate messages on Bill's phone to a contact misleadingly saved as Roger. Confronted at her condominium, Sherri admits that she and Bill continued having sex after their divorce, including in his truck on the night he was killed. She says Bill picked her up near Bob's Bar and denies any involvement in his death. She concealed the affair because she did not want Carrie to learn about it. Packard now has a likely explanation for the disguised contact, but Sherri's account does not resolve the murder.
Digital examiner Suresh reports that Bill had little online activity. One authentic contact with Roger Freeman is saved under a joking reference to Minnesota's dairy-princess contest, helping Packard distinguish the farmer's number from the false Roger contact. Carrie's gunshot-residue tests are negative, which does not establish that she could not have fired a gun. A search of the pond behind the house finds no weapon. At the casino, Raymond Pike reports that Bill last used his player card on June 17, but the record cannot exclude visits without the card. Administrator Kelly Phelps again urges Packard to run for sheriff and identifies the planned brewery developers Kyle and Mark as her nephews. Packard formally confronts Deputy Shepard over notifying Sherri against department rules, files an incident report and recuses himself from deciding the discipline.
That evening Packard visits architect Leon Chen's expensive lakefront home for a poker game. Chen, county commissioner Jim Wolf, Alan, Richard and former professional pitcher Tim O'Reilly are among the participants. They say Bill lost everything he brought to an earlier game and describe his poor play, but their statements do not independently establish what happened after he left. Packard plays with $20,000 supplied by Chen and wins nearly $75,000, much of it from Wolf. He refuses to accept his winnings because he is questioning the players as part of a murder investigation. During a break he interviews the players and the dealer, Arnold, about their knowledge and whereabouts.
While Packard and Chen stand near the lake-facing glass, gunfire shatters the windows. Packard suffers facial and scalp cuts from the glass, not from bullets. He suspects the shooter is escaping by boat, takes Chen's motorboat and pursues another craft across the dark lake. He intercepts Walter, a known poacher operating illegally, but Walter is not the shooter. Walter says a separate unlit boat passed through a connecting channel to another lake before Packard arrived. The actual shooter escapes. Back at Chen's house, Chen argues that the attack was directed at Packard rather than himself because a shooter could have targeted him when the house was empty. Packard has no proof of the target's identity and orders the poker guests to remain available for questioning.
Key Events
- Autopsy evidence and Sherri's admission identify her as Bill's concealed sexual contact on the night he died.
- Suresh distinguishes Roger Freeman's actual phone number from the contact falsely saved as Roger.
- Negative GSR results and missing weapon do not establish Carrie's innocence or an alternative perpetrator.
- Packard files an internal complaint against Shepard and recuses himself from discipline decisions.
- Poker players claim Bill lost his entire stake; Packard refuses winnings from an official questioning session.
- A shooter fires toward Leon Chen's house and escapes by water; Walter is a poacher and witness, not the shooter.
Characters Appearing
- Ashley, medical examiner
- Suresh, digital forensics specialist
- Raymond Pike, casino customer-loyalty employee
- Leon Chen, poker host and architect
- Arnold, poker dealer
- Tim O'Reilly, retired pitcher
- Walter, poacher and witness to a separate boat
Themes
- Concealed relationships and misleading phone identities
- Limitations of negative forensic evidence and witness testimony
- Professional conflict and police conduct
Chapter Ten
The morning after the shooting at Leon Chen's house, Packard returns to the scene, where Jill Thielen has taken charge of that investigation. The recovered bullets appear to be .223 caliber, but the security cameras did not record a shooter or boat because the house lights obscured the water. Chen again offers Packard his poker winnings privately. Packard declines and suggests that Chen instead reimburse Roger Freeman, whose money Bill had taken from their business account and, Packard believes, lost in the game. Thielen raises the possibility that the shooting was tied to the sheriff election or Jim Wolf's hostility toward Packard, but neither detective has evidence of the shooter's motive.
A nearby resident, Sharon Seversen, reports an abandoned boat in a connected lake, consistent with the escape route described by Walter. Her husband Chuck helps Packard and Thielen retrieve it. The boat belongs to Scott Layman, who has returned to his law office near Minneapolis and says he left a spare key aboard. Thielen finds indications that the wheel has been wiped. Packard discovers a spent casing stamped WIN 223 entangled in a ski rope inside the boat. The casing supports the possibility that this stolen or borrowed craft was used in the attack, though its significance still requires forensic comparison and the actual shooter remains unidentified.
At the sheriff's office, Kelly again presses a candidacy form on Packard. Suresh reports that Bill's seldom-used work laptop contains an employee-benefits document. It lists $100,000 life-insurance policies on Bill and Carrie, with Bill named as beneficiary on Carrie's policy and his former wife Sherri, not Carrie, named beneficiary on his own policy; Wendy is the secondary beneficiary. Suresh cannot establish whether Bill intended to change his elections. He also finds a deleted Craigslist listing followed by a map search for a rural property transferred from Gerald Whitehouse to Robert Whitehouse. Packard consults dealership employee Katherine about how benefits and beneficiaries can be changed but gains no further proof of Bill's intentions.
At the Whitehouse property, Gerald confirms that Bill visited about a week earlier to inspect an old commercial fryer for the restaurant he planned with Roger, then left without buying it. A foul smell comes from under a trapdoor in Gerald's barn. Gerald refuses Packard access without a warrant, denies holding anyone captive, and says his private activity is unrelated to the killing. Packard leaves without entering the space or establishing wrongdoing.
Key Events
- Thielen leads the investigation of shots at Chen's house, where the bullets appear to be .223 caliber.
- Packard and Thielen recover an unattended boat with a WIN 223 casing and indications of wiped controls.
- Suresh finds Bill's life-insurance record naming Sherri, not current wife Carrie, as primary beneficiary.
- A deleted Craigslist ad and later mapping search lead Packard to Gerald Whitehouse's rural property.
- Gerald confirms Bill inspected a fryer and refuses access to a concealed area in the barn without a warrant.
Characters Appearing
- Sharon and Chuck Seversen, residents who locate the abandoned boat
- Scott Layman, owner of the recovered boat
- Gerald Whitehouse, rural property occupant
Themes
- Physical evidence in the separate shooting
- Insurance beneficiaries and possible motives
- Search authority and limits on investigating private premises
Chapter Eleven
At Sheriff Stan Shaw's funeral on Friday, Packard speaks about Stan's military service, law-enforcement career, personal kindness and frustrations with modern technology. Stan's widow Marilyn and longtime colleague Kelly join in the laughter and grief. Packard also sees Shannon Gherlick, Stan's granddaughter, recovering in sober housing after her involvement in the prior Emmett Burr investigation. Shannon's father Dan Gherlick asks about Bill Sandersen and tells Packard that Carrie and Sherri have an estranged older sister, Mary, who runs a craft shop in town.
During the funeral reception, Thielen shows Packard a newly public campaign page announcing Deputy Howard Shepard's candidacy for sheriff. Shepard claims his wife released the page prematurely. Packard tells Shepard that he does not intend to run. Shepard says county-board chair Jim Wolf warned him about the election before Stan died and plans to help his campaign. Marilyn asks Packard to visit because she has something Stan wanted him to have.
Packard and Thielen interview Mary Gherlick at her bead-and-craft store. Mary says she avoids her mother and sisters. She describes a childhood of manipulation and abuse, accusing Margaret of encouraging competition among the girls and blaming Mary for her father's unhappiness. Mary says her sisters bullied her at home and school. She recalls her father's suicide and her subsequent move away to study. She later met Jay in Duluth and returned to Sandy Lake with him. Jay was shot and killed while deer hunting nearly twenty-eight years earlier, before their planned wedding; Mary calls him her husband despite their never having married. His death was never conclusively explained. Mary used her trust inheritance to sustain her business and refuses contact or financial support to Sherri. She says she was home alone on the night of Bill's murder after working at the festival, providing no independently confirmed alibi. Asked who killed Bill, she immediately accuses Carrie, but supplies no direct evidence.
Back at the department, Thielen urges Packard to run rather than permit Shepard to become sheriff. Packard argues that he wants to remain a detective and fears voters will prefer a longtime local deputy to a gay newcomer; the two disagree sharply. Reviewing his notes at home, Packard maps the relationships, money disputes, gambling and infidelity but has no proof implicating any of the sisters. His neighbor Bert later reports that a man appears to have driven slowly past Packard's house on separate days in a white sedan and gray SUV. Bert cannot identify him or a license plate. Packard regards the observations as ambiguous but asks Bert to report further suspicious activity.
Key Events
- At Stan's funeral Packard honors the sheriff and speaks with Shannon and Dan Gherlick.
- Dan reveals Mary is the eldest of three Gherlick sisters; Mary is estranged and runs a downtown craft shop.
- Shepard's candidacy becomes public, with Jim Wolf helping his election effort.
- Mary describes family abuse and the unsolved shooting death of her fiancé Jay, and accuses Carrie without evidence.
- Mary reports being home alone during the murder, without corroboration.
- Bert describes a possibly suspicious driver making repeated passes near Packard's house.
Characters Appearing
- Mary Gherlick, oldest sister of Carrie and Sherri
- Jay, Mary's deceased fiancé, killed while hunting
- Bert, Packard's neighbor
Themes
- Family history and allegations versus established facts
- Unsolved older death and survivor grief
- Political pressure to oppose Shepard
Chapter Twelve
On Saturday Packard visits Sheriff Stan Shaw's widow, Marilyn, who asks him to reconsider refusing to run for sheriff. She explains that Stan's decision to appoint him acting sheriff was deliberate: longtime chief deputy Ron Callahan was preparing to retire and had agreed that Packard was the best choice. Stan respected Packard's investigative skill and believed he could lead the department. Marilyn recognizes that Packard doubts voters in a conservative rural county will elect a relatively new resident who is gay, but promises to help assemble an election team and endorsements. She identifies Howard Shepard and Alan Costas, a former deputy fired for sexual misconduct on duty, as alternative candidates. Packard does not agree to run, only to think about it.
Marilyn then brings out evidence box 18729, which Stan had asked her to give Packard after his death. It concerns the disappearance of Packard's older brother Nick nearly thirty years earlier. Ben was twelve when Nick, seventeen, sneaked out of their family's winter cabin two days after Christmas to meet a friend. The brothers argued, and Nick shoved Ben into the snow before riding off on a snowmobile. Nick never returned. The snowmobile was found in open water several days later, near a glove and signs someone had tried to climb out, but extensive searches never recovered Nick's body. The box had been missing from the sheriff's cold-case storage since Packard searched for it the previous spring. Marilyn says Stan had recognized Nick's surname and retained the file; she does not know his conclusions. Packard leaves with the box unopened.
Working on his home renovations, Packard considers Stan's confidence in him, his concealed relationship with Marcus in Minneapolis and the assumptions underlying his refusal to campaign. He recognizes that he never tested whether he could be openly gay as a police officer in his former city. A race against Shepard and Costas might be winnable, but campaigning would subject his private life to public scrutiny. By the chapter's end he has begun to reconsider, without deciding to run or opening Nick's file.
Key Events
- Marilyn says Stan and retiring chief deputy Ron Callahan deliberately selected Packard as acting sheriff.
- She urges Packard to oppose Shepard and fired former deputy Alan Costas in the sheriff election.
- Marilyn hands Packard the missing cold-case evidence box concerning Nick, which Stan retained and wanted delivered after his death.
- The source recounts Nick's disappearance by snowmobile, the recovery of his snowmobile and glove, and the absence of a body.
- Packard takes the box home but does not open it and remains undecided about campaigning.
Characters Appearing
- Marilyn Shaw, Stan's widow
- Ron Callahan, retired chief deputy
- Alan Costas, former deputy seeking election
- Nick Packard, Ben's older brother who disappeared as a teenager
Themes
- Stan's assessment of Packard's leadership
- The still-unsolved disappearance of Nick Packard
- Private identity and public election
Chapter Thirteen
A week after Bill's murder, Carrie remains at her mother Margaret's house, avoids calls and arranges for professional cleanup of the bedroom where Bill died after police release the property. She plans to have the furnishings and carpet removed, and considers selling the home rather than living there again. Margaret's dementia is worsening in the evenings, and Carrie struggles to care for her.
A call from a blocked number interrupts Carrie's isolation. The caller accuses her of lying to police about what she saw at the murder scene and refers to the sheriff's public statement that no suspect description was available. Carrie recognizes the man's voice as the killer's and recalls that he wore a balaclava and large safety glasses. She could give police some description but concealed it. The caller asks why she is protecting him and warns that he could return for her. The phone conversation is known to Carrie and the reader; Packard has not been told about it.
Carrie delegates Bill's funeral arrangements to his sister Wendy. At the service, where Packard also attends, Sherri unexpectedly takes the microphone, publicly reveals her ongoing sexual affair with Bill and claims that his CPAP machine was an excuse for sleeping separately from Carrie. She threatens Carrie if she turns out to have caused Bill's death. Carrie is humiliated and initially refuses to leave the church. In her private thoughts she acknowledges that winning Bill away from Sherri had been an important part of her own satisfaction with the marriage. Wendy takes responsibility for Bill's ashes when Carrie cannot bear to take them home.
Outside the church, Packard approaches Carrie to discuss Sherri's allegations and revisit Carrie's account of the killing. Carrie does not reveal the caller's threats or the killer's appearance. They arrange to meet at Carrie's house the next morning at ten.
Key Events
- Carrie arranges extensive cleaning at the released crime scene and contemplates selling her home.
- The killer calls Carrie, reveals awareness of her false statement and threatens her; Packard is not informed.
- At Bill's funeral, Sherri exposes her affair and the disputed CPAP excuse while accusing Carrie of possible involvement.
- Carrie's internal narration reveals that hurting Sherri was part of the attraction of reclaiming Bill.
- Packard and Carrie arrange a detailed return visit to the murder house.
Characters Appearing
- Bill's sister Wendy and her family
- Sherri's friend Kristie
Themes
- Concealed witness knowledge and threats
- Family humiliation at the funeral
- Distinction between Carrie's private thoughts and investigators' knowledge
Chapter Fourteen
Carrie returns to the murder house with her mother Margaret before Packard's scheduled interview. She retrieves the jeweled hummingbird brooch from her coat and discovers an inscription dedicating it to a woman named Sarah from someone named John. Because hummingbirds were her father John Gherlick's favorite birds, Carrie suspects the inscription may refer to an unknown relationship, though she does not yet know who Sarah was. Margaret's dementia prevents a coherent answer. Carrie places the pin in her purse before Packard arrives.
Packard explains his investigative findings, including the affair between Sherri and Bill and a life-insurance policy making Sherri the primary beneficiary of Bill's death benefit. Carrie interprets the policy as a motive for Sherri to kill him; Packard considers that a possibility but has no proof. He then has Carrie retrace the night of the shooting. Carrie's private recollections reveal that her statements have been systematically false. She was awakened by the sliding door beneath her bedroom and the sound of Bill's CPAP turning off, not by a gunshot. Taking a loaded handgun from her nightstand, she silently approached the lower level and noticed the open safe. She heard two men whispering, including a demand from the intruder for the hummingbird pin and Bill's insistence that he knew little about the jewelry. Carrie suspected Bill and an accomplice were staging a robbery as cover for her murder and a life-insurance payout. She conceals these observations and her possession of the gun from Packard.
When Carrie eventually admits that her jewelry box was missing from the safe, Packard confronts discrepancies in the account. A diamond earring found by the safe suggests someone handled the jewelry, yet valuable firearms remained. Carrie continues to claim she heard only one shot and offers explanations Packard finds implausible. During a break, the masked killer telephones Carrie again. He knows Packard is with her from monitoring police radio traffic and demands one million dollars within ten days in exchange for withholding his account of the murder. Carrie challenges him about the brooch, knowing he had detailed information Bill did not possess, and refuses his demand.
Returning inside, Carrie discovers Margaret has spilled her purse and is holding the pin. Packard examines its inscription. Margaret abruptly claims Sarah intended to take her husband John and that she struck Sarah with a fireplace poker while John helped dispose of the body. This is Margaret's allegation, not yet an established historical murder. Carrie is alarmed because Packard hears it directly.
Key Events
- Carrie finds a dedication to Sarah and John inscribed on the hummingbird pin.
- During Packard's reconstruction, Carrie's own memories contradict her police account: she was armed, knew the safe was open and heard two men arguing about the pin.
- Carrie reports her missing jewelry only after questioning at the safe; Packard notes the unexplained omission of valuable guns.
- The masked killer demands one million dollars and demonstrates knowledge of Bill's death and the pin.
- Margaret tells Packard she struck Sarah and that John helped conceal the body; the claim remains unverified.
Characters Appearing
- Sarah, an unidentified woman named on the hummingbird brooch
Themes
- Reader knowledge versus intentionally false witness testimony
- Possible staged robbery and disputed motive
- Threatened extortion and a possible older killing
Chapter Fifteen
Leaving Carrie's house, Packard considers why her statements about the shooting and stolen jewelry conflict with the physical evidence. Bill had a defensive wound yet remained under his bedcovers; the safe was left unlocked and valuable guns were not taken. Carrie did not initially mention a missing jewelry box, even though the stolen items would have been important evidence. Her silence about the box and about her marriage makes Packard suspect she knows more than she has admitted, but he has no proof that she killed Bill.
Packard is also unsettled by Margaret's remark that she struck a woman named Sarah with a fireplace poker and that her husband John helped dispose of the body. Carrie dismisses it as confusion caused by dementia, but Margaret briefly seemed unusually lucid. Packard photographed the engraved hummingbird pin and asks office administrator Kelly Phelps to research possible missing or deceased women named Sarah connected to John Gherlick before Carrie's birth in April 1979.
Kelly has been angry because Packard ignored her encouragement to run for sheriff. He discovers that she has completed his candidacy paperwork and obtained the hundred voter signatures needed to file without paying the alternative fee. Packard acknowledges the support and reassesses the office as a responsibility he can accept rather than a position he must seek for personal advancement. He signs the form, and when Marilyn Shaw calls, he tells her that he is running. The chapter does not depict a completed filing or election result.
Key Events
- Packard reviews inconsistencies in Carrie's account and questions why a robber would leave valuable firearms.
- He directs a search for an unidentified Sarah possibly connected to John Gherlick before Carrie's birth.
- Kelly supplies completed candidacy papers and one hundred voter signatures.
- Packard signs his application and tells Marilyn he intends to run for sheriff.
Themes
- Persistent uncertainty surrounding the murder evidence
- Researching Margaret's possible older victim
- Decision to enter the sheriff election
Chapter Sixteen
Three days after filing for sheriff, Packard joins a campaign-planning meeting hosted by detective Jill Thielen and her husband Tim. His cousin Susan Wheeler and Stan Shaw's widow Marilyn attend, while office administrator Kelly stays away publicly to preserve the appearance of neutrality. With five weeks until the election, they plan campaign events, funding, letters to the newspaper, endorsements from retired chief deputy Ron Callahan and novelist Jim Henkel, and responses to the expected attention to Packard's sexuality. Thielen expects the two other candidates, deputies Howard Shepard and Alan Costas, to emphasize their local roots rather than their qualifications. Packard worries the campaign could expose his private life to hostility.
The narrative then recounts a disciplinary meeting Packard had with Shepard the previous day, before the campaign meeting. The city attorney determined that Shepard's unauthorized disclosure of Bill Sandersen's murder to Sherri was a serious code-of-conduct violation warranting at least a lengthy suspension and presumptively dismissal. Packard tells Shepard he has filed to run against him and intends to release the personnel records for all three sheriff candidates, including his own Minneapolis file, so voters can evaluate them. However, to avoid the appearance that Packard is damaging his rival's campaign through discipline, he will withhold the newly completed misconduct report from the released materials.
Packard tells Shepard that his continued employment as a deputy is over even if he loses the sheriff election to someone other than Packard. If Shepard does not win and resign within two weeks after election day, Packard will make the conduct finding public and dismiss him before the next sheriff takes office. If Shepard wins, his move to sheriff makes the deputy dismissal moot. Shepard is alarmed and appears likely to contact Jim Wolf, who is helping his campaign. Returning to the campaign meeting, Packard does not disclose the private disciplinary matter to his supporters.
Key Events
- Packard's campaign committee plans outreach, endorsements and preparation for possible attacks on his sexuality.
- The narrative recounts a disciplinary meeting with Shepard held the day before the committee meeting.
- The city attorney finds Shepard's disclosure violated rules and merits serious discipline.
- Packard decides to release all candidates' earlier personnel records but withhold Shepard's new misconduct report until after the election.
- Packard demands that Shepard leave deputy service if Shepard does not win election as sheriff, with resignation or dismissal after the vote.
Characters Appearing
- Susan Wheeler, Packard's cousin and campaign volunteer
- Tim Thielen, social-media campaign organizer
- Marilyn Shaw, campaign supporter
Themes
- Campaign transparency and conflict of interest
- Personnel accountability under electoral pressure
- Distinction between prior disciplinary meeting and current campaign planning
Chapter Seventeen
Carrie searches the garage of her mother's house for evidence explaining the hummingbird brooch, its inscription to Sarah and the masked killer's knowledge of it. She suspects her father John Gherlick may have had an affair with a young employee at his bank. Carrie believes her impoverished sister Sherri could have directed the killer toward the valuable pin, but has no evidence of that connection. Margaret waits in a chair by the open garage while Carrie examines old bank files and climbs into the loft where discarded belongings from her father's office were stored after his suicide.
In the loft Carrie finds a metal box holding an old Smith & Wesson .44 Magnum revolver and ammunition. She also finds bank calendars with photographs of former staff. In one, Sarah Pellak appears as a teller; in a later calendar she is customer service manager and wears the hummingbird pin. The following year's photograph no longer includes Sarah. This confirms Sarah worked at John's bank and at one time possessed the pin, but does not establish whether she resigned, disappeared or died. Carrie nevertheless decides that Margaret's claim to have killed her father's lover is true, interpreting it as part of the threats Margaret used to control John. This is Carrie's conclusion, not yet independently verified history.
As Carrie descends with the calendars and gun box, Sherri arrives in an unfamiliar car, confronts her angrily and thrusts an envelope toward her. The source does not disclose the envelope's contents in this chapter.
Key Events
- Carrie searches stored family and banking records for a woman named Sarah connected with John Gherlick.
- She discovers a boxed .44 Magnum revolver and ammunition in the garage loft.
- Old bank calendars identify Sarah Pellak as a bank employee and show her wearing the hummingbird brooch.
- Sarah disappears from a subsequent staff photograph; Carrie interprets this as supporting Margaret's murder confession without confirmation.
- Sherri arrives and confronts Carrie with an envelope whose contents remain unrevealed.
Characters Appearing
- Sarah Pellak, former employee at John Gherlick's bank
Themes
- Bank records and physical clues to an older event
- Distinction between an absence from a photograph and evidence of death
- Carrie's unverified conclusions about Margaret
Chapter Eighteen
Kelly brings Packard a May 5, 1979, newspaper report identifying Sarah Pellak as the woman whose body was recovered inside a car in a roadside drainage pond in Cass County. The car appeared to have been submerged since winter, and the article says her cause of death was undetermined at the time. It reports that Sarah once lived in Sandy Lake and later in Wilbur, Iowa. This confirms a death but not Margaret's claim of murder. Kelly plans to contact retired bank employee Martha Clay about Sarah's connection to John Gherlick.
At a candidates' forum moderated by Gazette publisher Ray Hanson, Packard competes with Howard Shepard and Alan Costas. Costas struggles with questions about department operations. Packard describes department budgets, grants, investigative accomplishments and hiring practices; he also acknowledges a past Minneapolis reprimand for striking a restrained suspect after officers found an abused child. Shepard explains his previous demotion without mentioning discrepancies in his own time records. In the final question, Shepard attacks Packard for hiring Suresh, a qualified specialist from India on a work visa, instead of a local candidate. Hanson ends the forum and cuts Packard's microphone when he attempts to defend the hiring decision. Packard suspects Hanson, county commissioner Jim Wolf and Shepard coordinated the question, but this remains his inference, not an established conspiracy.
After the forum Sherri approaches Packard with an anonymous letter mailed locally. It says Carrie killed Bill, claims the writer was present and warns Sherri she may be next. Sherri has already confronted Carrie, who accused her of sending the letter to herself and conspiring with Bill to stage a burglary and kill Carrie for insurance money. Sherri denies such a plan, insists Carrie could have killed Bill and acknowledges threatening Carrie again. Packard warns that her threats could implicate her if Carrie is harmed and asks her to avoid further confrontation. The letter's author and reliability remain unknown.
Key Events
- A 1979 newspaper report identifies Sarah Pellak as a deceased former Sandy Lake resident; cause of death was initially unknown.
- Packard answers sheriff-candidate questions, including a disclosed Minneapolis use-of-force reprimand.
- Shepard attacks the hiring of Suresh, and moderator Ray Hanson stops Packard's reply.
- Packard suspects but cannot substantiate coordination between Hanson, Wolf and Shepard.
- Sherri provides a locally mailed anonymous letter accusing Carrie of Bill's murder and warning Sherri she may be next.
Characters Appearing
- Sarah Pellak, subject of a 1979 death report
- Ray Hanson, local newspaper publisher and election moderator
- Martha Clay, retired bank employee Kelly intends to contact
Themes
- Distinguishing a death record from proof of murder
- Election rhetoric and a disputed public forum
- Anonymous accusation and its uncertain credibility
Chapter Nineteen
Four and a half weeks after Bill Sandersen's death, Packard reviews his chart of the suspects, financial interests and possible motives. He has added the missing jewelry, the hummingbird pin, Sarah Pellak and the unidentified shooter from the boat. None of his leads yet explains the murder. The high-stakes poker game seems unlikely by itself to explain the shooting, and the burglary scenario is inconsistent with an unlocked safe from which valuables were selectively removed. Packard also considers whether the shooter at Leon Chen's house might have been unrelated to Bill's death, since a different weapon and location were involved. These are his working interpretations rather than confirmed conclusions.
Packard visits Roger Freeman again to review the history of the partners' business account and Bill's claim that he had a plan to restore missing funds. Roger supplies more specific bank-statement dates and describes a restriction requiring both signatures for future withdrawals after discovering the loss. Packard realizes his earlier assumption was wrong. Bill did not withdraw the full $20,000 at once and lose it all in Leon Chen's private poker game. Instead, he withdrew $10,000 to play, then removed another $10,000 almost three weeks later. Roger's bank record establishes a second withdrawal after the poker loss, leaving that additional money unaccounted for. Packard admits he should have requested and checked the transaction dates earlier.
Roger is upset that Bill lied to him, but Packard notes Bill had also searched for restaurant equipment, supporting the possibility that the planned business was genuine even if Bill deceived Roger about financing it. Roger denies knowledge of a co-conspirator or of Bill's continuing affair with Sherri. Packard shows him the anonymous letter accusing Carrie of murder. Roger says he does not know whether Carrie killed Bill; he is willing to believe the Gherlick family would pursue its interests ruthlessly, but supplies no firsthand evidence. The newly established withdrawal chronology gives the investigation a separate $10,000 transaction to trace.
Key Events
- Packard adds the unidentified boat shooter, stolen jewelry and Sarah Pellak to his account of possible motives.
- Roger obtains statements revealing that Bill withdrew $10,000 for the earlier poker game and another $10,000 nearly three weeks later.
- Packard acknowledges that his previous assumption that Bill lost the entire $20,000 at poker was wrong.
- The second $10,000 remains unaccounted for and may relate to Bill's undisclosed plan.
- Roger cannot corroborate allegations that Carrie killed Bill or identify any co-conspirator.
Themes
- Correcting an investigative error with transaction dates
- Unexplained second withdrawal
- Evidence-based separation of financial theories
Chapter Twenty
Packard checks the financial discrepancy identified in Roger Freeman's account records. Leon Chen confirms Bill lost $10,000 and only a small amount more at the private poker game; no one extended him a loan to keep playing. Suresh finds no payment application or $10,000 deposit on Bill's cellphone or linked checking account, which had only $1,135 when Bill died. A cleaning company that cleared the murder bedroom says it did not discover that amount in cash. Packard leaves Sherri a message asking whether Bill mentioned the missing money. The second $10,000 remains untraced.
Suresh tells Packard that Shepard's remarks at the candidate forum about employing a specialist on a work visa have reached him. Packard condemns using Suresh's immigration status as a campaign attack and assures him that his technical work and his place in the department are valued.
At a campaign event in the senior center, Packard calls bingo, meets local voters and finds that informal conversations make it easier for him to engage with residents outside his police role. Supporter Gary Bushwright reports that several campaign signs have been defaced with homophobic references to Packard's surname. Packard jokes about it in front of Gary but is privately shaken. A dispatch call then reports a dead woman with head trauma at an address Packard recognizes, abruptly pulling him back into the murder investigation. The victim's identity is not disclosed until the next chapter.
Key Events
- Leon confirms a $10,000 poker loss without additional loans; the later $10,000 withdrawal remains unexplained.
- Suresh finds no electronic transfer explaining the second withdrawal, and the crime-scene cleaners found no cash.
- Packard reassures Suresh after Shepard's remarks about his immigration status.
- Homophobic vandalism of Packard's campaign signs undermines his confidence.
- Dispatch reports a female homicide victim with head trauma at an address Packard recognizes.
Characters Appearing
- Olivia McDonald, senior-center resident and Packard supporter
- Gary Bushwright, campaign volunteer
Themes
- Investigating a separate financial transaction
- Political attacks targeting a colleague and candidate
- Another fatality while the initial homicide remains unresolved
Chapter Twenty-one
Packard responds to the reported death and finds Sherri Sandersen lying on the floor of her condominium with a fatal head injury. The apparent weapon is a heavy stone molcajete that Sherri used as an ashtray. Deputy Shepard reports that a neighbor looking to buy marijuana saw Sherri through the sliding glass door. The neighbor and nearby residents report no useful observations, and there are no cameras or signs of forced entry. Bartender Kristie Capote said she dropped Sherri home around midnight after their shift. Sherri is still wearing her work clothes, suggesting she was killed after returning home, but the precise time and killer are unknown.
Packard notices a vintage jewelry box on Sherri's dining table matching the one reported stolen from Carrie and Bill's gun safe. The jewelry itself is not recovered in this scene. The box's presence links Sherri's premises to the stolen property but does not establish when or by whom it was placed there. Packard wonders whether the unexplained $10,000 withdrawal also reached Sherri, without evidence. He orders Shepard to apologize to Suresh for his remarks at the candidates' forum.
Unable to reach Carrie by phone, Packard rushes to Margaret's house fearing the attacker may have struck again. Carrie answers unharmed and says she had muted the phones because Margaret was distressed. Packard informs her Sherri has been killed and shows her a photo of the jewelry box. Carrie confirms that it is hers, immediately suspects Sherri was involved in the stolen-jewelry scheme and says that she and Bill must have been plotting to kill her for the life insurance. Packard points out that Carrie herself could have been involved. Carrie says she spent the previous night at her mother's house, where Margaret cannot provide a reliable alibi.
Packard finds Carrie's self-protective response suspicious, particularly because she does not ask how or where Sherri died. He arranges for a deputy to remain outside Margaret's house, citing protection from a possible killer but primarily intending to monitor Carrie. The chapter does not identify either murderer or confirm that the two killings were committed by the same person.
Key Events
- Sherri is found bludgeoned with a stone bowl at her condominium; no forced entry or confirmed assailant is found.
- A box matching Carrie's stolen jewelry container is found at Sherri's condo, without its missing jewelry.
- Packard orders Shepard to apologize to Suresh for his forum comments.
- Packard informs Carrie of Sherri's murder and questions her uncorroborated alibi.
- Packard places surveillance outside Margaret's house under the additional pretext of protecting Carrie.
Characters Appearing
- Kristie Capote, bartender who reportedly drove Sherri home
Themes
- Second homicide and uncertain connection to first
- Recovering a stolen container without identifying who brought it
- Questionable alibi and police surveillance
Chapter Twenty-two
After the discovery of Sherri's body, the preliminary forensic findings indicate she was struck at least twice with a heavy object between midnight and two in the morning, without clear signs of a struggle. Packard continues tracing the second $10,000 that Bill Sandersen took from his business account. Wendy, Ronnie Winder and Bill's dealership boss Stephen Carter initially offer no explanation. At Sandy Lake Auto, Stephen then reports that mechanic Paul, whom Packard previously interviewed, vanished after payroll staff discovered his Social Security number was invalid. He had worked at the dealership about nine months and left without collecting final wages.
Katherine provides Paul's employee photograph and purchasing records. Four days after Bill's later $10,000 withdrawal, Paul bought an older Mazda pickup using $10,000 in cash and a check for the remainder of the $11,500 price. A biometric search of his distinctive palm tattoo depicting dice reveals that the name Paul Brewer was false: he is Paul Bowers, a convicted armed robber who served a lengthy prison sentence in Missouri. He moved from Iowa to Sandy Lake after completing parole. Packard contacts his former parole officer, Hutchins, for information about his history and surviving family.
Paul's former landlord Phyllis Egan says he rented a basement room beginning in March and unexpectedly moved out in July, before leaving his dealership job. She remembers that he repeatedly asked about the downtown bank and the Gherlick family, who formerly owned it. Packard recognizes Phyllis as the proprietor of a five-and-dime shop he visited as a child and repays her for a minor shoplifting incident from his youth. The bank questions suggest Paul's interest may predate or exceed his acquaintance with Bill, but do not yet establish his purpose.
Packard recruits Thielen to accompany him on a seven-hour drive to Iowa to interview Paul's elderly father, Arthur Bowers. At their hotel, they discuss a possible scheme in which Bill paid Paul to burglarize Carrie's jewelry while Bill provided access, and alternatives involving insurance and a planned murder. The missing jewelry was insured for more than $200,000, but these theories do not explain why Bill was killed or why the empty jewelry box later appeared at Sherri's condominium. Packard also thinks the shooting at Chen's house may be unrelated. The pair plan to interview Arthur the next morning.
Key Events
- A repeat inquiry at Sandy Lake Auto reveals Paul used a false Social Security number and disappeared.
- Katherine's records show Paul bought a pickup using $10,000 cash four days after Bill's second withdrawal.
- A palm tattoo identifies Paul Brewer as Paul Bowers, a previously imprisoned armed robber.
- Former landlord Phyllis reports that Paul questioned her about the former Gherlick bank and moved out in July.
- Packard and Thielen travel to Iowa to question Arthur Bowers, considering but not confirming a burglary conspiracy.
Characters Appearing
- Paul Bowers, mechanic using the false name Paul Brewer
- Phyllis Egan, Paul’s former landlord
- Hutchins, former Iowa parole officer
- Arthur Bowers, Paul's father, to be interviewed
Themes
- False identity and financial linkage
- Unresolved connections to the old Gherlick bank
- Distinguishing an investigative theory from proof of a conspiracy
Chapter Twenty-three
Packard and Jill Thielen visit Arthur Bowers at a senior-living residence in Van Grove, Iowa. Arthur is worried that his son Paul may have committed another crime but says he has not heard from him for nearly a year and does not know where he lives. Packard explicitly tells Arthur that Paul is a person of interest, not someone for whom investigators yet have evidence sufficient to accuse him of murder. Arthur recounts Paul's juvenile offenses, imprisonment and later technical training as an auto mechanic.
Arthur describes his late wife Evelyn's dementia and cancer. Paul, previously estranged from the family, visited Evelyn frequently during her final illness. Arthur was not present for their conversations but says Evelyn claimed afterward that she had unburdened herself to Paul. Packard notices a family photograph showing a young Evelyn beside another woman, with a bundled baby. He photographs it. When Packard asks whether Arthur is Paul's biological father, Arthur responds angrily that he raised Paul and considers him his son. He does not directly or unambiguously answer the biological question. The conversation ends abruptly.
Packard says the interview provided what he needed, but he still lacks grounds to arrest Paul and must locate him for questioning. Thielen drives them back to Sandy Lake. Packard collects his dog Frank from neighbor Bert, checks the worsening weather forecast and confirms dispatch has issued a lookout bulletin for Paul Bowers, using the false name Paul Brewer and identifying his Mazda truck. No sighting has been reported by the end of the chapter.
Key Events
- Arthur states he has not contacted Paul for almost a year and cannot supply a current address.
- Arthur describes Paul's visits to his dying mother Evelyn and her claim to have disclosed a long-held burden to him.
- Packard photographs an old picture of Evelyn, another unidentified woman and a baby.
- Asked if he is Paul's biological father, Arthur affirms a paternal relationship but does not unambiguously confirm biology.
- The officers return to Minnesota, and the active lookout for Paul has not yielded his location.
Characters Appearing
- Evelyn Bowers, Paul's late mother
- Arthur Bowers, Paul's father or father figure
Themes
- Family evidence without established biological relationship
- Investigative value of a photograph and late-life disclosure
- Need to locate a suspect before arrest
Chapter Twenty-four
A heavy first snowfall leaves many motorists stranded or involved in collisions. As acting sheriff, Packard assists deputies at accident scenes and manages staffing until Deputy Reynolds reports spotting the Mazda pickup identified in the lookout notice for Paul Bowers, who had worked at Sandy Lake Auto under the false surname Brewer.
Packard asks Reynolds to follow the truck rather than stop it, hoping to learn Paul's destination. Paul pulls into the Big Beaver bar and appears to be waiting for another person. Packard enters, orders food and observes discreetly. Paul notices or suspects the surveillance and tries to leave by a side door. Outside, Packard calls to him and asks him to come in voluntarily for questioning about Bill Sandersen. Paul refuses and asks whether he is under arrest. Packard says he is not, but states that he knows Paul's real identity and prior armed-robbery conviction.
Paul attacks Packard, and they struggle on the icy pavement between parked vehicles. Paul attempts to seize Packard's gun, then reaches into his pickup for a shovel and swings it at Packard. Packard unstraps his Taser but does not deploy it. Seeing Reynolds's approaching cruiser, Paul throws the shovel, jumps into the truck and drives toward the highway. He loses control in the snow and crashes into the ditch across the road. Packard pulls Paul from the disabled pickup and handcuffs him. Paul is arrested for the confrontation and flight; the source does not yet establish an arrest or conviction for Bill's murder.
Key Events
- Snow emergencies occupy the sheriff's department before Reynolds locates Paul's pickup.
- Paul appears to be waiting at the Big Beaver bar, then refuses voluntary questioning.
- Paul attacks Packard, attempts to seize his gun and threatens him with a shovel.
- Packard prepares but does not use his Taser.
- Paul flees, crashes in the snow and is handcuffed after Packard opens his truck door.
Themes
- Attempted voluntary interview and escalation to assault
- Maintaining safety and evidence during a suspect confrontation
- Distinction between apprehension and proving the original homicide
Chapter Twenty-five
Paul Bowers is medically assessed after his crash and booked into the county jail. The next day Packard reviews the inventory of Paul's impounded truck and finds that officers recovered a bag containing jewelry matching items reported stolen from Carrie and Bill Sandersen's house, along with a Glock 19 pistol loaded with two rounds missing from its magazine. The pistol may be the weapon used to shoot Bill, but ballistic identification has not yet been completed.
Packard and Thielen interview Paul, who immediately requests a lawyer and insists he will not answer questions without counsel. Packard presents his theory despite Paul's refusal to engage. He asserts that Paul and Bill planned a break-in or an attempted murder of Carrie and that Bill paid him $10,000, which Paul used to buy his pickup. Packard does not yet know whether robbery or a life-insurance scheme was the original purpose or why Bill was killed instead.
Packard then shows Paul an old photograph obtained from Arthur Bowers's residence. It depicts Evelyn Bowers with another woman wearing the distinctive jeweled hummingbird pin. Packard argues that the woman was Sarah Pellak, Evelyn's sister, and conjectures that Evelyn and Arthur raised Paul after Sarah's death. He further proposes that John Gherlick, who gave Sarah the pin, was Paul's biological father, making Paul a half-sibling of Carrie, Sherri and Mary if the inference proves true. Packard uses this theory to explain Paul's interest in the Gherlick family and the old bank. Paul neither confirms the genealogy nor explains his move to Sandy Lake. Packard also accuses him of killing Bill and Sherri and attempting to shoot Packard from a boat, but the facts linking him to the separate killings and boat attack are not yet proven.
Paul repeatedly denies killing anyone and requests legal counsel. The interview ends when a deputy removes him. Thielen commends Packard's reasoning, while Packard says the department is preparing charging paperwork. No formal charge, forensic comparison or final resolution is shown within this chapter.
Key Events
- The impounded pickup contains jewelry matching Carrie's stolen property and a Glock 19 with two rounds missing.
- Paul requests counsel and denies Bill's murder; Packard presents accusations rather than obtaining a confession.
- Packard identifies the second woman in Arthur's old photograph as Sarah Pellak and hypothesizes that she was Paul's biological mother.
- Packard hypothesizes that John Gherlick was Paul's father, which would make Paul a half-sibling of the Gherlick sisters if confirmed.
- Packard accuses Paul of the murders and boat shooting without yet establishing proof of all the events; charging paperwork is in preparation.
Themes
- Physical evidence versus unconfirmed forensic identification
- Hypothesized family relationships versus verified kinship
- Investigator reconstruction versus a suspect's denial and right to counsel
Chapter Twenty-six
Paul Bowers's defense attorney, Lisa Washington, meets with Packard, who lists the stolen jewelry, a Glock pistol recovered from Paul's truck and tire impressions linking the vehicle to the Sandersen scene. The gun's ballistic match is still pending. Lisa obtains Paul's signed statement and arranges another interview after he admits firing the shots at Bill but insists that the account contains an essential qualification.
Paul says the masked burglary was planned with Bill, who paid him with money taken from Roger's business account. Paul had sought out the Gherlick family after his adoptive mother Evelyn disclosed on her deathbed that her sister Sarah Pellak was his biological mother. According to his account, Sarah had an affair with banker John Gherlick, who gave her the hummingbird brooch, and she died in a car crash while returning from an attempt to see John. Paul believes John was his biological father and resents the wealth enjoyed by his half-sisters. More than the other stolen jewelry, he wanted his mother's brooch, which he had seen in later photographs of Margaret. The claim about his parentage and the historical circumstances comes through Paul's account, supported in part by the photograph and records but not fully established by independent genetic evidence.
Paul says he and Bill intended to stage a theft of Carrie's jewelry and firearms for an insurance claim, not to kill her. When Paul could not find the hummingbird pin, the men argued and Carrie unexpectedly confronted him with her own gun. He says Carrie ordered him to shoot Bill or be shot himself. Paul fired the first shot at Bill and, while escaping with the stolen jewelry, fired a second when Carrie demanded Bill not survive. Paul admits the shooting but claims coercion. He denies shooting at Packard from a boat or murdering Sherri.
Paul says he left Sherri the first anonymous letter accusing Carrie, then placed the empty jewelry box and a second explanatory letter on Sherri's patio, hoping to pressure Carrie to pay him. He admits calling Carrie twice to demand money and mailing a later letter naming people close to her as possible future targets. He destroyed a burner phone at the Big Beaver before his arrest. Packard finds the admission partly credible because of Carrie's inconsistent statements, although the allegation that she coerced the shooting still lacks independent proof.
Packard visits Margaret's house to confront Carrie and finds the front door unanswered. Tracks in fresh snow show someone left across the backyard toward a boat landing, evading the deputy posted outside. Margaret is unconscious but breathing in her bedroom. An open gun box holds .44 Magnum ammunition with six rounds missing and no gun. Packard discovers Paul's new letter threatening Carrie's children, friend and foundation colleagues if she refuses to pay, and hears Carrie's cellphone ringing inside the house. He concludes she has left deliberately, armed and without her tracked phone, and mobilizes deputies to locate her.
Key Events
- Lisa Washington produces Paul's signed account admitting he shot Bill, while alleging Carrie forced him to fire.
- Paul explains that Sarah Pellak was Evelyn's sister and his biological mother, according to Evelyn's deathbed disclosure, and identifies John Gherlick as his possible father.
- Paul says Bill commissioned a staged burglary for insurance and that Carrie confronted them armed, then forced him to shoot Bill twice.
- Paul admits writing letters, placing the empty jewelry box on Sherri's patio, threatening Carrie and destroying a burner phone.
- Paul denies killing Sherri or shooting at Chen's house, neither allegation being independently resolved here.
- Packard finds Margaret unresponsive, Carrie's phone left at home, an empty .44 revolver box and a threat letter, then organizes a search.
Characters Appearing
- Lisa Washington, Paul's defense attorney
Themes
- Confession, disputed coercion and need for corroboration
- Kinship account explaining the hummingbird pin
- Blackmail and escalating threats to relatives
Chapter Twenty-seven
Carrie has secretly left Margaret's house after giving her mother Ambien, inventing a neighbor to look after her and paying home aide Zeinab to pick her up near the boat landing beyond the posted deputy's view. As Zeinab drives, Carrie privately recalls how she killed Sherri, confirming that Paul was telling Packard the truth about leaving the second letter and empty jewelry box on Sherri's patio. On the night of Sherri's murder, Carrie came to the condominium to inspect an anonymous letter that accused her of holding Paul at gunpoint during Bill's killing. Sherri brought the jewelry box inside without recognizing it and began reading the accompanying letter.
When Carrie referred to hearing the masked intruder discuss the hummingbird pin, she inadvertently admitted to Sherri that she had witnessed more than she told police. Sherri accused her of withholding evidence and moved to telephone Packard. Carrie, convinced Sherri was colluding with Bill and the blackmailer despite Sherri's denial, picked up the heavy stone molcajete used as an ashtray and struck her sister from behind. She then struck Sherri in the forehead as Sherri tried to recover. Carrie took the explanatory letter, left the jewelry box in place to incriminate Sherri, wiped the door handle and drove home, privately rationalizing her actions.
In the present, Zeinab stops at another client's house. Carrie slips into the driver's seat and takes the aide's car without permission to reach an address she has memorized and removed from her browsing history. She parks outside a remote log house, approaches armed with an old revolver and enters without knocking. A figure standing in the dark at the top of the stairs points a shotgun at her and remarks that her arrival was expected. The source withholds the figure's identity until the following chapter.
Key Events
- Carrie drugs Margaret with Ambien and evades the deputy by walking through the snow to Zeinab's vehicle.
- Her recollection confirms she murdered Sherri with the molcajete after Sherri discovered she had concealed critical witness knowledge.
- Carrie removed Paul's second letter but deliberately left the stolen jewelry box at Sherri's house.
- She takes Zeinab's car and drives to a secluded log house with her revolver.
- An unidentified person confronts her at the house with a shotgun.
Themes
- Confirmed killer viewpoint for Sherri's murder
- Concealment, planted evidence and deliberate violence
- Danger to an unattended caregiver
Chapter Twenty-eight
Packard coordinates the search for Carrie from a parking area outside the not-yet-open brewery. He establishes that she took caretaker Zeinab Abdi's car while Zeinab was visiting another client. Zeinab herself is safe but does not know Carrie's destination, and her phone has no useful location tracking. Brewer Kyle, Kelly Phelps's nephew, approaches Packard to see whether he needs help and suggests a small election-night gathering at the brewery. They exchange a few friendly words, but Packard remains concerned about Carrie's actions.
Reexamining Paul's latest blackmail letter, Packard notices that it lists Carrie's children, friends and foundation colleagues but omits her estranged sister Mary. The omission makes him question why Mary is absent when she is otherwise linked to the Gherlick family and possibly knowledgeable about their history. He recalls Paul's distinctive beaded keychain, the scented stationery used for the anonymous letters and the smell of incense in Mary's craft shop. He also realizes that the old Gherlick bank Paul asked about stood directly across the street from Mary's shop. Packard infers that Mary may have helped Paul learn family details or find accommodation. This is a deduction pending confrontation, not proof that Mary orchestrated murders.
Concluding that Carrie may have reached the same answer, Packard asks dispatch to make Paul available by phone and calls Mary, hoping to prevent an armed confrontation.
Key Events
- Zeinab is located safely, confirms Carrie took her car and cannot supply Carrie's destination.
- Kyle offers the brewery as a possible election-night venue.
- Packard recognizes Mary's absence from Paul's threat list as an investigative clue.
- Scented stationery, a beaded keychain and the craft shop's location support a hypothesis linking Paul to Mary.
- Packard calls dispatch about Paul and attempts to contact Mary.
Themes
- Inference from omissions and material details
- Concern for potential target rather than proven culpability
- Locating an armed missing suspect
Chapter Twenty-nine
Carrie confronts her estranged sister Mary at Mary's isolated house. Mary keeps a shotgun trained on her, knowing Carrie entered without permission carrying a gun. Carrie notices shoes and a Sandy Lake Auto jacket that suggest a man has been staying there. She accuses Mary of helping the masked intruder who killed Bill. Mary says she offered the man shelter while he sought to expose what Carrie did, not while he sought to arrange a murder.
Carrie explains that she recognized the distinctive scented stationery from Mary's craft shop and concluded that Mary supplied information used in the anonymous letters. Mary says Paul and Bill planned a burglary of Carrie's jewelry to collect insurance and resale money, not a murder, and accuses Carrie of exploiting the situation to dispose of Bill and later killing Sherri. Carrie continues to insist the burglary was intended to conceal a plot against her, although her own recollections establish she shot no one at the first scene and personally killed Sherri. Mary explains that the man knows about the hummingbird brooch because it belonged to his biological mother Sarah, who had an affair with their father John Gherlick. This makes Paul a likely half-brother of Carrie, Mary and Sherri, a relationship Carrie had not known.
When headlights and a vehicle arrive outside, Carrie conceals her revolver in the couch and then aims it at Mary as someone comes toward the front door with groceries. Mary drops behind the kitchen counter and warns the visitor. Carrie fires through the closed front door; a tactical team simultaneously enters through the rear and orders her to surrender. Carrie places the revolver down and is arrested. The person wearing the parka at the front door is Packard, not Paul. Carrie narrowly missed shooting Packard, who emerges and remarks on how close the shot came to killing someone.
Key Events
- Carrie confronts Mary about Paul's accommodation, revealing evidence from scented stationery and his belongings.
- Mary explains Sarah Pellak, not Margaret, had an affair with John Gherlick and gave birth to Paul.
- Mary says Paul and Bill planned theft, while Carrie argues a murder plot existed; the statements are not mutually corroborated.
- Carrie points a revolver at Mary and fires through the front door toward someone approaching.
- Tactical officers arrest Carrie; the person she almost shoots is Packard.
Themes
- Family revelations and confrontation
- Conflicting motive explanations
- Disarming an armed homicide suspect without a further death
Chapter Thirty
On election night, Packard gathers with his campaign team at the newly built Hopfenstopfen Brewery, where Kyle and Mark host a private celebration before the business officially opens. Touring the brewing equipment with Kyle, Packard learns that a strong smell from fermented corn can indicate moonshine production. This offers a possible explanation for the smell coming from the concealed area in Gerald Whitehouse's barn; Packard has not verified the suspected still. Packard and Kyle continue to show mutual interest, although the approaching election result occupies Packard's thoughts.
Carrie had been released on bail following her arrest because of her community standing and responsibility for her mother. While free she gave a Sandy Lake Gazette interview accusing Packard and his department of unfairly targeting her despite Paul's confession. Two weeks later, DNA and physical evidence linked her to Sherri's murder: skin from Carrie's hand was abraded against the coarse stone bowl, and Sherri's blood was recovered from Carrie's shoe and an unwashed blouse. A judge revoked her bail, and she has been jailed for three days by election night.
During the party Packard receives a photograph of Roger Freeman and Bill's sister Wendy discussing a business plan. Leon Chen has reimbursed Roger $10,000 for the money Bill lost at poker. Since Sherri, the primary beneficiary of Bill's workplace life insurance, is dead, Wendy is the contingent beneficiary. Packard had encouraged her and Roger to consider the chicken-wing restaurant Bill wanted to open, though no new business has yet been established. His cousin Susan and Jenny Wheeler also attend; Jenny is still regaining use of the hand injured during the earlier Emmett Burr case. Meanwhile the separate investigation into the shots fired at Packard from a boat has no suspect, witness or identified motive.
The official sheriff election returns give Howard Shepard 9,717 votes (47 percent), Packard 8,481 (41 percent), and Alan Costas 2,413 (12 percent). Shepard wins. Packard addresses his disappointed supporters, thanks them for their work and says he will continue serving the county as a detective. He is not elected sheriff.
Key Events
- The private election-night gathering takes place at Hopfenstopfen Brewery, hosted by Kyle and Mark.
- Forensic evidence from Carrie's hand and Sherri's blood on her belongings prompts revocation of Carrie's bail.
- Leon Chen reimburses Roger $10,000, and Wendy inherits the beneficiary position in Bill's life insurance following Sherri's death.
- The investigation into the separate boat shooting remains open without a named suspect.
- Howard Shepard wins the sheriff election with 9,717 votes to Packard's 8,481 and Costas's 2,413.
- Packard concedes and says he will remain a detective.
Themes
- Election loss and professional transition
- Forensic corroboration of Sherri's murder
- Financial aftermath for Wendy and Roger
Chapter Thirty-one
On the same night that Howard Shepard wins the sheriff election, an unnamed person who fired at Packard from a boat stands outside Jim Wolf's house during Shepard's victory party. Wolf joins the visitor on the deck. They celebrate Shepard's victory, and Wolf says that although Shepard is incompetent, having a compliant sheriff will be useful for local business interests. Both dislike Packard.
Wolf asks whether the visitor was responsible for the shooting at Leon Chen's house. The visitor denies attempting to kill Packard and reacts sharply when Wolf alludes to a troubling record. Wolf retreats from the question. The narration, however, identifies this person as the shooter; the denial is not credible to the reader. Their identity is not supplied, and Wolf's question does not establish that he commissioned the attack.
After Wolf returns to his party, the shooter reflects that Packard has deeper ties to the area than most people know. The shooter expects Wolf to use Shepard's authority to burden Packard and prevent him from investigating matters that could threaten the visitor. If that does not work, the shooter is prepared to fire another long-range shot at Packard and intends not to miss. Packard remains unaware of the shooter's identity and renewed threat.
Key Events
- The narrative identifies an unnamed guest at Jim Wolf's victory party as the person who shot toward Packard at Leon Chen's house.
- Wolf describes Shepard as useful because he is controllable, not because he is competent.
- Wolf questions the guest about the shooting and receives a denial; Wolf's prior knowledge or complicity is not established.
- The shooter considers using the new sheriff to obstruct Packard and threatens to attempt another killing if necessary.
- The shooter's real identity is not revealed to Packard or the reader.
Themes
- Ongoing danger unknown to the investigator
- Political influence over incoming sheriff Shepard
- Reader knowledge versus Wolf's suspicion and Packard's ignorance
Chapter Thirty-two
Mary Gherlick reluctantly visits the family home for the first time in nearly thirty years to relieve a gap in the care provided to her mother, Margaret. Margaret has advanced dementia and continues to ask for Carrie, who has been jailed for two weeks in connection with the deaths of Bill and Sherri. Home aide Janet finishes household chores before leaving Mary with her mother.
Mary confronts Margaret about her earlier statement that she killed Sarah Pellak, John Gherlick's lover and the woman named on the jeweled hummingbird pin. Margaret says she saved her marriage from Sarah, reinforcing her allegation without providing a verifiable account of Sarah's death. Mary then mentions the unsolved shooting of her fiancé Jay while hunting decades earlier. Margaret responds that Mary had no right to be happier than the rest of them. Mary suspects her mother might have caused Jay's death too, but the exchange does not establish who killed him.
Mary privately recalls how Paul Bowers first came to her craft shop looking for information about his biological mother, Sarah, who had worked for John Gherlick. Together they found a report of Sarah's body recovered from a submerged car and newspaper photographs showing Margaret wearing Sarah's hummingbird pin after Sarah died. Mary helped Paul investigate the family's history. She knew of his prior imprisonment and did not object when he befriended Bill at the dealership and pursued a scheme involving the family's jewelry. After the burglary and Bill's death, Mary sheltered Paul and suggested sending anonymous information to Sherri to pressure Carrie for money. She did not expect Carrie to murder Sherri. Mary has undertaken to pay for Paul's defense, although his signed admission to shooting Bill makes the result uncertain.
Mary plans to transfer legal responsibility for Margaret from the imprisoned Carrie and place her in residential care. She has not yet completed the transfer or placement. Alone with her mother, Mary recognizes that the family's violence and estrangement have left her as the only surviving daughter who is not imprisoned. She regards that survival as no victory.
Key Events
- Mary visits Margaret after a decades-long estrangement to cover a gap in home care.
- Margaret reiterates that she acted against Sarah Pellak to preserve her marriage, but no independent historical homicide proof is produced.
- Mary wonders whether Margaret was involved in Jay's hunting death; Margaret does not confess to killing him.
- Mary recalls cooperating with Paul on the Sarah investigation, hiding him and suggesting that he use Sherri to pressure Carrie.
- Mary plans to fund Paul's defense and arrange a transfer of Margaret's care and power of attorney.
Characters Appearing
- Janet, home-care worker
Themes
- Unverified older deaths and family suspicion
- Mary's involvement with Paul's extortion strategy
- Caregiving obligations after criminal consequences
Chapter Thirty-three
Packard realizes in the weeks after the election that losing to Howard Shepard was more painful than he admitted at the party. With Shepard due to take office in January, Packard prepares a departmental transition and takes leave to finish renovating his house. Jill Thielen and Kelly Phelps are both dismayed by the prospect of Shepard becoming their boss. Packard continues an occasional relationship with Dave, the Maneater drummer he met at the beginning of the novel, and spends Thanksgiving with Susan and Jenny Wheeler and Christmas with his sister Anne's family in Wisconsin. His other brother Joseph and their parents attend. The family still hangs a Christmas stocking for Nick, who disappeared twenty-nine years earlier, but the anniversary passes without discussion.
When Packard returns home shortly before Shepard's inauguration, he finally opens the evidence box Sheriff Stan Shaw left him. He finds the glove recovered near the hole in the ice where Nick's snowmobile was located, a binder containing family photographs and a handwritten letter from Stan. Stan explains that he reviewed Nick's cold case after joining the sheriff's department, repeatedly questioning a man whose family members had also been interviewed. Although Stan suspected the man knew more than he acknowledged, he never had proof against him.
After learning that Packard was Nick's younger brother, the terminally ill Stan contacted the man again. Over several conversations Stan made an agreement: the man would disclose a location to search for Nick in exchange for Stan's protection of his family. Stan did not obtain a complete account. The letter apologizes to Packard and includes directions, a sketch map and geographic coordinates for the proposed search. Packard then discovers that the rest of the supposedly preserved case file consists entirely of blank pages. Stan deliberately destroyed the old records, including the interviews and other material collected before digital backup, leaving only the glove, photographs and new directions. Packard is angered and distressed by Stan's decision.
Packard immediately calls Thielen and requests deputies, search dogs, lights and equipment to clear deep snow. He says the possible body is his brother Nick. The novel ends with Packard's conviction that the location can lead them to Nick, not with a recovered body, identified remains or a completed search. Nick's disappearance and the separate attempted shooting at Packard both remain unresolved.
Key Events
- Packard loses the election and prepares for Shepard's January succession while renovating his house.
- His family still remembers missing brother Nick at Christmas; Packard has not opened the returned evidence box until after the holiday.
- The box contains Nick's recovered glove, photographs and a letter written by Stan Shaw before his death.
- Stan's letter describes an agreement with a historically uncooperative witness for a search location in exchange for protection of the witness's family.
- Stan intentionally destroyed the original cold-case file and replaced its records with blank pages.
- The note supplies a map and coordinates; Packard summons a search team, but no body is recovered before the novel ends.
Characters Appearing
- Anne, Packard's sister
- Joseph, Packard's surviving brother
- Nick, Packard's older brother, still missing
Themes
- The consequences of election defeat
- Conflict between information gained and evidence destroyed
- Possible new lead in Nick's disappearance without resolution